Israel v Lebanon

Talk about anything not related to dancing...
Have fun, it's your Forum!
Post Reply
User avatar
ducasi
Senior Member
Posts: 10015
Joined: Thu Feb 24, 2005 9:18 am
Contact:

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by ducasi »

... UN Observer post shelled 14 times by the Israelis and then bombed, killing 4 UN observers. [...] But it's hard to call such a strike "surgical", either...
Based on these numbers it sounds very surgical – unfortunately the surgeons seems to be removing random body parts hoping that they might find the heart eventually.
Let your mind go and your body will follow. – Steve Martin, LA Story
[RIGHT][SIGPIC][/SIGPIC][/RIGHT]
User avatar
stewart38
Senior Member
Posts: 7480
Joined: Fri May 09, 2003 8:56 am

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by stewart38 »

DavidJames wrote: In truth, I don't think that a strategic bombing campaign plus partial occupation will work - it didn't work 20 years ago, so it probably won't work now. "Buffer zones" just tend to make things worse - look at Korea. And a pie-in-the-sky UN peacemaker force is just wishful thinking.



Got a source?
Re the Source ,the statistics re Death toll !

Personally I don’t believe they are deliberately targeting civilians

Lets face it ‘conventional war' is largely a thing of the past’ when whole armies met on the battle field .In fact the biggest killer in the American Civil war was infection /disease , times change

Re Korea and the buffer zone about 10 deaths in 50yrs i think that works very well thankyou (removing the moral argument etc)
User avatar
David Franklin
Senior Member
Posts: 3426
Joined: Fri Feb 22, 2002 1:52 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Franklin »

ducasi wrote:Based on these numbers it sounds very surgical &#8211]removing random body parts[/b] hoping that they might find the heart eventually.
Remind me never to get appendicitis where you live!
User avatar
ducasi
Senior Member
Posts: 10015
Joined: Thu Feb 24, 2005 9:18 am
Contact:

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by ducasi »

David Franklin wrote:Remind me never to get appendicitis where you live!
Unfortunately it seems like quite a common problem.
Let your mind go and your body will follow. – Steve Martin, LA Story
[RIGHT][SIGPIC][/SIGPIC][/RIGHT]
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

MartinHarper wrote:ESG, if your indignation is quite so righteous and upstanding on behalf of the victims of bigotry,
My indignation is on behalf of nonsense arguments, poorly argued. I do that where ever I see them on the Forum, be they political, dancing, or related to any other topic.
Martin Harper wrote:why is it that we only ever hear this line of argument from you in relation to Israeli conflicts?
You don't. I'm mouthy and argumentative (and keen to point out when someone's being a fool) on any topic.
Martin Harper wrote:Never used the same argument about any other conflicts anywhere in the world? Should I look on the Forum for your essays about the anti-Iraqi bigotry displayed by commentated on Iraq? Darfur? Chinese opression in Tibet? Indian bombing (or was it Pakistan) in Kashmir? More problems in Aceh?
I haven't seen any half-baked ill-judged (started with "I know nothing about this but here's my view-from-behind-the-Independent") threads on those topics. If I had, and I had the background to comment on them - believe me, I would.
Martin Harper wrote:Nothing to say about the anti-Arab racism displayed in this topic?
I haven't spotted any. If you want to point some out (and if I agree with you) then I'll come down like a ton of bricks on that too.
Martin Harper wrote:Despite the parody in my phrasing, it's a serious question.
Yes it is. I hope I've answered it to your satisfaction.
Martin Harper wrote:I get bored of random accusations of anti-Semitism.
I haven't raised any question of anti-semitism. You're the first person to mention it in this thread.
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
MartinHarper
Senior Member
Posts: 4157
Joined: Mon Jul 12, 2004 4:24 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by MartinHarper »

Heh, my question has just been answered in a simul-post. Deleted.
jiveknight
Senior Member
Posts: 247
Joined: Wed Oct 12, 2005 12:28 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by jiveknight »

While it is commonly believed to take two to make a fight, a third party must exist and must develop it for actual conflict to occur.
MartinHarper
Senior Member
Posts: 4157
Joined: Mon Jul 12, 2004 4:24 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by MartinHarper »

El Salsero Gringo wrote:I'm mouthy and argumentative (and keen to point out when someone's being a fool) on any topic.
Yes. However, this is the very first time, to my knowledge, that you have asked a thread starter to explain their failure to start threads on different topics. I would like you to explain your failure to ask other thread starters to explain their failure to start threads on different topics.
El Salsero Gringo wrote:I haven't raised any question of anti-semitism.
In that case, my apologies. I mistakenly thought that when you wrote:
El Salsero Gringo wrote:(Apart from the fact that in your opinion the world's only Jewish state is the root of all evil on this planet, obviously..)
... that you were raising a question of anti-Semitism. Thanks for setting me straight.
User avatar
David Bailey
Senior Member
Posts: 17001
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Bailey »

stewart38 wrote:Re Korea and the buffer zone about 10 deaths in 50yrs i think that works very well thankyou (removing the moral argument etc)
:what: If North Korea (a nuclear-armed state run by a loony tyrant) is "working very well", I shudder to think what you'd call "working badly"...

{Vast Generalisation Mode=ON}
The only long-term answer to all these issues is never military, it's involvement, engagement and diplomacy - military force should be limited to containment operations only. And whilst that approach will never provide a completely "clean" solution, and it'll never be ideal, and it'll take years or decades, it's the only approach that has ever worked in the long term. Examples: IRA, Libya, Soviet Union - hell, even in the middle of the Cold War, we had diplomatic relations with Stalinist Russia.

But "talking to people you don't like" seems to have gone out of fashion as a general approach in the past 20 years, unfortunately.
{Vast Generalisation Mode=OFF}
Jivetango Godfather
"if your arguments are poorly constructed, they are often misinterperetated" - CJ
User avatar
stewart38
Senior Member
Posts: 7480
Joined: Fri May 09, 2003 8:56 am

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by stewart38 »

DavidJames wrote: :what: If North Korea (a nuclear-armed state run by a loony tyrant) is "working very well", I shudder to think what you'd call "working badly"...


I don’t think North Korea or Iran governments are loony, very switched on Id say.

The ‘buffer zone’ has worked very well as I say avoiding moral arguments of what type of government you prefer.

The Berlin wall was again a general success sure a few died trying to cross it but it did its purpose (again avoiding moral issues)

If Iraq had nuclear weapons Sadam would still be there now and the only thing you would hear about would be pg 27 of the Independent every month. Or page 3 of the Daily Mail e.g. I have 23 kids and live on welfare state says Iraq father from Baghdad

So I don’t support North Korea or Iran but re Iran could you seem them give up a nuclear route given USA history

If Iraq had gone smoothly , USA would have gone in Iran by now !

Buffer zones can and have worked
User avatar
Dreadful Scathe
Senior Member
Posts: 12530
Joined: Sun Jan 20, 2002 12:00 pm
Contact:

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by Dreadful Scathe »

i think "loony" is a fair label for most liberal minded people to use when referring to countries that try to have complete control of their citizens lives. :)
"defiantly a pork soared" -fletch DS is talking as much sense as most people I've heard - batnurse
"This is a discussion forum, not some sort of hippy poetry-reading commune" - TAFKADJ
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

MartinHarper wrote:I would like you to explain your failure to ask other thread starters to explain their failure to start threads on different topics.
I think my point has been made...
MartinHarper wrote:... that you were raising a question of anti-Semitism. Thanks for setting me straight.
I'm told several times a week that one must not conflate criticism of Israel with anti-semitism (being anti-Jewish.) If that is the case, then it cuts both ways: I'm entitled to ask if someone's biased against Israel without calling them anti-Jewish.

I haven't a clue about his motives, and I'm not suggesting any.
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
User avatar
Chicklet
Senior Member
Posts: 2555
Joined: Mon Mar 03, 2003 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by Chicklet »

Been reading this tread with great interest. I lived for many years in an Islamic country where we had to cut out the M&S labels from our underwear on returning after the summer every year and hide Cadbury treats inside socks to smuggle them in. At (Church of England sponsored) primary school we were not allowed to decorate our classrooms with six pointed stars for the "December Festive Period". Flippant dinner party anecdote practical consequences of life "out there" they may be but they have left me with a fascination for the whole thing so thank you to all involved on this thread for bringing together a useful amount of history, your efforts are appreciated.

Genuine question - for some reason I have always held the opinion that one of the things that makes it all so difficult is that there are not really distinct recognised leaders / figure heads who could be "taken out" (not getting into by whom) on either side to calm it down.

Yes of course I know it's far too simplistic to suggest that's THE answer, take out a figure head and it all gets far worse in the short term at least, but y'all know what I'm getting at - are there known characters known to be particular rabble rousers?

Agree? Disagree? Thoughts?

Also, anyone know the extent of organised crime in the area? Is this in any way a factor ?

Genuinely interested.
Ash
Junior Member
Posts: 64
Joined: Fri Aug 09, 2002 6:02 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by Ash »

User avatar
David Bailey
Senior Member
Posts: 17001
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Bailey »

stewart38 wrote:I don’t think North Korea or Iran governments are loony, very switched on Id say.

The ‘buffer zone’ has worked very well as I say avoiding moral arguments of what type of government you prefer.
Well, personally, I prefer a government with nukes, and soon with missiles, to be as peaceful, stable and democratically-accountable as possible. Call me weird on that one.
stewart38 wrote:The Berlin wall was again a general success sure a few died trying to cross it but it did its purpose (again avoiding moral issues)
:what: Since the Soviets put it up to keep out the West, I'd call it an abject failure,
stewart38 wrote:If Iraq had nuclear weapons Sadam would still be there now and the only thing you would hear about would be pg 27 of the Independent every month. Or page 3 of the Daily Mail e.g. I have 23 kids and live on welfare state says Iraq father from Baghdad
:rofl: So true... If only that were the case :sad:
stewart38 wrote:Buffer zones can and have worked
The point is, the Israelis have tried this already in Lebanon - pretty much setting up a puppet state - and the end result of that period was Hezbullah.

Ignoring those arguments, however, a clear reason why a buffer zone won'tl work is that the missiles Iran / Syria supplies to Hezbullah are getting better (i.e. longer-range). So, Hezbullah don't need to be within 10 miles of the Israeli border to hit Israeli targets - soon they'll be able to do it from further and further away. And no, I don't think Patriot systems will help much either, if only because anti-missile systems are always much more expensive than missiles.
Jivetango Godfather
"if your arguments are poorly constructed, they are often misinterperetated" - CJ
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

Chicklet wrote:Genuine question - for some reason I have always held the opinion that one of the things that makes it all so difficult is that there are not really distinct recognised leaders / figure heads who could be "taken out" (not getting into by whom) on either side to calm it down.
It's long been an Israeli tactic to kill the leaders of the various groups commmitted to its destruction. Leaving aside questions of legality and morality, it doesn't seem clear to me that it has achieved anything in the long run. I certainly don't think that killing the Israeli PM would achieve much, nor killing Tony Blair or George Bush for that matter.

My opinion is that the leaders are a consequence of feeling 'on the street', and while they might shape or direct that popular opinion they are not personally responsible for it in its entirety. Removing them by whatever means may be tactically useful but holds no strategic benefits. Menahem Begin and Anwar Sadat signed a peace treaty in 1979 at Camp David, both attempting to lead their people towards some kind of reconcilliation with each other. Sadat paid the price with his life (he was assasinated, as was Itzchak Rabin) and despite two leaders of stature, Egypt and Israel are now very far from any kind of real peace.
DavidJames wrote:So, Hezbullah don't need to be within 10 miles of the Israeli border to hit Israeli targets - soon they'll be able to do it from further and further away.
A good point.
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
RogerR
Senior Member
Posts: 430
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:25 am

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by RogerR »

Perhaps the anschused east and west bank territories to provide Lebensraum for the Israeli people and their "settlements" dont sit too well with their neighbours.

Many of my Jewish friends are distancing themselves from Israel and the Israeli attitude. Statements coming from Israel they "we will bomb you to peace" are hardly reasonable, and hardly likely to de-fuse the tension in the area.

The last missiles used in the name of fanatical Islam were 400 tonnes each with a warhead of about 100 tonnes (7/11 at al). After a few of those Jerusalem wouldnt have any religous artifacts for any faith.

During the 1967 conflict the Israelis attacked and all but sank a US listening ship in the Med by air strike and torpedo attack. Because what they said publicly and over tactical radio was SO DIFFERENT. - They eventually paid compensation to the US and the families
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

RogerR wrote:Statements coming from Israel they "we will bomb you to peace" are hardly reasonable, and hardly likely to de-fuse the tension in the area.
I've not heard any such statements from Israel, and I don't think anyone in Israel believes that peace was either ever on the cards or is likely to be an immediate outcome of this war. A grudging acceptance of their existence by the enemy and less rocket fire on the northern border of Israel might be a more reasonable goal]The last missiles used in the name of fanatical Islam were 400 tonnes each with a warhead of about 100 tonnes (7/11 at al)[/quote]No, actually, the last missiles used in the name of fanatical Islam are the ones raining daily on Northern Israeli towns.
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
RogerR
Senior Member
Posts: 430
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:25 am

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by RogerR »

GO On THEN ESG

Justify the colonisation of the east bank and the west bank, and the establishment of "settlements" .
Post Reply