Are the names of moves important to you...???
-
MartinHarper
- Senior Member
- Posts: 4157
- Joined: Mon Jul 12, 2004 4:24 pm
Re: Are the names of moves important to you...???
- Gordon J Pownall
- Senior Member
- Posts: 1000
- Joined: Thu Oct 10, 2002 11:00 am
Re: Are the names of moves important to you...???
I would love to and on an thread somewhere, you will see that accommodation is ready and raring to go - the thread listed people in Oz and the UK who could accommodate visitors from other places....Yliander wrote:so very good to hearcan you come dance with me .....
You're more than welcome when Sally and I come to Oz for our teaching tour with Nicky H...
Just don't know when yet...
~ It's a Dance Thing ~
www.vatsim-uk.org
-
The Pilgrim
- Junior Member
- Posts: 20
- Joined: Mon Aug 02, 2004 7:20 pm
Re: Are the names of moves important to you...???
----------------
"A seeker of truth is no stranger to controversy."
-
alex
- Junior Member
- Posts: 96
- Joined: Thu Jan 17, 2002 11:39 am
Re: Are the names of moves important to you...???
I'd be interested to know where you teach, as you believe you have more knowledge, better teaching skills, and a better memory than all the teachers you comment on.
alex
-
under par
- Senior Member
- Posts: 6312
- Joined: Mon Feb 09, 2004 2:08 pm
- Contact:
Re: Are the names of moves important to you...???
alex wrote:Pilgrim
I'd be interested to know where you teach, as you believe you have more knowledge, better teaching skills, and a better memory than all the teachers you comment on.
alex
yeah let us hear a bit more about the pilgrims credentials!!!
- Gordon J Pownall
- Senior Member
- Posts: 1000
- Joined: Thu Oct 10, 2002 11:00 am
Re: Are the names of moves important to you...???
The Pilgrim wrote:Giving ‘]
Errr........asinine.....???
I often will write down the names of the intermediate class that I intend to teach and have it up on stage with me on the floor of the stage as a reminder.How does this affect you as a dancer...??? Is the bit of paper, hidden out of sight off putting...???
![]()
Does it distract you from looking at the teacher / your partner...???![]()
I teach usually four nights / week and avoid teaching the same routine every night as many dancers come to more than one of my venues.....
I am curious as to why you think that a teacher making sure he or she is prepared, confident in what he / she is about to teach and takes a precaution to ensure the best possible delivery is asinine...???![]()
Surely having an aide memiore is better that forgetting the name / beats of a move / routine...???
No different that when learning a choreographed routine - having a guide available is a safety precaution - that's all and many renowned teachershave the moves written down and prepared.
And...considering I tend to teach straight after work and with three different demonstrators at 3 or four different venues, I see it is as a useful way of ensuring both I and my demonstrator deliver a quality product.![]()
Of course at Sainsbury's, Tescos, B&Q etc, the girls / blokes on the tills don't have a list of products / items which they refer to do they... No... they remember every single item in the store....NOT
Not a good post - have to give you negative rep for this one mate...
I'm still curious about your background as it appears that you are avoiding in this and other threads, giving us forumites an isight into your background and experience... or are you just stirring the pot without being willing to stand by your own convictions / observations / comments
It might give us humble readers of your knowledgeable posts a foundation upon which to base our perspective - for all we know, you could be James Cronin and therefore well qualified to make some of the comments you have.....
Then again......
On a final note, I do welcome your observations - even more so I welcome your criticisms as they, in particular, reveal so much about you to me......
~ It's a Dance Thing ~
www.vatsim-uk.org
- jiveoholic
- Member
- Posts: 161
- Joined: Fri Feb 01, 2002 12:13 pm
Re: Are the names of moves important to you...???
- Andy McGregor
- Senior Member
- Posts: 9276
- Joined: Mon Mar 03, 2003 12:00 pm
Re: Are the names of moves important to you...???
And that comment reveals to me that Gordy is annoyed, and he's trying to get even in a subtle way. Don't be subtle, go round his house and break his train-setGordon J Pownall wrote: On a final note, I do welcome your observations - even more so I welcome your criticisms as they, in particular, reveal so much about you to me......![]()
And, on a final note, Gordy's comment reveals so much more about Gordy. But does this comment reveal anything new about me - I think not: you already knew it all
-
The Pilgrim
- Junior Member
- Posts: 20
- Joined: Mon Aug 02, 2004 7:20 pm
Re: Are the names of moves important to you...???
In my saying –
Giving ‘intermediate’ moves which are simply variations of a beginner move complex names, invariably read by the teacher from a pre prepared note because they can’t remember them, is asinine.
this was NOT a personal swipe at you - although from your post you recognised your own personal behaviour within the statement.
Watch other good teachers, a few are mentioned in my previous post (and I shall be pleased to advise of others) none of them feel the need to give pseudo made up names to moves which no one then remembers.
(Although - and I know you like to joke about, names like – "the ladies half nelson crab duck octopull comb dip American”- can be a source of levity amongst the class at the time.)
----------------
"A seeker of truth is no stranger to controversy."
- Gordon J Pownall
- Senior Member
- Posts: 1000
- Joined: Thu Oct 10, 2002 11:00 am
Re: Are the names of moves important to you...???
Actually Andy mate, gotta put you right here...Andy McGregor wrote:And that comment reveals to me that Gordy is annoyed, and he's trying to get even in a subtle way.
Not annoyed, just at a bit of a loss why an anonymous individual feels it appropriate to make value judgements without any justification.
The forum is a place where discussion and opinions are expressed and are done so by intelligent (?) people who will explain and justify the basis for such comments.
Just saying teachers who write own moves are asinine as an isolated comment is no different than the opinions held by Nazi germany, South Africa during apartheid etc.
"You're a lesser person because you are black or because your are a Jew..."
"Why....?"
"....Because you are....."
This comment I found totally inappropriate, unjustified and one that perhaps the forum could do without.
If The Pilgrim was a 'regular' forumite, known be reputation or by his / her sharing of a sense of humour or perspective, then that would be a different case and the comment may be taken in a different way.
Perhaps when you and I spar with the Gimp comments - however who is this Pilgrim, what basis does he / she have for making such comments......?
Sorry Andy, not annyed, just confused and seeking some resolution.
Pilgrim has also played a game on other threads with Rachel as well... It is for this post and others that I question then comment and The Pilgrims motivation...the signature also gives clues to motivation...
Is The Pilgrim just here to cause controversy and mayhem...???
~ It's a Dance Thing ~
www.vatsim-uk.org
- Gordon J Pownall
- Senior Member
- Posts: 1000
- Joined: Thu Oct 10, 2002 11:00 am
Re: Are the names of moves important to you...???
IMHO This is a personal swipe at any teacher who makes notes... and done so without any reason, justification or, as long as you remain unwilling to state from which perspective you come from, any substance whatsoever - are you a teacher, have you ever taught a class, have you ever been in the situation of needing to feel confident and prepared...???The Pilgrim wrote: In my saying –
Giving ‘intermediate’ moves which are simply variations of a beginner move complex names, invariably read by the teacher from a pre prepared note because they can’t remember them, is asinine.
this was NOT a personal swipe at you - although from your post you recognised your own personal behaviour within the statement.
Nor do I.....when giving names of moves, I use those which can be found (where appropriate) from the Ceroc Moves Folder as issued to all qualified Ceroc teachers...???The Pilgrim wrote: Watch other good teachers, a few are mentioned in my previous post (and I shall be pleased to advise of others) none of them feel the need to give pseudo made up names to moves which no one then remembers.
Don't understand your comment here - if you are referring to a post earlier, you will also read that I gave this as a (stated as made up) example of where moves have been overnamed in some instances.,.....still confused...???
I notice, with interest, that you still hide behind your pseudonym.... still unwilling to share any details about yourself as requested by Rachel...???
~ It's a Dance Thing ~
www.vatsim-uk.org
-
under par
- Senior Member
- Posts: 6312
- Joined: Mon Feb 09, 2004 2:08 pm
- Contact:
Re: Are the names of moves important to you...???
Is the Pilgrim another BASIL BRUSH!!!!alex wrote:Pilgrim
I'd be interested to know where you teach, as you believe you have more knowledge, better teaching skills, and a better memory than all the teachers you comment on.
alex
- Lory
- Senior Member
- Posts: 9918
- Joined: Mon Oct 20, 2003 11:00 am
- Contact:
Re: Are the names of moves important to you...???
I know the names of and how to properly execute, precisely 4 moves,
The first move
The hand jive
The comb and
The slow comb
After that, all I ever worry about is, if I hear the words..... Duck, Tunnel or Drop, at the end of anything, it's time for me to beat a hasty retreat!
"If you're going to do something tonight, that you know you'll be sorry for in the morning, plan a lie in." Lorraine
- Gordon J Pownall
- Senior Member
- Posts: 1000
- Joined: Thu Oct 10, 2002 11:00 am
Re: Are the names of moves important to you...???
Sorry to go off thread - last time hopefully.
I had a PM which I feel I need to respond to with respect to the sender here on the thread, just to add a little perspective upon my comments earlier as the sender of the PM has made me aware of how my comment may have been taken out of context. Please accept my unreserved apolgies if anyone has taken offence at this comment and below is also the message to the PM sender.....
I would also add that this was an open and honest dialogue and not an angry exchange.....
On reflection maybe a little strong however such uninformed beliefs held and expressed by individuals who have little consideration for the other person (such as The Pilgrim) are fundamentally what caused such atrocities.sender of the PM wrote: I'm afraid that I find your comparison lacking in perspective and rather offensive - not to "The Pilgrim", about whom I care little, but to the millions of people dead as a result of Nazi actions. Godwin's law very much applies.
In terms of being offensive, as a writer and researcher into the Holocaust, my mother has brought myself and brothers up with an in depth understanding and insight of the WW2 atrocities.
I made the comment (albeit perhaps tentatively linked) based upon that fact that The Pilgrim holds and has expressed views that are offensive to many people, that hold absolutely no substance, that are based upon discriminatory beliefs and that he cannot (and has refused to) justify other than him / her saying that 'individuals are asinine '...because he / she says so.
That is no different than saying people with dyslexia are asinine because they can't read or write, or people with a hearing impairment are asinine because they use a hearing aid or minicom.
I understand your perspective however still stand by the conviction that The Pilgrim is out to stir up trouble in making the comment he did and which I still find totally unjustified.
Thanks however for your thoughts and comments...
....and The Pilgrim still remains a pseudonym.......
~ It's a Dance Thing ~
www.vatsim-uk.org
- Andy McGregor
- Senior Member
- Posts: 9276
- Joined: Mon Mar 03, 2003 12:00 pm
Well done Gordy
As I said some time ago, The Pilgrim is posting like an old hand. In fact, to use the usual pub comparison, like someone who's just stepped outside as if leaving then put on a disguise and come back in as someone else. We've seen people who wouldn't reveal their true selves before on here - so far I've not observed any of them to be a force for good.
- spindr
- Senior Member
- Posts: 1617
- Joined: Tue Apr 15, 2003 12:41 am
Re: Are the names of moves important to you...???
asThe Pilgrim wrote:Giving ‘intermediate’ moves which are simply variations of a beginner move complex names, invariably read by the teacher from a pre prepared note because they can’t remember them, is asinine.
by removing the extra clause in the commas.Giving ‘intermediate’ moves which are simply variations of a beginner move complex names is asinine.
And I have some sypathy for the editted version -- names with no information are just jargon. For example: it would be somewhat foolish to call a standard first move with a double return, say ``Neil's move'' or ``The Aadvark'' or whatever [although, I believe that a first move with a travelling double return coming back into dancehold is sometimes taught as "A Double Dennis"].
In contrast, names with too much information are never going to be remembered.
I would prefer teachers tried to relate complex moves to their simpler versions -- e.g. a loophole is *just* a travelling return with an extra handhold that breaks and makes, etc.
As for the clause in commas:
it's a bit harsh. Although I so find that MY confidence in a teacher (or rather their professionalism) tends to drop somewhat if they have to keep referring to their notes A LOT during a class.The Pilgrim wrote:invariably read by the teacher from a pre prepared note because they can’t remember them
SpinDr.
- Rentaghost
- Junior Member
- Posts: 20
- Joined: Wed Oct 01, 2003 7:04 pm
Re: Are the names of moves important to you...???
However, as a professional teacher, I often have notes with me when I am teaching. It keeps lessons running smoothly and was something that
Please can I have a dance tonight, Gordon?
Sarah
- Gordon J Pownall
- Senior Member
- Posts: 1000
- Joined: Thu Oct 10, 2002 11:00 am
Re: Are the names of moves important to you...???
Couldn]As I said some time ago, The Pilgrim is posting like an old hand. In fact, to use the usual pub comparison, like someone who's just stepped outside as if leaving then put on a disguise and come back in as someone else. We've seen people who wouldn't reveal their true selves before on here - so far I've not observed any of them to be a force for good.[/QUOTE]spindr wrote:As for the clause in commas:
it's a bit harsh. Although I so find that MY confidence in a teacher (or rather their professionalism) tends to drop somewhat if they have to keep referring to their notes A LOT during a class.
SpinDr.
....I have to concur here Andy
~ It's a Dance Thing ~
www.vatsim-uk.org
- Gordon J Pownall
- Senior Member
- Posts: 1000
- Joined: Thu Oct 10, 2002 11:00 am
Re: Are the names of moves important to you...???
....and as Sarah demo'd for me last week - she speaks from the front line finger right on the pulse position.....Rentaghost wrote:To be fair to Gordon, he only has the names of the moves written on a piece of paper with the beat counts written next to them. Please can I have a dance tonight, Gordon?
Sarah
And of course I would love to dance with you this evening........
~ It's a Dance Thing ~
www.vatsim-uk.org
- Gordon J Pownall
- Senior Member
- Posts: 1000
- Joined: Thu Oct 10, 2002 11:00 am
Re: Well done Gordy
Gotta spread it around a bit so here's a hug insteadAndy McGregor wrote:I think Gordy has done well in his recent post apologising for an earlier slightly OTT comparison. I thought some people might have been upset by this. And it seems I was right. I think that the person who was upset was right to email Gordy alerting him and I think Gordy was right to make his apology public as others may have been upset and not PM'd anyone about it. Gordy has apologised and I believe that apology is sincere. Let's hope that's an end to it. Well done Gordy
As I said some time ago, The Pilgrim is posting like an old hand. In fact, to use the usual pub comparison, like someone who's just stepped outside as if leaving then put on a disguise and come back in as someone else. We've seen people who wouldn't reveal their true selves before on here - so far I've not observed any of them to be a force for good.
~ It's a Dance Thing ~
www.vatsim-uk.org