You can't really be a good partner dancer unless...

Confused by the Accordion Comb Pull Crab?

Spinning gets you dizzy?
Would like some help with a tricky intermediate move? Ask here, and share your fave tips...
You need to be registered / logged in to read this forum

Do you need to be a confident solo dancer to be a better partner dancer?

Yes, definitely
5
16%
No, doesn't make any difference
16
52%
Depends on the individual
10
32%
 
Total votes: 31

User avatar
Gav
Senior Member
Posts: 5424
Joined: Tue Sep 12, 2006 7:23 am
Contact:

You can't really be a good partner dancer unless...

Report a concern about this post

Post by Gav »

you're confident dancing on your own.

That's a quote I've heard a few times recently, particularly at a Lindy Hop class and I'm starting to think they might be right.
What do you think?
Do you know any exceptions?

My thinking is that people who are confident dancing on their own will therefore have less inhibitions than those of us who aren't, and therefore will be better partner dancers. A wide generalism of course, but it makes some sense to me.
"You can't argue with stupid" - Me
User avatar
Beowulf
Senior Member
Posts: 7985
Joined: Tue Jul 01, 2003 10:17 pm
Contact:

Re: You can't really be a good partner dancer unless...

Report a concern about this post

Post by Beowulf »

I think saying "You can't be good at A unless you're confident in doing B" is just another way of saying "You can't do A unless you're confident." Full stop.

Substitute "public speaking" or "acting" etc for B instead of "dancing solo" then you'll see my point. Some people may be great at partner dancing but nervous wrecks when it comes to public speaking.. or vice versa. Some people (not sitting a nanometer away from me at the moment) are woefully lacking in confidence and don't think I've .. erm I mean.. they've ever danced "solo" in my..erm.. their life! However, I've done acting etc and found that easier.

I guess if you're confident in dancing you're generally confident in all forms of dancing but it does depend on the individual. I certainly feel more comfortable dancing with a partner than dancing around my manbag on my ownsome (in theory)
User avatar
jivecat
Senior Member
Posts: 2041
Joined: Sun Oct 26, 2003 8:49 pm

Re: You can't really be a good partner dancer unless...

Report a concern about this post

Post by jivecat »

I think dancing on your own helps to develop musicality faster than dancing with a partner because you've got liberty to listen to the music and interpret it without the worry of dealing with a partner. It would also help to develop general movement skills.

But you need more than those things to be a good partner dancer, like timing, precision, empathy, social communication, self-awareness.

I don't think lack of inhibition is a particular advantage in a dancing partnership. Perhaps you were thinking of something else? :wink:
Dim ond calon lân all ganu
Canu'r dydd a chanu'r nos.
User avatar
whitetiger1518
Senior Member
Posts: 2119
Joined: Thu Jul 06, 2006 11:22 am
Contact:

Re: You can't really be a good partner dancer unless...

Report a concern about this post

Post by whitetiger1518 »

Absolutely hopeless while dancing on my own.... I never did get the dancing around handbags in a group thing. I used to manage the twist OK, but as my knees have stiffened :tears: that is a no go area now.

A combination of Ceilidh and MJ in my recent history means that I can't think what to do next if an opportunity to dance by myself happens (I proved this at a muggle wedding reasonably recently - I hadn't a clue how to dance and mainly watched my colleagues instead! :confused: )

WT
This is so nice, it must be Illegal!: Fats Waller
Sustained Intensity equals Ecstacy: Wynton Marsalis
emmylou25
Senior Member
Posts: 554
Joined: Tue Jul 01, 2008 8:36 am

Re: You can't really be a good partner dancer unless...

Report a concern about this post

Post by emmylou25 »

Confidence in dancing ability definitely helps with how you portray yourself to others when dancing, how you learn, and probably a positive attitude towards dance which will help learn & take on new dancing skills & style. You'll also give your partner more confidence. There's also the two sides of confidence - you can be confident in your skills, but you may be really shy and hate the 'showy' or performance aspect so that will impact any dancing whether solo or partner.

I don't believe that being a confident solo dancer will make you a good partner dancer. What it can do is give the impression that you are a good dancer, that you know what you're doing, and that you can cover up any lack in technique/following or leading ability with the performance and confidence that say 'I can dance'. You may feel totally exposed as a solo dancer, but feel totally at home in partner dancing.

For instance, I've done lots of dance in the past - ballet, modern, jazz, a bit of tap - all solo which has provided me with a lot of technical knowledge and confidence in my ability to pick up pretty much all technical sides of dance (but I still feel self conscious and that people are watching if i'm bopping at a wedding or such like). This knowledge helped me pick up the technical side of any ballroom dancing i've tried, and made me a proficient salsa dancer. The being a good follower came from having a salsa teacher who drummed into us correct lead & follow technique, adapting to different leads, tension/compression etc - and it's that which has enabled me to become a good partner in ceroc and also helped me pick up WCS fairly quickly. But would people watching say I'm a better partner dancer than one of my friends (similar background) who's admitted that I've got better technique and following/leading ability vs all her styling - because she's generally a more confident person with no inhibitions when it comes to dancing. Probably not.

Also, it will depend on who you're dancing with and what they want from a partner and a specific dance.

A lot of waffle there, but ultimately I don't think confidence to dance solo makes you a better partner dancer, but it will help the way you think about and learn dance, as well as enabling you to be a natural performer.

I think it's a lot like being a musician - you can be a great classically trained musician and play through reading music with no ability or confidence to improvise. Alternatively you could be a jazz musician, self taught and not able to read music. Both could be great musicians, just at different things (needless to say I was a music reader, and just didn't have the confidence to improvise!)
User avatar
Andy McGregor
Senior Member
Posts: 9276
Joined: Mon Mar 03, 2003 12:00 pm

Re: You can't really be a good partner dancer unless...

Report a concern about this post

Post by Andy McGregor »

There's two answers to this.

My first answer is that you can't be a good partner dancer until you're a good partner dancer. You don't need to be anything else before you can become a good partner dancer. You just become good when you get good. And you usually get good by taking lessons and practicing what you'd like to be good at.

The second answer is specific to Modern Jive. And that answer is that you can't be a good partner dancer at a social dance like Modern Jive if you are anti-social. You might be a good dancer, you might even be technically good at Modern Jive and win competitions. But that's not the point. MJ is a social dance and if you are anti-social you are IMHO, rubbish.
“Any fool can make things bigger, more complex, and more violent. It takes a touch of genius-and a lot of courage-to move in the opposite direction.” Albert Einstein
CheesyRobMan
Senior Member
Posts: 1220
Joined: Fri Feb 22, 2008 1:55 pm

Re: You can't really be a good partner dancer unless...

Report a concern about this post

Post by CheesyRobMan »

Maybe I'm just an aberration in this regard but I would say I'm not good at solo dancing at all, while considering myself a reasonably competent MJ/blues dancer with partner. That's because I learnt to dance at a ceroc class and all the dance instruction I've ever had has been with a partner. I can get up and shamble around a bit if I'm muggling but it's not the same at all. I learnt rhythm through learning music at school but the problem is just what to do with myself! With a partner it's easy, your hands/arms are occupied with them and your feet are concerned primarily with not stepping on them. When alone it's a very different story and I mostly have no idea. The results can be quite comical :lol: :lol:
User avatar
Double Trouble
Senior Member
Posts: 5534
Joined: Sun Apr 09, 2006 7:19 pm

Re: You can't really be a good partner dancer unless...

Report a concern about this post

Post by Double Trouble »

Seems I'm in the minority.

I think there are 2 types of dancer

"dancing by numbers dancer" = can't solo dance

"wow factor dancer" = can solo dance

I imagine there are exceptions, but I don't know any.
Up there for thinking, down there for dancing
User avatar
robd
Senior Member
Posts: 3696
Joined: Wed May 11, 2005 5:01 pm
Contact:

Re: You can't really be a good partner dancer unless...

Report a concern about this post

Post by robd »

Gav wrote:you're confident dancing on your own.
Is that to be taken literally - as in 'confident dancing solo with nobody watching'? If so, I suspect many/most partner dance participants would fit this category. If it means 'confident dancing solo within a group of others dancing solo' then the numbers probably hold up reasonably well. If it means 'confident dancing solo with other people watching' then I suspect the numbers drop through the floor. Like any generalisation it's true in some cases and not in others. There are elements of commonality but also quite significant differences between partner and solo dancing.
You thought the beat slowed down?
COME ON!
Amir
Senior Member
Posts: 410
Joined: Fri Nov 08, 2002 12:00 pm

Re: You can't really be a good partner dancer unless...

Report a concern about this post

Post by Amir »

Well everyone’s standard of what ‘good’ is will be different, so I will say this: if you haven’t developed the confidence to move by yourself you are falling way way short of your potential as a partner dancer, in my opinion.

I don’t mean the confidence to dance when someone else is watching - alone in your room is just as good. But I believe there are two things you should be able to do to to become a competent partner dancer:

1) Feel able to express yourself by yourself. That way you have something to bring to the dance which at some level is your personality. This is the ‘why’ you move and not the ‘how’ you move.
2) Be able to dance the important elements of your dance by yourself. If I can’t do that I don’t trust I am really competent at moving with my partner. In partner dance the ‘how’ you move is also important, since it affects your partner a lot!

This isn't complicated. All you need to do is put on some music in your bedroom and boogie around until you feel comfortable or self expressive. The second one involves picking some of the most common moves you lead or follow, and see if you can do them with an imaginary partner. An outside opinion on this one can be helpful.
Amir
cederic
Senior Member
Posts: 346
Joined: Wed Mar 24, 2010 11:08 pm

Re: You can't really be a good partner dancer unless...

Report a concern about this post

Post by cederic »

I can't dance on my own. Doesn't ever happen (occasional victory dances don't count).

I've been partner dancing for a whole ten weeks. I know a ton of things I want to improve on, particularly my musicality, and I only know half a dozen "intermediate" moves.

Despite this, I think I can reach the level of 'good' as a partner dancer. It's something I want to achieve, and something that feels like an attainable objective.

More importantly, I can already often ensure that my partner enjoys the dance, and surely that's all that's needed to be a good partner dancer?
User avatar
Lory
Senior Member
Posts: 9918
Joined: Mon Oct 20, 2003 11:00 am
Contact:

Re: You can't really be a good partner dancer unless...

Report a concern about this post

Post by Lory »

Amir wrote: This isn't complicated. All you need to do is put on some music in your bedroom and boogie around until you feel comfortable or self expressive.
........ And then enter yourself on 'Britains got Talent' :rofl:
MODERATOR AT YOUR SERVICE :)
"If you're going to do something tonight, that you know you'll be sorry for in the morning, plan a lie in." Lorraine :wink:
Amir
Senior Member
Posts: 410
Joined: Fri Nov 08, 2002 12:00 pm

Re: You can't really be a good partner dancer unless...

Report a concern about this post

Post by Amir »

cederic wrote:I can't dance on my own. Doesn't ever happen.
Can you march on the spot in time to the music?
Amir
Prian
Senior Member
Posts: 770
Joined: Tue Sep 23, 2008 2:12 pm
Contact:

Re: You can't really be a good partner dancer unless...

Report a concern about this post

Post by Prian »

Andy McGregor wrote:There's two answers to this.

My first answer is that you can't be a good partner dancer until you're a good partner dancer. You don't need to be anything else before you can become a good partner dancer. You just become good when you get good. And you usually get good by taking lessons and practicing what you'd like to be good at.

The second answer is specific to Modern Jive. And that answer is that you can't be a good partner dancer at a social dance like Modern Jive if you are anti-social. You might be a good dancer, you might even be technically good at Modern Jive and win competitions. But that's not the point. MJ is a social dance and if you are anti-social you are IMHO, rubbish.
I know exactly what you mean. There is always a group/crowd at MJ events rather than classes (generally dance near the stage/DJ), who think that they are gods gift to MJ. And will not dance with, ask to dance or accept a dance from someone they do not think are of their level. And on the odd occasion that their radar fails them, refuse to acknowledge or smile or show enjoyment to the person they are dancing with. I would much rather dance with a beginner that smiled.

I once asked Viktor what one should say when asked "are you any good at this." He told me to say "I am only as good as my partner." I think that a good dance partner is someone who dances within the field or scope of the person they are dancing with. If you dance with someone and enjoy the dance then they are a good dance partner, highlighted by whether you or they wish to dance with each other again. I think it as simple as that. One ability to dance solo or whatever has little bearing on whether they are a good partner for you.

As you say Andy MJ is social. to my mind that means it is to be enjoyed. I have danced with some of the "legendary" ladies of Ceroc, Christine Keeble, Sylvia Coleman, Janie Cronin and Lydia Maurer among others (anyone not knowing these ladies, I will gladly explain). All with varying levels of enjoyment. Now I would be the first to compliment them on their dancing prowess and sing their praises to others, but as for being a good dance partner for me, some of them I'm not sure.
ant
Senior Member
Posts: 632
Joined: Fri Apr 27, 2007 12:22 pm

Re: You can't really be a good partner dancer unless...

Report a concern about this post

Post by ant »

Amir wrote:Can you march on the spot in time to the music?

I suspect leaders can almost get away with this if they have good connection and timing.

However I think followers have to move much more.

And the better they are as a solo dancer the better they may look at partner dancing. However to enjoy a dance with a follower their connection and timing to the music would be the more important.
martingold
Senior Member
Posts: 1864
Joined: Tue Nov 20, 2007 10:33 am

Re: You can't really be a good partner dancer unless...

Report a concern about this post

Post by martingold »

Double Trouble wrote: "dancing by numbers dancer" = can't solo dance
thats me then cos i am rubbish at solo dancing :D
You can do nothing about the length of your life but you can do something about it's width and depth

Keep it simple Keep it smooth
User avatar
Gav
Senior Member
Posts: 5424
Joined: Tue Sep 12, 2006 7:23 am
Contact:

Re: You can't really be a good partner dancer unless...

Report a concern about this post

Post by Gav »

lots of people wrote: but I am quite good
Maybe I need to define what I'm trying to say a bit better. I'm not saying that you can't be a competent/good partner dancer if you can't/won't dance on your own]je ne sais quoi[/I].
Double Trouble wrote:I think there are 2 types of dancer:
"dancing by numbers dancer" = can't solo dance
"wow factor dancer" = can solo dance
I imagine there are exceptions, but I don't know any.
:yeah: , that's pretty much what I mean.
robd wrote:Is that to be taken literally - as in 'confident dancing solo with nobody watching'?
No, as you say, anyone can do that. I mean definitely with people watching. Like at a club, party etc but without getting hammered first.
martingold wrote:thats me then cos i am rubbish at solo dancing :D
Yes it is you (and me, and the majority of MJers).
"You can't argue with stupid" - Me
User avatar
Gav
Senior Member
Posts: 5424
Joined: Tue Sep 12, 2006 7:23 am
Contact:

Re: You can't really be a good partner dancer unless...

Report a concern about this post

Post by Gav »

To give my own thoughts a bit more context, I have been trying to learn Lindy Hop on and off for quite a while. Technically, I think I've become a good beginner.
Something they seem to do in most Lindy classes (from time to time) is teach, or just do, strolls. A stroll is similar to line dancing, but with a bit of swing and the freedom to do something different if the music inspires you to.
So I've been learning strolls and the jazz steps that they're made up of. The teachers insist that it's important because of the whole solo dancing thing.
I hope it'll make my Lindy better, but I know it still won't give me that x-factor because I'll still be doing it in a crowd of people doing the same routine.

[eureka moment]and maybe that's it. Whether you're improvising the order of the moves you've learnt, or following a complete routine, you're still in your comfort zone and doing what you've been taught.
When you see good dancers on their own, they're doing what they feel to the music and I think that's what those lucky b4st4rds bring to a partner dance that makes the difference.[/eureka]
"You can't argue with stupid" - Me
rtwwpad
Senior Member
Posts: 300
Joined: Sun Jan 25, 2009 12:24 am

Re: You can't really be a good partner dancer unless...

Report a concern about this post

Post by rtwwpad »

I think comfort zones are the issue. Everyone can dance it's just that the funky stuff you do in the kitchen doesn't get brought to the floor. Of course if you've had to learn stone cold sober as you can no longer drink it can be a little harder again.
rtwwpad
Senior Member
Posts: 300
Joined: Sun Jan 25, 2009 12:24 am

Re: You can't really be a good partner dancer unless...

Report a concern about this post

Post by rtwwpad »

Sorry got cut off mid flow. I think that being a good dance partner doesn't mean you have to be confident solo. I think it means you have to make the other person enjoy the dance. Its different things for men and women though.

Women who compliment me (yes, on rare occasions it happens) on a dance, usually like the fact that is a) been smooth and b) provided them with the opportunity to express themselves a little. So for them, the fact that I don't do spins or complicated footwork doesn't seem to matter.

For me, I like it when a follow takes the opportunity presented to do something stylish or artistic. So for me a good partner follows well and takes her chances.

I find it hard when I have to follow to put he flourishes or footwork in. But this is mainly because I'm a stout bearded welshman being led by an exotic woman who is cackling at me (sorry I meant wife), I haven't been following that long.

So does confidence in solo dancing equate to the attributes mentioned. For women maybe, for men, not so much.
Post Reply