Alan Doyle wrote:The 4-beat starter step is only used at the start of the dance, it starts on beat 5 and it danced through 8 so the next move starts on count 1 of the next phrase.
If you are counting:
1& 2& 3& 4& 5& 6& 7& 8& as opposed to
12 34 56 78 12 34 56 78
you're going to start it on the wrong beat!
You could dance the starter step on 5,6,7,8 before the start of the next phrase. Then the routine should be 32 beats long to phrase and you omit the starter step and repeat the 32 beats to phrase.
The starter step is only danced once in the dance, to 'start' the dance.
Sure, but I believe your reasoning for the starter step was so that everyone could start on beat 1 right? (your words were “I think introducing a 4-beat starter step in Modern Jive would be beneficial because it would have everyone starting on beat 1 as opposed to beat 8.”
What you’re now asking is for them to count themselves in so that they start dancing on count 5 rather than count 1. Given that count 1 is almost always the more dominant of the two it’s the easier one for people to count themselves in on. If you’re able to count yourself in on count five, you’re almost certainly more than capable of counting yourself in on count 1 without using a starter step.
I think you’ll find the purpose of the starter step is to establish connection and feel each other out a little before the dance proper begins. This is why some MJ schools of thought teach “starting” on count 8. It lets the partners start out in leverage an smooths out the start.
It’s also worth noting that they typically start on the other foot as those starting on 1, which means that immediately after count one there is no difference between the two. Somehow though, this is apparently the difference between dancing on the downbeat and the upbeat….
Terminology...
The downbeats are beats 1,3,5,7
The upbeats are beats 2,4,6,8
If you start the dance on count 8, you are dancing on the upbeat.
If you start the dance on count 1, you are dancing on the downbeat.
Yeah yeah…….. that’s pretty old news.
You should start the dance on a downbeat or it looks strange, it really changes the look of the dance if you start on beat 1 rather than beat 8.
For how long? See the first half of this post.
Pulsing is a recurring accent that intensifies the essence of a dance. If you accent the downbeat or if you accent the upbeat it changes the look of the dance.
So I can choose to accent either the downbeat or the upbeat, but I’m only dancing MJ if I accent the downbeat right (because it’s apparently a downbeat dance)? What about if I accent the downbeats more often, but pick out some of the funky upbeats in an R&B tune? How about if I have no sense of music and don’t accent anything all – will that still be MJ?
Terminology...
You don't change the footwork, you're still dancing it using the same footwork, but to accent the downbeat or accent the upbeat, you give more emphasis as you step to the downbeat or upbeat. It doesn't change the pattern, it doesn't change what foot you're on. It changes the look of the dance.
I’ll ask again: define what emphasis is then?
Pulled out from a thread that was before your time Alan, I have the following quote from Myles Munroe (
this guy)
Hi All, Myles Munroe here (Tessa's partner)
Tessa asked my opinion on this matter and thought my background in multiple dances would lend for a very informative post, so here goes:
The first question about the possibilty of being limited by dancing upeat/down beat vs. Downbeat/upbeat is a good one, the debate is still going on in the Hustle community and the Nite club Two-step community. There are two answers, one simple, one not so much.
Once two dancers start moving (one on the down, the other on the up) they will look equally on time. If a hustle dancer or MJ dancer were dancing to a techno song that had bass hits on all beats 1, 2, 3, 4 etc..... then you would not be able to tell the difference of an upbeat dancer or a down beat dancer.
Here's the trickier part. Most modern music (unlike classical) is accented on the up beats. The main pulse is on the ups (think of what beat you would snap on) and the phrasing and structure of the songs are all set on the 1's or downbeat. This allows people to think it best to dance on the upbeat to stay on the accent. These people will dance to only one aspect of a song. Musicians aren't thinking about dancers when they write music. They will start their instrumentation around the 1 beat and same with the lyrics. When a song hits a break or a dancer starts dancing to the start of the song is where the difference of the downbeat or upbeat dancer shows itself.
A downbeat dancer will begin moving when the song starts or resumes after a break. An upbeat dancer will either move before or after the start/resume of a song and will appear to be "off-time". Again, once they're going and until the next break they will both look fine except to the musically trained person who understands phrasing.
Almost every song that we would wcs or mj to will have the breaks on 1 or 5 of an 8 beat measure of music. A down beat dancer will be more likely to be "naturally" hitting it by having their patterns beginning on the downbeats because they will hear the break or phrase change coming a few beats early and will only have to pause or not start a pattern and they will hit the music.
An Upbeat dancer will have to interupt their patterns or wait an extra count once they hear the break coming. The upbeat dancer will be forcing the breaks as it is more likely that they will be beginning a new pattern on the 8 and have to wait from 7 until the break on 1 or start and stop their patterns.
As far as the interpretation of music goes, it is in most cases more beneficial to the overall dance to dance on the downbeat. Obviously there are exceptions to every rule, again in the case of classical music and most traditional asian songs where the pulses/accents are on the downbeats. These songs would best be danced on the upbeat. (I have a fascinating summary of a study done on Chinese people and North American music and Dance, I'll bring it up in another post if people ask)
According to this rationalization, both MJ and WCS are downbeat dances rather than WCS being upbeat as you claim.
So, which is it?