Originally posted by DavidY
Me too, but not for the right reasons... I can hear stuff going on in the music, but don't know how to turn it into dancing.
Been there.
Spent a lot of time there.
So long, in fact, that it drove me so crazy that I came within a hairsbreadth of giving up MJ completely.
However...
A musicality workshop from Amir was what put me on the road to cracking it, and the part of it that somehow opened up the relevant mental pathways for me was putting on a track with entirely regular predictable breaks, and getting the class to just stop in the break, on every break, regardless of where in the move we all were.
Don't know quite what happened after that, but I suddenly found myself hearing the breaks coming, long enough ahead of time to be able to do something about it.
Occasionally I would be in the right place in a move on the break, and it wouldn't be an accident. I didn't know what I was doing, but it felt deliberate, and gradually the proportion of breaks where I was able to be somewhere useful at the right time increased.
I would suggest listening to, and dancing to, tracks with a regular structure that includes a break... examples that come to mind are "Wade in the water", "King of the Road", but there are lots of others like it... (help, please, DJs ??)
Listen not only for the break, but the start of the phrase that follows it.
Aim initially to stop on the break, and to start simply with a step back at the beginning of the next phrase.
There are some, doubtless advanced musical dancers, who speak disparagingly of just stopping on the breaks as playing "musical statues" - but IMHO you should disregard such comments, since we all have to start somewhere.
Chris