Ask a few Israeli citizens that question and you'll probably get the answer "not enough" - and probably not entirely tongue-in-cheek either. A friend who was a BBC dish producer at the time told me she was astonished to hear of the level of antipathy and vitriol directed at western journalists (particularly the BBC) by ordinary Israelis in the street because of the perceived bias against them in the way their country is routinely presented. That was after a heated two hour discussion in which she presented me with argument after argument about how Israel was wrong, illegitimate, unwise and immoral. I don't think she ever saw the irony.Gus wrote: how many have journalists have Israeli troops manage to 'censor' in such a final way??![]()
Israel v Lebanon
- El Salsero Gringo
- Senior Member
- Posts: 4881
- Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
- Gus
- Senior Member
- Posts: 5203
- Joined: Mon Mar 04, 2002 12:00 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
And it appears that you don't see the irony of your comment either.El Salsero Gringo wrote:A friend who was a BBC dish producer at the time told me she was astonished to hear of the level of antipathy and vitriol directed at western journalists (particularly the BBC) by ordinary Israelis in the street because of the perceived bias against them in the way their country is routinely presented. That was after a heated two hour discussion in which she presented me with argument after argument about how Israel was wrong, illegitimate, unwise and immoral. I don't think she ever saw the irony.
I suppose it comes back to your earlier comment. Whereas I would like to believe that a modern 'Christian' state (e.g. UK) believes in the sanctity of life, Geneva convention, UN resolutions and that we don't have the right to destroy the innocent to get to the bad guys, that patently is not a view held by Israel, nor by yourself. Look at the outrage of the shooting of 1 innocent Brazilian, despite the appalling losses incurred in London the week before.
When we went to war in the Gulf the UK acted with tremendous restraint to minimise civilian casualties. Therein lies my issue with Israel. I believe they have acted as barbarians. I do not believe that a modern state has the right to cause such suffering on the innocent.
The old testament has writings that warn against such action. I have a terrible feeling of foreboding that in ignoring the scriptures (that both Christians and Jews believe in) that Israel may have sealed its own doom, and may take many others with it.
- David Bailey
- Senior Member
- Posts: 17001
- Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 12:00 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
Of course, it's a publicity ploy, but it's interesting that he felt he had to both make the threat and the offer - does that mean he's feeling the pressure? In other words, is the Israeli attack actually working?
Of course, Hezbullah sent 200+ missiles into Israel yesterday, so "working" is clearly an elastic term. But even then, that's 200 missiles Hezbullah don't have now - at this rate, assuming no resupply, they'll be out of stock (est. 13,000 in total) by the time this "international force" is deployed in a couple of months. And if they slow down in firing them off, this'll be seen as a weakness, so they've got to keep on.
So in a couple of months, they could have no missiles left. With a meaty UN military force in the area, it's possible that could be seen as a good result by the Israelis. Actually, that'd be seen as a good result by most people I think.
Of course, Tony Blair would then want to send yet more British troops into the Middle East, he couldn't possibly admit that we've run out of army due to his massive cock-ups in Iraq and Afghanistan...
"if your arguments are poorly constructed, they are often misinterperetated" - CJ
- David Bailey
- Senior Member
- Posts: 17001
- Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 12:00 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
I think it's true that Israel's lost a lot of moral superiority over the past few decades.Gus wrote:I suppose it comes back to your earlier comment. Whereas I would like to believe that a modern 'Christian' state (e.g. UK) believes in the sanctity of life, Geneva convention, UN resolutions and that we don't have the right to destroy the innocent to get to the bad guys, that patently is not a view held by Israel
But I think if we were being attacked by France, Ireland, Germany and most of the rest of Europe, all of whom declared they wanted to see the UK destroyed as a nation, we'd probably lose a lot of our own moral superiority.
The last time we were in a war of national survival (WW II), the UK did a lot of morally-questionable things: I'm sure we'd act the same today. I don't think Israelis are different from us, they're just in a terrible situation.
That doesn't mean we shouldn't hold democracies to higher standards than terrorists of course - but it does mean that, as the saying goes "it's not that simple".
As I said before, 7 years ago, NATO bombed the crap out of Serbia. Infrastructure, power plants, TV stations, bridges - you name it, we bombed it. And we caused an estimated 2,500 - 5,000 civilian deaths in that 11-week campaign. Was that evil?Gus wrote: I believe they have acted as barbarians. I do not believe that a modern state has the right to cause such suffering on the innocent.
"if your arguments are poorly constructed, they are often misinterperetated" - CJ
- El Salsero Gringo
- Senior Member
- Posts: 4881
- Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
(sotto voce: Now Gus is a Talmudic scholar as well as a professor of ethics?)Gus wrote:I have a terrible feeling of foreboding that in ignoring the scriptures (that both Christians and Jews believe in) that Israel may have sealed its own doom, and may take many others with it.![]()
With people like you to support her, I'm not surprised you feel that way. Gus, I must tell you honestly: I am quite envious of your world of Ronald McDonald simplicity, where everything is black, white, red and yellow - and right or wrong. (Don't forget to say hi to Mayor McCheese from me on your way to lunch.)
- David Franklin
- Senior Member
- Posts: 3426
- Joined: Fri Feb 22, 2002 1:52 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
The thing is, I've seen people (both inside and outside Israel) complaining that the casualties in Lebannon are not being widely reported in Israel. And so it's natural that the Israeli's think their troops aren't killing civilians, and are outraged at the lies being reported by the BBC.El Salsero Gringo wrote:A friend who was a BBC dish producer at the time told me she was astonished to hear of the level of antipathy and vitriol directed at western journalists (particularly the BBC) by ordinary Israelis in the street because of the perceived bias against them in the way their country is routinely presented. That was after a heated two hour discussion in which she presented me with argument after argument about how Israel was wrong, illegitimate, unwise and immoral. I don't think she ever saw the irony.
Hmm - that paragraph didn't really come out as I intended. The point I'm trying to make is that you could have two scenarios: "Israeli media doesn't report on all the bad things Israel does, and so they see the BBC's truthful reporting (and belief that Israel is immoral etc.) as bias", and "Israeli media reports the truth, and the BBC really is biased - it's us in the west who can't see it". Neither hypothesis is "self evidently" wrong. (And the truth is probably somewhere in the middle).
In terms of working out who's biased, I've found some of the more illuminating reports to be the callous or even hate filled statements of the actual political leaders concerned. It's just a pity the situation has got so polarized that there's enough from both sides to leave me thinking "a pox on both your houses".
You really think that we didn't kill innocent civilians during the Iraq war? I grant you we tried not to, but even in this day and age, "surgical strikes" is a bit of an oxymoron. The fact is, we were perfectly prepared to choose targets where there was a risk civilians would be killed.Gus wrote:Whereas I would like to believe that a modern 'Christian' state (e.g. UK) believes in the sanctity of life, Geneva convention, UN resolutions and that we don't have the right to destroy the innocent to get to the bad guys,
Now there's a strong case to say Israel isn't trying nearly as hard as they should to protect civilians.
But there's an even stronger case that Hezbullah is actively targetting civilians.
Speaking of BBC bias - 8 Israelis killed last night - got about 3 seconds coverage on Breakfast News this morning. I do think coverage of Israeli casualties has been sparing, to say the least.
- David Bailey
- Senior Member
- Posts: 17001
- Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 12:00 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
McDonalds are giving out free "Cars" games, including Snap cards, at the moment.El Salsero Gringo wrote:I am quite envious of your world of Ronald McDonald simplicity
Just thought I'd mention that
"if your arguments are poorly constructed, they are often misinterperetated" - CJ
- Gus
- Senior Member
- Posts: 5203
- Joined: Mon Mar 04, 2002 12:00 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
Aye, very true. Where the current conflict differs from the 'major' wars is that thsi has been a circle of blood engagement, where we kill one of yours so you kill one of mine etc. etc. The rights and wrongs of the situation have now been lost in time ... and I don't think that there are any ready solutions to the problem ... or if there were any I would suggest that they have now been made harder. Given the 9/11 attackes and similar across Europe, how long before Israel (and I mean its innocent civilians) feel the full force of a major series of terrorist attacksDavidJames wrote:That doesn't mean we shouldn't hold democracies to higher standards than terrorists of course - but it does mean that, as the saying goes "it's not that simple".
- El Salsero Gringo
- Senior Member
- Posts: 4881
- Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
It's no doubt true that Israeli TV gives a different spin. The discussion I mentioned about the BBC was I think four or five years ago, and it was in relation to the reporting of suicide bombings and Israeli actions in Gaza and the West Bank. Personally I think the BBC has tightened up it's reporting a lot in the last few months. There was a wide-ranging review of BBC coverage into the Middle East, and one of the recommendations was that they should spend more time on background, and more time explaining how events affect ordinary people there - Palestinians, Israelis, and so on. I can certainly detect a difference anyway.David Franklin wrote:The thing is, I've seen people (both inside and outside Israel) complaining that the casualties in Lebannon are not being widely reported in Israel. And so it's natural that the Israeli's think their troops aren't killing civilians, and are outraged at the lies being reported by the BBC.
Hmm - that paragraph didn't really come out as I intended. The point I'm trying to make is that you could have two scenarios: "Israeli media doesn't report on all the bad things Israel does, and so they see the BBC's truthful reporting (and belief that Israel is immoral etc.) as bias", and "Israeli media reports the truth, and the BBC really is biased - it's us in the west who can't see it". Neither hypothesis is "self evidently" wrong. (And the truth is probably somewhere in the middle).
I'm not sure that the phrase "surgical strikes" is very useful either. A lot of Israeli attacks have been absolutely accurate - just at the wrong targets.David Franklin wrote:You really think that we didn't kill innocent civilians during the Iraq war? I grant you we tried not to, but even in this day and age, "surgical strikes" is a bit of an oxymoron.
What planet is this man on? How many suicide bombings in buses, hotels, markets would it take to register on your scales? Wake up, Gus!Gus wrote:Given the 9/11 attackes and similar across Europe, how long before Israel (and I mean its innocent civilians) feel the full force of a major series of terrorist attacks
- Dreadful Scathe
- Senior Member
- Posts: 12530
- Joined: Sun Jan 20, 2002 12:00 pm
- Contact:
Re: Israel v Lebanon
The UK and really all of the western world are very much secular states, religion has no part to play in government or government support of factions or foreign policy. the days of the crusades are long gone. Which is the way it should be, much easier then for people to get on with their religion of choice without interference. I dont think you can say the same about any of the arab countries or, for that matter, Israel - after all - the land Israel takes up "belongs" to the Jews biblically.Gus wrote: Whereas I would like to believe that a modern 'Christian' state (e.g. UK) believes in the sanctity of life..
"This is a discussion forum, not some sort of hippy poetry-reading commune" - TAFKADJ
-
MartinHarper
- Senior Member
- Posts: 4157
- Joined: Mon Jul 12, 2004 4:24 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
You'll hear the same antipathy/vitriol from non-Israelis in the region too. For example, western media is often considered to give more space to non-Arab casualties. I vaguely recall a survey comparing the actual casualty ratios in various conflicts to the perceived ratios, which (if I could find it) would be stronger evidence for bias than people's perceptions.El Salsero Gringo wrote:A friend who was a BBC dish producer at the time told me she was astonished to hear of the level of antipathy and vitriol directed at western journalists (particularly the BBC) by ordinary Israelis in the street.
"tremendous restraint" is overstating the case. We used depleted Uranium and cluster bombs, for example.Gus wrote:When we went to war in the Gulf the UK acted with tremendous restraint to minimise civilian casualties.
Running your opponent out of bullets is an interesting strategy, certainly.DavidJames wrote:So in a couple of months, they could have no missiles left.
- Dreadful Scathe
- Senior Member
- Posts: 12530
- Joined: Sun Jan 20, 2002 12:00 pm
- Contact:
Re: Israel v Lebanon
Gus wrote: Given the 9/11 attackes and similar across Europe, how long before Israel (and I mean its innocent civilians) feel the full force of a major series of terrorist attacks![]()
"This is a discussion forum, not some sort of hippy poetry-reading commune" - TAFKADJ
-
bigdjiver
- Senior Member
- Posts: 4899
- Joined: Mon Mar 03, 2003 1:38 am
- Contact:
Re: Israel v Lebanon
"As soon as you accept that "You have got to have faith" they have got you. From then on anything they say is not subject to reasoned argument or logical proof."
Religious leaders and religions money carry undemocratic influence in Western democracies.
- El Salsero Gringo
- Senior Member
- Posts: 4881
- Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
I recall the same surveys too. But, while measuring 'column inches' or 'broadcast minutes' is a tangible metric I don't think it's the only thing that counts.MartinHarper wrote:You'll hear the same antipathy/vitriol from non-Israelis in the region too. For example, western media is often considered to give more space to non-Arab casualties. I vaguely recall a survey comparing the actual casualty ratios in various conflicts to the perceived ratios, which (if I could find it) would be stronger evidence for bias than people's perceptions.
I also don't think that being sympathetic to one side precludes being sympathetic to the other. My preference would be for reporting to be more sympathetic to both sides, in terms of aims, actions, and so on. As I said before the media debate is asymmetric in that the controversy tends to focus on whether it's pro or anti-Israeli, but not on its coverage of the other side. I don't want to read how awful Israel is - but I don't want to read how awful Hizbullah is either. I want to read how they both see themselves to be in the right. Let the media paint both sides as human, and let me then decide the pros and cons.
- El Salsero Gringo
- Senior Member
- Posts: 4881
- Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
The "more deaths deserves more coverage and more sympathy" assumption is very dangerous. It means that a well armed and well defended side (like Israel) starts off at a disadvantage to a force like Hizbullah, who have nothing to lose and everything to gain by maximising civillian casualties on their side. Whatever steps Israel does take to minimise civilian deaths (be those steps 'sufficient' or 'insufficient') they can always be neturalised by Hizbullah, who know well what images of dead Lebanese children will earn them.MartinHarper wrote:You'll hear the same antipathy/vitriol from non-Israelis in the region too. For example, western media is often considered to give more space to non-Arab casualties.
Has anyone thought to ask what Hizbullah is doing itself to help move civillians out of the areas that Israel announces well in advance will be targeted? Given that it practically forms the entirety of goverment in southern lebanon, shouldn't that be a high priority for them? I confess I'd take the moral outrage at Israel killing civillians rather more seriously if I thought Hizbullah were doing anything practical to mimise those deaths.
- Gus
- Senior Member
- Posts: 5203
- Joined: Mon Mar 04, 2002 12:00 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
I'm talking in terms of magnitude. Ignoring the curent rocket attacks, there are many more Islamic forces out there who have the capability of wreaking carnage on a scale that will make the current hostilities look like happy slapping. Most of the attacks to date have inflicted deaths in the 10's, 9/11 was measured in the thousands! Look at the comparison with the IRA. The continual bombings and murders carried out in the 70s/80s is similar in magntiutude to the situation that Isreal experienced prior to the current situation. Though there were many incidents, the actual death count (though terrible in itself) was not on the scale that recent Islamic attacks in Europe have been.Dreadful Scathe wrote:erm...a major series? day in day out attacks not enough to be major?....got to say Im speechless at that comment.
Al-Queda etc have the capability of wreaking massive damage in a way that we hoped would never be seen. The current hostilities have galvanised many Islamic States into sabre rattling. If they decide to do something about it, either through overt military action or through increased funding to Islamic 'militants', the consequenes for Israel would be dire.
- El Salsero Gringo
- Senior Member
- Posts: 4881
- Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
Should that happen, are you going to say "inevitable really, Israel is getting what it deserves," as you appeared to suggest in your previous posts? Because I've heard that about the Jews before, somewhere.Gus wrote:I'm talking in terms of magnitude. Ignoring the curent rocket attacks, there are many more Islamic forces out there who have the capability of wreaking carnage on a scale that will make the current hostilities look like happy slapping. Most of the attacks to date have inflicted deaths in the 10's, 9/11 was measured in the thousands!
- Gus
- Senior Member
- Posts: 5203
- Joined: Mon Mar 04, 2002 12:00 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
No ... but I am saying that you can't expect to kick sh*t out of one of the 'islamic mafia' and not expect his associates to pay you a visit! Same old problem, in a war of attrition to have to kill off ALL of your enemies, or sooner or later they will get you.El Salsero Gringo wrote:Should that happen, are you going to say "inevitable really, Israel is getting what it deserves," as you appeared to suggest in your previous posts? Because I've heard that about the Jews before, somewhere.
I do not revel in the thought of future pointless bloodshed. All life is a precious thing, regardless of race, creed or belief .... but I do believe in the adage, "Live by the sword, Die by the sword". Those words will written in ancient times by an intelligence far beyond you and I, and it is as true now as it was then.
-
MartinHarper
- Senior Member
- Posts: 4157
- Joined: Mon Jul 12, 2004 4:24 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
However, they have the advantage of being well-armed and well-defended.El Salsero Gringo wrote:The "more deaths deserves more coverage and more sympathy" assumption is very dangerous. It means that a well armed and well defended side (like Israel) starts off at a disadvantage to a force like Hizbullah.....
The number of civilian deaths is set according to what Israeli and world opinion is willing to tolerate. If Hizbullah acted to make civilians safer, Israel could respond by increasing the severity of its attacks, such that they could achieve more of their military objectives while still keeping the level of collateral damage at an "acceptable" level.El Salsero Gringo wrote:I confess I'd take the moral outrage at Israel killing civillians rather more seriously if I thought Hizbullah were doing anything practical to mimise those deaths.
The main thing Hizbullah can do to minimise deaths is to maximise the publicity associated with those deaths. Higher publicity means that Israeli and world opinion will reach its tolerance threshold earlier, so fewer will die. This is something they are already doing.
- stewart38
- Senior Member
- Posts: 7480
- Joined: Fri May 09, 2003 8:56 am
Re: Israel v Lebanon
Food for thought ?
----------------------------------------------
There's no doubt Israel is losing the propaganda war. You don't have to be a paid-up peacenik to find some of the pictures coming out of the Middle East distressing. No one with an iota of humanity wants to see the corpses of women and children caught up in the conflict.
But you don't have to be a conspiracy theorist, either, to wonder how many of the male 'civilians' killed by the Israelis are actually Hezbollah terrorists or whether everything we're being shown from Lebanon is for real.
Islamonazis are sophisticated propagandists and they know they'll find a gullible audience in the civilised world for their carefully-strewn teddy bears, strategically-placed 'Baby Milk Factory' signs (in English) and wailing widows from central casting.
Have you ever noticed how every time a coalition air strike goes astray in Iraq, it always manages to hit a 'wedding party'?
Why is there only ever one child's shoe in the rubble, never a pair? There always seems to be a broken medicine box, too, with a handy red cross - never a red crescent, mind you - on the lid, just in case we haven't got the message.
Credulous CNN correspondents and handwringing BBC reporters fall over themselves to sign up for the Hezbollah guided tour of the ruins.
I use a rough rule of thumb whenever I watch television coverage of the Middle East. Anyone who pronounces Hezbollah as 'Hiz-bull-arrrgh' and Israeli as 'Izza-ra-ay-lee' is almost certainly telling lies.
The bien-pensant buzzword used to describe Israel's bombing is 'disproportionate'. But what's 'proportionate'? Are the thousands of rockets fired at genuine civilian targets in Israel 'proportionate'?
It is only because Israelis are hunkered down in underground shelters built out of necessity and bitter experience, or have fled out of range of Hezbollah's salvoes, that there haven't been piles of bodies on their side of the border.
What would 'world opinion' consider an acceptable death toll before acknowledging Israel's right
to retaliation and self-defence - 1,000? 10,000? 100,000? 1,000,000?
--------------------------------------------