A little moan

Talk about anything dance related ...

Anything to do with dancing, classes, etc...
Post Reply
User avatar
Franck
Senior Member
Posts: 3045
Joined: Tue Jan 15, 2002 12:00 pm

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by Franck »

Andy McGregor wrote:If people want special treatment and a different product I think they should pay a special and different price.
Andy, I totally agree with you.
Ceroc / MJ is one of the few dance classes where you don't have to go with a partner and the above practise seriously jeopardises this.
I personally get irritated, as a teacher, when one or two couples opt out of the rotation, and can't imagine how I would feel or what I would do if 19 couples opted out of the rotation.
Regular weekly classes are different from workshops (where numbers should be balanced) and in my opinion the rotations and changing of partner is not only expected but beneficial to all parties.
Jayne wrote:I can see why some people might perceive this behaviour as selfish. However, I hope that replies on this thread with dispel such myths.
I disagree, it is selfish, most of the dancers who retreat to the back would probably not be dancing today if that practise was widely adopted as they would either have given up when facing the prospect of an extra 15 women and only 20 or so couples rotating, or simply they wouldn't have had a chance to dance with some of the better dancers at all :sad:
The money you are paying is for a group class, where everyone helps each other. The 6 or 7 pounds your are paying for 2 hours of tuition + freestyle is exactly that. If you want private lessons, then pay for private lessons (typically 30/50 pounds an hour) or do a workshop...

Nothing like that happens in any venue I attend, thankfully, but I would fight it if it ever did. sorry Jayne :flower:
Franck.

There's an A.P.P. for that!
User avatar
Divissima
Senior Member
Posts: 1461
Joined: Sun Aug 25, 2002 11:00 am

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by Divissima »

TheTramp wrote:Taking Andy's example to the extreme (who, me?). You could have every man in the class taken off to be a fixed couple, and that'd leave 9 women there with no-one to dance with. I guess no-one would want to be one of those 9 spare ladies. Maybe it's worth just considering how you'd feel in that situation?
Well, I'm sure in this extreme example, many of the fixed couples would, of course, move into the class to rotate.
Trampy wrote:Of course, it does look elitist, as Emma says. Probably a bit like 'Hotshots' were considered elitist.
Well, as I said earlier, IMHO this is just a matter of one's point of view.
User avatar
TheTramp
Senior Member
Posts: 10672
Joined: Mon Nov 18, 2002 12:00 pm

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by TheTramp »

Can I just say, that it seems a shame that this post seems to have focussed on Hipsters.

I remember ChrisA defending it vigorously to someone a while back, as being really immensely friendly, and that the person (can't remember who - Stewart38 maybe?) who came along once, and found it very unfriendly was totally wrong.

Of course, this perception of it being unfriendly wouldn't have anything to do with almost half the class (in Andy's example) being exclusive amongst themselves at the back of the room, and not joining in with the class.

Obviously, when Jayne says that she does the class at the back with one person, she wouldn't at all mean ChrisA, who is there, in the rotational, helping to maintain the 'friendliness' that we all know totally pervades the room at Hipsters (we know this, ChrisA defended it very vigorously).

Sorry. This was said almost very tongue-in-cheek :devil: :whistle: :flower:

Trampy
Fluent in sarcasm! :flower:
User avatar
TheTramp
Senior Member
Posts: 10672
Joined: Mon Nov 18, 2002 12:00 pm

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by TheTramp »

Divissima wrote:Well, I'm sure in this extreme example, many of the fixed couples would, of course, move into the class to rotate.
So. Where does this extreme example start/end then Divi??

10 ladies, 1 man, 38 exclusive couples?
11 ladies, 2 men, 37 exclusive couples?
12 ladies, 3 men, 36 exclusive couples?
.
.
.
.
48 ladies, 39 men, 0 exclusive couples?

And, of course, which of the exclusive couples would start the move back to the class. And which of the exclusive couples would wait for other exclusive couples to make the move back to the class, to the point where they considered it back to being 'acceptable' to stay at the back, as exclusive.

Maybe there could be a rota of exclusivity or something?? :devil: :D

Trampy
Fluent in sarcasm! :flower:
under par
Senior Member
Posts: 6312
Joined: Mon Feb 09, 2004 2:08 pm
Contact:

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by under par »

Trish wrote:Yes that's what bothers me about it too. I don't personally agree with people dancing with fixed partners, except in exceptional circumstances (like where someones got a bad back and the teacher is teaching drops - although they do often teach alternatives anyway). As a woman who comes to Ceroc on her own (my husband doesn't dance) I get a bit fed up with it really. Especially when it's mainly the best men (who happen to be dancing with their regular partners) who are "at the back", leaving the lesson filled with the not so good men. It does make you feel that they think they're better than the rest of us. If it's beginners who are keeping to exclusive partners, I can understand this from a confidence perspective. Although two beginners together would in my opinion actually benefit more from rotating, as they're likely to be helped by the more experienced dancers that are rotating, and more likely to confuse each other if they are separate.

At my regular venue, you seem to get a lot of "exclusivity" anyway - which is a shame, as it cuts down the number/vairety of people to dance with.

There - got that off my chest - no offence meant!

No offence taken a valid point of view in a really good discussion.

I have taken on board Andy Franck and others opinion, I still reserve the right to dance lesson with Mrs Par but as i have already stated I do the rotation most if the time and realise that most should do so. :flower: :worthy:
User avatar
Simon r
Senior Member
Posts: 815
Joined: Tue Dec 23, 2003 12:00 pm

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by Simon r »

Obviously, when Jayne says that she does the class at the back with one person, she wouldn't at all mean ChrisA, who is there, in the rotational, helping to maintain the 'friendliness' that we all know totally pervades the room at Hipsters (we know this, ChrisA defended it very vigourously).

Sorry. This was said almost very tongue-in-cheek :devil: :whistle: :flower:

Trampy
I step forward as witness number 1 Judge Tramp but was totaly guilty of the same... :flower:
User avatar
Jayne
Senior Member
Posts: 1000
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2002 9:40 am

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by Jayne »

Gus wrote:Ignoring Hipsters, the 'Ceroc' model of running a night is fundamentaly based on rotation and interaction.
Actually, this is an interesting point. With the exception of the "Ceroc Advanced" nights (which I've not been to and so cannot comment on) I think that there is a fundamental difference between Ceroc and Hipsters - primarily that ceroc teaches beginners & intermediates and that Hipsters teaches advanced.

One of the most important aspects of MJ at the start of the learning curve is getting out there and dancing with as many people as possible - which is where the rotation is so important. Furthermore, rotating means that you get to meet so many people - giving you a social aspect of the night and making newbies want to return the following week.

Historically, Ceroc has been weak in providing for the more advanced dancer. This (I believe) lead to the establishment of nights like Hipsters, where (mainly) competant dancers could go to improve technique and learn advanced moves with advanced dancers. Advanced dancers generally know the people on the dance scene and so there is less emphasis on meeting people and more emphasis on technique and complex moves. The requirements of this group of customers are different from those of the new dancers. This, I believe, is reflected in the way that people learn in the two classes - i.e. initially in rotation and then by dancing with a fixed partner.

I think that the requirements of the two groups of paying customers should be taken into account.

J :nice:
" 'Remember one thing' replies his master 'you do not drown simply by plunging into water, you only drown by staying beneath the surface.' "
User avatar
Divissima
Senior Member
Posts: 1461
Joined: Sun Aug 25, 2002 11:00 am

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by Divissima »

TheTramp wrote:Sorry. While I agree with the rest of your post Divi. I don't quite understand why you can only 'bank' a move that you've done when you do it as a fixed couple.

If you like a move that much when you're moving round in a class, what's to stop you getting together with Toby after the class, running though it a couple of times, and then 'banking' it.

Seems like a bit of a fallacious arguement to me :flower:

Trampy
I wasn't advancing this as an argument for fixed couples - just explaining why I personally have found it more effective for me to do Amir's class in a fixed couple. Maybe this is splitting hairs, but the point I was trying to make is that there are bound to be lots of reasons why people might want to do a class in a fixed couple. I don't really draw any distinction between the possible reasons - good or bad, justifiable or not - it depends on your point of view.
User avatar
TheTramp
Senior Member
Posts: 10672
Joined: Mon Nov 18, 2002 12:00 pm

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by TheTramp »

Uh huh.

But I still don't understand why you can't 'bank' a move with Toby, having done the class in rotation. You say that you've found it more effective. I just don't understand how/why it would be more effective in this example.

Of course, since you're not advancing it as an arguement, then it's not really a reason, which means that you can't be saying that it's more effective. Because, if it was more effective, as you say, then you'd surely be advancing it as an arguement??

Trampy
Fluent in sarcasm! :flower:
User avatar
Divissima
Senior Member
Posts: 1461
Joined: Sun Aug 25, 2002 11:00 am

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by Divissima »

TheTramp wrote:So. Where does this extreme example start/end then Divi??

10 ladies, 1 man, 38 exclusive couples?
11 ladies, 2 men, 37 exclusive couples?
12 ladies, 3 men, 36 exclusive couples?
.
.
.
.
48 ladies, 39 men, 0 exclusive couples?

And, of course, which of the exclusive couples would start the move back to the class. And which of the exclusive couples would wait for other exclusive couples to make the move back to the class, to the point where they considered it back to being 'acceptable' to stay at the back, as exclusive.

Maybe there could be a rota of exclusivity or something?? :devil: :D

Trampy
Hey Trampy, I was commenting on the extreme example you gave! Of course it's a matter of degree :rolleyes: I'm hoping that your post is mostly tongue-in-cheek as most dancers I know are perfectly capable of using their discretion to judge such a situation. Sorry, Trampy, I don't want to get drawn into a spurious argument with you (and, besides, my brain doesn't do arithmetic on a Friday afternoon :tears: ).

I have been trying to put the alternative view to Emma's in a reasonable way. Don't want this thread to degenerate like so many others.... :tears:
User avatar
Jayne
Senior Member
Posts: 1000
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2002 9:40 am

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by Jayne »

Franck wrote:Nothing like that happens in any venue I attend, thankfully, but I would fight it if it ever did. sorry Jayne :flower:
I can see your point of view Franck. :flower: However, please also see my second post on this thread (composed while you were replying to my post).
Franck wrote:most of the dancers who retreat to the back would probably not be dancing today if that practise was widely adopted as they would either have given up when facing the prospect of an extra 15 women and only 20 or so couples rotating.
With all due respect, when I learnt MJ on a Wednesday at Glasgow University Union it was quite often the case that there were so many extra women that it was one dance partner, then off to the bench again. I know exactly how frustrating this can be. However, three and a half years later I am still dancing.

J :nice:
" 'Remember one thing' replies his master 'you do not drown simply by plunging into water, you only drown by staying beneath the surface.' "
User avatar
Andy McGregor
Senior Member
Posts: 9276
Joined: Mon Mar 03, 2003 12:00 pm

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by Andy McGregor »

Firstly, I think the 'they're better than me' reason for not being fixed couples is weak. All the upset, if there is any, is with the observer: with no intent to upset by the individuals dancing as fixed couples.

But, when thinking about whether or not fixed-couples are selfish, consider this example: every woman grabs a man, and pursuades him to do the lesson as fixed couples: once all the men are taken there will be women who have no men to do the lesson with them :tears:

Is this fair?

The reason I don't rotate at Hipsters is this very one. If we all did it on the night I used as an example we'd have had nine women who wanted to do the lesson and no men available to partner them :tears:

I know all the arguments for sticking with the same partner and I agree with them. But I also think it's unfair because of the difference in the number of leaders and followers.

Now, if we both led and followed and weren't worried about dancing with a same-sex partner there'd be no such problem ...

.. just a thought.
“Any fool can make things bigger, more complex, and more violent. It takes a touch of genius-and a lot of courage-to move in the opposite direction.” Albert Einstein
User avatar
Divissima
Senior Member
Posts: 1461
Joined: Sun Aug 25, 2002 11:00 am

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by Divissima »

TheTramp wrote:Uh huh.

But I still don't understand why you can't 'bank' a move with Toby, having done the class in rotation. You say that you've found it more effective. I just don't understand how/why it would be more effective in this example.
I don't think it is up to you to decide if something is more effective for me?? What is there to understand? I have found it to be effective for me
The Tramp wrote:Of course, since you're not advancing it as an arguement, then it's not really a reason, which means that you can't be saying that it's more effective. Because, if it was more effective, as you say, then you'd surely be advancing it as an arguement??

Trampy
I was advancing it as an example (applicable to me) of one reason why a couple might choose not to rotate. I was also trying to say that, just because it was my reason, I could appreciate why other people might not necessarily agree that, in their opinion, it was a good reason.

I think you can back off now, Steve.
User avatar
ChrisA
Senior Member
Posts: 3831
Joined: Wed Sep 10, 2003 11:00 am

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by ChrisA »

Jayne wrote:earlier post about Weds Hipsters and not rotating snipped
........ :yeah: What Jayne said. :clap:

For a moment, I was worried I'd have nothing to add :whistle: but fortunately Andy came to the rescue :D
Andy McGregor wrote: I think that Divissima is right that she paid her money. But she didn't design the product. And I think the product is a lesson where people move on in lines and dance with different people. If people want special treatment and a different product I think they should pay a special and different price.
The product at Hipsters on a Wednesday, consists of two classes and a style workshop, as Jayne has explained in detail. The third one is based on the techniques taught in the first one. And both the first and third classes are relatively difficult (at least for me), not possible for most intermediate-level dancers to pick up in an instant if they turn up late.

Which, regrettably, is what many people tend to do. I think that Amir's classes are terrific, and make a big effort to get there on time. I know that Jayne makes a similar effort. But despite the difficulty, some people still expect to turn up half way through the lesson and muddle through.

Since I find Amir's classes pretty difficult at times, I don't have any qualms about not rotating in the third class, since on at least one rotation out of three I'm likely to get someone who turned up late to the first one - or missed it entirely - and will be very likely to scupper my attempts at learning - of course there are exceptions, and sometimes the dedicated ones are delayed for some reason...

...but it's extraordinary that the latecomers are sometimes the worst yankers and anticipators. You'd think they'd be the ones that tried the hardest to follow... :tears:

Chris
User avatar
TheTramp
Senior Member
Posts: 10672
Joined: Mon Nov 18, 2002 12:00 pm

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by TheTramp »

Divissima wrote:Hey Trampy, I was commenting on the extreme example you gave! Of course it's a matter of degree :rolleyes: I'm hoping that your post is mostly tongue-in-cheek as most dancers I know are perfectly capable of using their discretion to judge such a situation. Sorry, Trampy, I don't want to get drawn into a spurious argument with you (and, besides, my brain doesn't do arithmetic on a Friday afternoon :tears: ).

I have been trying to put the alternative view to Emma's in a reasonable way. Don't want this thread to degenerate like so many others.... :tears:
But it's not really a spurious arguement is it?? And there isn't really a need to do any arithmetic to understand the point that I was trying to make. Unless you were going to aim to provide us with numbers, where it would be 'acceptable' (I say 'acceptable', since, if the people who are being exclusive would move back into the class in this extreme situation, then presumably even they would find the extreme example 'unacceptable') for couples to be exclusive.

It's not spurious, since it addresses the point that you make, about couples moving back into the class in an unacceptable extreme situation. Who decides that the situation is extreme? And who picks the couples who move back? Since, presumably all the couples want to be exclusive now. So, I don't perceive any mass rush to go back to being unexclusive.

Though, it was still sort of said tongue-in-cheek.

And of course, you don't have to respond, and be drawn into any arguement, ever (spurious, or unspurious). That's your freedom of choice. (Is that exclusive??) :devil:

ODA mode, defintely on! :D

Trampy
Fluent in sarcasm! :flower:
User avatar
TheTramp
Senior Member
Posts: 10672
Joined: Mon Nov 18, 2002 12:00 pm

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by TheTramp »

Divissima wrote:I don't think it is up to you to decide if something is more effective for me?? What is there to understand? I have found it to be effective for me

I was advancing it as an example (applicable to me) of one reason why a couple might choose not to rotate. I was also trying to say that, just because it was my reason, I could appreciate why other people might not necessarily agree that, in their opinion, it was a good reason.

I think you can back off now, Steve.
Sorry Divi... I'm really not picking on you. I'm just striving to understand....

I never said that it wasn't effective for you, or not effective, or anything of the sort. In fact, if you re-read what I said, I asked you a question. I was merely also seeking to come to some understanding of your position, so that I would be able to agree with you :flower:

Trampy
Fluent in sarcasm! :flower:
Gus
Senior Member
Posts: 5203
Joined: Mon Mar 04, 2002 12:00 pm

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by Gus »

Jayne wrote:) I think that there is a fundamental difference between Ceroc and Hipsters - primarily that ceroc teaches beginners & intermediates and that Hipsters teaches advanced.
Urrr ... think thats a sweeping generalisation. I was talking about the 'Ceorc' model. Within that model a number of clubs, mainly non-Ceroc have been teaching advanced classes for some time. Even in my days at Ceroc Nantwich we were teaching 'unofficial' advanced lessons because we recognised the need for them. Blitz has had advanced lessons for a number of years. I don't want to get into the argument of whether Hipsters is MORE advanced ... but maybe the point is this .... if you are going to dance 'advanced moves/style' on the dancefloor with dancers who aren't your regular partner ... shouldnt you learn how to do the moves without your regular partner in the first place? Jut a thought :wink:
"We all believe in something... greater than ourselves, even if it's just the blind forces of chance" - G'Kar.
User avatar
TheTramp
Senior Member
Posts: 10672
Joined: Mon Nov 18, 2002 12:00 pm

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by TheTramp »

Jayne wrote:With all due respect, when I learnt MJ on a Wednesday at Glasgow University Union it was quite often the case that there were so many extra women that it was one dance partner, then off to the bench again. I know exactly how frustrating this can be. However, three and a half years later I am still dancing.
With all due respect (just so that I'm not accused of picking on Divi exclusively), Franck didn't say ALL ladies would be put off dancing. Just many. Maybe that's why so many people start, and don't come back (just a thought).

Of course, we're all glad that you carried one dancing Jayne :flower: Though, you'll probably never dance with me again :tears:

Trampy
Fluent in sarcasm! :flower:
User avatar
Franck
Senior Member
Posts: 3045
Joined: Tue Jan 15, 2002 12:00 pm

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by Franck »

Jayne wrote:I think that the requirements of the two groups of paying customers should be taken into account.
I totally agree, and I think that classes should be open about their intentions from the outset.
If Hipsters advertise their classes as open to everyone with / without partner etc... then they should deliver on that promise. If they are selling a premium product where you need a certain level of expertise and a partner, then that should be reflected in the advertising / price etc...
The problem arises when a night isn't sure of what it is...
I still think that for special workshops and classes exclusive partners should be allowed (and indeed advertised is it's a potentially dangerous class - aerials or drops for example).
On a regular class, advertised as such, then opting out is selfish. Notwithstanding exceptional cases like the 'partially sighted' lady on Tuesday at Jumpin' Jaks who for obvious reasons opted out of the rotation.
Jayne wrote:With all due respect, when I learnt MJ on a Wednesday at Glasgow University Union it was quite often the case that there were so many extra women that it was one dance partner, then off to the bench again. I know exactly how frustrating this can be. However, three and a half years later I am still dancing.
Well, exactly, when there were 15 or more extra women, at least you didn't have to feel insulted because half a dozen couples thought they could bypass the problem selfishly!
Most classes have extra women, there is little we can do about it, but there is no need to add insult to injury.
Franck.

There's an A.P.P. for that!
User avatar
David Franklin
Senior Member
Posts: 3426
Joined: Fri Feb 22, 2002 1:52 pm

Re: A little moan

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Franklin »

TheTramp wrote:Sorry. While I agree with the rest of your post Divi. I don't quite understand why you can only 'bank' a move that you've done when you do it as a fixed couple.
Here are two specific reasons:

Something that quite often happens to me is that I realise I'm "stuck" with a bit of the move where I can't actually see what's going on (i.e. I'm facing away from the teacher). If I'm rotating (and particularly if the ladies are getting moved on a lot), I really don't want to say "do you mind not having your turn so I can watch the teacher?".

Also, if I just can't get the first part of the routine, if I'm not rotating, we can just agree "we'll just do a first move and travelling return instead" (say), and still get something from the rest of the class. You can't really do this when rotating.

These are situations where if I'm rotating, I might not even "get" the move enough to be able to repeat it outside the class, so the "solution" of practising it with my partner afterwards doesn't really work.

Going from the abstract to the specific - in practice the m/f imbalance at Hipsters is such that I do usually rotate - seems a bit unkind not to. (Plus I can never do the routine anyhow, so Bryony needs to rotate so as to have a chance :tears: )

Dave
Post Reply