Maybe it was just Franco opening all the windows to get us in the mood for Strictly Come Ice Dancing?!David Franklin wrote:
Biggest pity for us was it was so freakin' cold in the hall.Bryony never warmed up and we ended up leaving early...
Dave
Hipsters feat. Robert Cordoba
- Feelingpink
- Senior Member
- Posts: 1782
- Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 9:47 am
- Contact:
Re: Hipsters feat. Robert Cordoba
- Rhythm King
- Senior Member
- Posts: 3057
- Joined: Thu Jun 17, 2004 10:16 am
Re: Hipsters feat. Robert Cordoba
The class as taught was really good, RC got through some moves which by my limited WCS standards were quite complicated to lead properly. He even threw in workable variations too. It was obvious from both leaders and followers sides that there were quite a few non-WCS people doing the class. There were some really good WCS people too, unfortunately a sizeable group stayed at the back and didn't spread their experience and wisdom around (Sheepy excused, as he gave a reasonable excuse
I have to agree with what people said about watching RC doing his modern jive bit, but it probably hit the mark for a lot of the people who were there last night.
Post class, it was a different story. I'm a big fan of Jon Brett, but overall, given the WCS class and crowd there, a lot of slower tracks would've been welcome. On a general note, it helps if two or three slower tracks are played back to back as it gives the budding West Coaster time to finish the dance he's probably just asked someone for, and then go and find another WCS partner, before it all speeds up again.
The other problem was in relation to floor craft. I know some people are not keen on Lindy for example, but I happen to enjoy it. I do try to ensure the safety of my partner and surrounding dancers at all times, whatever style I'm dancing, but people can sometimes get a bit exuberant, whatever they're dancing and I appreciate this can be frustrating, if not downright dangerous on occasions (thinking lifts and drops particularly). The thing was, last night it was the modern jivers who were quite often the problem. I can't count the number of times I experienced or witnessed people moving into the slot behind WCS dancers, where they were obviously aiming to place their partners. Can't we all try to be a bit more tolerant and observant of others' space on the floor?
As for Robert Cordoba's dancing, on two occasions I was stopped dead in my tracks. Once, when he was dancing with the fabulous Catriona Wiles, what a spectacle and an inspiration to try harder
Finally my apologies to those I didn't get to dance with, but I was hardly off the floor. In spite of the above it was a great night.
R-K
- ChrisA
- Senior Member
- Posts: 3831
- Joined: Wed Sep 10, 2003 11:00 am
Re: Hipsters feat. Robert Cordoba
As indeed it often is. I've been most careful to refer to the "inconsiderate Lindy people" rather than "the Lindy people", since some are very considerate, and I would not tar all with the same brush.Rhythm King wrote:The other problem was in relation to floor craft. I know some people are not keen on Lindy for example, but I happen to enjoy it. I do try to ensure the safety of my partner and surrounding dancers at all times, whatever style I'm dancing, but people can sometimes get a bit exuberant, whatever they're dancing and I appreciate this can be frustrating, if not downright dangerous on occasions (thinking lifts and drops particularly). The thing was, last night it was the modern jivers who were quite often the problem.
However, to my untutored eye, Lindy does seem to intrinsically need more space, and bad Lindy is often very flailing indeed.
Regrettably, it would appear not.Can't we all try to be a bit more tolerant and observant of others' space on the floor?
As I've said before, the organisers have no real interest in solving the problem of dangerous and inconsiderate dancers, since it would hit them in their wallet, presumably (though I would pay more for a venue where it was solved).
And it's the inconsiderate ones that gain most, since they get all the space they want while the rest of us keep out of their way.
Grrrrr...
- Sheepman
- Senior Member
- Posts: 3687
- Joined: Wed May 14, 2003 4:52 pm
- Contact:
Re: Hipsters feat. Robert Cordoba
Be prepared for rather a long list, I think I mentioned 400 or so for starters... and David has a whole lot more.djtrev wrote: it would be nice if you could share your list of tracks with us
Greg
- Graham W
- Senior Member
- Posts: 542
- Joined: Sun Feb 16, 2003 11:44 pm
Re: Hipsters feat. Robert Cordoba
..he was fab in bristol last year - pitched the class to the people there (not Hipsters standard) gave a v good demo with Lily & made the demonstrator for a beginners class (the lovely Marie) look good at 10mins notice!ElaineB wrote:Hello from Bristol!
I had a mixed night last night! This was my third time at WCS (huge gaps in between!) and as usual find Robert's instructions very easy to follow as he calls out the timing. However! Some of the Guys blatantly ignored his calling and instead of 1,2, 123, 123 in the sugar push, danced 1,2, 123, 1,2 and pulled through on that beat! Then to cap it all, when the Lady was supposed to do her 'thing', I followed RC's instructions to block the guys hand (hello, I am doing something!!!) and found myself in an arm wrestling competition with the Guy furiously attempting to pull me through!![]()
![]()
When I was lucky enough to get a partner who had previously done WCS, it was lovely, although by then I had lost the confidence to do the 'Ladies' bit!
The up side was that I had some really lovely dances with some new people and some of the 'old hands' (thanks Sheepman - ever the Gent!), but managed to be 'perved' big time This is the second time - different Guy, I hasten to add!![]()
The music was dissapointing and I had hoped for some WCS to follow the lesson and consolidate what I had just learned, but as Chris A says it was far too fast. And as for that Jive Aces track - sorry, but yuch!
As for RC - he really is a good ambassador for dance Gods - I didn't dance with him last night, but when he came to Bristol about 18 months ago, I had two dances with him and he gave me the impression that he enjoyed himself, despite the fact that I had only been dancing for 9 months! So as far as I am concerned, he gets my vote anytime!![]()
![]()
![]()
Elaine
PS - Arrived home at 2.15am.............5 hours sleep............zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
G
- jockey
- Senior Member
- Posts: 316
- Joined: Wed Oct 20, 2004 9:07 pm
Re: Musicality: What is it to you?
I issued an invitation to all DJs on their own bit of this forum (which I found fascinating to read - which tracks they like and dislike; lots of slagging of for liking 'X' instead of 'Y'; qwhen to play it slow etc.,) to give me and anyone else inrterested a run down of the criteria for their playlist e.g., old favourites (when and where?) fast and slow (when and where?) difficult tracks vs easy etc.ChrisA wrote:Well on this occasion I'm mostly criticising the music - elsewhere I've banged on about inconsiderate dancers on crowded floors.
I've been dancing at Hipsters for a couple of years or so now, and usually I've enjoyed it, except when it's been too packed to dance without stress. But I do think that the music mix needs updating, and I'm obviously not the only one.
Well, for most visiting teachers I'd agree. But Robert Cordoba isn't just any visiting teacher. And there were a number of people in the class that almost never do classes, which IMHO says a lot.
To put on predominantly slower music (for a change) to make it possible for those people (and lots of others) to benefit from such a treat is hardly hijacking the night.
Chris
This is a golden opportunity for them to hold forth: should the music be geared to that of the (noteworthy) visiting teacher for the benefit of those who have come sometimes miles especially to sample something different taught by a leader in that field? The answer is bl....dy obvious....
- jockey
- Senior Member
- Posts: 316
- Joined: Wed Oct 20, 2004 9:07 pm
Re: Musicality: What is it to you?
jockey wrote:I issued an invitation to all DJs on their own bit of this forum (which I found fascinating to read - which tracks they like and dislike]Postscript ~ The post was 133 on 'The DJ Booth' Favourite Dance Tracks..I just checked : thankyou for the response to 'why oh why so much latin?' but as yet there has been no response to my polite request for reasons DJs play what they do when they do..
-
Lounge Lizard
- Senior Member
- Posts: 1435
- Joined: Tue Aug 05, 2003 11:00 am
Re: Hipsters feat. Robert Cordoba
My approach in this circumstance is the busier the room the slower the music - this keeps dancing safer - if the organiser wants really fast music, limit the numbers to provide space for the resulting dance style
if you want WCS swing music I am playing a blues'ish set at Ashtons tonight - guaranteed to be WCS'able
LL
- ChrisA
- Senior Member
- Posts: 3831
- Joined: Wed Sep 10, 2003 11:00 am
Re: Hipsters feat. Robert Cordoba
Ah... the voice of common sense.Lounge Lizard wrote:My approach in this circumstance is the busier the room the slower the music - this keeps dancing safer - if the organiser wants really fast music, limit the numbers to provide space for the resulting dance style
And from one of the best...
Have some rep
- Gadget
- Senior Member
- Posts: 7053
- Joined: Wed Oct 09, 2002 9:08 pm
- Contact:
Re: Hipsters feat. Robert Cordoba
Rhythm King wrote:The other problem was in relation to floor craft. ...The thing was, last night it was the modern jivers who were quite often the problem. I can't count the number of times I experienced or witnessed people moving into the slot behind WCS dancers, where they were obviously aiming to place their partners. Can't we all try to be a bit more tolerant and observant of others' space on the floor?
Personally, I don't think that 'slots' can work on a crowded dance floor - you have to be flexable enough in your dance space to expand and contract into any oportune space. A fixed 'slot' is too ridged a form for this.
... Unless you are takling about line dancing
Now that i'm a devil, my mind's on other things...
My feathers turned to ash, and my harp has broke in two;
I took uppon myself, to have a dance with you...
-
Savant
- Junior Member
- Posts: 12
- Joined: Wed Dec 01, 2004 12:00 pm
Re: Hipsters feat. Robert Cordoba
You could fit a lot more people doing WCS onto a dancefloor than you can fit people doing MJ. Dancing in a slot takes up a lot less space than dancing in a circular motion.Gadget wrote:Personally, I don't think that 'slots' can work on a crowded dance floor - you have to be flexable enough in your dance space to expand and contract into any oportune space. A fixed 'slot' is too ridged a form for this.
As for 'fixed' slots. Any half-decent WCS dancer will be able to lead his partner into space if there is one, and not if there isn't. Adjusting is as easy, if not easier than adjusting your modern jive to take advantage of space.
When you've actually seen some, Mr. Gadget, then maybe you'll be able to comment with more than a guess perhaps?
-
Jon Brett
- Member
- Posts: 147
- Joined: Mon Sep 30, 2002 5:27 pm
Re: Hipsters feat. Robert Cordoba
Difficult choice having Hipsters regulars & lots of WCS visitors at the same time. Do you keep the visitors happy and upset the regulars, or keep the visitors happy & upset the regulars?
The "Jive Aces" track was a request from one of our regulars. Referring to my comment above, if you ain't happy, tell the DJ. If you want something played, tell the DJ. He might listen.
I was watching the floor the whole night & had a good floor throughout. Which is my job. It wouldn't be so crowded on the floor if I didn't. So to suggest that most people weren't happy is not a fair reflection on the evening.
As to new tracks, every week I play tracks you haven't heard before. Perhaps I should take more "risks" as suggested - I'll have a think on that one & bear it in mind.
Finally, thank you once again for the feedback. Keep it coming. I do read it all and think about it more than you perhaps realise!
-
RobC
- Senior Member
- Posts: 534
- Joined: Fri Jul 04, 2003 6:32 pm
Re: Hipsters feat. Robert Cordoba
And that is one important aspect of floorcraft that just isn't taught in your typical MJ night...... but more importantlyGadget wrote: but if I am on a busy dance floor and see a space open around me, then I will take advantage of it. Either by guiding my partner into it or moving into it my self.
And this is the part that all but the top dancers seem to forget. All to often 'leaders' are too wrapped up in what they are doing, occasionally looking out for space for their partner to dance in (if the follower is lucky) that they completely disregard everyone else dancing around them.The only time I would pass it up is if ....... I noticed someone about to move into it.
This is standard floorcraft, regardless of style, speed of music or anything else. It doesn't matter if you are doing MJ and the couple one side of you is Lindying, and you have a WCS on the other side with someone Quickstepping around the floor, it is common courtesy (which seems sadly lacking in today's society as a whole, not just in MJ) to pay attention to what everyone else around you is doing.
Going back to the WCS couple dancing next to you, it should be abundantly clear that all their movements are between point A and point B on the floor, and if they are part way through a sequence then may not be at point A/B at the time, but it's a fair bet that within a bar or two they will be back there. [/rant over]
Apart from that I had a great night
-
bigdjiver
- Senior Member
- Posts: 4899
- Joined: Mon Mar 03, 2003 1:38 am
- Contact:
Re: Hipsters feat. Robert Cordoba
RobC wrote:... This is standard floorcraft, regardless of style, speed of music or anything else. It doesn't matter if you are doing MJ and the couple one side of you is Lindying, and you have a WCS on the other side with someone Quickstepping around the floor, it is common courtesy (which seems sadly lacking in today's society as a whole, not just in MJ) to pay attention to what everyone else around you is doing. ..
I think there is a quantum leap between floorcraft in MJ and floorcraft in a mixed environment. We all predict from experience. It does not take too much experience to recognise a Lindy swingout, or that they are going to kick this way after kicking that, but it does take some. Equally the MJ moves that involve travel are pretty easy to recognise early on, if you have that experience under your belt.
It is easier to recognise common moves than the less often seen expert ones. If you get experts from many different genres in one place, each strutting their specialist stuff, even the most advanced predictive skills are overloaded. In those circumstances the only solutions are lots of room to manouvre, or for everybody to "dance down", or for the dance to be genre restricted. In the days of ballroom each dance was identified by the time signature, and there was supposed to be only one dance form happening at a time. The versatility of MJ has brought its own problems.
- latinlover
- Senior Member
- Posts: 352
- Joined: Wed Jun 23, 2004 7:05 am
Re: Hipsters feat. Robert Cordoba
bigdjiver In the days of ballroom each dance was identified by the time signature, and there was supposed to be only one dance form happening at a time. The versatility of MJ has brought its own problems.[/QUOTE wrote:
In my admittedly limited experience of ballrom dancing, even when everyone is dancing the same dance in the same direction around the floor, floorcraft is still a major issue. I guess it always will be when you mix skill & experience levels.
I have witnessed 'Hotshots' and the clumsy beginners (I'm one myself) and the social dancers who are just having a good chat while they slow foxtrot around and get in people's way and aren't aware of what anyone else might do.
It's just the rich mixture of personalities that makes up human nature ,you will find the same patterns in all aspects of human interaction.
no amount of whingeing will make those who are so far up themselves change. Some who are interested enough will learn to cope better, some are not able to do anything other than concentrate on their own dancing.
It's life , just deal with it!
- Gadget
- Senior Member
- Posts: 7053
- Joined: Wed Oct 09, 2002 9:08 pm
- Contact:
Re: Hipsters feat. Robert Cordoba
This is sort of my point]every[/i] move that everyone else is doing arround me; If I am used to MJ, how am I meant to know that all their movements are between point A and B. Especially when the slot may be rotating to take advantage of their own space available?RobC wrote:Going back to the WCS couple dancing next to you, it should be abundantly clear that all their movements are between point A and point B on the floor, and if they are part way through a sequence then may not be at point A/B at the time, but it's a fair bet that within a bar or two they will be back there.
From the previous posts, it sounds like WCS dancers expect everyone to keep their slot clear - "a bar or two" is a long time (4/4 music - 4 beats to the bar; 4-8 beats; 2-4 MJ counts): I could have done an MJ move and retracted from that space again in that time.
The main floorcraft skill of using space is identifying 'opening' spaces rather than 'closing' spaces. When I am moving out of a space, it is opening. When I am moving into a space it is closing. A truley 'free' space (neither opening or closing) is where most of the danger lies - anyone around it may want to take advantage of it.
I admit that dancing in a slot takes up less space than dancing in a circle would, but MJ is not dancing in a circle: most of it is amorphus - expanding and contracting. MJ is taught in a 'slot'. I dance in a 'cross' that rotates to fit the space.Savant wrote:You could fit a lot more people doing WCS onto a dancefloor than you can fit people doing MJ. Dancing in a slot takes up a lot less space than dancing in a circular motion.
If WCS is danced in a slot - like a matchstick, then if everyone was lined up in the same direction, and moved up and down the slot at the same times, I could see it could taking up less space. If MJ was danced in a strict circle - like a marble, then it would take up more space. But MJ is more like a jelly and the 'circles' squish and deform to take up all the space.
So if it's not a 'fixed slot', and it's easy to adjust to fill space, then what's the problem with other dancers using the 'opening' space you just vacated?As for 'fixed' slots. Any half-decent WCS dancer will be able to lead his partner into space if there is one, and not if there isn't. Adjusting is as easy, if not easier than adjusting your modern jive to take advantage of space.
Perhaps. But does this not raise the same point? The people on the particular dance floor in discussion were mixed dancers, most only introduced to WCS recently; untill they have the experiance that BigDJiver mentioned, how are they to judge their floor craft? anticipate other dancers?When you've actually seen some, Mr. Gadget, then maybe you'll be able to comment with more than a guess perhaps?
Now that i'm a devil, my mind's on other things...
My feathers turned to ash, and my harp has broke in two;
I took uppon myself, to have a dance with you...
-
Savant
- Junior Member
- Posts: 12
- Joined: Wed Dec 01, 2004 12:00 pm
Re: Hipsters feat. Robert Cordoba
None. No problem.Gadget wrote:So if it's not a 'fixed slot', and it's easy to adjust to fill space, then what's the problem with other dancers using the 'opening' space you just vacated?
And I would disagree with what Rhythm King said. You are not responsible to watch other dancers and not fill 'their' space. If there's a space on the dancefloor, then you can send your partner into it. And the WCS dancer who was intending to use that space will have to find another (this applies within reason of course).
WCS, while a slotted dance, does not have to be up and down the same tramlines for the entire 3.5 minutes. When dancing WCS, I wouldn't expect to face in only two directions the whole time.
On another note, I quite often find that (most) people are more reasonable when the floor is fuller. Conversely, I seem to be bumped into more often when the floor is emptier, as people then seem to think that they have a licence for big moves (not necessarily dips/aerials).
- Zebra Woman
- Senior Member
- Posts: 2106
- Joined: Sun Apr 11, 2004 1:36 pm
Re: Hipsters feat. Robert Cordoba
You want more? Are you Sure? Love you JB xxxJon Brett wrote:Thanks for the feedback on the music last night everyone. Just wish you'd come to me and said it at the time, then I could do something about it on the spot.
Difficult choice having Hipsters regulars & lots of WCS visitors at the same time. Do you keep the visitors happy and upset the regulars, or keep the visitors happy & upset the regulars?
...I was watching the floor the whole night & had a good floor throughout. Which is my job. It wouldn't be so crowded on the floor if I didn't. So to suggest that most people weren't happy is not a fair reflection on the evening.
...Finally, thank you once again for the feedback. Keep it coming. I do read it all and think about it more than you perhaps realise!
Not talking about Robert Cordoba night ...but Tuesday nights in general.
When Andy and Rena were teaching Lindy downstairs the freestyle music included Lindy tracks which were too fast for me to enjoy jiving to . I sat them out and it seemed fair enough at the time as Hipsters was billed as a mix of Modern Jive and Swing.
Now David and Lily are teaching WCS downstairs it seems logical to me to play a proportion of slower tracks for WCS. I don't feel that we are getting the same 'musical' consideration as the Lindy hoppers had. It seems to me that plenty of Lindy is still being played even though Lindy is not taught there anymore .
Is it just me?
When I learned Salsa 7 years ago it was a fledgling class in MK and all the freestyle music was slow/med and I remember the dances would regularly falling to pieces when the music reached a certain BPM. For the last few years the freestyle salsa music has been blastingly fast to satisfy the experienced dancers and teachers...and the poor beginners look on in awe for a bit and then drift off home. I think where footwork is involved there is a gradual speeding up that is part of the journey.
The difference between Salsa and WCS? Well one of them...... If you keep losing it in WCS 'cos the music is too fast for you, you can slip into jive and keep dancing....and the problem is invisible to the DJ.
Unless we go and tell him. Fair point JB. Although I did talk to you about this on 23rd Nov when you played a wonderfully slower than usual set.
Is it possible to keep us all happy JB? Tough Job . Rather you than me.
Alison xx
-
MartinHarper
- Senior Member
- Posts: 4157
- Joined: Mon Jul 12, 2004 4:24 pm
Lindy needs space
Interesting observation. Personally I find that my Lindy has the ability to use more space than my jive. I also find that with Lindy I can move around the floor quicker, because Lindy follows have more "momentum". However, I wouldn't say that my Lindy needs more space, because Lindy also gives me more options to dance small, compared to the jive I've been taught.ChrisA wrote:To my untutored eye, Lindy does seem to intrinsically need more space
- Rhythm King
- Senior Member
- Posts: 3057
- Joined: Thu Jun 17, 2004 10:16 am
Re: Hipsters feat. Robert Cordoba
Sorry, I wasn't trying to suggest that people should give the WCS people a vacuum in which to dance, and I agree with what both you and Gadget have said about taking advantage of spaces which open up. David B and Paul Warden both teach that during WCS moves such as the whip, which involves the lady travelling, that one looks over one's shoulder first to ensure the slot is clear before potentially launching the lady into someone else. Incidentally when inflicting my inexperienced WCS lead on someone, I always try to stay at the side of the floor, parallel to the walls, so as to take up as little space as possible. My comments were directed more at a certain type of dancer who simply "closes down" other couples on the floor, for his own benefit, without any consideration. No matter how careful one is there will always be some bumps on a crowded floor, and recognition of this with a wave, or an apology is much nicer than being trampled on by the same person, more than once, without so much as a "by your leave" - or indeed being given a firm shove in the back by them, as happened on TuesdaySavant wrote:None. No problem.
And I would disagree with what Rhythm King said. You are not responsible to watch other dancers and not fill 'their' space. If there's a space on the dancefloor, then you can send your partner into it. And the WCS dancer who was intending to use that space will have to find another (this applies within reason of course).
WCS, while a slotted dance, does not have to be up and down the same tramlines for the entire 3.5 minutes. When dancing WCS, I wouldn't expect to face in only two directions the whole time.
I agree with you but, as you said yourself, if there's a space on the dancefloor, then you can send your partner into it, and also I think it depends on the speed of the music to some extent.SAVANT wrote:On another note, I quite often find that (most) people are more reasonable when the floor is fuller. Conversely, I seem to be bumped into more often when the floor is emptier, as people then seem to think that they have a licence for big moves (not necessarily dips/aerials).