Misleading moves

Confused by the Accordion Comb Pull Crab?

Spinning gets you dizzy?
Would like some help with a tricky intermediate move? Ask here, and share your fave tips...
You need to be registered / logged in to read this forum
Post Reply
User avatar
David Bailey
Senior Member
Posts: 17001
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Misleading moves

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Bailey »

Lou wrote: :clap: Bless you, Young Paduan. Wise, you are, in the way of the dance....
This is true, I can't deny it.

But I thought it was "padawan" - or was that just some subtle insult instead of compliment last time someone said that to me? :eek: :whistle:
Jivetango Godfather
"if your arguments are poorly constructed, they are often misinterperetated" - CJ
User avatar
Gadget
Senior Member
Posts: 7053
Joined: Wed Oct 09, 2002 9:08 pm
Contact:

Re: Misleading moves

Report a concern about this post

Post by Gadget »

Lou wrote:It is possible to use signals in good ways.

I like my tap on the shoulder signal (which started this whole debate off) because I think it shows courtesy to a less experienced Follower, and warns her that something different is coming up. I often use it in Catapult and Figure of 8 variations.
:what: ok, to a beginner, everything is "something different". And you use the same signal for multiple variations - won't that lead to more confusion rather than less?
When following, I will also sometimes use a squeeze of the hand to indicate to my partner that I'd like some time to play. And I've had it done to me by the Leader, to say that there's an opportunity to take control, if I want.
Personally, I would take a hand squeeze as a 'that was good' or 'thank-you' (unless there is a terrified expression on my partner's face at the time) Most partners who want time to play, generally just take it when the opportunity arrives or I lead them into some 'dead' space.
Was the hand-squeeze followed by a lack of leading? If so, why the hand-squeeze in the first plce?
The use of a head movement, or simply a look by the Leader, can help the Follower understand a change of direction that he wants her to step towards.
So can leading... although the thought of simply leading by standing and nodding the head too and fro is amusing :D
{good signals}... ensure that the Leader's arm and body position are best placed to perform the move. To take the Ceroc&#8482]But why prepare so far in advance? And the action of 'winding up' means that the signaling arm wants to continue on this path - much harder to deviate and go into a different move from a man-spin start. Harder to catch left because the right is already heading towards your partner's hand. It also can unballance the lead; one arm is out to the side and the other is close in - this can result in the leads raising their leading hand/elbow without realising it just to balance out.
Yet another problem is the 'half-hearted' signals that are even more confusing than 'proper' signals: the follower is left wondering "was that a signal? If so, which one was it?
{snip agreeing points} However, with moderate and appropriate usage, I still think they're an extremely helpful tool.
How do they help? They encourage the follower to anticipate rather than follow and the lead to signal rather than lead. Using them only to indicate there's a tricky move coming up conditions them into being on 'auto-pilot' for the rest of the dance and only paying attention when you signal for it.

signals = bad.
I used to be an angel, you know with halo and those wings;
Now that i'm a devil, my mind's on other things...
My feathers turned to ash, and my harp has broke in two;
I took uppon myself, to have a dance with you...
User avatar
Lou
Senior Member
Posts: 3772
Joined: Tue Jun 25, 2002 11:00 am
Contact:

Re: Misleading moves

Report a concern about this post

Post by Lou »

DavidJames wrote:But I thought it was "padawan" - or was that just some subtle insult instead of compliment last time someone said that to me? :eek: :whistle:
I think both are valid - maybe the dialect & spelling depends on where you are in the galaxy?
@( * O * )@
User avatar
Lou
Senior Member
Posts: 3772
Joined: Tue Jun 25, 2002 11:00 am
Contact:

Re: Misleading moves

Report a concern about this post

Post by Lou »

Gadget wrote: :what: ok, to a beginner, everything is "something different". And you use the same signal for multiple variations - won't that lead to more confusion rather than less?
Not if they're used to the common beginner's move version. By indicating that it's a variation, it helps the Follower learn to "listen" to what the Lead is asking her to do. Remember - I'm advocating the use of signals for inexperienced dancers here.
Was the hand-squeeze followed by a lack of leading? If so, why the hand-squeeze in the first plce?
Just a matter of courtesy, to allow the Follower a nano-second more to understand that playtime is coming up. That means that she knows that the Leader is aware there's a break coming up & she can do something, without hi-jacking his lead (which, if I recall correctly, is something you're not too fond of). Also, I use it if I'm in a R-R hold going into a return & I fancy doing a ronde. Quite often a chap will fancify a R-R return himself - so this warns him that I'd like a go... :whistle:
So can leading... although the thought of simply leading by standing and nodding the head too and fro is amusing :D
Why do I suddenly get an image of DavidB popping into my head...
But why prepare so far in advance?
Good training for a beginner lead to think in advance of what move he can do next?
And the action of 'winding up' means that the signaling arm wants to continue on this path - much harder to deviate and go into a different move from a man-spin start. Harder to catch left because the right is already heading towards your partner's hand. It also can unballance the lead]
Sorry, Gadget - you've lost me there. Maybe we can experiment at BFG & you can show me what you mean?
How do they help? They encourage the follower to anticipate rather than follow and the lead to signal rather than lead.
Sorry? I'm confused? How does that help? I listed that as a disadvantage previously. Are you disagreeing? :confused:
Using them only to indicate there's a tricky move coming up conditions them into being on 'auto-pilot' for the rest of the dance and only paying attention when you signal for it.
Actually, autopilot is a lovely stage to be at as a Follower. I'd rather not think! ;)
@( * O * )@
MartinHarper
Senior Member
Posts: 4157
Joined: Mon Jul 12, 2004 4:24 pm

Re: Misleading moves

Report a concern about this post

Post by MartinHarper »

DavidJames wrote:I thought the main point was that the lady doesn't need to do anything abnormal, therefore raising the hand and using it as a signal is kind of pointless.
I find it's good for reassurance when dancing with beginners.
User avatar
David Bailey
Senior Member
Posts: 17001
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Misleading moves

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Bailey »

MartinHarper wrote:I find it's good for reassurance when dancing with beginners.
Yeah, but the problem with all these cheats or tricks or handy hints is that they tend to turn into bad habits all too soon, and it takes years to get rid of them.

Of course, it's a trade-off as always in MJ between getting people dancing quickly, and getting them dancing well. But let's not fool ourselves - the "getting everyone to dance" concept is a largely commercially-driven proposition, designed to maximise retention numbers.

And the tools Ceroc (mainly) uses to do this aren't tools designed to get everyone to dance ideally - they're tools designed to get beginners to a level where they can sort of dance, very quickly.

Signalling is such a tool - it may be useful for teaching purposes, but I'm not keen on them in any freestyle, it simply reinforces bad habits in my opinion.
Gadget wrote:So can leading... although the thought of simply leading by standing and nodding the head too and fro is amusing
That sounds like a challenge to me... OK, I'm game. I'll give it a go next time I'm with a super-follower.
Jivetango Godfather
"if your arguments are poorly constructed, they are often misinterperetated" - CJ
User avatar
LMC
Senior Member
Posts: 4508
Joined: Wed Jun 01, 2005 11:00 am

Re: Misleading moves

Report a concern about this post

Post by LMC »

DavidJames wrote:That sounds like a challenge to me... OK, I'm game. I'll give it a go next time I'm with a super-follower.
Pick me, pick me - I don't count as a super-follower (not even close) but I *am* game for a laugh... :devil:

Signals are Evil. Even for moves with more or less universally recognised signals eg the manspin, the *lead* - i.e. follow steps forward - is the important thing.
I'm blonde, what's your excuse?
clevedonboy
Senior Member
Posts: 1544
Joined: Tue Feb 15, 2005 12:00 pm
Contact:

Re: Misleading moves

Report a concern about this post

Post by clevedonboy »

Regarding the Man Spin or Change Places.

As a veteran of two Swing Dance classes, I can talk (a little) about the what I presume to be the original version.

In six count swing in an open hold the shape for the lead goes rock (quick) step (quick) step forward on the left (slow) taking your left hand (partner right) to your left hip release grip step onto right and pivot (slow) collect partners right hand. You do have to be aware of what your right hand is doing so as not to get tangled but there is no exagerated right arm across the chest movement.

Not sure what it adds to the conversation but I've been dying to tell people about how much fun I'm having doing it
User avatar
Gadget
Senior Member
Posts: 7053
Joined: Wed Oct 09, 2002 9:08 pm
Contact:

Re: Misleading moves

Report a concern about this post

Post by Gadget »

Lou wrote:Not if they're used to the common beginner's move version. By indicating that it's a variation, it helps the Follower learn to "listen" to what the Lead is asking her to do. Remember - I'm advocating the use of signals for inexperienced dancers here.
So it's a matter of "I can't actually lead this next bit, but if I signal to you what I mean, you will execute the move." Yes? SO... you want inexperianced leaders to get into the habbit of letting the followers lead themselves, and the inexperianced followers that they lead to get into the habbit of anticipating.

I agree, it has been used as a tool for beginner dancers. It does work to get people dancing because both partners are watching for signals and working together to perform the move. BUT I think that relying on obvious visual signals instead of "feeling" and using the tactile signals of lead and follow {which is not that different} inserts a barrier to the dancer's progress before they have even begun to progress!
Just a matter of courtesy, to allow the Follower a nano-second more to understand that playtime is coming up.
and that nano-second couldn't be a subtle deceleration or lightening of the lead instead? Why use an obvious signal that probably takes longer and has to be translated by your partner instead of easing them into it?
...without hi-jacking his lead (which, if I recall correctly, is something you're not too fond of).
{ :whistle: } With some of the ladies I dance with, I've had to become a bit more tollerant in my old age :innocent: Na - I still dislike someone hi-jacking - I am just a bt more aware of the "signals" and l pretend that it was all my idea in the first place :D :rofl:
Why do I suddenly get an image of DavidB popping into my head...
yea... I deleted a reference to him before I actually posted that :)
Sorry, Gadget - you've lost me there. Maybe we can experiment at BFG & you can show me what you mean?
Simple really: stand on one foot. extend left hand as if holding your partner's right. Signal for a man spin (real-time, not bullet-time) and see what happens to the left hand. Remember that beginners are much more enthusiastic in signals and movements - the act of raising the right elbow and pulling back twists the shoulders and torso to almost start the follower moving to the lead's right before the move has even started to be led.
You may see this as a good thing. Personally, I want my partner to be moving towards me, not to my right: I will move out her way and collect with her on the same line. I like to be aware of my movements and how they affect my lead - signals (and excessive stylings :blush: ) can result in unintentional messages being given through the lead.
{I hope I will be too busy dancing with you to bother about experiments like this. :flower: }
Sorry? I'm confused? How does that help? I listed that as a disadvantage previously. Are you disagreeing? :confused:
Badly put perhaps - the intent was to show why signals were bad.
Actually, autopilot is a lovely stage to be at as a Follower. I'd rather not think! ]There is the 'dream state' of following that you are refering to, but there is also the 'auto-pilot' where it's autonomous "first move"-execute-"arm-jive"-execute-"basket"-execute-"octo.... that is almost catatonic rather than dream-like.
I used to be an angel, you know with halo and those wings;
Now that i'm a devil, my mind's on other things...
My feathers turned to ash, and my harp has broke in two;
I took uppon myself, to have a dance with you...
Tellina
Junior Member
Posts: 36
Joined: Wed Jun 08, 2005 11:00 am

Re: Misleading moves

Report a concern about this post

Post by Tellina »

Lou wrote: :devil: I sometimes do that too - with an evil twinkle, of course... :whistle:
Oh no! I do that all the time (tapping the guy's shoulder after he taps mine). I had no idea that it was a signal and I just copied it thinking that it was a styling thing. Actually, I seem to remember that one guy I danced with actually told me that I should tap his shoulder too. This was way back, before I had even heard of visual signals for moves.

Lily
User avatar
Lou
Senior Member
Posts: 3772
Joined: Tue Jun 25, 2002 11:00 am
Contact:

Re: Misleading moves

Report a concern about this post

Post by Lou »

Gadget wrote:So it's a matter of "I can't actually lead this next bit, but if I signal to you what I mean, you will execute the move." Yes?
No. :D It's not that the Leader can't lead. It's more that he knows that the Follower is less experienced, so he's asking her to listen closely to the lead he's going to give her next.
I agree
:clap:
it has been used as a tool for beginner dancers. It does work to get people dancing because both partners are watching for signals and working together to perform the move. BUT I think that relying on obvious visual signals instead of "feeling" and using the tactile signals of lead and follow {which is not that different} inserts a barrier to the dancer's progress before they have even begun to progress!
Yup. Totally. Wouldn't disagree at all. In fact, this is the point I've been arguing all along. Yup - it does insert that barrier that you mention - however, I think the good outweighs the bad because signals do get new beginners dancing together sooner.

What I was hoping was that this thread might have veered off & started talking about how teachers can best convey concepts such as Lead & Follow to their Iprovers & Intermediate dancers.
and that nano-second couldn't be a subtle deceleration or lightening of the lead instead? Why use an obvious signal that probably takes longer and has to be translated by your partner instead of easing them into it?
Dunno. I have partners who do both. And both methods work fine.
Na - I still dislike someone hi-jacking - I am just a bt more aware of the "signals" and l pretend that it was all my idea in the first place :D :rofl:
:hug:
Signal for a man spin (real-time, not bullet-time)
Meaniehead. With bullet-time at least I can pretend my partner is Keanu...
I will move out her way and collect with her on the same line
*swoon* You're a rare man indeed, Gadget! :flower:
. I like to be aware of my movements and how they affect my lead - signals (and excessive stylings :blush: ) can result in unintentional messages being given through the lead.
Again - totally agreed. But I never argued that signals are right for everybody. We have a local dancer who uses a lot of signals. He points to where he wants his lady to follow. He gestures. He signals. It actually works well for him, and although I have to admit that the styling isn't to my personal taste, I find him extremely pleasant to dance with.

See ya at BFG for those dances! :hug:
@( * O * )@
User avatar
Lou
Senior Member
Posts: 3772
Joined: Tue Jun 25, 2002 11:00 am
Contact:

Re: Misleading moves

Report a concern about this post

Post by Lou »

Tellina wrote:Actually, I seem to remember that one guy I danced with actually told me that I should tap his shoulder too. This was way back, before I had even heard of visual signals for moves.
Ahhh.. there is a move called the Back Barrier, when sometimes both dancers are encouraged to tap shoulders - for style, of course.... ;)
@( * O * )@
Tellina
Junior Member
Posts: 36
Joined: Wed Jun 08, 2005 11:00 am

Re: Misleading moves

Report a concern about this post

Post by Tellina »

Lou wrote:Ahhh.. there is a move called the Back Barrier, when sometimes both dancers are encouraged to tap shoulders - for style, of course.... ]

Oh ok, maybe that's the move. Thanks! :cheers:
bigdjiver
Senior Member
Posts: 4899
Joined: Mon Mar 03, 2003 1:38 am
Contact:

Re: Misleading moves

Report a concern about this post

Post by bigdjiver »

When I send a lady into a spin I do not use just the right amount of force to make her turn 360 degrees. It is her that decides how far she will turn. Some beginners stop at 120 degrees, and then give the "what now?" look. Some of the advanced spin twice, or more. a lady might spin 1 1/2 times, and stick out there arms behind them, trying to take the lead into a catpult exit. The lead is all nearly signals. For me the only right or wrong issue is whether the partners understand each other, and are content.
User avatar
Ghost
Senior Member
Posts: 3209
Joined: Thu Sep 01, 2005 11:00 am

Re: Misleading moves

Report a concern about this post

Post by Ghost »

Ok,
I had an experiment with signaling and not signalling. Found out a couple of things.

Firstly the signal for the neckbreak doesn't seem to make sense in the context of Ceroc. I was dancing with a newish Intermediate who knew the signals for the secret and the pretzel. I deliberately keep my spare hand hidden form the lady's view if I don't want her to take it to avoid confusion. So her train of thought is that if I offer my other hand she's supposed to take it. Fair enough. I raised my hand into the neckbreak signal and the best way I can describe it is that she tried to high five me with her left hand as we stepped in. I have to admit, this makes perfect sense to me. The signal reads to someone who doesn't know it as "please take my raised right hand". If the lady does take your raised right hand it does leave you in a position to do some interesting moves.

I found that not signalling wth a couple of other people made the dance flow more smoothly as they weren't trying to anticipate which variation of the neckbreak I was going to do.

Take care,
Christopher
User avatar
David Bailey
Senior Member
Posts: 17001
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Misleading moves

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Bailey »

Ghost wrote:Fair enough. I raised my hand into the neckbreak signal and the best way I can describe it is that she tried to high five me with her left hand as we stepped in.
That's classic :rofl:

Hmmm, there's no need to signal a neck-break - you can just lead a first move, then transfer her hand from your left to your right at the appropriate point. I think it looks a little smoother if you transfer as a continuous motion, but the staccato version may also have advantages.
Jivetango Godfather
"if your arguments are poorly constructed, they are often misinterperetated" - CJ
User avatar
Ghost
Senior Member
Posts: 3209
Joined: Thu Sep 01, 2005 11:00 am

Re: Misleading moves

Report a concern about this post

Post by Ghost »

DavidJames wrote:Hmmm, there's no need to signal a neck-break - you can just lead a first move, then transfer her hand from your left to your right at the appropriate point. I think it looks a little smoother if you transfer as a continuous motion, but the staccato version may also have advantages.
:cheers:

Agreed - had a "lightbulb goes off over my head moment" when I was leading this without signals and realised that it's just a first move variation. Definetely a lot smoother without the signal.

I also tried Cynthia's Pretzel without signalling and found that if I only kept one hand contact it goes a lot more smoothly

Take care,
Christopher
User avatar
LMC
Senior Member
Posts: 4508
Joined: Wed Jun 01, 2005 11:00 am

Re: Misleading moves

Report a concern about this post

Post by LMC »

Well, I've never been able to take a crucifix seriously since Southport (and it's ALL killingtime's fault - well done that man). And yesterday's intermediate class demonstrates that there will never be any hope... me and the crucifix will never be friends

Crucifix variation. Follow "goes down" (yes, that's a quote :non-existent zippy mouth guy: ) for two beats. The lead is, apparently, for the lead to shout "Go down". This really happened - ask wittybird if you don't believe me :innocent:

*wanders off again, trying NOT to snigger - WARNING: any guy who tries this may get more than they bargained for... 99.9 recurring % probability of a slap...*
I'm blonde, what's your excuse?
User avatar
Ghost
Senior Member
Posts: 3209
Joined: Thu Sep 01, 2005 11:00 am

Re: Misleading moves

Report a concern about this post

Post by Ghost »

LMC wrote:Well, I've never been able to take a crucifix seriously since Southport (and it's ALL killingtime's fault - well done that man). And yesterday's intermediate class demonstrates that there will never be any hope... me and the crucifix will never be friends

Crucifix variation. Follow "goes down" (yes, that's a quote :non-existent zippy mouth guy: ) for two beats. The lead is, apparently, for the lead to shout "Go down". This really happened - ask wittybird if you don't believe me :innocent:

*wanders off again, trying NOT to snigger - WARNING: any guy who tries this may get more than they bargained for... 99.9 recurring % probability of a slap...*
:rofl:
I have a mental image of trying this lead with someone who doesn't know the move :whistle:

What's the line from Stealth? "I believe a man should kneel before a woman, but there are times when a woman should bow down before a man"

Take care,
Christopher
User avatar
David Bailey
Senior Member
Posts: 17001
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Misleading moves

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Bailey »

LMC wrote:Crucifix variation. Follow "goes down" (yes, that's a quote :non-existent zippy mouth guy: ) for two beats. The lead is, apparently, for the lead to shout "Go down". This really happened - ask wittybird if you don't believe me :innocent:
OK, let's not confuse a cr&p teacher (blue touchpaper, here I come baby) with a nice move.

Anyone teaching that you need to shout, in order to lead any move should be shot - OK, they should hung, then drawn, then quartered, then shot (then nuked from orbit to make sure).

I like the crucifix - it's an opportunity for the follow to play around. I think it's supposed to be difficult to lead any move - the follower chooses what she wants to do at that point, and she can pretty much control the sequence. The most the follower can do, even with a rigid frame, is suggest or invite.

Both Miss Conduct and ZW both have very clear and very :drool: ideas about what they can do with a crucifix... :whistle:
Jivetango Godfather
"if your arguments are poorly constructed, they are often misinterperetated" - CJ
Post Reply