Page 1 of 2

Footwork LeRoc or otherwise

Posted: Fri Dec 10, 2004 8:40 pm
by jiveoholic
I was just wondering about footwork - especially the lady's. There seem to be two camps, those who do strict "LeRoc" footwork (eg step back on right at the start of a lady-spin but step back on left for an arm-jive) and those who just use whatever foot comes most easily.

Have a look at http://www.jiveoholic.org.uk/footwork.asp if you are not sure what this is about. I am interested how many follow such footwork, whether all LeRocers are that strick and what our ozzy friends think.

The note is just my best understanding of the footwork, any correction appreciated!

Re: Footwork LeRoc or otherwise

Posted: Sat Dec 11, 2004 11:40 pm
by Baruch
By "footwork" you're obviously referring to the basic stuff. Personally, when I'm dancing I'm not thinking of the lady's feet, unless I'm leading something a little more complicated. It just comes naturally, probably because the majority of the ladies I dance with are also from a Le Roc background.

I'm more concerned about my own feet, and with doing something a little more interesting than just the basic "step in - step back" stuff, although having said that, as I'm a Le Roc dancer, I naturally follow the "rules", at least when learning moves, because that's how I've been taught from the beginning. It's no hardship really, and it's not really rocket science.

Re: Footwork LeRoc or otherwise

Posted: Sun Dec 12, 2004 11:53 pm
by MartinHarper
FWIW, beginner/intermediate JazzJive follows the same rules as those in your linked article (which I'll call "LeRoc footwork" for simplicity). Those rules are taught explicitly (eg "this move interrupts a return"). Later on it starts getting more swing-like, which is kinda like an extension to LeRoc footwork.

Ceroc (locally) also basically follows the LeRoc footwork, as you describe it. One difference is that Ceroc considers the basket(+variations) to be a move you do after a return. Another difference is that the rules are never explicitly taught. Fortunately, beginners rapidly work them out, consciously or not. A final difference is that Ceroc teachers very occasionally teach routines that break the rules, which doesn't happen in JazzJive.

Re: Footwork LeRoc or otherwise

Posted: Mon Dec 13, 2004 8:55 am
by Lou
MartinHarper wrote:Ceroc (locally) also basically follows the LeRoc footwork, as you describe it. One difference is that Ceroc considers the basket(+variations) to be a move you do after a return.
Good point. Purest LeRoc does teach a basket with the right foot back, however it's not unknown for it to be put in after a return too (so, left foot back to begin).

I liked your 6 rules, Jiveoholic. They're spot on for our taught footwork - although I'd argue with one of your examples for rule 3. I've never seen an Octopus taught at a LeRoc class. It would be a two handed travelling Return followed by a Loophole! :wink: And I'm not certain about the "Observations" paragraph, because I can't figure out what you mean. Although, that's most likely due to the fact that I haven't drunk enough coffee this morning yet. :whistle:

The compatability idea is interesting. I have to say that when I've danced with CerocTM (or other) taught dancers, I've not particularly felt my footwork to be a big issue. Mostly, it's more to do with signals (that Neckbreak one in particular freaks me out). Although, saying that, when RobC & Debi were teaching at Boppin', their routine contained a move combination that didn't seem quite comfortable for LeRoc footwork (I think it was the Whips, but I can't remember precisely), so incompatability does happen. However, some LeRoc men do insist on leading a return before a Sway, so I guess we women are used to bending the rules occasionally. :rolleyes:

Re: Footwork LeRoc or otherwise

Posted: Mon Dec 13, 2004 7:04 pm
by jiveoholic
Lou wrote:I liked your 6 rules, Jiveoholic. They're spot on for our taught footwork - although I'd argue with one of your examples for rule 3. I've never seen an Octopus taught at a LeRoc class. It would be a two handed travelling Return followed by a Loophole!
Ah - I remember now - LeRoc-eeze for Octopus is "Loophole" and its done with the man turning first so would come after a return. I shall remove it from my list. Has anyone a definitive list?

It also interesting about Jazzjive. Does anyone have a definition of its difference from LeRoc or Ceroc....but then again who has a definition for the latter? Perhaps there are a set number of "flavours" and each venue has a mix...personally I fit into the slightly robotic, hate most swing music, Manhatten footwork, can do a break usually, no fixed footwork sort of guy!

Re: Footwork LeRoc or otherwise

Posted: Mon Dec 13, 2004 7:41 pm
by RobC
Lou wrote:when RobC & Debi were teaching at Boppin', their routine contained a move combination that didn't seem quite comfortable for LeRoc footwork (I think it was the Whips, but I can't remember precisely), so incompatability does happen.
That's because we weren't exactly teaching from the Ceroc Manual :wink:

My dance style is naturally a lot more slotted with footwork (probably from my background in Ballroom) and has more in common with WCS than "by-the-book Ceroc". What we were trying to do with our routine at Bristol, was introduce the concept of dancing in a slot, with the lady moving forwards and backwards in a straight line, and with the man "moving out of the way". I suspect that it was more this movement that seemed unusual - afterall, men are attrociously bad at moving their feet, let alone moving around their partner :whistle:

Re: Footwork LeRoc or otherwise

Posted: Mon Dec 13, 2004 10:31 pm
by jockey
Briefly, footwook is seldom a problem unless my partner is doing 'something else' i.e., non standard footwork. I was taught by Graham Leclerc (Le Roc) and did many many classes. Sometimes a partner in freestyle feels all wrong and it is usually down to unorthodox feet; extra steps or a 'skip' step is a common mistake or nt taking a long enough step and having to smuggle in something extra to get there as a result (or not get there). Whatever is happening it is highly disruptive: bit like a self taught golf swing - looks awful and gets you nowhere except in the wrong place (the bunker). To compound the problem the girls seem jolly pleased with themselves and if and when I say something about it they just reply that they are here to enjoy themselves (implying ' why aren't you, you creep..!!'). Ho hum. :sad:

Re: Footwork LeRoc or otherwise

Posted: Tue Dec 14, 2004 7:09 am
by Lou
RobC wrote:That's because we weren't exactly teaching from the Ceroc Manual :wink:
Hehe! As The Manual is such a closely guarded secret, I couldn't possibly know if what you're saying is true, so I'll just have to trust you on that! (Or you could show me, but then they'd no doubt have to kill me, I expect) :wink:
RobC wrote:What we were trying to do with our routine at Bristol, was introduce the concept of dancing in a slot, with the lady moving forwards and backwards in a straight line, and with the man "moving out of the way". I suspect that it was more this movement that seemed unusual - afterall, men are attrociously bad at moving their feet, let alone moving around their partner :whistle:
Well - that's, of course, if you had a partner who was listening & would get out of the way! :whistle: Of course, most men would do that, wouldn't they?!

I really enjoyed the class, Rob, which is why it's stayed with me & came to mind as an example of where my learnt footwork didn't help! I think there were a couple of clockwise turns in a row, or something, in the routine, which meant that at one point I felt slightly wrong footed in a purist LeRoc way.

Re: Footwork LeRoc or otherwise

Posted: Tue Dec 14, 2004 9:37 am
by Gus
jockey wrote:Briefly, footwook is seldom a problem unless my partner is doing 'something else' i.e., non standard footwork.
{ODA Mode ON}
Must admit I'm peversley amused by this conversation. Only having done half a dozen Le Roc classes in the past (and no recollection of being given strict footwork) I'm now curious to see it in action. The questions that comes to mind ... is this footwork neccesary and does it make you dance better? As the majority of Modern Jivers dont follow this strict footwork and seem to get on quite well without it ... the reason for the footwork would be?
{ODA Mode OFF}

Re: Footwork LeRoc or otherwise

Posted: Tue Dec 14, 2004 10:32 am
by Lou
Gus wrote:the reason for the footwork would be.....
....to show off our lovely shiny shoes, of course! :nice: :rolleyes:

Re: Footwork LeRoc or otherwise

Posted: Tue Dec 14, 2004 10:35 am
by Franck
Gus wrote:{ODA Mode ON}
Must admit I'm peversley amused by this conversation. Only having done half a dozen Le Roc classes in the past (and no recollection of being given strict footwork) I'm now curious to see it in action. The questions that comes to mind ... is this footwork neccesary and does it make you dance better? As the majority of Modern Jivers dont follow this strict footwork and seem to get on quite well without it ... the reason for the footwork would be?
{ODA Mode OFF}
Can't say I disagree :wink:
My personal view is that leRoc introduced the arbitrary footwork as a means of evening out the playing field between Beginner men and women, ensuring that women wouldn't be able to follow and dance so naturally by forcing them to concentrate on what foot they were stepping back on.

Any man that pays attention to his partner's momentum / position will lead her in a way that feels comfortable for her, regardless of her footwork anyway, and a man who doesn't will make the woman feel awkward whether of not she follows a 'strict' footwork.
Conversely, a woman who spends more time thinking about her footwork will become more difficult and unpredictible to lead... I spend a lot of time at workshops and regular classes trying to get the women to feel the direction from the lead rather than look at their (or the man's) feet as the improvement is usually significant.

Re: Footwork LeRoc or otherwise

Posted: Tue Dec 14, 2004 10:43 am
by Franck
Lou wrote:....to show off our lovely shiny shoes, of course! :nice: :rolleyes:
Can't argue with that :D

and before my previous post is mis-interpreted, footwork is a very useful thing to do / teach.
My issue is with arbitrary footwork taught for basic steps (like the turn / returns) trying to force anyone to step on a specific foot is a major turn-off for most Beginners.
In the example above, the basket can be and is just as comfortable (or indeed uncomfortable) when started from a right foot step back or a left foot step back. Both can be right / wrong depending on the individual and how they balance.
I can understand not doing a return before a Basket to avoid 2 consecutive anti-clockwise turns, which can make some beginners feel dizzy!

Re: Footwork LeRoc or otherwise

Posted: Tue Dec 14, 2004 10:48 am
by Lou
Franck wrote:Can't say I disagree :wink:
Well - there's a surprise! :rofl:
Franck wrote:My personal view is that leRoc introduced the arbitrary footwork as a means of evening out the playing field between Beginner men and women, ensuring that women wouldn't be able to follow and dance so naturally by forcing them to concentrate on what foot they were stepping back on.
Damn. You've figured us out, Franck! Any resemblance to logic & ease in the footwork is, in truth, purely coincidental.

Forget CTA training - LeRoc teachers need to pass an exam in S&M before they're allowed to teach, in order that a certain level of wickedness & deviance is maintained. I'll lend you my whip sometime, dearheart! :whistle:

Re: Footwork LeRoc or otherwise

Posted: Tue Dec 14, 2004 11:00 am
by Gus
Lou wrote:Forget CTA training - LeRoc teachers need to pass an exam in S&M before they're allowed to teach, in order that a certain level of wickedness & deviance is maintained. I'll lend you my whip sometime, dearheart! :whistle:
Well at least that has solved on issue thats been bugging me. Given the well known predeliction of Bristol folk for consorting with sheep and close family relatives I couldnt work out how they had been tempted away from such practices to learn to dance. The S&M angle explains it all :sick:

Re: Footwork LeRoc or otherwise

Posted: Tue Dec 14, 2004 11:32 am
by spindr
jiveoholic wrote:Ah - I remember now - LeRoc-eeze for Octopus is "Loophole" and its done with the man turning first so would come after a return. I shall remove it from my list. Has anyone a definitive list?
Wouldn't claim it to be definitive, but you could have a look at http://www.afterfive.co.uk/guide/latest ... start.html -- it's got all the moves in the site broken into categories.

I guess you'd be looking for moves with an intial anticlockwise movement for the follower.

SpinDr.

Re: Footwork LeRoc or otherwise

Posted: Tue Dec 14, 2004 12:10 pm
by MartinHarper
Franck wrote:arbitrary footwork
Not entirely arbitrary, IMO.

1. spin left with weight on left foot.
2. use right foot to stop spin, thus transferring weight onto the right foot.
3. The left foot is now free, so step back with the left foot.

If the lady steps back on her right foot, she makes an additional weight change, and reverses her direction of spin. Makes a difference to faster music.

Re: Footwork LeRoc or otherwise

Posted: Tue Dec 14, 2004 12:38 pm
by Franck
MartinHarper wrote:Not entirely arbitrary, IMO.

1. spin left with weight on left foot.
2. use right foot to stop spin, thus transferring weight onto the right foot.
3. The left foot is now free, so step back with the left foot.

If the lady steps back on her right foot, she makes an additional weight change, and reverses her direction of spin. Makes a difference to faster music.
Of course, not entirely arbitrary, at some point a teacher must have decided that one way worked better for him / her and respective partners and made it the norm at their classes.
I also understand that one foot will feel more natural than the other in some cases, but in the example above you assume that the Beginner concerned is able to transfer weight at all, something that many Beginners struggle with, and often just step straight back on the right foot after an ACW turn, without transferring. While you or other dancers might feel that is more awkward, it works for them, and my view (as expressed in this thread: Rules for stepping back ) and repeated here is that telling women that one foot is right and the other is wrong will cause more stress than help. It also perpetuates the myth / belief that they have two left feet :sad:
As Adam, Amir and a few others mentioned, a good lead will not require his partner to step back on a specific foot to continue dancing and a beginner leader will not notice the difference anyway...
As for followers, I would rather spend the time teaching them to turn properly on one foot and on the spot rather than introduce a weight transfer that (usually) becomes an excuse to travel.

Re: Footwork LeRoc or otherwise

Posted: Tue Dec 14, 2004 1:21 pm
by Chicklet
Franck wrote: repeated here is that telling women that one foot is right and the other is wrong will cause more stress than help.
women however should continue to tell men one foot is right and one is left :grin:

Re: Footwork LeRoc or otherwise

Posted: Tue Dec 14, 2004 1:58 pm
by MartinHarper
Franck wrote:... you assume that the Beginner concerned ...
You assume I was talking about beginners (with or without a capital 'B'), and the best way of teaching them. I was just saying out that "LeRoc footwork" isn't arbitrary. I'm glad we agree. :)

Re: Footwork LeRoc or otherwise

Posted: Tue Dec 14, 2004 2:10 pm
by Franck
MartinHarper wrote:You assume I was talking about beginners (with or without a capital 'B'), and the best way of teaching them. I was just saying out that "LeRoc footwork" isn't arbitrary. I'm glad we agree. :)
Indeed I was :D
If we are not talking about Beginners ( :wink: ) then there is no problem, I'm all for encouraging people who already have a bit of dance experience / and crucially are already addicted to think more about the way they move their feet, the way they lead / follow etc...