Is there anything new to say about MJ?

Confused by the Accordion Comb Pull Crab?

Spinning gets you dizzy?
Would like some help with a tricky intermediate move? Ask here, and share your fave tips...
You need to be registered / logged in to read this forum
User avatar
Gadget
Senior Member
Posts: 7053
Joined: Wed Oct 09, 2002 9:08 pm
Contact:

Is there anything new to say about MJ?

Report a concern about this post

Post by Gadget »

Twirly wrote:Is there anything new to say about MJ? Actually, that could be a whole new thread in itself!
This forum goes back a long time - lots of questions have been asked and answered... Is there anything new? :confused:
I used to be an angel, you know with halo and those wings;
Now that i'm a devil, my mind's on other things...
My feathers turned to ash, and my harp has broke in two;
I took uppon myself, to have a dance with you...
Magic Hans
Senior Member
Posts: 825
Joined: Mon May 17, 2004 11:00 am

Re: Is there anything new to say about MJ?

Report a concern about this post

Post by Magic Hans »

Gadget wrote:This forum goes back a long time - lots of questions have been asked and answered... Is there anything new? :confused:
Nope!! ... It's all been asked now .... might as well close it all down.


Whilst we're at it, I'm sure that everything's been invented now too .... can we close the Patent Office too?
:na:
User avatar
Double Trouble
Senior Member
Posts: 5534
Joined: Sun Apr 09, 2006 7:19 pm

Re: Is there anything new to say about MJ?

Report a concern about this post

Post by Double Trouble »

Gadget wrote:there anything new?
oh, oh... I bumped into Phil and Ferm from This Morning on the South Bank yesterday morning! They were doing an outside broadcast in a caravan!

Ok, I know this isn't dance related, but I nearly pissed myself with excitement and just had to share! :D
Up there for thinking, down there for dancing
Sporty Jeff
Junior Member
Posts: 55
Joined: Wed Jun 20, 2007 3:47 pm

Re: Is there anything new to say about MJ?

Report a concern about this post

Post by Sporty Jeff »

Double Trouble wrote:oh, oh... I bumped into Phil and Ferm from This Morning on the South Bank yesterday morning! They were doing an outside broadcast in a caravan!

Yes I love caravans too! :wink:
DavidB
Senior Member
Posts: 2263
Joined: Wed Feb 20, 2002 12:00 pm

Re: Is there anything new to say about MJ?

Report a concern about this post

Post by DavidB »

Gadget wrote:Is there anything new?
A few things I've been thinking about

Timing of leads - building on from expectation vs anticipation. Is there an equivalent of 'resonant frequency', where a light lead at the right time is far more effective than a stronger lead at the wrong time. More importantly, what happens if this frequency is out of sync with the music, or even a different frequency.

Is it harder to spin when you are heavier (and therefore have more friction between you and the ground). Or is is just simply that I can't spin.

Why does MJ still feel better than it looks?

Characterisation of the music.
User avatar
straycat
Senior Member
Posts: 5221
Joined: Mon May 05, 2003 2:32 pm

Re: Is there anything new to say about MJ?

Report a concern about this post

Post by straycat »

DavidB wrote: Is it harder to spin when you are heavier (and therefore have more friction between you and the ground). Or is is just simply that I can't spin.
A few factoids.
  • I've been trying to learn to spin for around twenty years.
  • Ten years ago, I had had little success.
  • Today, I can spin much better than I could ten years ago.
  • I am a lot heavier than I was ten years ago.
  • It is quite possible that none of these facts are related.
(I really want to get my teeth into your timing comment, but I don't think I have time to do it justice this afternoon. Maybe tomorrow)
Straycat
Cheap, but not as cheap as your girlfriend... ;)
Rachel
Senior Member
Posts: 1432
Joined: Tue Aug 13, 2002 12:38 pm

Re: Is there anything new to say about MJ?

Report a concern about this post

Post by Rachel »

DavidB wrote:A few things I've been thinking about

Timing of leads - building on from expectation vs anticipation. Is there an equivalent of 'resonant frequency', where a light lead at the right time is far more effective than a stronger lead at the wrong time. More importantly, what happens if this frequency is out of sync with the music, or even a different frequency. ...
Christ, David - I just have to wish for your return and there you appear! The only problem now is understanding your posts. :wink:
R.
User avatar
straycat
Senior Member
Posts: 5221
Joined: Mon May 05, 2003 2:32 pm

Re: Is there anything new to say about MJ?

Report a concern about this post

Post by straycat »

DavidB wrote:Timing of leads - building on from expectation vs anticipation. Is there an equivalent of 'resonant frequency', where a light lead at the right time is far more effective than a stronger lead at the wrong time. More importantly, what happens if this frequency is out of sync with the music, or even a different frequency.
I suspect this is going to be one of those ones where I feel I know what you're talking about, but you're actually talking about something quite different. I'll assume I know what you're talking about ;)
Wouldn't such a 'resonant frequency' depend very much on your partner, rather than on the music? It seems obvious (to me) that a light lead at the right time is going to be the more effective option - the trick is judging the 'right time', or finessing it so that it occurs when you want it to. Which will depend on your partner, her movements and her responses to your lead.

Simple example: right to right handhold. prep a spin by turning your partner a little anti-clockwise, spin her clockwise. Easy enough. You could quite easily do this by starting the prep on 1, then pushing her round with a powerful lead on 2, and it would work.

A different way of looking at it was summed up by a martial arts friend of mine who was talking about fighting techniques - the philosophy he subscribes to is 'Listen, Follow, Change'.
'Listen' to what your opponent is doing (with your body, not your ears :whistle :)
'Follow' their movement.
'Change' that movement (to him, that change seems to involve throwing them against walls, floors and on, but I think that in this context it can involve a little less drama)

Applying it to said example, after the prep, you 'listen' to get a feel for your partner's direction / speed / power of movement, 'follow' it, then change it by gently absorbing that momentum, and redirecting it back the other way to get a spin.

This probably sounds like a ridiculously overblown and unnecessary analysis of a perfectly simple move... but the second method, done well, results in a much much smoother, gentler and more energy-efficient lead.

The 'resonance' is in the timing of the absorbtion / redirection - and that dynamic will change from partner to partner.

Or did you mean something else entirely?
DavidB wrote:Why does MJ still feel better than it looks?
Lack of basic technique in the dance?
DavidB wrote:Characterisation of the music.
Not completely clear what you mean here.
Straycat
Cheap, but not as cheap as your girlfriend... ;)
User avatar
stewart38
Senior Member
Posts: 7480
Joined: Fri May 09, 2003 8:56 am

Re: Is there anything new to say about MJ?

Report a concern about this post

Post by stewart38 »

How about being happy with the moves you know and not feeling guilty about not wanting to learn anything new.

Can you share that on a forum or should we all try and 'get better'
User avatar
straycat
Senior Member
Posts: 5221
Joined: Mon May 05, 2003 2:32 pm

Re: Is there anything new to say about MJ?

Report a concern about this post

Post by straycat »

stewart38 wrote:How about being happy with the moves you know and not feeling guilty about not wanting to learn anything new.

Can you share that on a forum or should we all try and 'get better'
Nothing wrong with that, in my book. If I could take that approach, I'd probably be much happier with my dancing.... but we all have different things driving us, and personally I love learning, and I always want to improve my dancing.

However - and this is probably going to sound pedantic, but to me, it's a huge distinction - I don't equate getting better with learning more moves. I equate getting better with improving my technique - that's what I find the most rewarding.
Straycat
Cheap, but not as cheap as your girlfriend... ;)
User avatar
Double Trouble
Senior Member
Posts: 5534
Joined: Sun Apr 09, 2006 7:19 pm

Re: Is there anything new to say about MJ?

Report a concern about this post

Post by Double Trouble »

DavidB wrote:Why does MJ still feel better than it looks?
That's an easy one...

MJ is like sex...only good looking, fit, sexy people look good when they are doing it, the rest of us mere mortals look like oompa loompa's on crack. :sick:
Up there for thinking, down there for dancing
User avatar
Twirly
Senior Member
Posts: 4204
Joined: Tue May 30, 2006 11:17 am

Re: Is there anything new to say about MJ?

Report a concern about this post

Post by Twirly »

Double Trouble wrote:That's an easy one...

MJ is like sex...only good looking, fit, sexy people look good when they are doing it, the rest of us mere mortals look like oompa loompa's on crack. :sick:
:lol:

And sad to say, I agree! Was thinking about this whilst I was out dancing last night. Admittedly, some basic dance technique does help the oompa loompa's not look quite so bad.

MJ as taught by Ceroc (which is what I have experience of) is about learning moves. There is very little technique taught, and even less about things like posture and precision. A move is taught in class, the class repeats it a few times, then goes off and “dances” it with no concept of how it actually looks, just how it feels.

Contrast that to other forms of dance, which are frequently taught in front of floor to ceiling mirrors – can you imagine the trauma that would cause at your average MJ class! :eek: :rofl: I’m thinking here of my (long ago) experience of jazz dance and ballet. You were taught to stand properly, how to hold your head, how to shape your arm, how to point your toe. How to structure your whole body to make it look as good as possible. And then you were taught to move. Each element of that movement and the shape you created with it would be broken down. Not only would you watch the teacher do it, and watch yourself in the mirror trying to replicate it, the teacher would then come around and pull you into the correct position so you could see how it felt to do it properly. And the movements are precise and controlled – this is almost completely lacking in much of MJ, and isn’t even taught as a concept. I try to apply it to my dancing because of what I’ve learnt in the past, but I simply don’t have the control I did due to age and the fact that I’m not doing a class every day.

Now I am not suggesting that MJ adopt this model, but it might go some way to explaining why some dances/dancers look a lot better than MJ. From my handful of AT classes, there is an element of this going on there too – less detailed, and in the class I was in I was drilled less, but you are taught how to point your foot whilst walking, where to place your hand on your partner’s shoulder, how to walk, etc and if you’re not doing it right, the teacher will come and correct you. Am sure the more experienced could elaborate, but the dance is broken down in more detail. I’ve never been corrected in MJ once without asking for it. Maybe someone else can confirm what happens in ballroom or other dance styles, but I would expect the same kind of detailed analysis and requirements for control to be present.

MJ is fun, relaxed and it’s not pretentious. But it’s also relatively uncontrolled and undisciplined compared to other dances. Am not too sure that you could get the discipline in without losing the fun… (stands by for jokes about :whip :)
Life is a journey. Death is the destination. So you’d better make sure it’s one hell of a journey!
bigdjiver
Senior Member
Posts: 4899
Joined: Mon Mar 03, 2003 1:38 am
Contact:

Re: Is there anything new to say about MJ?

Report a concern about this post

Post by bigdjiver »

DavidB wrote:... Timing of leads - building on from expectation vs anticipation. Is there an equivalent of 'resonant frequency', where a light lead at the right time is far more effective than a stronger lead at the wrong time...
There are better words than "resonant frequency" for the effect in electronics, but I cannot remember what they are. :blush: and in Judo, but I never learned those.
...More importantly, what happens if this frequency is out of sync with the music, or even a different frequency...
As you know it is possible to block a lady with minimal force, at the right time, even if she has not been trained to expect it. I suspect it is on a par with hitting a ball with a bat. It is possible to teach the basics and the concept, but being able to do it is down to experience and practise.
...Why does MJ still feel better than it looks?...
I have just spent some time looking at some clips of a class. I was saddened to see how bad I looked, and surprised to see how disjointed some others looked. Lots of little breaks in the dance where partners were reviewing what just went wrong, learning as they danced. What did not surprise me at all was how happy we all were.

The clips did support what others have said. If you want to be a dance professional, or look like a dance professional, you may be better off not learning MJ. However if you want to enjoy dancing and learn whilst you are enjoying yourself, I have found no better way.
...Characterisation of the music...
One of the great, and totally unexpected, joys MJ has brought me is that I can really enjoy dancing to Latin music and Tango without ever had a lesson in either. Even more unexpectedly, and beyond my imaginings, is that my partner can enjoy it too.
Rachel
Senior Member
Posts: 1432
Joined: Tue Aug 13, 2002 12:38 pm

Re: Is there anything new to say about MJ?

Report a concern about this post

Post by Rachel »

straycat wrote: ... Applying it to said example, after the prep, you 'listen' to get a feel for your partner's direction / speed / power of movement, 'follow' it, then change it by gently absorbing that momentum, and redirecting it back the other way to get a spin....
Love it! Can I steal that quote, please?
stewart38 wrote:How about being happy with the moves you know and not feeling guilty about not wanting to learn anything new.
There is absolutely nothing wrong with this, IMO, unless:
- you think that you absolutely know it all
- you still do classes but only for the purpose of showing off to your partner how good you are by doing 'your' version of the move, ahead of the rest of the class, rather than what's being taught.
Twirly wrote:I’m thinking here of my (long ago) experience of jazz dance and ballet. You were taught to stand properly, how to hold your head, how to shape your arm, how to point your toe. How to structure your whole body to make it look as good as possible. And then you were taught to move. Each element of that movement and the shape you created with it would be broken down. Not only would you watch the teacher do it, and watch yourself in the mirror trying to replicate it, the teacher would then come around and pull you into the correct position so you could see how it felt to do it properly. ...

... MJ is fun, relaxed and it’s not pretentious. But it’s also relatively uncontrolled and undisciplined compared to other dances. Am not too sure that you could get the discipline in without losing the fun… (stands by for jokes about :whip :)
Agree completely! Although Marc has jumped off the stage several times during a class to go and correct people's positions - much to their surprise.

Rachel
User avatar
straycat
Senior Member
Posts: 5221
Joined: Mon May 05, 2003 2:32 pm

Re: Is there anything new to say about MJ?

Report a concern about this post

Post by straycat »

Rachel wrote:Love it! Can I steal that quote, please?
Be my guest! Not that it was really my quote in the first place...
Straycat
Cheap, but not as cheap as your girlfriend... ;)
geoff332
Senior Member
Posts: 677
Joined: Sat Oct 13, 2007 10:07 pm

Re: Is there anything new to say about MJ?

Report a concern about this post

Post by geoff332 »

DavidB wrote:Timing of leads - building on from expectation vs anticipation. Is there an equivalent of 'resonant frequency', where a light lead at the right time is far more effective than a stronger lead at the wrong time. More importantly, what happens if this frequency is out of sync with the music, or even a different frequency.
It really depends on what you define as the lead. In my view, there are a whole lot of elements to the lead, which vary, but the lead itself is very near to continuous. For a simple travelling return, we step back and create tension. I lead the follow forward, giving flight. I raise my arm and invite her to turn under, providing direction. As she travels and turns I keep my leading hand over her head. When she gets to the end of the turn and faces me, she should give me compression which I then use to step back into tension read for the next movement.

All of this is leading... getting each part at the right time is really important (and the exact timing depends on the move, the follow, the music etc). As a rule, I find the best follows almost effortless to lead if the timing of my lead is right (that is, all the energy of the movement is provided by the tension/compression between the two partners). If either of us gets it wrong, I feel the lead become a lot harder: I have to provide the energy for the movement from my muscles.
DavidB wrote:Is it harder to spin when you are heavier (and therefore have more friction between you and the ground). Or is is just simply that I can't spin.
Everyone can improve spinning with practice. Some people do need more practice than others. As I've said repeatedly, one of the biggest differences between Ceroc in the UK and Ceroc in NZ is at the start of every class in NZ they have a short drill that includes spinning and finding the beat to music. The whole drill takes about 5 minutes and has the net effect of making the average punter in NZ significantly better at these two basic dance skills.
straycat wrote:...a ridiculously overblown and unnecessary analysis of a perfectly simple move...
I find this sort of analysis is really useful. Understanding what's going on inside a move is reasonably important, particularly if you want to take yourself beyond the things that you feel naturally comfortable doing.
straycat wrote:
DavidB wrote:Why does MJ still feel better than it looks?
Lack of basic technique in the dance?
Twirly wrote:
Double Trouble wrote:MJ is like sex...only good looking, fit, sexy people look good when they are doing it, the rest of us mere mortals look like oompa loompa's on crack.
And sad to say, I agree! Was thinking about this whilst I was out dancing last night. Admittedly, some basic dance technique does help the oompa loompa's not look quite so bad.
It's amazing how much better someone's dancing looks if they straighten their spine, roll their shoulders back and stop sticking their butt out; that gives you a good frame. Then there's controlling your balance and weight (ie keeping your weight over your feet, not the amount of weight you have). That links into smaller steps, less reaching, staying closer to your partner. Perhaps it's worth thinking about leading from the body, rather than waving your hands all over the place. Learning how to spin properly. All of this is basic partner dancing technique, and nothing to do with body size/shape/oompa loompaness.

Admittedly someone with a svelte shape would look better than I would if they have good technique; but I am pretty sure I look better on the dance floor than the hottest guy around who slouches forward and stick their butt out. Equally, I know it feels much better for me when I'm dancing that way and, based on the comments I've heard, it feels much better for my partner.

Personally, I find the hand jerking up and down both unattractive and unappealing, but some people seem to like it (I am still talking about dancing here).
Twirly wrote:MJ as taught by Ceroc (which is what I have experience of) is about learning moves. There is very little technique taught, and even less about things like posture and precision.
That's ceroc's wings of wax. By not teaching that stuff, they make the dance far more appealing to novices, who generally seem to assume that sort of stuff doesn't matter. Unfortunately, it also severely limits the progress one can make: I don't know of a single good dancer who doesn't have very good technique; without it, your wings melt. If you've learned dancing sans technique, then you often need to go back and unlearn a whole raft of bad habits before you can relearn and then progress on.
Twirly wrote:I try to apply it to my dancing because of what I’ve learnt in the past, but I simply don’t have the control I did due to age and the fact that I’m not doing a class every day.
It'll show. Even if your skills have slipped (I know mine have, quite badly), the basics stick with you and it makes a huge difference. Right from my first ceroc class, people realised that I'd done ballroom. The silly thing is, it's actually pretty easy and makes an almost incomparable difference in your dancing...
Twirly wrote:But it’s also relatively uncontrolled and undisciplined compared to other dances. Am not too sure that you could get the discipline in without losing the fun…
I think it can be incorporated, without robbing ceroc of the fun. If I've more time later, I might put some of those ideas down... alternatively, I may go dancing.
Alan Doyle
Member
Posts: 188
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2008 6:41 pm

Re: Is there anything new to say about MJ?

Report a concern about this post

Post by Alan Doyle »

geoff332 wrote:It's amazing how much better someone's dancing looks if they straighten their spine, roll their shoulders back and stop sticking their butt out; that gives you a good frame. Then there's controlling your balance and weight (ie keeping your weight over your feet, not the amount of weight you have). That links into smaller steps, less reaching, staying closer to your partner. Perhaps it's worth thinking about leading from the body, rather than waving your hands all over the place. Learning how to spin properly. All of this is basic partner dancing technique, and nothing to do with body size/shape/oompa loompaness.

:yeah:
User avatar
whitetiger1518
Senior Member
Posts: 2119
Joined: Thu Jul 06, 2006 11:22 am
Contact:

Re: Is there anything new to say about MJ?

Report a concern about this post

Post by whitetiger1518 »

Just my tuppence worth.

Apart from my spins (which if they are "together" something else falls apart:tears :) , I love musicality, and I would love to learn more...

I often hear a phrase and can't act on it, either because my lead has me in the middle of another move, or because I have the position and time to do so, but can't think of a move (wriggle, body roll, pose etc etc) to use. - So I would love to build up a mental library of these styling type of moves - so whenever I hear a phrase I want to style, and I am in a position to take advantage of it, I can.

WT
This is so nice, it must be Illegal!: Fats Waller
Sustained Intensity equals Ecstacy: Wynton Marsalis
bigdjiver
Senior Member
Posts: 4899
Joined: Mon Mar 03, 2003 1:38 am
Contact:

Re: Is there anything new to say about MJ?

Report a concern about this post

Post by bigdjiver »

whitetiger1518 wrote:Just my tuppence worth.

Apart from my spins (which if they are "together" something else falls apart:tears :) , I love musicality, and I would love to learn more...

I often hear a phrase and can't act on it, either because my lead has me in the middle of another move, or because I have the position and time to do so, but can't think of a move (wriggle, body roll, pose etc etc) to use. - So I would love to build up a mental library of these styling type of moves - so whenever I hear a phrase I want to style, and I am in a position to take advantage of it, I can.

WT
As a lead it annoys me when my partner tries to "do her thing" and I am too slow to react and break it up. I know I am supposed to be able to predict when to give her space, but too often it is beyond me. Even a tiny tap of a finger as a signal would be a help (I know, signals are evil ...) Maybe it is as simple as looking at her at the right moment, instead of scanning the surroundings for where it is safe to put her next.

Meanwhile my twitter research is pulling me in all sorts of directions, including this clip of how do to some Beyonce styling.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OcCQwImNd3c
User avatar
whitetiger1518
Senior Member
Posts: 2119
Joined: Thu Jul 06, 2006 11:22 am
Contact:

Re: Is there anything new to say about MJ?

Report a concern about this post

Post by whitetiger1518 »

bigdjiver wrote:As a lead it annoys me when my partner tries to "do her thing" and I am too slow to react and break it up. I know I am supposed to be able to predict when to give her space, but too often it is beyond me. Even a tiny tap of a finger as a signal would be a help (I know, signals are evil ...) Maybe it is as simple as looking at her at the right moment, instead of scanning the surroundings for where it is safe to put her next.
Sorry if this is the effect I am having. I certainly don't want to break your flow, but I tend to look at better dancers than me, and wish I could style in a similar vein... If in order to not break the lead's concentration needs a signal then I am quite willing to learn it or whatever else I need to know..

An example that I have used elsewhere is the catapult... Sometimes if I am not spinning well (for whatever reason) I find lots of leads on back to back tracks give me the catapult several times each :tears:

I would be fine with one or two catapults, but any more than that I do get a bit dizzy, so I would love to use the music / styling to give myself a bit of space to recover...

Drathzel gave me a couple of plays that don't go down too badly (particularly in the Blues room), but being able to use them in the ordinary room is not so easy.. If there is a signal or way to do this officially then I am 1st in the queue to learn.

I would hate to alienate any of the leaders who put up with me. :worthy:

Whitetiger
This is so nice, it must be Illegal!: Fats Waller
Sustained Intensity equals Ecstacy: Wynton Marsalis
Post Reply