Alan Doyle wrote:Sounds to me like they were teaching WCS![]()
It was a lot like WCS but using MJ moves and no triple steps.
It was a very good class.
Alan Doyle wrote:Sounds to me like they were teaching WCS![]()
kps wrote:It was a lot like WCS but using MJ moves and no triple steps.
It was a very good class.![]()
kps wrote:It was a lot like WCS but using MJ moves and no triple steps.
It was a very good class.![]()
We probably were, I only recently started doing WCS and there were a lot of similarities with it but I felt it was more a slotted MJ dance with a slight technique change. But as I said I have only been dancing WCS for a few months so when I have a bit more experience I might well agree with you.Alan Doyle wrote:A lot of MJ moves were taken from WCS and it's possible to dance WCS using no triples. You were still dancing WCS in my opinion.
kps wrote:We probably were, I only recently started doing WCS and there were a lot of similarities with it but I felt it was more a slotted MJ dance with a slight technique change. But as I said I have only been dancing WCS for a few months so when I have a bit more experience I might well agree with you.
Alan Doyle wrote:A lot of MJ moves were taken from WCS and it's possible to dance WCS using no triples. You were still dancing WCS in my opinion.
But the Anchor is led (whether the follower tripples or not) as it is a result of the leader slowing the follower down before the redirection. Without this lead the follow should continue to travel in the direction that they were going. The main reason that the anchor step is trippled is due to this change of speed (as are most of the tripples in the dance). However a tripple is not essential as long as the follow is slowed to the point that they are ready for redirection.Gadget wrote:I have a real problem with the anchor step. Mainly because it's an anchor. It stops the follower from following and roots them for that beat.
Every problem I have ever encountered from leading WCS people has been with the anchor(*) - it's not a led step and followers go into automatic.
(* That and tripples)
Exactly.robd wrote: I still think this talk of it being MJ or WCS in this thread is a red herring when the stuff being talked about (stretch, gradual connection, etc) is simply a characteristic of accomplished dancing in either style.
TA Guy wrote: You step back to extension in MJ. You 'settle' with stretch, you enter the next move. Fundamentally exactly the same as WCS (Yes, WCS often adds a triple and takes two beats usually, but the 'settle' & 'anchor' purpose is the same). This MJ 'anchor' (for want of a better name) has nothing to do with a WCS influence.
Lazy Dave wrote:keep your bum under control.
Your talking about the mechanics, there are lots of differences in the mechanics; the (usual) triple in the WCS anchor, the number of beats etc. That is a givenAlan Doyle wrote:It's not fundamentally the same as WCS. To reiterate, the lady steps back on count 1 in MJ and the lady steps forward on count 1 in WCS.
Geordieed wrote:... As a default MJ does not work to the action/reaction affect on a frame in an open dance position from the use of the semi circle action. Whether or not social dancers see the semi circle as something that they use in their dance Ceroc still teach it as a default and feature it in their beginner DVD. ...
I'm trying to understand here what the semi-circle (used as a teaching aid to start a sequence of dance moves) has to do with what happens in the actual dance...kps wrote:... I do hope this could possibly be the way ceroc is heading along with saying good bye to the semicircle as I think it looks and feels much better when dancing.
I disagree - sounds more like they were teaching an MJ variation on "Deans Collins Style" Lindy hop, which is slotted and has the rock step/step back.Alan Doyle wrote:Sounds to me like they were teaching WCS![]()
kps wrote:At the end of each move we stepped away from each other building the tension. The lady then took at step forward at the start of the move as the man moved out of the slot to allow her to pass to allow her to travel to the other end of the slot.
It would actually. At least it'd make the start a bit more awkward socially if it wasn't there.ducasi wrote: I reckon you could teach WCS with something like a semi-circle in place of the starter step. It wouldn't affect how the actual dance is danced, would it?
"Semi-circle and triple-step back!"
[nitpick mode]While Lindy makes a lot of use of rock-steps, and it's one of the normal ways of teaching newcomers, it would be a mistake to say that that's the "standard" Lindy method - seasoned Lindyhoppers often use walk-walk or twist-twist, or any number of variations. The leads will tend to rock-step more than the follows, but when it comes down to it, the "standard" thing is simply to do any footwork which fits the dance, and allows for a degree of anchoring. Amongst the higher echelons, the rocksteps can seem to vanish altogether - here's a fun example.Alan Doyle wrote:West Coast Swing was also derived from Lindy Hop but the rock step was replaced with a 'walk walk'