Israel v Lebanon

Talk about anything not related to dancing...
Have fun, it's your Forum!
Post Reply
User avatar
David Bailey
Senior Member
Posts: 17001
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Bailey »

El Salsero Gringo wrote:That is an oft stated view, but it doesn't actually hold a lot of water. Hizbullah is not interested in Palestinian state per se, but in fact in an Islamic republic (like Iran, it's sponsor) over the whole of what is now Israel.
Actually, I think they mainly want an Islamic Republic in Lebanon first. In fact, if you looked solely at their domestic political agenda, it's not too loony - public services, democratic Islamic republic, that sort of thing. But then you look at their 12,000 missiles, their spiritual mentor (Khomenei) and their aim of the destruction of the state of Israel...
El Salsero Gringo wrote:Whatever Israel does, as long as it exists in some form or other, there will always be sufficient people in the Arab world (and outside it) to support extremist groups like Hamas and Hezbullah.

The ultimate answer to this lies in the real and final acceptance across the arab world of the existence of a sovereign Jewish State in the Middle East. The plight of the Palestinians is, and has been for 60 years, used as an excuse to avoid having to face up to this fact.
I absolutely agree with this. But, it's a very very good excuse.

And as I said, I think a big step towards taking the wind out of the sails of these extremists is the establishment of a Palestinian state. Preferably also with refugee return, but that's probably unrealistic. If that happened, the only excuse the fanatics would have is "we don't like Israel", which I believe is less of a recruiting slogan.
Jivetango Godfather
"if your arguments are poorly constructed, they are often misinterperetated" - CJ
User avatar
Dreadful Scathe
Senior Member
Posts: 12530
Joined: Sun Jan 20, 2002 12:00 pm
Contact:

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by Dreadful Scathe »

DavidJames wrote:stuff....big words.... democratic Islamic republic
Ive always wondered how they would define "Democratic" and what Democratic freedoms would exist for a new countries citizens - freedom of religion or lack of religion and equal partnerships in marriage (either heterosexual or homosexual) are 2 things I dont see happening... . What DIRs already exist and how democratic are they ?
"defiantly a pork soared" -fletch DS is talking as much sense as most people I've heard - batnurse
"This is a discussion forum, not some sort of hippy poetry-reading commune" - TAFKADJ
MartinHarper
Senior Member
Posts: 4157
Joined: Mon Jul 12, 2004 4:24 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by MartinHarper »

El Salsero Gringo wrote:As someone remarked: if the arabs put down their weapons tomorrow, the fighting will cease.
False. Israel continued to kill members of Hamas during the Hamas ceasefire.
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

DavidJames wrote:... the only excuse the fanatics would have is "we don't like Israel", which I believe is less of a recruiting slogan.
It's working for them at the moment.

I see no real expressions of sympathy for the Palestinians from across the Arab world, aside from some remarks in the UN, a few demonstrations and weapons with which to fight Jews: I see no aid, I see no hospitals, I see no help in building political institutions, I see nothing of any practical use whatsoever. I'll wager that if you look at the relative economic growth in the Gaza and West Bank regions between 1948 and 1967 (when they were respectively under Egyptian and Jordanian occupation) and between 1967 and say 2000, the start of the second Intifada, the period under Israeli occupation has proved to be by far the most beneficial. Likewise I think you'll find, in terms of improvement in standard of living, healthcare, life expectancy, deaths during childbirth and pretty much any other criterion you can name.

It is because practical assistance from the Arab world has been so markedly absent that the Palestinian economy has been so badly hit by the withdrawal of aid from the EU and the USA (following the election of Hamas) - yes, aid from that great sponsor of Israel (the "Terrorist State"). Not aid from the Islamic world, mark you.

I don't mean for an instant to diminish the very real political and economic problems that the Palestinians face. But I will not take seriously anybody's claim that across the Arab world, a real sympathy for the Palestinan cause is driving anyone's agenda.
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

MartinHarper wrote:False. Israel continued to kill members of Hamas during the Hamas ceasefire.
It wasn't much of a cease-fire from the Arabs. Whether they call themselves Hamas, Islamic Jihad, Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigade or go under any other label. There were still suicide bombing attempts (not generally reported in the western media) which were foiled by Israel, shootings, and rocket fire.
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
User avatar
David Bailey
Senior Member
Posts: 17001
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Bailey »

Dreadful Scathe wrote:Ive always wondered how they would define "Democratic" and what Democratic freedoms would exist for a new countries citizens - freedom of religion or lack of religion and equal partnerships in marriage (either heterosexual or homosexual) are 2 things I dont see happening... . What DIRs already exist and how democratic are they ?
Indonesia? Good example of a peaceful (ish) democratic (ish) Islamic (ish) state.

Historically, there have been plenty of tolerant and peaceful Islamic states, who respected the rights of minorities - at least, they were up until they were attacked by a series of Western Christian states starting with the Crusaders.

I could be wrong, but I don't believe there is anything in Islam (or any major religion for that matter) that precludes tolerance or democracy.
Jivetango Godfather
"if your arguments are poorly constructed, they are often misinterperetated" - CJ
User avatar
Baruch
Senior Member
Posts: 2261
Joined: Mon Mar 22, 2004 1:54 am

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by Baruch »

Dreadful Scathe wrote:What DIRs already exist and how democratic are they ?
I don't think DJ mentioned the word "democratic". For an example of an Islamic republic, look at Iran.
To err is human, to moo bovine.
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

DavidJames wrote:Historically, there have been plenty of tolerant and peaceful Islamic states, who respected the rights of minorities - at least, they were up until they were attacked by a series of Western Christian states starting with the Crusaders.
I'm not sure how useful an appeal to history is, on this one. There were in the past also many Christian states that practised the most appalling religious bigotry and intolerance resulting in torture, persecution and out and out war. In England under Henry VIII it was a capital offence for a layman simply to read from the bible, and people were executed for it. I think we've moved on a little way since then; characterising a society by how it behaved five hundred or a thousand years ago tells us what?
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
User avatar
Dreadful Scathe
Senior Member
Posts: 12530
Joined: Sun Jan 20, 2002 12:00 pm
Contact:

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by Dreadful Scathe »

Baruch wrote:I don't think DJ mentioned the word "democratic". For an example of an Islamic republic, look at Iran.
he did, I quoted him directly :) and I know there are IR's I was asking about DIRs.
JavidDames wrote:Historically, there have been plenty of tolerant and peaceful Islamic states, who respected the rights of minorities - at least, they were up until they were attacked by a series of Western Christian states starting with the Crusaders.
Ive read a fair bit about Islamic history and it is interesting that compared to the Christians, historically Islamists were far more moderate and peaceful. But as ESG says, that isnt particularly relevant now. The Western World has moved on and most countries dont even have a death penalty for ANY crime (no pedants pointing out that 'technically' you could be sentenced to death - it's nonsense). I dont see anyone in the Arab world using the "you did it in the past" as an excuse thankfully (although it could be argued that "Israel has no right to exist" qualifies). We need to concentrate on the present, as the dead are already dead but the living could , perhaps, live a little longer.
"defiantly a pork soared" -fletch DS is talking as much sense as most people I've heard - batnurse
"This is a discussion forum, not some sort of hippy poetry-reading commune" - TAFKADJ
User avatar
David Franklin
Senior Member
Posts: 3426
Joined: Fri Feb 22, 2002 1:52 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Franklin »

El Salsero Gringo wrote:I'm not sure how useful an appeal to history is ... I think we've moved on a little way since then.
Precisely. I make no claim the trend is monotonic(*), but the general trend has been towards tolerance. Essentially as most people get wealthier, they find there is less and less it's worth fighting about.

Now I do think the situation in the Middle East is far more "extreme" than people in the west are used to, and so claims of "Why can't they all just get along?" are naive. Yes, there will always be extremists, and probably a large number of people who don't particularly like Israel. But given a sufficient period of "near peace" I (perhaps in turn naively) believe the number of people prepared to kill and die for their cause would fall to much more manageable levels.

Whether or not that view is naive, I think the converse is pretty clear. When millions of people are told "if you don't abandon your homes we will consider you terrorists", when thousands lose relatives and are told "well, we wanted to kill terrorists and they were in the way", then you are creating a fertile recruiting ground for the likes of Hizbullah. And it will take generations for that to go away. Morality aside, I just don't see it as a winning strategy.

(*) Of course, from a Jewish point of view, the worst recent "dip" in tolerance was actually from largely Christian countries.
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

David Franklin wrote:When millions of people are told "if you don't abandon your homes we will consider you terrorists", when thousands lose relatives and are told "well, we wanted to kill terrorists and they were in the way", then you are creating a fertile recruiting ground for the likes of Hizbullah. And it will take generations for that to go away. Morality aside, I just don't see it as a winning strategy.
I totally agree.

I don't see the Arab strategy (or strategies) as winning either, though. And I don't (myself) see any other strategy that Israel could adopt that would 'win' in it's turn. (We might differ on that point, David.)

One comes to the conclusion that each side is reduced for the moment to trying to make life as difficult and unpleasant as possible for the other, so that one side or the other is forced to change its objectives. Once the objectives are changed (once you change your definition of a 'win') then a 'winning' strategy might emerge.
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

David Franklin wrote:...then you are creating a fertile recruiting ground for the likes of Hizbullah. And it will take generations for that to go away.
Although I said I agree with this, on reflection I'm not so sure it has to be true. There have been many many wars between nations in the last say hundred years; to take one example (might not be the best but let's examine it) the Allied Powers united to fight Nazi Germany. The British and American armed forces inflicted horrible fates on millions of civilians in Germany, I don't need to give more detailed examples. Also, vice versa. Although we make jokes about the war (mainly it seems at football time) does anyone in Germany still hold a serious grudge against England? Or vice versa? We're what, sixty years away from that conflict. In another forty, won't by then it be remembered in the head, rather than the heart?

Why should the Middle East conflict be any different?
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
User avatar
David Franklin
Senior Member
Posts: 3426
Joined: Fri Feb 22, 2002 1:52 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Franklin »

El Salsero Gringo wrote:Although we make jokes about the war (mainly it seems at football time) does anyone in Germany still hold a serious grudge against England? Or vice versa? We're what, sixty years away from that conflict.
In my book, sixty years = generations. But you could say there was a lot of rapproachment well before that, so on some levels it's a fair point. I've often found it surprising how quickly it happened, to be honest. I think the cold war had a lot to do with it: "if we don't hang together, we will all hang separately" so to speak.
Why should the Middle East conflict be any different?
I do think culturally there's a difference - most specificially, there's a ready supply of leaders in the middle east who are only too eager to encourage people to hold grudges until they fester. The other obvious difference is that we don't seem to be able to get even ten years of peace in that area, let alone 60.

More than anything, that's why the attacks in Lebanon seem a mistake. It feels like there have been all these years of efforts towards normalising relations, and it's all been sent back to square one in a couple of weeks.

As far as alternative strategies go, I think Israel would have been better served making a far greater effort to avoid Lebanese casualties, even if that meant some Hizbullah targets could not be attacked. Because if Israel can't be bothered to distinguish between Lebanese civilians and terrorists, it's almost saying "you might as well be terrorists for all we care".
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

David Franklin wrote:More than anything, that's why the attacks in Lebanon seem a mistake. It feels like there have been all these years of efforts towards normalising relations, and it's all been sent back to square one in a couple of weeks.
It's funny how you don't recognise what you had, until it's suddenly gone, isn't it? A month ago, if you'd mentioned efforts to normalise relations between Israel and Lebanon, you'd have been laughed at.

I tend to agree with the rest of your post.
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
User avatar
Dreadful Scathe
Senior Member
Posts: 12530
Joined: Sun Jan 20, 2002 12:00 pm
Contact:

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by Dreadful Scathe »

In the new Private Eye magazine.

Spot the difference guide for Israeli Soldiers


Hezbollah
Brings rocket launchers to region
A terrorist organisation
Determined to bomb Israel to smithereens
Hated by US and targeted by Israeli rockets

The UN
Brings humanitarian Aid to region
Helps those caught up in terror
Determined to find a peaceful solution
Hated by US and targeted by Israeli rockets
"defiantly a pork soared" -fletch DS is talking as much sense as most people I've heard - batnurse
"This is a discussion forum, not some sort of hippy poetry-reading commune" - TAFKADJ
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

Here is a very interesting excerpt from a transcript of a CNN programme: "ANDERSON COOPER 360 DEGREES". You can find the original page here:

http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0607/28/acd.02.html

and let me say straight off that there is much harrowing coverage of how the war is affecting both sides, in the transcript of this programme and others broadcast that week. But this is the part that is especially interesting:
Anderson Cooper 360 Degrees wrote:(Voice-over): Drive into southern Beirut and you quickly discover another city entirely. A heavily bombed state within a state, beyond the control of the Lebanese government.

This is Hezbollah territory. Along the road posted like billboards, pictures of so-called martyrs, Hezbollah fighters who died battling Israel.

(On camera): You can drive around. It doesn't seem like there's anyone around. And all of a sudden your eyes -- it's almost like adjusting to the darkness. Suddenly you realize there are people who are watching you, guys on motorcycles talking on cell phones who pass you by, watching very closely what you're doing.

(Voice-over): Tension in this neighborhood is high. Many here are convinced Israel is sending in agents to help guide their aerial attacks.

(On camera): We're not allowed to enter Hezbollah territory really without their permission. They control this whole area even after the sustained Israeli bombing campaign. We arranged with a Hezbollah representative to get permission to come here. We've been told to pull over to the side of the road and just wait.

(Voice-over): We'd come to get a look at the damage and had hoped to talk with a Hezbollah representative. Instead, we found ourselves with other foreign reporters taken on a guided tour by Hezbollah. Young men on motor scooters followed our every movement. They only allowed us to videotape certain streets, certain movements.

Once, when they thought we had videotaped them, they asked us to erase the tape.

These men are called al-Shabab, Hezbollah volunteers who are the organization's eyes and ears. (On camera): Look over there. You can still see their CDs on the wall still. Hezbollah representatives are with us now, but don't want to be photographed will say -- will point to something like that and say, well, look, this is a store. The civilians lived in this building. It's a residential complex. And while that may be true, what the Israelis will say is that Hezbollah has their offices, their leadership has offices in bunkers even in residential neighborhoods. And if you're trying to knock out the Hezbollah leadership with air strikes, it's very difficult to do that without killing civilians.

As bad as this damage is, it certainly could have been much worse in terms of civilian casualties.Before they started heavily bombing this area, Israeli war planes did drop leaflets in this area, telling people to get out.

The civilian death toll, though, has angered many Lebanese. Even those who do not support Hezbollah are outraged by the pictures they've seen on television of civilian casualties.

(Voice-over): Civilian casualties are clearly what Hezbollah wants foreign reporters to focus on. It keeps the attention off them and questions why Hezbollah should still be allowed to have weapons when all the other militias in Lebanon have already disarmed.

After letting us take pictures of a few damaged buildings, they take us to another location where their ambulance is waiting.

(On camera): This is a highly orchestrated Hezbollah media event. When we got here, all the ambulances were lined up. We were allowed a few minutes to talk to the ambulance drivers. And then one by one they've been told to turn on their sirens and zoom off so that all the photographers here can get shots of ambulances rushing off to treat civilians. That's the story that Hezbollah wants people to know about.

(Voice-over): These ambulances aren't responding to any new bombings. The sirens are strictly for effect.
The emphases are mine. You can find the quoted section about half way down the page.

Two obvious questions: what would the news reports from Beirut look like if the media were allowed to see the damage that Hizbullah doesn't want reported? And what is the responsibilty of the media *not* to play up to (for instance) staged ambulance runs?
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
bigdjiver
Senior Member
Posts: 4899
Joined: Mon Mar 03, 2003 1:38 am
Contact:

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by bigdjiver »

El Salsero Gringo wrote:... Two obvious questions: what would the news reports from Beirut look like if the media were allowed to see the damage that Hizbullah doesn't want reported?
My guerss would be that it was more the lack of damage that they did not want reported. They would not want reporters acting as spotters for their semi-successful strikes.
And what is the responsibilty of the media *not* to play up to (for instance) staged ambulance runs?
The media works for their masters. If their masters want pictures of ambulances rushing about that the photographers did not get because they stayed away from the bombs that preceded the ambulances, then that is what you will see. If they want to smear much of the reporting of others then they will show that the media is being manipulated. Truth is the first casualty ...
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

bigdjiver wrote:My guerss would be that it was more the lack of damage that they did not want reported. They would not want reporters acting as spotters for their semi-successful strikes.
Maybe. Or successful strikes of military targets hidden in residential areas? Or military activities that have not yet been hit? The report does say "Many here are convinced Israel is sending in agents to help guide their aerial attacks." Israel has spy satellites and reconnaisance aircraft, and is unlikely to need to make much use of media to know what damage they are causing.

This is all just late-night speculation, but I am still entitled to wonder, what is the underlying truth?
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
bigdjiver
Senior Member
Posts: 4899
Joined: Mon Mar 03, 2003 1:38 am
Contact:

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by bigdjiver »

El Salsero Gringo wrote:...This is all just late-night speculation, but I am still entitled to wonder, what is the underlying truth?
We can all speculate, and speculation has little respect for boundaries. The USA has the best electronic surveillance. It supplies Israel with advanced guided missiles, just where do the guidance systems end? Just where are its boundaries on the "war against terror"? All wild speculation. Mossad infiltrating US intelligence? As I said, no boundaries on speculation.
Gus
Senior Member
Posts: 5203
Joined: Mon Mar 04, 2002 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by Gus »

El Salsero Gringo wrote:Two obvious questions: what would the news reports from Beirut look like if the media were allowed to see the damage that Hizbullah doesn't want reported? And what is the responsibilty of the media *not* to play up to (for instance) staged ambulance runs?
And how many journalists have Hizbullah shot in cold blood ... and how many have journalists have Israeli troops manage to 'censor' in such a final way?? :rolleyes:
"We all believe in something... greater than ourselves, even if it's just the blind forces of chance" - G'Kar.
Post Reply