The judges decision is final!

Confused by the Accordion Comb Pull Crab?

Spinning gets you dizzy?
Would like some help with a tricky intermediate move? Ask here, and share your fave tips...
You need to be registered / logged in to read this forum

Should the judges voting in competitions be made available for all to see?

No. The results should be kept hidden. It allows for more (friendly) debate.
7
13%
Don't really care. I wouldn't look at them anyway.
5
9%
Yes. For the finals. Protecting the anonimity of the judges.
3
6%
Yes. For every round. Protecting the anonimity of the judges.
20
38%
Yes. For the finals. Allowing the judges names to be seen.
3
6%
Yes. For every round. Allowing the judges names to be seen.
15
28%
 
Total votes: 53

DavidB
Senior Member
Posts: 2263
Joined: Wed Feb 20, 2002 12:00 pm

Report a concern about this post

Post by DavidB »

Originally posted by gcapell
Not a big deal, but I believe this system was first trialled by Deb Cantoni's LeBop comp last year.
I'd never heard of this system being used in Modern Jive before this, but it has been used in other forms of dancing for a long time.

The whole Dance With A Stranger concept was invented by Jack Carey in the States back in the '50s. They call it 'Jack and Jill'. I'm not sure when they started swapping partners during a heat, but they were doing it at the first comp we went to in the US in 1998.

The Jack and Jill is the most serious category for non-professionals. They have plenty of different levels - Novice, Intermediate, Advanced, All-Star, Champions, and Masters (ie seniors). They use a national points system to works out which level you are at. A 'serious' dancer who might enter the intermediate or advanced freestyle in the UK would enter the Jack and Jill in the US, not the freestyle. (My definition of serious is anyone who practices.)

For the very best dancers, the Showcase (choreographed with lifts) and the Classic (choreographed without lifts) are the main events. But they still have a Champions Jack And Jill category for them, and is run primarily for entertainment of the audience (and the competitors!) It is one of the highlights of the weekend

One of the biggest competitions of the year is held in Phoenix. It is only Jack and Jill - nothing else. It is very difficult to get tickets because so many people want to go and watch.

I wouldn't advocate anything like this at every comp in the UK. The existing DWAS format is too popular, and I think people appreciate a real 'fun' category. But maybe one competition could try it for a change.

David
Geordieed
Senior Member
Posts: 521
Joined: Tue Mar 04, 2003 5:31 pm

Test

Report a concern about this post

Post by Geordieed »

DWAS is a fascinating concept. It has the potential to be a good test to a dancers' ability. What do people think of DWAS pitched at different levels. Beginner, intermediate and advanced. Yes I know some may automatically express the opinion that a guy should lead a partner well at any level. If you are good enough to win then you should make even a beginner look like a princess at the ball.

From the other end of a lead many women have complained that they have ended up with a less experienced lead when they have entered DWAS and only lasted a couple of rounds although their ability should progess them alot further.
User avatar
Sheepman
Senior Member
Posts: 3687
Joined: Wed May 14, 2003 4:52 pm
Contact:

Report a concern about this post

Post by Sheepman »

Originally posted by DavidB
On a slightly different track - how about a DWAS version of the Jive Masters? The audience judges the best man and lady, but you get separate prizes for
- the best man according the men
- the best man according the ladies
- the best lady according the men
- the best lady according the ladies
I think this is a fab idea, and before anyone says that all those top dancers have danced together loads anyway, looking at the Jive Masters final, the finalists were spread both geographically and stylisticly, so it wouldn't be a problem.

Where can I get my ticket to see this?!

Greg
With one hand the past moves us forward, with the other it holds us back.
User avatar
ChrisA
Senior Member
Posts: 3831
Joined: Wed Sep 10, 2003 11:00 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by ChrisA »

Originally posted by Geordieed
DWAS is a fascinating concept. It has the potential to be a good test to a dancers' ability. What do people think of DWAS pitched at different levels. Beginner, intermediate and advanced. Yes I know some may automatically express the opinion that a guy should lead a partner well at any level. If you are good enough to win then you should make even a beginner look like a princess at the ball.
I guess I should never say never, but DWAS is the only type of competition I'd contemplate these days - I had my fill of the rest of it competing in ballroom and latin at uni, and although it was fun, there was too much stress and aggro for me to want to get all competitive again at my advanced age :)

But I love DWAS as a concept. As a Ceroc taxi I am frequently in a situation where beginner ladies are telling me how cr*p they think they are, having been led badly throughout the beginners' class. And then I dance with them, just simple stuff but led with care, and their eyes light up when they discover that they're fine after all. I tell them that any non-beginner guy should never lead a move they can't follow, since a dancer worth his salt will know in the first 10 seconds what level his lady is at.

And of the many ladies that are much better dancers than I am, sometimes I'll dance with one who is also highly skilled at sensing my level, and dances with me there, or (to challenge me a little) slightly above.

Nina and Lydia for example, are fine exponents of this art - I've seen them dancing with virtually complete beginners, just doing some basic moves well; then I've had dances with them where I'll attempt a bit more than that and not only do they not humiliate me when it doesn't quite come off, but I come away encouraged and inspired...

... and then I see Nina dance with Nigel, or Lydia with Viktor, and their status is truly revealed.

Sorry to ramble on like this, but it's this connection thing that I find so exciting to discover on the dance floor. I wouldn't deny that it can be taught, learned and developed, but I do think that the ability to connect with anyone, at any level, in this way gets right to the heart of the measure of a dancer.

Chris
User avatar
Martin
Senior Member
Posts: 2345
Joined: Mon Oct 20, 2003 7:29 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by Martin »

What an interesting thread, just read it through...

Firstly having been at both ends regularly :D Both Judge and competitor, I would like to see the results available to the competetors if they request it (which was done this year at Canberra)

My first competition at advanced level (1997) I got marked by one judge on presentation ZERO, I only knew as the judge sitting next to her questioned her and let me know why I did not make the top 3 in the finals, this helped me as I was then aware that a smile as well as hand movements, style etc. was required by some.

I favour rankings, 1,2,3,4,5 etc. as apposed to a 0-10 system, as some judges mark 0-10 to try to effect the marks, others mark mid-way 5-9.

I am in danger of reaching for my soap box, to keep it short I will finish on DWAS.

My first comp, I only did DWAS as I considered it "fun" and "safe"
I would love to see DWAS just for those who are not taking part in any other category, to add fun to otherwise spectators. This keeps it smaller, I also love the Aussie idea (started by Debs in Melbourne I think) this saves getting stuck with a lemon.

Marty
User avatar
Tiggerbabe
Senior Member
Posts: 5844
Joined: Thu Jan 17, 2002 12:00 pm

Report a concern about this post

Post by Tiggerbabe »

Originally posted by Martin
this saves getting stuck with a lemon.

Marty


What on earth is that supposed to mean?
If it means what I think it does, then so much for the competition being for fun (I'm sure I was awful when I first started ceroc but people still didn't seem to mind dancing with me) ................if it doesn't :confused: please clarify!!!!
"If you rebel against high heels, take care to do so in a very smart hat.'' George Bernard Shaw
User avatar
Martin
Senior Member
Posts: 2345
Joined: Mon Oct 20, 2003 7:29 am

What's in a word?

Report a concern about this post

Post by Martin »

So "Lemons" causing a problem, luckily we have lots of lemon trees here in Australia. Anyone who knows lemons, knows they are yellow, oval and have pointy bits at both ends...

In the UK the dance with a stranger is truely a fun "lucky dip" event. 100% fun and seen as such. :D

In Australia there is fun in competition also they do seperate between beginner, intermediate and advanced for the "lucky dip" where people who do not have a regular partner hope to do well. They also try a lot harder to suceed (in my opinion from what I have seen so far). :waycool:

If I entered DWAS in the UK I would do so in the spirit of the event and hope to have some great fun with whoever I was partnered with.

In Aussie or USA (quote from David) - "The Jack and Jill is the most serious category for non-professionals. They have plenty of different levels - Novice, Intermediate, Advanced, All-Star, Champions, and Masters (ie seniors). They use a national points system to works out which level you are at. A 'serious' dancer who might enter the intermediate or advanced freestyle in the UK would enter the Jack and Jill in the US, not the freestyle. "
It is far more a case of upper level competition.

My point was that by changing partners 3 times you get to 'show your stuff' across a range of partners who are new to you which gives a fairer reflection of your ability to dance with total strangers regerdless of the ability of one specific dancer.

One of the problems being that you might be matched with someone who does not suit your particular 'dance style'.

There is no right or wrong - mix a swing dancer with a 'smoothy' and things do not gel. Bit like watching a Kangaroo dancing with an ice skater.

In Australia we have had some fun challenges - a 'girl' with an adams apple and taller than the regular male dancers in "advanced" competed, who could not do a simple dip. Maybe as a "he", reached advanced so advanced was the catogory applicable. :sorry

Hope you can get past he one word "syndrome" and view the rest of the mail as intended.

Marty
User avatar
Tiggerbabe
Senior Member
Posts: 5844
Joined: Thu Jan 17, 2002 12:00 pm

Re: What's in a word?

Report a concern about this post

Post by Tiggerbabe »

Originally posted by Martin
Anyone who knows lemons, knows they are yellow, oval and have pointy bits at both ends...
Yes, I do believe I've seen them in the supermarket - have even been known to purchase them - but can honestly say I've never seen any at a dance competition.

In the UK the dance with a stranger is truely a fun "lucky dip" event. 100% fun and seen as such. :D

Absolutely, and for many people - for whatever reason - probably the only competition they'll ever enter.

My point was that by changing partners 3 times you get to 'show your stuff' across a range of partners who are new to you which gives a fairer reflection of your ability to dance with total strangers regerdless of the ability of one specific dancer.

One of the problems being that you might be matched with someone who does not suit your particular 'dance style'.

Hope you can get past he one word "syndrome" and view the rest of the mail as intended.

Marty

I agree that changing partners would definitely be more of a challenge :waycool:
however, I would suggest that there must have been a better way of describing someone whose style doesn't click with yours - you could maybe just have said "it saves you getting stuck with someone who does not suit your particular dance-style".

I'm sure you would be less than pleased if you heard yourself referred to in a similar manner :sad:
I think all dancers, regardless of anyone's perception of their ability or style deserve some courtesy.
"If you rebel against high heels, take care to do so in a very smart hat.'' George Bernard Shaw
User avatar
Martin
Senior Member
Posts: 2345
Joined: Mon Oct 20, 2003 7:29 am

Dance comps - the thread...

Report a concern about this post

Post by Martin »

I am truely sorry if you have been refered to as a lemon in the past as this must have hit a nerve.

I would never want to go head to head with you (certainly not in a dark ally)

Did you have any comment on the rest of the mail which refered to the original thread of dance comps?

Marty
User avatar
Tiggerbabe
Senior Member
Posts: 5844
Joined: Thu Jan 17, 2002 12:00 pm

Re: Dance comps - the thread...

Report a concern about this post

Post by Tiggerbabe »

Originally posted by Martin
I am truely sorry if you have been refered to as a lemon in the past as this must have hit a nerve.
Not that I'm aware of, Marty - but maybe - have we danced? :wink: :rofl: sorry, couldn't resist it! :D

Did you have any comment on the rest of the mail which refered to the original thread of dance comps?
Marty

The point of marking people on rankings is certainly one I would agree with, but then some people like to know exactly why they've been placed 3rd as opposed to 2nd and so on. Also as you say there may be the odd time when politics enter the equation but doubt you can eliminate this whichever system you opt for.

I'm glad I'm not a judge, we got the opportunity to try it recently at the Jive Masters heat and I think it made people realise that it's not as easy as it seems to be.

Re the alley - I'm frightened of the dark, I'm just 5ft 6" and weigh 9stone 4lbs - only dangerous when roused :devil:
"If you rebel against high heels, take care to do so in a very smart hat.'' George Bernard Shaw
User avatar
Martin
Senior Member
Posts: 2345
Joined: Mon Oct 20, 2003 7:29 am

Keep it on-line

Report a concern about this post

Post by Martin »

Glad to have had the intellectual reparse, hope to dance with you soon.

Any further comments please do feel free to PM me.

Otherwise do tell about your comp adventures.

Marty
Daisy
Senior Member
Posts: 397
Joined: Wed Oct 15, 2003 11:00 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by Daisy »

It is precisely Martins view that prompted me to pull out of the DWAS comp. in Sydney in Sept. I soon realised that the Aussie blokes, in the advanced section, would not be too pleased if they were paired with a Pom that doesn't do big arials!

I'm sure I would have been called several names.....'lemon' being one of the kinder ones. :sad:

Give me the UK version any day. DWAS should be fun as well as a test of the mans ability to lead and the womans to follow. Forget big fancy moves and look at the way the guy takes care of his partner, whatever level dancer she is, gives her the opportunity to look good and most of all.........feels relaxed enough to smile and enjoy it!

One of the nice things, in my oppinion, is the way partners build up a report throughout the rounds and you can see them dancing better together as they progress.

I and others didn't enjoy watching the Aussie version as it was bitty and muddled. One Australian female dancer complained at two Brits being paired up together, even though they rarely danced together when all the other contestants were Aussies from regular venues, and she ended up in the final with a guy she dances with regularly....and won! Some people lose perspective when they got too serious! :really:

Nothing personal Martin...just making a point.
Gary
Senior Member
Posts: 347
Joined: Tue Nov 12, 2002 7:29 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by Gary »

Originally posted by Daisy
It is precisely Martins view that prompted me to pull out of the DWAS comp. in Sydney in Sept. I soon realised that the Aussie blokes, in the advanced section, would not be too pleased if they were paired with a Pom that doesn't do big arials!
That's a shame :sad: I would hope that it would be unusual for a guy to pout about any move his DWAS partner doesn't know -- that's part of the point of DWAS, you can only go with stuff that's lead/follow-able (generally). It'd be crazy to try big aerial moves with someone you haven't practiced with anyway. I must confess I did a couple of little aerial moves in the DWAS, but only after checking with the girl that she knew them and was OK with them. And I'm pretty sure I wouldn't have wasted time pouting or name-calling if the girl hadn't known them.

Give me the UK version any day. DWAS should be fun as well as a test of the mans ability to lead and the womans to follow. Forget big fancy moves and look at the way the guy takes care of his partner, whatever level dancer she is, gives her the opportunity to look good and most of all.........feels relaxed enough to smile and enjoy it!
Firstly, haven't danced in UK (yet), so maybe I can't comment.

Secondly, I had major fun in the DWAS, and so did everyone else I talked to about it. "Challenging" needn't mean "not fun".

Thirdly, "big" and "fancy" are in the eye of the beholder, I imagine. I see some advanced couples doing moves in normal freestyle that I think are fancy, but it's just normal to them. I guess in DWAS the couple has to quickly find the level/moves that are comfortable for the couple (but a bit challenging/interesting).

I and others didn't enjoy watching the Aussie version as it was bitty and muddled.
I suspect that this was partly the "avoid regular partners dancing together" thing. If I were running it I would just do a random rotation, and if people end up getting one minute with their regular partner, don't worry about it. If you wanted to be fancy you could arrange the draw so that regular partners were not in the same heat (assuming you're using a computer for the draw here).

One Australian female dancer complained at two Brits being paired up together, even though they rarely danced together when all the other contestants were Aussies from regular venues,
I would guess that she was joking?
DavidB
Senior Member
Posts: 2263
Joined: Wed Feb 20, 2002 12:00 pm

Report a concern about this post

Post by DavidB »

I think the two versions of DWAS are so different they shouldn't be compared.

You enter the UK version for fun and to meet someone new. You don't enter with any hope or expectation of getting to the second round, let alone the final or winning. The chance that a beginner can get to dance with one of the top dancers is generally said to be one of the attractions of this format, but these pairings never do well. The judges can only judge in absolute terms - a beginner dancing out of their socks will not look as good as an advanced dancer. So the finals always have the few intermediate/advanced dancers who were lucky enough to get drawn together. But winning is not the point - neither is competing. It is more of a social dance than a competition.

The Australian version is still fun, but in a different way. You enter knowing that the best dancers on the day will make the final, and the hope that you are one of them. You have this chance as an intermediate, an advanced or as a professional dancer. It is not a social dance - it is a competition that tests social dance skills. People enter to see how good they are at leading and following, etc. Marking the individuals and not the couple means that you get more credit for how well you treat your partner, and not less.

I don't think one is better than the other to take part in - they are just different competitions. I'd just like the chance to do both types without having to travel to the other side of the planet.

I didn't like everything about the Aussie version. I don't think aerials should be allowed in any type of DWAS. And if you swap partners a couple of times in the heats, then don't worry if people draw their regular partner. Only worry about it in the final, when you don't swap.

Similarly I don't like everything about the UK version - particularly that by the time the final comes around it is anything but 'Dance with a Stranger'. Some couples will have spent most of the day practising together, and the moves have become too choreographed. If people want to take it that seriously, then they should enter the freestyle instead.

As a spectator I found the Aussie version more interesting to watch than the UK version. I rarely watch the a UK DWAS until the final.

David
Chris
Senior Member
Posts: 889
Joined: Thu Jan 17, 2002 5:48 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by Chris »

Originally posted by DavidB
I think the two versions of DWAS are so different they shouldn't be compared.


Nice to see a post extolling the differences, pluses and minuses of both, instead of falling into the 'is one better than the other' thing.

Now, if I could if you could be so wise and balanced on subjects in my own threads or the so-called Manchester football club Mr B . . . :wink: :wink: :devil: :rofl: :rofl:
:cheers:
User avatar
TheTramp
Senior Member
Posts: 10672
Joined: Mon Nov 18, 2002 12:00 pm

Report a concern about this post

Post by TheTramp »

Manchester City don't have any virtues though, Chris. :na:

Steve
Fluent in sarcasm! :flower:
Chris
Senior Member
Posts: 889
Joined: Thu Jan 17, 2002 5:48 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by Chris »

Originally posted by TheTramp
Manchester City don't have any virtues though, Chris. :na:


You mean not ones that you've noticed? :wink: :waycool:
User avatar
Martin
Senior Member
Posts: 2345
Joined: Mon Oct 20, 2003 7:29 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by Martin »

Thanks David,

Much more eloquently put.

I shall never use the term “Lemon” again…

Interestingly the same guy won DWAS in the Ceroc London 2003 comp as won the Australian DWAS 2003. Our very own Louie (Elias) Raish, some of you may remember him from Camber Sands in May where he taught a class.

The girl who won DWAS in Australia, Adriana was also in the Ceroc London 2003 comp and got through to the finals. She was also at Camber in May as my demoer for the classes I taught and fellow “Jetset Amarni” team show partner in the cabaret. (and yes she was joking Daisy re- the UK match up partner wise)
:cheers:
User avatar
Gordon J Pownall
Senior Member
Posts: 1000
Joined: Thu Oct 10, 2002 11:00 am

Re: The judges decision is final!

Report a concern about this post

Post by Gordon J Pownall »

TheTramp wrote:Manchester City don't have any virtues though, Chris. :na:

Steve
Yes they do !!!!!! :mad:

They have the new stadium....


Onlu problem is it's facing the football pitch..... :eek:
Gordy
~ It's a Dance Thing ~


:what: 'Τα δόντια μου είναι μου δικοί - οι γόμμες δεν είναι' :what:

www.vatsim-uk.org
User avatar
Gordon J Pownall
Senior Member
Posts: 1000
Joined: Thu Oct 10, 2002 11:00 am

Re: The judges decision is final!

Report a concern about this post

Post by Gordon J Pownall »

TheTramp wrote:Manchester City don't have any virtues though, Chris. :na:

Steve
Yes they do !!!!!! :mad:

They have the new stadium....


Only problem is it's facing the football pitch..... :eek:
Gordy
~ It's a Dance Thing ~


:what: 'Τα δόντια μου είναι μου δικοί - οι γόμμες δεν είναι' :what:

www.vatsim-uk.org
Post Reply