NickC wrote:Do you think a civil war lasting say 2 years would leave less dead
Dunno, it's "how long is a piece of string". I don't see how any outcome with Gaddafi as a leader will be acceptable, however, he's proven he's happy to butcher his own people and if he stayed in power, I'm sure he'd be very happy to provide state sponsorship for Al-Quaeda, he's got form in that area.
So a victorious Gaddafi would mean:
- A large refugee crisis in Europe (and so in the UK)
- Major humanitarian crisis in Libya (thousands of deaths, tens or hundreds of thousands "ethnically cleansed")
- A dictator with a history of support for terrorism (IRA sponsorship, Lockerbie etc.), looking to take revenge on the West.
Besides, it's not a "civil war" - that implies that a significant number of Libyans support Gaddafi, and that's clearly rubbish. It's simply that he's a ruthless dictator with control over a lot of people with guns (they're not an army, they're a bunch of well-armed thugs), which he uses to terrorise the population.
NickC wrote: and what will be the result will be, my prediction is the replacement of a tyrant by another tyrant
As happened in Egypt, you mean? Where the dictator got booted out, and the Egyptian people have voted in a referendum for a new constitution in advance of free election?