Libya

Talk about anything not related to dancing...
Have fun, it's your Forum!
User avatar
Gav
Senior Member
Posts: 5424
Joined: Tue Sep 12, 2006 7:23 am
Contact:

Re: Libya

Report a concern about this post

Post by Gav »

Trouble wrote:but its not just that is it.
Right now? Yes, it is exactly just that because we are acting under a UN Mandate which defines what we can do.
Trouble wrote:"Libyans must be able to choose their own destiny
So you don't think we should get involved, but you think that Libyans should be free to choose their own destiny?

So how exactly do you think they will achieve that whilst Gaddafi is exterminating them?
"You can't argue with stupid" - Me
philsmove
Senior Member
Posts: 3166
Joined: Sat Apr 03, 2004 9:03 am

Re: Libya

Report a concern about this post

Post by philsmove »

Trouble wrote:. But the rebels would not have the capacity to challenge his hold on much of the western part of the country.

.
So they will be looking for someone to help them
and they will be free to choose who
True the american are not going to be too please if they choose Russia or China
but that's better than leaving them to killed by Gaddafi
The customer is allways right , but sometimes they are in the wrong place
Bubble
Senior Member
Posts: 290
Joined: Wed Aug 26, 2009 6:13 pm

Re: Libya

Report a concern about this post

Post by Bubble »

Trouble wrote:Send in Jack Bauer - he'll sort them out.

All I know is that this Friday, i was deducted;

£1400 in tax from my salary.
I paid £70 to fill up my car.
I ordered a gift for one of the girls 50th birthday and paid 20% VAT on it
and im sick of it.

One Tomahawk Land Attack Missile (TLAM) is reported to cost $1,066,465 (approximately £650863)

So your £1400 tax has purchased about 0.215% of one TLAM. Over 100 TLAMS have already been fired into Libya, some from a Trafalgar Class submarine (i.e. a British platform), and some from American platforms.

Does that make you feel better? :flower:
User avatar
David Bailey
Senior Member
Posts: 17001
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Libya

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Bailey »

Trouble wrote:but its not just that is it. How far are the coalition forces prepared to go. what is their aim - end point.
It's been made clear that the aim of military intervention is the protection of civilians from being murdered by the Gaddafi regime's armed forces. If Gaddafi stopped doing things like starving, bombing and simply shooting the populace of opposing cities, then the military operations would have to stop as they'd have no further legitimacy.

(Of course, if Gaddafi stopped doing things like starving, bombing and simply shooting the populace of opposing cities, then he'd immediately lose any control over almost all the country, probably including Tripoli, so that's not going to happen.)

The military operation is not the same as the political operation - the aims of the political operation are, of course, regime change.

Two different things.
Jivetango Godfather
"if your arguments are poorly constructed, they are often misinterperetated" - CJ
User avatar
David Bailey
Senior Member
Posts: 17001
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Libya

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Bailey »

Trouble wrote:but its not just that is it. How far are the coalition forces prepared to go. what is their aim - end point.
It's been made clear that the aim of military intervention is the protection of civilians from being murdered by the Gaddafi regime's armed forces. If Gaddafi stopped doing things like starving, bombing and simply shooting the populace of opposing cities, then the military operations would have to stop as they'd have no further legitimacy.

(Of course, if Gaddafi stopped doing things like starving, bombing and simply shooting the populace of opposing cities, then he'd immediately lose any control over almost all the country, probably including Tripoli, so that's not going to happen.)

The military operation is not the same as the political operation - the aims of the political operation are, of course, regime change.

Two different things.
Jivetango Godfather
"if your arguments are poorly constructed, they are often misinterperetated" - CJ
User avatar
David Bailey
Senior Member
Posts: 17001
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Libya

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Bailey »

Trouble wrote:We have gone in full guns ablazing, protecting the civillians of this country from being massacared YET.... who is protecting the civillians of this country from being massacred finanically.. who is protecting the young from not being able to afford to buy property, not being able to leave the nest of mum and dad, thats of course if mum and dad still have a nest and haven't lost it due to bankrupcy or financial difficulties due to the high taxes, cost and general living this country now has due to it STICKING IT BLOODY NOSE IN WHEN WE CANT AFFORD IT.
Firstly, as I said earlier, we can't afford to house, feed, educate and maintain a flood of thousands of Libyan refugees either.

So if it's a choice between spending state money on supporting refugees because of a failure to act, or spending state money preventing those people from becoming refugees in the first place, I think the latter is the best choice. You can almost look at it as an investment.

Secondly, it's not like the UK is taking on this burden by itself. Our contribution is relatively modest, I'd be surprised if we're contributing more than 10% of the forces involved.
Jivetango Godfather
"if your arguments are poorly constructed, they are often misinterperetated" - CJ
User avatar
David Bailey
Senior Member
Posts: 17001
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Libya

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Bailey »

Dreadful Scathe wrote:Indeed. You can take our lives but you'll never raise our VAT rate inline with the European average Didn't William Wallace say that? no ? I'm sure he meant to.
Probably better than the "lives but not freedom" speech Gibson gave. I mean, what sort of a motivational speech is "You're all going to die, lads"? :D
Jivetango Godfather
"if your arguments are poorly constructed, they are often misinterperetated" - CJ
User avatar
David Bailey
Senior Member
Posts: 17001
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Libya

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Bailey »

Sorry for quoting myself, but:
David Bailey wrote:Firstly, as I said earlier, we can't afford to house, feed, educate and maintain a flood of thousands of Libyan refugees either.
I notice that the refugee problem is already becoming a crisis:
Thousands of Libyans are risking their lives to escape to a small Italian island, where conditions are appalling.
Imagine that problem multiplied by 10; that's the sort of thing we'd be facing if we'd not intervened. A massive humanitarian crisis on our doorsteps.
Jivetango Godfather
"if your arguments are poorly constructed, they are often misinterperetated" - CJ
User avatar
David Bailey
Senior Member
Posts: 17001
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Libya

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Bailey »

So, we're a week in now.

The good news is, we've managed to protect the lives of, probably, a couple of million people, and caused the deaths of possibly zero civilians. Which is pretty good going.

We've also managed to halt the inexorable advance of Gaddafi's forces, and allowed the rebels to at least attempt a take-back of the territory in the East. We've even managed to provide some assistance for Misrata.

So militarily, for 1 weeks' work, that's pretty damn good going. We have a fully-functioning No Fly Zone, and we've stopped the Gaddafi forces from advancing any further.

So make no mistake, the airstrikes have directly saved the lives of thousands of people who would otherwise be dead right now.

In a wider context, the intervention has been welcomed by the Libyan people and by the Arab League; the one attempt by the AL chairman to criticize the actions was stamped-on thoroughly and he had to issue a grovelling apology immediately. So in theory, if played right, this could go some way help mend the damage done by Bush and Blair in Iraq, and we could end up with the majority of the North African (=Southern Mediterranean) countries becoming stable democracies by the end of the year.

So there's good local support - and several Arab countries (the UAE and Qatar) are even flying patrols as part of the NFZ.

That's the good news.

Politically, it's a bit of a mess. No-one's really in sure who's in charge of the coalition, and neither is anyone sure who's in charge of the rebels. This may get clarified in time, but for the moment one side is divided and the other is united under a single political and military command.

There are also serious military obstacles coming up; the rebels "armed forces" are about 1,000 soldiers, and 15,000 people who happen to have cars and (if they're lucky) AK-47s, and that's about it. Whilst the airstrikes mean that anyone operating armour or heavy weapons out in the open is committing suicide, it's almost impossible to hit those forces in urban areas without casualties. It's also difficult politically - the UN mandate is to protect civilians, not kill them in collateral damage as part of air support for one side in a civil war.

Where do people see it going from here?
Jivetango Godfather
"if your arguments are poorly constructed, they are often misinterperetated" - CJ
NickC
Member
Posts: 187
Joined: Tue Jul 15, 2008 1:03 pm
Contact:

Re: Libya

Report a concern about this post

Post by NickC »

I see it getting really bad, the NFZ means Gadaffi's forces are stuck, so protracted civil war it is then, the infrastructure will collapse, water and food will not get through, starvation, disease and war, great arn't we
User avatar
David Bailey
Senior Member
Posts: 17001
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Libya

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Bailey »

NickC wrote:I see it getting really bad, the NFZ means Gadaffi's forces are stuck, so protracted civil war it is then,
You think it'd be better to have a short civil war which Gaddafi won? You don't think he'd have massacred thousands of opponents in Benghazi and other areas?
NickC wrote: the infrastructure will collapse, water and food will not get through, starvation, disease and war,
Where? Just generally, or in specific areas?
NickC wrote:great arn't we
Well, I'm pretty amazing yes. Dunno about you. :na:
Jivetango Godfather
"if your arguments are poorly constructed, they are often misinterperetated" - CJ
NickC
Member
Posts: 187
Joined: Tue Jul 15, 2008 1:03 pm
Contact:

Re: Libya

Report a concern about this post

Post by NickC »

David Bailey wrote:You think it'd be better to have a short civil war which Gaddafi won? You don't think he'd have massacred thousands of opponents in Benghazi and other areas?


Where? Just generally, or in specific areas?


Well, I'm pretty amazing yes. Dunno about you. :na:

Do you think a civil war lasting say 2 years would leave less dead and what will be the result will be, my prediction is the replacement of a tyrant by another tyrant

Generally, but close to the fighting will be by definition the worse hit.
User avatar
David Bailey
Senior Member
Posts: 17001
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Libya

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Bailey »

NickC wrote:Do you think a civil war lasting say 2 years would leave less dead
Dunno, it's "how long is a piece of string". I don't see how any outcome with Gaddafi as a leader will be acceptable, however, he's proven he's happy to butcher his own people and if he stayed in power, I'm sure he'd be very happy to provide state sponsorship for Al-Quaeda, he's got form in that area.

So a victorious Gaddafi would mean:
- A large refugee crisis in Europe (and so in the UK)
- Major humanitarian crisis in Libya (thousands of deaths, tens or hundreds of thousands "ethnically cleansed")
- A dictator with a history of support for terrorism (IRA sponsorship, Lockerbie etc.), looking to take revenge on the West.

Besides, it's not a "civil war" - that implies that a significant number of Libyans support Gaddafi, and that's clearly rubbish. It's simply that he's a ruthless dictator with control over a lot of people with guns (they're not an army, they're a bunch of well-armed thugs), which he uses to terrorise the population.
NickC wrote: and what will be the result will be, my prediction is the replacement of a tyrant by another tyrant
As happened in Egypt, you mean? Where the dictator got booted out, and the Egyptian people have voted in a referendum for a new constitution in advance of free election?
Jivetango Godfather
"if your arguments are poorly constructed, they are often misinterperetated" - CJ
NickC
Member
Posts: 187
Joined: Tue Jul 15, 2008 1:03 pm
Contact:

Re: Libya

Report a concern about this post

Post by NickC »

David Bailey wrote:Dunno, it's "how long is a piece of string". I don't see how any outcome with Gaddafi as a leader will be acceptable, however, he's proven he's happy to butcher his own people and if he stayed in power, I'm sure he'd be very happy to provide state sponsorship for Al-Quaeda, he's got form in that area.

So a victorious Gaddafi would mean:
- A large refugee crisis in Europe (and so in the UK)
- Major humanitarian crisis in Libya (thousands of deaths, tens or hundreds of thousands "ethnically cleansed")
- A dictator with a history of support for terrorism (IRA sponsorship, Lockerbie etc.), looking to take revenge on the West.

Besides, it's not a "civil war" - that implies that a significant number of Libyans support Gaddafi, and that's clearly rubbish. It's simply that he's a ruthless dictator with control over a lot of people with guns (they're not an army, they're a bunch of well-armed thugs), which he uses to terrorise the population.


As happened in Egypt, you mean? Where the dictator got booted out, and the Egyptian people have voted in a referendum for a new constitution in advance of free election?

A significant number of people do support Gadaffi, they are the ones from his tribe who will have done very well from his leadership.

So its a done deal in Egypt? The F**k up fairy might well make a suprise visit there, you seem to suppose that it all works the same way out there, I assure you it does not.
User avatar
David Bailey
Senior Member
Posts: 17001
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Libya

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Bailey »

NickC wrote:A significant number of people do support Gadaffi, they are the ones from his tribe who will have done very well from his leadership.
Sure, same as in any dictatorship. That's not the same as having the support of ordinary people.
NickC wrote: So its a done deal in Egypt? The F**k up fairy might well make a suprise visit there, you seem to suppose that it all works the same way out there, I assure you it does not.
If you look here, you'll see that:
- The dictator has been thrown out
- The secret police have been disbanded
- The corrupt Parliament has been dissolved, and several members arrested
- Banned political parties have been recognised
- A free and fair referendum on constitutional change has been held
- A Parliamentary election is scheduled for June

That's pretty good progress for 5 weeks, in a country of 80 million. In fact, there are concerns that the election will be too soon - some activists want it to be delayed to give them time to set up their organisations properly.

It's far from a done deal, of course. But it's a damn sight better than most people predicted.
Jivetango Godfather
"if your arguments are poorly constructed, they are often misinterperetated" - CJ
philsmove
Senior Member
Posts: 3166
Joined: Sat Apr 03, 2004 9:03 am

Re: Libya

Report a concern about this post

Post by philsmove »

David Bailey wrote: Where do people see it going from here?
House prices are going to go up

Sorry :flower:
The customer is allways right , but sometimes they are in the wrong place
User avatar
Dreadful Scathe
Senior Member
Posts: 12530
Joined: Sun Jan 20, 2002 12:00 pm
Contact:

Re: Libya

Report a concern about this post

Post by Dreadful Scathe »

philsmove wrote:House prices are going to go up

Sorry :flower:
no, down :)
"defiantly a pork soared" -fletch DS is talking as much sense as most people I've heard - batnurse
"This is a discussion forum, not some sort of hippy poetry-reading commune" - TAFKADJ
philsmove
Senior Member
Posts: 3166
Joined: Sat Apr 03, 2004 9:03 am

Re: Libya

Report a concern about this post

Post by philsmove »

Coalition countries attacking targets in Libya will not supply arms to anti-Gaddafi rebels, UK Defence Secretary Liam Fox has told the BBC.

But are supplying the Gaddafi rebels with training ,advice and intelligence ?


The media keep tell us the rebels are disorganised, yet they seem to be doing quite well attacking Site
The customer is allways right , but sometimes they are in the wrong place
User avatar
David Bailey
Senior Member
Posts: 17001
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Libya

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Bailey »

philsmove wrote:But are supplying the Gaddafi rebels with training ,advice and intelligence ?
It's been officially denied. So yes, I think we can assume it's true :grin:
philsmove wrote:The media keep tell us the rebels are disorganised, yet they seem to be doing quite well attacking Site
They are disorganised. They're basically a bunch of civilians with small arms (AK-47s and RPG), riding on pickup trucks or in cars.

And I'm not at all convinced they can or will take Sirte, at least not easily.

However:
- The heavy equipment of the Gaddafi forces has clearly been turned into junk by the airstrikes, so the Gaddafi forces are mostly dead, demoralised or (at best) reduced to the same level.
- The rebels are not an occupying force, they're a liberating force. All they need to do is drive the Gaddafi forces out of an area.
- This is not a civil war, this is a revolution. There's a real difference between the two.
Jivetango Godfather
"if your arguments are poorly constructed, they are often misinterperetated" - CJ
User avatar
JiveLad
Senior Member
Posts: 2388
Joined: Sun Dec 03, 2006 10:59 am
Contact:

Re: Libya

Report a concern about this post

Post by JiveLad »

David Bailey wrote:
{snip}

Various intelligent posts, usually written with insight and based on the Ceroc-Forum-Reasonable-and-Moderately-Liberal perspective.
Are you auditioning for a position as the Guardian North Africa correspondent or some diplomatic post in Benghazi? Maybe they could do with a Tango venue to bring the 2 sides together in a warm and intimate embrace......

Make ocho's not war!

:nice:
Happy Dancing from Jive Lad
Post Reply