Page 1 of 4
Avoiding pain.
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 12:59 pm
by johnthehappyguy
I have searched without success, hence this thread.
TheTramp wrote:.......I'd never turn anyone down based purely on their dancing ability (unless there's a pain factor involved here).....
Steve
Recently I was at a class, and there were many ladies who were painful to dance with.
Putting things rather simplistically:-
I have been told I am a good lead.
However I had particular difficulty with a lady who did not know "how to follow". Moves are anticipated incorrectly, and the lady will put in a "return" here or there if she feels like it.
My first reaction was to be firmer in my lead, however things turned into a bit of a wrestling match.
I tried to joke and say "who is supposed to be doing the leading" etc.
I also restricted my moves to those beginners moves which had been taught that night.
When this was unsuccesful, I stuck firmly to the moves being led in the same order as they had been taught.
Then I tried to protect myself from injury by anticipating what the lady might do next, and willed for the dance to end. Then kept willing it to end, then really willed for it to end and eventually I escaped from purgatory as the track faded..
I had a few good dances, however I had similarly poor dances with others at the same venue, which were almost as traumatic.
On the drive home, my shoulders were aching, which was a first for me.
Any advice,
Please
johnthesomewhatsoreanddistressedguy

Re: Avoiding pain.
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 1:24 pm
by El Salsero Gringo
In no particular order....
-Turn up with both arms bandaged across your chest - if they can't reach to your hands they can't do any damage...
-Ask the girls to lead you - since they don't seem able to do otherwise, and practice the follower's part yourself.
-Try a different venue!
Seriously though - rather than wrestling matches, try just stopping for a couple of beats and locking your arms solid. As soon as she's got the idea that she's not going anywhere, start dancing again. Repeat as necessary.
How about asking the teacher to explain during the class what it means to follow - and that unled returns are not the done thing? If everyone's up to the same tricks then the teacher is the best person to put it right.
I suppose it depends on whether you *want* them to be more fun to dance with in the long run, or whether you just go dance with someone else instead. There's no point in dancing if it's painful and not enjoyable.
Re: Avoiding pain.
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 1:26 pm
by drathzel
johnthehappyguy wrote:I have searched without success, hence this thread.
Recently I was at a class, and there were many ladies who were painful to dance with.
Putting things rather simplistically:-
I have been told I am a good lead.
However I had particular difficulty with a lady who did not know "how to follow". Moves are anticipated incorrectly, and the lady will put in a "return" here or there if she feels like it.
My first reaction was to be firmer in my lead, however things turned into a bit of a wrestling match.
I tried to joke and say "who is supposed to be doing the leading" etc.
Unfortunately these women do exist and no matter how much you try and follow the moves or try to anticipate where they are going to put themselves you still end up getting hurt! I have also tried to speak to the ladies and suggest they dont use thumbs/loosen up/stop leading but they actually dont listen. Its the same with some men. Not everyone can be good but as long as they are enjoying themselves and not dancing with or hurting me then thats ok! My view is that you try and talk to them about it while you are dancing but if they dont listen or think they are better than that then i just tend not to ask them to dance. (and again this is male and females!

Re: Avoiding pain.
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 1:31 pm
by Gadget
A couple of ideas - may, or may not be of use...
- Use BIG movements: stir returns, over-emphisise hand placements... basically make sure that the lady's body
has to follow the hand.
- If the lady is managing to insert turns, then try and make your leads with a definite "Low" or "High" hand: Low hands should remain at waist level or lower, only rising to turn the lady - cut out any signals or blocks that rely on you having your hand high, and don't turn under your own hand; use a quick placement of shoulder-slide or man-spin variant instead.
- Use baskets, octopusses, arm-jives, 'ballroom' style first-moves... where you have both hands and the lady is close. Insert a few walks where you can keep her in close.
- Try going the other way: lead lighter with a greased hand. OK; not actual grease, but a light contact that will break when the lady trys to force anything.
- Follow: switch off all "I'm leading" thoughts and follow your hand; It may not teach the lady anything, but it will prevent injury.
- Try and convince her to close her eyes and trust you {

}: even if it's only for one move, you can then build on it and get her to try again.
- Stop trying to dance and try to teach her to 'lighten up';
"I'm sorry, this isn't working. Can you try...." "...Excelent, thank you; you are dancing a lot better."
Inadaquate Teaching Model?
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 1:37 pm
by Gus
Since I've been exiled to London, and so free of any teaching obligations, I've discovered the 'delights' of freestyle again ... AND IT HURTS

Forget all the advice about how to avoid the pain ... the simple truth is that the pain shouldn’t be there in the first place! WHY do so many women jerk, yank and generally follow so badly?? I thought such complaints were just form a few whinners ... but after 2+ weeks dancing at a few clubs I've become really concerned about the number of really bad followers out there. Things got so bad that there are two clubs where I will not return to as my existing shoulder injuries have been made significantly worse. Is this just a London thing or is it a UK wide problem? If so ... what is so wrong with our teaching that we are allowing this to happen?
Re: Avoiding pain.
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 1:44 pm
by Aleks
My suggestion is you talk to the taxi dancers at the night.....maybe they could incorporate stuff about not yanking into their refresher session (I am assuming these were (relative)beginners you were dancing with). The teacher could also mention this as part of the class.
Another thought.....try suggesting that contact is maintained by only one/two fingers each - there's no way to hold on then.
One thing I think could be mentioned more often at a beginner class (or any class) is that each partner should be responsible for their own momentum and movement and neither should rely on the other to keep their balance.
Re: Inadaquate Teaching Model?
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 1:45 pm
by drathzel
Gus wrote: Is this just a London thing or is it a UK wide problem? If so ... what is so wrong with our teaching that we are allowing this to happen?
Nope its a uk wide thing i think. Although i sometime put it down to the fact thta i am a women lead and women follows must think i can't lead so they dont let me. When i feel this in class i sometime either go slower or faster than the teacher, i am hoping this reminds the lady that the LEAD is meant to be LEADING!

Re: Avoiding pain.
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 1:52 pm
by drathzel
Aleks wrote:My suggestion is you talk to the taxi dancers at the night.....maybe they could incorporate stuff about not yanking into their refresher session (I am assuming these were (relative)beginners you were dancing with). The teacher could also mention this as part of the class.
This is a good idea although when i have been trying to help out in taxi classes, i sometimes feel that even though the taxi is saying it, some of the women think it doesn't apply to them and they just switch off and do it as they were doing it before, even if you point it out.
I also feel that some people who have danced before or have done something similar think that because of this they are automatically good and dont listne either.
Oh dear i have gone off in a rant. I just feel that no matter what stage you are at you always have something to learn and should always listen and see if you can change something you are doing wrong.

Re: Inadaquate Teaching Model?
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 2:13 pm
by Chef
Gus wrote: Is this just a London thing or is it a UK wide problem? If so ... what is so wrong with our teaching that we are allowing this to happen?
Sorry to say Gus but it is not just a London thing. I can only say that it does extend down to the South Coast as well. I can't comment on other area. Go to places where boom boom music is rare as the hand manglers find anything else tricky and they avoid those venues - which leaves you safe.
What is wrong with the teaching is that TECHNIQUE is never taught unless you go on good weekenders. Although it is taught at these weekenders there are those that just don't want to listen and keep coming back year after year just as painful to dance with. Sometimes this leads to the impression that things are getting worse when the reality is that you are getting better and others are standing still.
Few teachers feel motivated to teach technique because they feel it will scare punters off and that may lose them income. The standard MJ model works if you recruit newcomers, let them mangle for a few years before they either meet the partner of their dreams and go for some romance or decide that going home with sore shoulders once a week is not as much fun as it used to seem.
3 ways of avoiding sore shoulders for me.
1) lead with a light hand and when your own personal comfort level of load on you fingers/arms has been reached then let go. Sure, the woman won't know where to go but then she didn't know anyway.
2) As soon as you get to a new venue pick out the best dancer that you can find (or failing that the teacher or demo). Find the most public spot you can and dance your socks off for 2 or 3 tracks. I find that usually deters the very worst hand manglers fro asking you.
3) Just observe from about 10 feet from the edge of the dance floor and note those people that fall over when they do a return or fall backwards when they do a rock step (usually signified by the front foot toes coming off the floor). Look for people with flashy rings (sharp) and bangles (places to trap fingers). You now have a "avoid at all costs list". Don't stand at the edge of the dance floor. It makes you fair game for anyone on your "avoid list". Instead stand back from the floor and target the people that you want to dance with by moving directly towards them as the music is ending. Have a nearby reserve option in case they go for a second dance together as you don't want to be caught in the open where a hand mangler can pick you off.
The worst thing is coming up against people who have been dancing regularly for years and are still no better than the people that are doing their first 6 classes. You would have thought that plain curiousity would have made then ask "why does this hurt so much?".
Happy Dancing
Re: Inadaquate Teaching Model?
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 2:15 pm
by Gadget
drathzel wrote:Gus wrote:Is this just a London thing or is it a UK wide problem? If so ... what is so wrong with our teaching that we are allowing this to happen?
Nope its a uk wide thing i think. Although i sometime put it down to the fact thta i am a women lead and women follows must think i can't lead so they dont let me. When i feel this in class i sometime either go slower or faster than the teacher, i am hoping this reminds the lady that the LEAD is meant to be LEADING!
I often do the 'put the moves together' bit one count behind the teacher]never[/u] had a partner who's following has hurt me*. I don't think I'm
that strong to force them to follow my every lead... I am trying to think on what I do that could be the reason for this - my above posts are all that come to mind. If it's not my lead, it must be the number of ladies who actually do this are so small here I just haven't met them.
*... except when I put my feet where they are about to step ... or smack her hand into my face... or step too close at the wrong time and get an elbow in the chest...

Actually, the most painfull thing is when lady grabs onto my side when I'm doing a man-spin (or equivilent) instead of just sliding.
Re: Inadaquate Teaching Model?
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 3:50 pm
by drathzel
Gadget wrote:
I must be blessed in that I have never had a partner who's following has hurt me*. I don't think I'm that strong to force them to follow my every lead... I am trying to think on what I do that could be the reason for this - my above posts are all that come to mind. If it's not my lead, it must be the number of ladies who actually do this are so small here I just haven't met them.
you must just be blessed honey!

Re: Inadaquate Teaching Model?
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 4:18 pm
by Franck
drathzel wrote:you must just be blessed honey!
I don't think he's alone, I've never been hurt by anyone's following either.
Some women insist on leading / and force themselves in any direction without paying attention to any lead but maybe it's the way I dance, I rarely fight it, I might mention a few things to make them relax, suggest they should take over the lead or sometimes ask them to focus on their right hand, and to go where it goes (this simple change of focus is usually enough to get them to improve greatly).
It could also be that I give them very few opportunities to grip my hand as I try to keep a 'touch' hold, and more often than not will be leading from their wrist / shoulders / hips / back of the hand, which doesn't offer them any opportunity to do any damage.
Re: Inadaquate Teaching Model?
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 4:33 pm
by Little Monkey
Franck wrote:I don't think he's alone, I've never been hurt by anyone's following either.
Some women insist on leading / and force themselves in any direction without paying attention to any lead but maybe it's the way I dance, I rarely fight it, I might mention a few things to make them relax, suggest they should take over the lead or sometimes ask them to focus on their right hand, and to go where it goes (this simple change of focus is usually enough to get them to improve greatly).
It could also be that I give them very few opportunities to grip my hand as I try to keep a 'touch' hold, and more often than not will be leading from their wrist / shoulders / hips / back of the hand, which doesn't offer them any opportunity to do any damage.
Your lead is simply FANTASTIC!!!

Light, but most of the time even I understand what you want me to do!
When I've encountered women who won't follow my lead (even when I do it right!

), who clamp onto my hands like they're drowning, and the only rescue is to hold on tight - I normally just smile, and remind them to BREATHE. A lot of beginners are petrified, and are sooo tense, they try to memorize the whole routine they've learnt in class, thinking it might help them.... I tend to tell them NOT TO THINK, as they've got no way of knowing what's coming next, apart from following the guy's lead. And sometimes, jokingly, I tell them to loosen the grip on my hands, as otherwise my fingers will go blue and drop off...
Most women, when they get a bit more comfortable with dancing, will start relaxing, and then they will follow much better. It sounds like the woman John was dancing with was a beginner, so her bad following might just be because she was nervous! If they don't get any better, well..... If I was a guy, I'd perhaps not ask her for a dance again.... That's what I do with guys who hurt me (yanking, gripping, using thumbs, throwing me into dips or drops etc). When I see them coming........I run in the opposite direction as fast as I can!
Anyway, I do agree wholeheartedly with a few other people who's said they don't think enough technique is taught in ceroc. If very basic techniques were stresses early on, people would soon become better dancers, and they wouldn't develop bad habits from the beginning...
LM
Re: Inadaquate Teaching Model?
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 4:36 pm
by Trish
Personally (as a woman who leads), I find that letting your arm go limp is the easiest way of avoiding injury. If a woman is determined to do her own thing and not following me, I tend to let her lead herself into whatever it is she decides to do until she's finished - I won't lead anything else. I then find eventually that she stops and looks at me a bit puzzled, and will say to her something like "you were doing such a good job at leading that I didn't like to interrupt you". This tends to work for a little while, she'll then do it again and you remind her again. After a while she tends to get the message! If she doesn't get the message I'll do Gadget's trick of leading her with her eyes closed, that seems to help quite a bit.
As various people have said though, there are some women who don't follow well even though they've been dancing for years. And there are both men and women who are terrible dancers that think they're great - these I avoid like the plague if I can help it. One particularly terrible dancer (man), I actually told that I won't dance with him any more, as he invariably pulls my arms out of their sockets and treads on my toes - I think he thought I was a bit mad, and I probably hurt his feelings, but hell it's better than pain

!!! I just had a horrible thought - I hope I'm not one of them, I don't think so, as I've had quite few compliments over the years but perhaps that was people just being nice

!!!
Re: Inadaquate Teaching Model?
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 4:55 pm
by drathzel
Trish wrote: I tend to let her lead herself into whatever it is she decides to do until she's finished - I won't lead anything else. I then find eventually that she stops and looks at me a bit puzzled, and will say to her something like "you were doing such a good job at leading that I didn't like to interrupt you". This tends to work for a little while, she'll then do it again and you remind her again.
I've tried this and gotten very dirty looks! Maybe its just my lead
Trish wrote:
I just had a horrible thought - I hope I'm not one of them, I don't think so, as I've had quite few compliments over the years but perhaps that was people just being nice

!!!

Re: Avoiding pain.
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 5:28 pm
by MartinHarper
johnthehappyguy wrote:My first reaction was to be firmer in my lead, however things turned into a bit of a wrestling match. [...]
On the drive home, my shoulders were aching, which was a first for me.
Yeah, wrestling does that to me - using muscles I don't often use. I don't mind those kinds of aches. I'm more concerned about pulled muscles, etc - they make my muscles weaker, not stronger.
Anyways, you tried wrestling. Others suggest following: Gadget says "It may not teach the lady anything, but it will prevent injury". I've done both before now. I sometimes try a third way: I try to provide enough force in my intended direction that my parter can feel if she's mis-followed, but not so much as to end up wrestling her into following regardless. That means that we make lots of "mistakes", though.
Re: Inadaquate Teaching Model?
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 5:34 pm
by MartinHarper
Little Monkey wrote:Women who clamp onto my hands like they're drowning, and the only rescue is to hold on tight
Nod. Sometimes I try to counteract this by making my own hold looser, but I find that tends to make them grip harder themselves, as if to compensate for my "wimpiness". At the moment, I'm experimenting with using my thumb more to grip onto their hand. My theory is that this will give them confidence that I have a hold on them, and they'll find it easier to let go a little. I figure it's worth trying.
Re: Inadaquate Teaching Model?
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 5:51 pm
by Minnie M
MartinHarper wrote:Nod. Sometimes I try to counteract this by making my own hold looser, but I find that tends to make them grip harder themselves, as if to compensate for my "wimpiness". At the moment, I'm experimenting with using my thumb more to grip onto their hand. My theory is that this will give them confidence that I have a hold on them, and they'll find it easier to let go a little. I figure it's worth trying.
Don't get into bad habits Martin, if your followers are not following, direct them to the taxi dancers or the teacher - mind you I think we have been here before
(too lazy to search for the thread)
Or maybe you need a 'one-to-one' with a dancer/teacher like DavidB or James Hamilton (as he is in your area) - both these guys are amazing leads and never use thumbs or pressure, they will give you tips
When I am leading and I get a 'back-leader' I just let them take over, easier that way and less painful

Re: Avoiding pain.
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 6:10 pm
by Andreas
It is true that some ladies are a pain in the shoulder to dance with

But then again, you are the guy, you decide what moves you do, you can restrain them by doing moves that do not provide them any room for 'interpretation'. The yanking is a bit more difficult but even there, if you have a strong frame they simply won't be able to yank your arm. The other extreme works too. If your arm is so relaxed that they simply can't lead themselves you can actually guide them by moving around them
There is no hiding that I too prefer to dance with ladies that 1) do not try to lead me or anybody else and 2) who dance smoothly. But even the other examples can be restrained. Something to work on, ey

Re: Avoiding pain.
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 6:32 pm
by Gus
Andreas wrote:It is true that some ladies are a pain in the shoulder to dance with

But then again, you are the guy, you decide what moves you do, you can restrain them by doing moves that do not provide them any room for 'interpretation'.
True ... but by then it can be too late

I learnt many years ago to only do double pretzels with partners I knew were 'safe' .. but even yo-yos were proving dangerous the other night.
HOWEVER my main point, as yet unanswered, is what is going fundamentally wrong that allows a preponderance of such dancing. I was speaking to some of the more experienced dancers over the last few weeks asking why they didn’t do lessons ... and the majority view was that they were fed up with dancers in the line pulling them around (male and female). Having spent a weekend workshop working on lead and follow I know how difficult it is to break these bad habits ... but why so allegedly intelligent people start with such habits in the first place?