Gus wrote:A certain forumites felt entitled to neg-rep me (and they are totally entitled to do so) because of my parody of the UK using a similar justification to Israel to nuke Eire. However, the justification of "You're trivialising and playing the fool over something way bigger than you" I felt was sanctimonious, condescending and fundamentally flawed.
No need to be shy about it - it was I, and I think my rep comment was pretty much on the mark. Your latest attempt to demonstrate that you understand this subject (you fail) is at least respectful to the seriousness of the subject so it deserves a longer reply.
the US has experienced this in Vietnam and Iraq, Russia has also come foul of this. even the good old UK found that the 'Irish Troubles' could only be solved by diplomacy not by force. So, what makes you think Israel can bomb its opponents into agreement
Hmmm.... "agreement". Well, let's see. Among the dozens of differences between the situation in the Middle East and your cliché analogies of Ireland, Vietnam etc is this significant one: The goal of the IRA was to drive the British from Ireland, not to drive the British from Britain. The Americans in Vietnam were not fighting a foe who wished to deny America its very existence. No-one in Chechenya had designs on replace Russia with an Islamic state.
Rightly or wrongly (and regretfully I must accept some reading this thread will have a spectrum of opinions on that point) Israel's enemies have a goal to destroy that state in it's entirety. Israel has a contradictory goal: acceptance as a sovereign Jewish state by it's neighbours. You can never use force to make your neighbours love you - which is no great shakes, really, as being loved is clearly way off Israel's agenda. But you can, perhaps, use force to make your neighbours understand that you're there to stay.
Gus wrote:Am I being too simple again?
Yes.
Let's look at it another way: If the solution is as easy as you say (negotiation) then ask why no-one in the Israeli Government (or Hizbullah for that matter) is taking that option. That could be because:
1. They're too stupid to think of it
2. They're all evil and they just enjoy killing people
3. Your analysis is wrong
I don't believe 2, even if it is printed daily in the Independent. I don't believe 1 either (no offence, Gus, but if even you thought of it...) So that leaves 3.