A little moan

Talk about anything dance related ...

Anything to do with dancing, classes, etc...
Post Reply
User avatar
Chicklet
Senior Member
Posts: 2555
Joined: Mon Mar 03, 2003 12:00 pm

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by Chicklet »

Wey Hey, Ems, honey I think everyone's missed the point, you were saying that the poor folks with only one person to dance with should come up to the front, not stay at the back, weren't you??????? :whistle:

And this whole thread was just so that I could jump in and say that I could *direct* them to the front of the plane, I mean room, in my nice new vintage 1976 Caledonian Airways uniform (complete with tammy) eh????

But seriously, personally I find this a very difficult question upon which to form ONE opinion, on the one hand I agree with practially all of the reasons put forward for rotation but, being perfectly honest, would have to say I have often looked at people dancing with a fixed partner with green eyed monster eyes (not jealous of particular people, OK one or two then, more of the concept) and would love to have such an opportunity. I can completely see Jayne and Divi's points of view.

So this post really doesn't help, but hey, I've not been round much recently and in my day we didn't have serious stuff on a Friday, we just had accountant jokes :D
User avatar
ChrisA
Senior Member
Posts: 3831
Joined: Wed Sep 10, 2003 11:00 am

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by ChrisA »

TheTramp wrote:I remember ChrisA defending it vigorously to someone a while back, as being really immensely friendly, and that the person (can't remember who - Stewart38 maybe?) who came along once, and found it very unfriendly was totally wrong.
I think Trampy's got a valid point (though I still reserve the right to be rude to him :devil: )

I think Wednesday Hipsters probably is a little less friendly and welcoming than it used to be, partly because of the drift towards fewer couples rotating.

But the product has changed. It is undoubtedly more serious now. It is not like a Ceroc night, it is difficult (to me) material that can really only be mastered with months of the classes, unlike four intermediate moves that are taught with little technique (and which most people won't dance in freestyle anyway). :rolleyes:

So there you go. Guilty as charged, but without apologies. If people don't like the product, there are plenty of other places offering alternate products - some very good, such as the fab duo of BillCo and Lily at the Jive Bar. But I am quite certain the MJ world is richer for the presence of the "Amir Product" - and big up to the Hipsters team for such a pioneering spirit. :clap:

My earlier defense of Hipsters' friendliness was about the people, not the product. I still maintain that they're a friendly bunch, although quite a few are doing Wednesdays because for the classes at least, they are predominantly interested in the serious learning, and only secondarily about the fun aspect.

And even the people who don't rotate dance with lots of people during the freestyle. :flower: :flower:

Chris
User avatar
Stuart M
Senior Member
Posts: 2042
Joined: Thu Jan 17, 2002 4:52 pm
Contact:

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by Stuart M »

I would say that with a standard Ceroc/other organisation night, with Beginner and Intermediate lessons, any benefits of dancing with a fixed partner would be outweighed by the various bad habits one could develop. As such it should be discouraged. As Gus says, Modern Jive is a social dance and the social aspect is a fundamental part of the teaching. So I agree with Franck I think.

However, with Advanced classes or workshops I can see the point of working separately - these are often moves etc. which require specific knowledge of a partner's limits/tastes/style/shape :what: .

I think, developing on points made earlier, whether fixed partners are allowed or not, should be advertised by the workshop organisers/advanced class venue. That way, customers can makes their choice before they pays their money...I've been to a couple of workshops where the woman have been grumbling about 'all the good blokes working with a fixed partner', thus meaning they got very little out of the workshop.

Apologies if someone's already suggested this - haven't been able to read the whole thread as it's moved so fast!
User avatar
Divissima
Senior Member
Posts: 1461
Joined: Sun Aug 25, 2002 11:00 am

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by Divissima »

TheTramp wrote:But it's not really a spurious arguement is it?? And there isn't really a need to do any arithmetic to understand the point that I was trying to make. Unless you were going to aim to provide us with numbers, where it would be 'acceptable' (I say 'acceptable', since, if the people who are being exclusive would move back into the class in this extreme situation, then presumably even they would find the extreme example 'unacceptable') for couples to be exclusive.
Sorry if I was unclear on this, I meant that it would be spurious to try to create some kind of mathematical formula (even if I could :tears: ). I'm certainly not going to offer myself as an expert on where it would be acceptable to draw the line. I think most dancers are pretty good at responding to this kind of situation.
User avatar
TheTramp
Senior Member
Posts: 10672
Joined: Mon Nov 18, 2002 12:00 pm

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by TheTramp »

David Franklin wrote:Here are two specific reasons:

Something that quite often happens to me is that I realise I'm "stuck" with a bit of the move where I can't actually see what's going on (i.e. I'm facing away from the teacher). If I'm rotating (and particularly if the ladies are getting moved on a lot), I really don't want to say "do you mind not having your turn so I can watch the teacher?".

Also, if I just can't get the first part of the routine, if I'm not rotating, we can just agree "we'll just do a first move and travelling return instead" (say), and still get something from the rest of the class. You can't really do this when rotating.
Hiya David. Nice of you to join in the discussion!! :flower:

Have to say that if someone with your experience is struggling that much to do the class all the time (or at least enough that you'd actually anticipate not being able to do the first part that you'd use that as an excuse to become an exclusive couple), then it must be blooming hard, and I can't see many (any) of the people in the class actually getting it, so I can quite understand why you'd maybe want to become exclusive. (I guess that kinda isn't the actual reason why though, and there's a compliment in there somewhere!!).

Trampy
Fluent in sarcasm! :flower:
User avatar
TheTramp
Senior Member
Posts: 10672
Joined: Mon Nov 18, 2002 12:00 pm

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by TheTramp »

Divissima wrote:Sorry if I was unclear on this, I meant that it would be spurious to try to create some kind of mathematical formula (even if I could :tears: ). I'm certainly not going to offer myself as an expert on where it would be acceptable to draw the line. I think most dancers are pretty good at responding to this kind of situation.
So you don't think that there'd be a need for my (great) idea of a rota of exclusivity??? :D

:hug:

:yum: <-- it's sort of in my cheek :na:

Trampy
Fluent in sarcasm! :flower:
User avatar
ChrisA
Senior Member
Posts: 3831
Joined: Wed Sep 10, 2003 11:00 am

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by ChrisA »

TheTramp wrote:However, taking Andy's example to the extreme (who, me?). You could have every man in the class taken off to be a fixed couple, and that'd leave 9 women there with no-one to dance with. I guess no-one would want to be one of those 9 spare ladies. Maybe it's worth just considering how you'd feel in that situation?
I have to say, all this business of taking examples to their extreme, and basing any kind of argument on the consequences of that extreme, is quite specious.

The extreme is not the reality - which is that for the most part, it works quite well on a Wednesday.

The product is different. It is not based, except loosely, on a Ceroc night model. It is difficult.

Yet despite all this it is popular.

More so, incidentally, and with no implication of disrespect to the great man himself, than when Viktor was teaching at Hipsters.

I put this down simply to there being a market for the new product which undoubtedly draws people in. Maybe there are lessons for other organisations to learn. Maybe they're learning them, as well. Didn't someone say recently that the Advanced Class at Fulham was fixed partner?

Chris
User avatar
Jayne
Senior Member
Posts: 1000
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2002 9:40 am

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by Jayne »

Gus wrote:Urrr ... think thats a sweeping generalisation. I was talking about the 'Ceorc' model. Within that model a number of clubs, mainly non-Ceroc have been teaching advanced classes for some time. Even in my days at Ceroc Nantwich we were teaching 'unofficial' advanced lessons because we recognised the need for them. Blitz has had advanced lessons for a number of years. I don't want to get into the argument of whether Hipsters is MORE advanced
Absolutely it was a sweeping generalisation. I wanted to get the point across that there were differences in the requirements of customers at different standards of dancing. Explaining that ceroc club x does this advanced class whilst blitz club y does this detracts from point. I know that ceroc does teach advanced classes, as mentioned in my initial post. Likewise, I do not wish to get into a pointless debate of which club is "better" than another club. This merely takes away from my point that different people have different requirements.
Gus wrote:if you are going to dance 'advanced moves/style' on the dancefloor with dancers who aren't your regular partner ... shouldnt you learn how to do the moves without your regular partner in the first place? Jut a thought :wink:
In an ideal world, yes. And when you show me a freestyle where the majority of men do many advanced moves I will be more than happy to do an advanced class in rotation. Sadly, a large proportion of men do 20 beginner moves and maybe a dozen intermediate moves in their standard repertoire. Learning an advanced class with a fixed partner enables my partner and I to actually learn advanced moves, which can be used in freestyle later.

The counter argument I can hear coming is that if there were more people in rotation then more men would learn more advanced moves. However, the number of women is usually greater than the number of men - which means that the men dance throughout the class. They should therefore be able to lead the ladies into advanced moves, irrespective of how many excess ladies there are in respect to the size of the class.

Furthermore, I can hear people telling their computer that they do advanced moves. I was only talking about "a large proportion", not all dancers.

J :flower:
" 'Remember one thing' replies his master 'you do not drown simply by plunging into water, you only drown by staying beneath the surface.' "
User avatar
TheTramp
Senior Member
Posts: 10672
Joined: Mon Nov 18, 2002 12:00 pm

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by TheTramp »

ChrisA wrote:I have to say, all this business of taking examples to their extreme, and basing any kind of argument on the consequences of that extreme, is quite specious.

The extreme is not the reality - which is that for the most part, it works quite well on a Wednesday.
Ummm.... I disagree with your premise. Taking any example to the extreme, and seeing where you end up, is quite often vital. My limited mathematics (sorry Divi) suggests that this is what happens in any integration principle, and a lot of mathematical modelling (which has a lot of impact in the real world) is based on this principle (David F will no doubt come on now and tell me how wrong this is).

When I last came to Hipsters (some time ago - prior to Amir taking over the teaching), this situation with almost half the class being exclusive was not the case. Hence, someone 'started' doing it. And other people followed. And now, almost the majority (one more than half) of people are doing it. Can you really predict where it will all stop? Hence, in theory, it might well reach the 'extreme' point - although, Divi assures us that this won't be the case, since some of the people (I still like my idea of an exclusivity rota) will take the plunge, and move back into the rotation.

(Wheeee. I'm having fun today :devil: ) :hug:

Trampy

PS. Incidentally, the theory that it works well on a Wednesday seems also to be fallacious. We've already heard in this thread that at least one person didn't like it enough to stop coming. It just seems to work well for you (and others, not everyone)
Fluent in sarcasm! :flower:
User avatar
TheTramp
Senior Member
Posts: 10672
Joined: Mon Nov 18, 2002 12:00 pm

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by TheTramp »

Jayne wrote:Furthermore, I can hear people telling their computer that they do advanced moves.
I don't. I'm just a beginner.... :clap:

Trampy
Fluent in sarcasm! :flower:
User avatar
ChrisA
Senior Member
Posts: 3831
Joined: Wed Sep 10, 2003 11:00 am

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by ChrisA »

TheTramp wrote:Of course, we're all glad that you carried one dancing Jayne :flower: Though, you'll probably never dance with me again :tears:
Ahem... she'd probably be safer if she didn't :devil:

Chris
User avatar
Jayne
Senior Member
Posts: 1000
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2002 9:40 am

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by Jayne »

TheTramp wrote:Of course, we're all glad that you carried one dancing Jayne :flower:
Thanks, Trampy. :flower:
TheTramp wrote:Though, you'll probably never dance with me again :tears:
The split lip has healed now, so I guess I'm ready for the second round. :what:

J :wink:
" 'Remember one thing' replies his master 'you do not drown simply by plunging into water, you only drown by staying beneath the surface.' "
under par
Senior Member
Posts: 6312
Joined: Mon Feb 09, 2004 2:08 pm
Contact:

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by under par »

TheTramp wrote:When I last came to Hipsters (some time ago - prior to Amir taking over the teaching), this situation with almost half the class being exclusive was not the case. Hence, someone 'started' doing it. And other people followed. And now, almost the majority (one more than half) of people are doing it. (Wheeee. I'm having fun today :devil: ) :hug:

Trampy
To clarify a point... this only occurs a lot on the Wednesday night with Amirs three lessons ........................................... not the Tuesday when Roger does first lesson and Nigel the second or on the Phat friday.

And to Amirs credit he has increased the wednesday numbers.
User avatar
David Franklin
Senior Member
Posts: 3426
Joined: Fri Feb 22, 2002 1:52 pm

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Franklin »

TheTramp wrote:Hiya David. Nice of you to join in the discussion!! :flower:

Have to say that if someone with your experience is struggling that much to do the class all the time (or at least enough that you'd actually anticipate not being able to do the first part that you'd use that as an excuse to become an exclusive couple), then it must be blooming hard, and I can't see many (any) of the people in the class actually getting it, so I can quite understand why you'd maybe want to become exclusive. (I guess that kinda isn't the actual reason why though, and there's a compliment in there somewhere!!).
Actually, outside of workshops, I do rotate (other than if I've missed half the class - not fair to inflict that on the other dancers). But I've definitely encountered both those situations in both classes and non-rotating workshops, and it's a lot less stressful in the latter case. I can totally understand a couple who really want to get the most out of a difficult class not rotating.

And in fact, Amir's classes really are that hard. Amir himself says that when you start his classes, if you "get" 25% (i.e. 1 move) from the class, you're doing well. The problem is, that if rotating, probablility says you will both get the move together only 1 time in 16!

Dave
User avatar
Franck
Senior Member
Posts: 3045
Joined: Tue Jan 15, 2002 12:00 pm

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by Franck »

ChrisA wrote:I have to say, all this business of taking examples to their extreme, and basing any kind of argument on the consequences of that extreme, is quite specious.

The extreme is not the reality - which is that for the most part, it works quite well on a Wednesday.
Sorry Chris, but most of the argument stemmed from the fact that the extreme (19 couples opting out) was reality... I expect that one or two couples opting out might be (initially) given the benefit of the doubt, but when extremes become trends, they threaten other classes around.

There are no issues with any class / teacher advertising a class (advanced or otherwise) as being non-rotational and as long as you had to book with a partner or were allocated one on the night / day, everything would be fine.
It seems however that this is not the case and while some of you are lucky enough to have a regular dance partner that you wish to practise with, what you are asking is for a 'cheap' form of private tuition...
I just checked the Hipsters website and it seems to target Intermediate / advanced modernjivers, which by implication (and with no statement to the contrary anywhere) means that rotation will be expected (as all modern jive classes use the rotation system) and is indeed in operation (for half the class anyway)
From the hipsters website wrote:VIBE NIGHT with AMIR
ADVANCED MODERN JIVE 8pm-11:30pm

Hipsters Wednesday are aimed at intermediate/advanced modern jivers
I would also question the assumption that you would learn better (even in an Advanced class) with a fixed partner... As a few people have mentioned you're more likely to pick up bad habits, how will you know for sure that you are 'leading' a move if you're partner is so used to your style... Is the real acid test that you can work out / lead / dance a move with most people?
Franck.

There's an A.P.P. for that!
philsmove
Senior Member
Posts: 3166
Joined: Sat Apr 03, 2004 9:03 am

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by philsmove »

With 44 posts in under 3 hours Emma has clearly hit a touchy subject

Frank you say
I personally get irritated, as a teacher, when one or two couples opt out of the rotation
But would you be prepared to turn away customers who do this?

The trend NOT to rotate seems to be on the increase

And if it continued we could see the end of “no need to bring a partner “

The fact I did not need a partner is what attracted me to MJ and it still does

Moving round has the slight disadvantage I may have to dace with someone who was as bad as me when I started

But the great advantage I get a chance to dance with people like Elaine


Classes that allow people to stay in couples should not pretend there is no need to bring a partner
User avatar
ChrisA
Senior Member
Posts: 3831
Joined: Wed Sep 10, 2003 11:00 am

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by ChrisA »

TheTramp wrote:When I last came to Hipsters (some time ago - prior to Amir taking over the teaching), this situation with almost half the class being exclusive was not the case. Hence, someone 'started' doing it. And other people followed. And now, almost the majority (one more than half) of people are doing it. Can you really predict where it will all stop? Hence, in theory, it might well reach the 'extreme' point
I'm not trying to predict where it'll stop. Maybe it will continue evolving as it has been (though the rate of change is much lower now).

But even if it does reach the extreme point, it comes back to the fact that the product is not Ceroc. It isn't promoting fun, frolics and social interaction on a Wednesday any more, though all that still happens. Maybe there's a market for a weekly non-rotating class, I don't know. I'd quite like it (just as I like the other products I buy at other times), others wouldn't.

So what? It would stand or fall on whether it was popular enough to be sustainable.
PS. Incidentally, the theory that it works well on a Wednesday seems also to be fallacious. We've already heard in this thread that at least one person didn't like it enough to stop coming. It just seems to work well for you (and others, not everyone)
I refer the honourable gentleman to the fact that the numbers have gone up, not down, since the format changed.

If one person has stopped coming, that's their choice. Others must have started if the numbers have gone up.

I'm all for variety. When I stop liking a product I'll stop buying it.

Chris
User avatar
Jayne
Senior Member
Posts: 1000
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2002 9:40 am

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by Jayne »

TheTramp wrote:PS. Incidentally, the theory that it works well on a Wednesday seems also to be fallacious. We've already heard in this thread that at least one person didn't like it enough to stop coming. It just seems to work well for you (and others, not everyone)
Can anyone else spot the lawyer in training?

There are probably about 50 people who regularly attend Amir's class - i.e. they come back week after week.

One person said that they didn't like it.

Whilst arguments and counter arguments can be made with stats, I think the numbers here can speak for themselves and don't need to be "reinterpreted" by anyone.

Sorry Trampy. :flower:
Franck wrote:Sorry Chris, but most of the argument stemmed from the fact that the extreme (19 couples opting out) was reality...
Sorry Franck, but Chris speaks as a Hipsters regular and is therefore aware of how many couples rotate and how many don't. I don't remember seeing you at Hipsters recently. :flower:

J :nice:
" 'Remember one thing' replies his master 'you do not drown simply by plunging into water, you only drown by staying beneath the surface.' "
User avatar
Will
Senior Member
Posts: 1476
Joined: Thu Aug 22, 2002 11:00 am

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by Will »

If I attend a class I'm likely to want to rotate if I'm there to socialise, and likely to want to stay in fixed partners if I want to improve my dancing. Trampy, Divissima is right, it is a lot easier to learn a difficult move if you just stick with your regular partner than if you rotate. I hope you never realise this though as if you do there is a severe danger you might start winning competitions and that would never do! :really:

The more advanced the class is, the more fixed couples you're gonna get. That is probably why you get alot of fixed couples at Hipsters. We have lots of fixed couples in our class when Kate & I teach advanced classes, and I don't have a problem with that if that's what people want to do.

Either way, I think if you pay your money on the door, you are neither the property of the organiser or the other dancers, so it's entirely upto you when and who you dance with. Pays to be nice though and consider other peoples feelings. :flower:
User avatar
Simon r
Senior Member
Posts: 815
Joined: Tue Dec 23, 2003 12:00 pm

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by Simon r »

Lets put this into context the proportion of people that do not rotate is very small and there is a place for both agreed it could be seen as off puting for others but i dont think a lot of people really care.

Those that do partner off do so as there own choice because they feel they learn better that way for more complicated moves .
I have seen many begginer couples start this way giving each other moral support.
I agree with most points raised but i dont think we will see a huge increase and the end of jive as we know it ( get real)....
Just my two penny worth :whistle:
Post Reply