Page 1 of 12

A little moan

Posted: Fri Jul 30, 2004 11:45 am
by Emma
...as opposed to a little whine, which is what the grape gave when the elephant sat on it..
[moan begins]
I did an intermediate class the other night. Four nice moves - the first with a bit of mambo-ish footwork, nothing *really* difficult, but hard enough you had to think a bit at first..the rest were pretty straightforward and at least one of them has been taught at the venue before, from what I remember

Anyway...after the routine had been demo'd, a proportion of dancers took themselves with their partners to the back of the hall, to do the class out of the routine. All of them were able dancers. This meant that there was a..how shall I put this..higher proportion of dancers who take a little longer than most to pick up a routine left in the class. Having said that, by the end most of them had pretty much got it :clap:

It *really* irritates me (yes! really! :angry: ) when people go off regularly to the back of the room - it's so selfish...I believe it sends a message to the people left in the class that they are not 'good enough' to dance with, and perpetuates the 'good dancer' hierarchy. It also breeds upon itself, because people staying in the routine or new to the intermediate will see (imo) the people at the back of the class doing the routine separately and think 'Oh, one day I can be good enough to go to the back with those good dancers' (some of whom are taxi dancers - what sort of message is that sending? ).
[/moan ends]

Anyway, I'd like to say for the sake of balance that I realise sometimes there are good reasons to go out of the class, but I don't mean those occasional times, I mean doing it week in, week out.

I'd really like to see an active policy of discouraging this behaviour. :flower: *thinks calm thoughts*

Re: A little moan

Posted: Fri Jul 30, 2004 12:02 pm
by Divissima
While I see your point of view, Emma, I'm afraid I don't really agree with what you are saying :blush:

I would probably have to count myself as a persistent offender in this category - certainly when attending Amir's classes (which I usually do on a weekly basis), although not usually when I go to ceroc venues (less frequently) where my normal practice is to circulate in the class, if I'm doing the class. My feeling is that I'm paying my money (which I work hard to earn), coming in my (all too scarce) free time, and if I feel I would benefit more from doing the class as a fixed couple, I should make no apology for doing so. :blush: :blush:

How it looks to others is, of course, not something I can control. I understand that, to some dancers in the class, it might look as though the dancers at the back might think they are 'too good to rotate', but that is in their mind, not the minds of the people who take themselves to the back (or, at least, not all of them, I hope :devil: ).

I remember that when I first started dancing, it felt demoralising to see the more established dancers apparently set themselves apart from the rank and file of the class, so I do know what you are saying. It's all a matter of perception - but I do think people are entitled to that choice.

Sorry to disagree :flower:

Re: A little moan

Posted: Fri Jul 30, 2004 12:14 pm
by under par
Divissima wrote:While I see your point of view, Emma, I'm afraid I don't really agree with what you are saying :blush:

I would probably have to count myself as a persistent offender in this category - certainly when attending Amir's classes (which I usually do on a weekly basis), although not usually when I go to ceroc venues (less frequently) where my normal practice is to circulate in the class, if I'm doing the class. My feeling is that I'm paying my money (which I work hard to earn), coming in my (all too scarce) free time, and if I feel I would benefit more from doing the class as a fixed couple, I should make no apology for doing so. :blush: :blush:

How it looks to others is, of course, not something I can control. I understand that, to some dancers in the class, it might look as though the dancers at the back might think they are 'too good to rotate', but that is in their mind, not the minds of the people who take themselves to the back (or, at least, not all of them, I hope :devil: ).

I remember that when I first started dancing, it felt demoralising to see the more established dancers apparently set themselves apart from the rank and file of the class, so I do know what you are saying. It's all a matter of perception - but I do think people are entitled to that choice.

Sorry to disagree :flower:
Emma got to say I agree with Divvi.

I have been asked to taxi several times at a couple of venues and refused each request on the ground that I pay my money I dance where I want and with who I want.

I mostly do the lesson and rotate round the class.

On occasions I do the lesson separatley with Mrs Par

I sometimes do the lesson separately with somebody else other than Mrs Par.

I sometimes go outside the hall to practice moves other than the lesson.

Finally I sometimes sit out the lesson completely and chat.

None of the options above are set up to upset the teacher /class. they are just my options when I pay my money at the door of any venue.

I can see how others may percieve the split but if explained properly no insult/harm should be done.
:hug: :yeah:

Re: A little moan

Posted: Fri Jul 30, 2004 12:19 pm
by Pammy
B. & I do it at the back of the room for the opposite reasons. He doesn't feel all that confident and prefers that it is me he yanks around until he gets it right and feels that he learns more at this stage with someone he knows. Not disagreeing with you, just saying here is a case of a beginner/intermediate doing it at the back. :nice:

Re: A little moan

Posted: Fri Jul 30, 2004 12:25 pm
by tsh
Emma wrote: I'd really like to see an active policy of discouraging this behaviour. :flower: *thinks calm thoughts*
I think you're mis interpreting this behaviour. If some people feel they can only cope with an intermediate lesson by keeping the same partner, then they shouldn't feel pressured to dance with people who can cope with changing partners :D

Maybe after the lesson, you should approach one of the couple, and offer to let them lead you through the routine, just to build their confidence?

Re: A little moan

Posted: Fri Jul 30, 2004 12:35 pm
by Andy McGregor
Well I agree with Emma. Which unfortunately means I find myself disagreeing with Divissima and under par - and I love them both, but in slightly different ways :hug:

I don't think the biggest problem of this is the impression less experienced dancers get, although that is still one of the problems: the biggest problem is that when women are over, as is usually the case, they get to do the lesson much, much less :tears:

This practice of fixed-partners at the back of the room has reached a ridiculous level at Hipsters on Wednesdays. So much so Sue has switched her allegiance to Tuesday Hipsters as a result. What happened the last time we went was that there were about 69 (approx - I've chosen this number because I can do the maths in my head, it was about 70) dancers doing the class with 9 women over so that's 30 men and 39 women. If everyone lined up like a normal class each woman would dance 3 times before waiting to rejoin the lines. BUT, 18 couples chose to be fixed partners at the back of the room. This left 12 men and 21 women (these are the actual numbers because I counted). So now we had 9 women over: you don't have to be a genius to work out that the first 6 women waiting to come on will dance just once and be back in the waiting line the very next time they are moved on :tears: Those women waiting in line had paid the same money as those women in the fixed couples - but they got about half the teaching. Is this fair? :angry:

I think that Divissima is right that she paid her money. But she didn't design the product. And I think the product is a lesson where people move on in lines and dance with different people. If people want special treatment and a different product I think they should pay a special and different price.

And, while we're having a little moan...

Posted: Fri Jul 30, 2004 12:40 pm
by Andy McGregor
Isn't this great, a Friday moan-in :wink:

The other thing that niggles me (no stronger than that) is what some men do at the start of a lesson. The just walk on and join a line on their own and hold their hand up in an imperious manner - as if to say "have a woman washed, oiled and brought to my room". Come on girls, wait for them to ask you like the gentlemen they should be :devil:

Re: A little moan

Posted: Fri Jul 30, 2004 12:43 pm
by under par
Andy McGregor wrote:I think that Divissima is right that she paid her money. But she didn't design the product. And I think the product is a lesson where people move on in lines and dance with different people. If people want special treatment and a different product I think they should pay a special and different price.
I think you are being ever so slightly provacative Andy. where does it say anywhere at any venue what "the product" is?

i've certainly not seen it anywhere nor have I seen any contract stating when I pay my money I must join in and rotate in the class(although I mostly do and enjoy it).

Freedom of choice is what I want for my money. :yeah:

Re: A little moan

Posted: Fri Jul 30, 2004 12:54 pm
by Jayne
I agree with Divi :flower:

I go to one class a week - Amir's class on a Wednesday. Now Amir's class is taught in three sections. First, there's the dance fundamentals where he teaches technique. This is taught in rotation. Second, there is a body styling section, for which you need no partner. Finally there is an advanced class of advanced moves.

As this is the only class I attend, I want to get as much out of it as possible.

I will rotate for the technique class as there's not much that can go wrong. In fact, I find that dancing with a range of people is a good way of understanding why some things don't work with some people. (The exception to rotating is if Amir is teaching drops - I have a dodgy back and so will either drop out completely or have a fixed partner.)

However, for the advanced class I retreat to the back of the room with my competition partner. That way we both get to learn the routine and associated style points and neither of us gets injured by people who are attempting a class that's beyond them. Occasionally we pick up things that we use for competition too.

I do not go to the back of the room because I think I'm a far better dancer than everyone else in the class.

I can see why some people might perceive this behaviour as selfish. However, I hope that replies on this thread with dispel such myths.

I'd also add that if there are very few couples in the class (a rare thing these days in Amir's classes :clap: ) then I don't dance at the back of the room, but will join the rest of the class. However, once the class has increased in size and can sustain itself I will go to the back of the room, where I find I can learn more effectively.

I hope that modern jive is sufficiently broad minded to appreciate that this is the most effective way for some people to learn (which, afterall, is what we're paying for). I would therefore NOT like to see policies discouraging this behaviour - sorry Emma. :flower:

J :nice:

Re: A little moan

Posted: Fri Jul 30, 2004 12:55 pm
by Sparkles
IMO, as long as everyone that is in the room and dancing is doing (following) the class how they decide to do it is up to them.

What I find irritating is people who use the back of the room for thier own practice while a class is going on. It's distracting to the people trying to learn and disrespectful to the teacher and demo :angry:

Oh it does feel good to have a moan on a Friday!

Re: A little moan

Posted: Fri Jul 30, 2004 12:58 pm
by spindr
Well taking it to its logical extreme -- if the class goes to 100% fixed partners, then the "Do I have to bring a partner?" answer would have to be fixed on any advertising literature :)

SpinDr.

Re: A little moan

Posted: Fri Jul 30, 2004 1:00 pm
by under par
Sparkles wrote:IMO, as long as everyone that is in the room and dancing is doing (following) the class how they decide to do it is up to them.

What I find irritating is people who use the back of the room for thier own practice while a class is going on. It's distracting to the people trying to learn and disrespectful to the teacher and demo :angry:

Oh it does feel good to have a moan on a Friday!

Another hug required Sparkles... :hug: :kiss: :hug:

Re: A little moan

Posted: Fri Jul 30, 2004 1:03 pm
by philsmove
This is a bit of a problem area and I can see both points view

I went with a partner to a specials class, and we decided to “rotate “ but a lot of the advanced dancers moved to the back and stayed together

This denied us the chance to practice with the better dancers, which is why we went to the class in the first place

Next time, we will probably also stay together, but I am not too happy about this, it seems to go against the spirit of things

Most classes have a set of rules or etiquette (admittedly unwritten) I don’t think just because you are paying to go to the class you have a right break that etiquette


I think teachers should try making it clear weather it is: couples only; all move round; or do as you please. We can then choose which classes we attend, and how we spend our hard earned cash

Re: A little moan

Posted: Fri Jul 30, 2004 1:06 pm
by Divissima
Andy McGregor wrote:Well I agree with Emma. Which unfortunately means I find myself disagreeing with Divissima and under par - and I love them both, but in slightly different ways :hug:
Hey, disagreement is a healthy part of any friendship :kiss:
McGregster wrote:This practice of fixed-partners at the back of the room has reached a ridiculous level at Hipsters on Wednesdays. So much so Sue has switched her allegiance to Tuesday Hipsters as a result. What happened the last time we went was that there were about 69 (approx - I've chosen this number because I can do the maths in my head, it was about 70) dancers doing the class with 9 women over so that's 30 men and 39 women. If everyone lined up like a normal class each woman would dance 3 times before waiting to rejoin the lines. BUT, 18 couples chose to be fixed partners at the back of the room. This left 12 men and 21 women (these are the actual numbers because I counted). So now we had 9 women over: you don't have to be a genius to work out that the first 6 women waiting to come on will dance just once and be back in the waiting line the very next time they are moved on :tears: Those women waiting in line had paid the same money as those women in the fixed couples - but they got about half the teaching. Is this fair? :angry:
Again, Andy, I have to say that I entirely appreciate the point you are making. And I must admit that, by more people doing the class in a fixed couple, this exacerbates the problem of an excess of men or women (as the case may be) who, as a result, may be rotated onto the bench more frequently than would otherwise be the case.

Hipsters on a Wednesday is perhaps a special case. The second class, after the style workout, is an advanced class, often comprising unusual and demanding moves. My personal motivation for doing the advanced class in a fixed couple with TwK is that it means we can 'bank' a move if we like it,so that we can put it into our repetoire. And if we can get it without having to repeat it too many times, this helps us protect our respective niggling injuries. I am sure that there are many and various reasons why other couples choose not to rotate - all of them as justifiable or unjustifiable as mine.

I'm not sure that it is right to say that the people who rotate get (to take the example you gave of your last visit to Hipsters) half the teaching - although you are right that they get half the practice. I'm not sure that it would be fair to enforce rotation in the class either, although there may be ways to encourage it.
McGregster wrote:I think that Divissima is right that she paid her money. But she didn't design the product. And I think the product is a lesson where people move on in lines and dance with different people. If people want special treatment and a different product I think they should pay a special and different price.
Again, I'm going to disagree. I would suggest that the product is - simply - a collective lesson where people are taught to dance. People can sit out all or part of the class, join part way through, can come one week, then have a few weeks out, come back and pick up where they left off. I'm not sure it is a case of people wanting special treatment or a different product - just to learn in the way which suits them best.

Re: A little moan

Posted: Fri Jul 30, 2004 1:09 pm
by TheTramp
Part (Most?) of me wants to agree with Jayne, UP and Divi. I've always maintained that you pay your money, you take your choice.

However, taking Andy's example to the extreme (who, me?). You could have every man in the class taken off to be a fixed couple, and that'd leave 9 women there with no-one to dance with. I guess no-one would want to be one of those 9 spare ladies. Maybe it's worth just considering how you'd feel in that situation?

Of course, it does look elitist, as Emma says. Probably a bit like 'Hotshots' were considered elitist. Though, of course, we know that none of Jayne, Divi or UP are hotshots, and they all dance with a wide variety of dancers all night.

Apart from a class involving drops, where I'd agree that maybe ladies should have a chance to say who they want to do drops with (though, of course, they could still go round the line, and say to anyone they don't want to do the drop with "I'm sorry, I don't know you well enough to do this with you"), maybe people should be expected to take part in the class, rather than being separate. I don't know.

I'm not sure that I have a problem with people who are practising things other than the class - unless they are doing things that draw attention away from the teacher.

Anyhow, since I very rarely do classes anyhow, who am I to say anything :D

Trampy

Re: A little moan

Posted: Fri Jul 30, 2004 1:11 pm
by Lounge Lizard
Sparkles wrote:IMO, as long as everyone that is in the room and dancing is doing (following) the class how they decide to do it is up to them.

What I find irritating is people who use the back of the room for thier own practice while a class is going on. It's distracting to the people trying to learn and disrespectful to the teacher and demo :angry:

Oh it does feel good to have a moan on a Friday!
I was guilty of this on Tuesday at Hipsters, cos we had to work out a routine for the intermediate class while Roger was teaching, (I was DJ'ing directly after his class), unfortunatly there was no other area (that I was aware off) to practice, but I did feel awkward as it could have distracted from the class being taught. So sorry to rog and anyone in the class
peter

Re: A little moan

Posted: Fri Jul 30, 2004 1:17 pm
by Zebra Woman
I am one of the women who Andy descibed as on and off again, because of the fixed couples at the back.

But I would defend Divi, Jayne and Mrs Par's right to keep their excellent partners to themselves at the back. It's a free country isn't it?

I have a bad shoulder and back and fingers (all caused by dancing in intermediate classes BTW) :( .....so I often sit out the class. Occasionally I'm offered the chance to keep the same partner, and I leap at the chance.
For me, and whoever my partner is it's the easiest way to really learn the move and add it to the man's repertoire. I find I'm more likely to remember the move too if he forgets it, because I haven't had to walk and count . :confused: very hard walking and counting....

Alison :flower: :flower:

Re: A little moan

Posted: Fri Jul 30, 2004 1:19 pm
by Gus
under par wrote:i've certainly not seen it anywhere nor have I seen any contract stating when I pay my money I must join in and rotate in the class(although I mostly do and enjoy it).
Afraid I have to back Andy. Ignoring Hipsters, the 'Ceroc' model of running a night is fundamentaly based on rotation and interaction. Its a social thing as much as anything else. at one club we strated having a significant numbers trying to 'partner' up ... we spent time with them to persuade them otherwise. some stayed some left. I've never had a real problem with people partnering up in our classes, not even in the advanced. People appreciate that its a group thing and so join in together.

Personally, if someone wants to 'perfect' the routine later with a partner...fine. BUT I would have a real issue with somone trying to do that during one of my lessons. Maybe its just a North/South thing ..... we're a friendlier bunch up North :devil:

Re: A little moan

Posted: Fri Jul 30, 2004 1:23 pm
by TheTramp
Divissima wrote:Hipsters on a Wednesday is perhaps a special case. The second class, after the style workout, is an advanced class, often comprising unusual and demanding moves. My personal motivation for doing the advanced class in a fixed couple with TwK is that it means we can 'bank' a move if we like it,so that we can put it into our repetoire. And if we can get it without having to repeat it too many times, this helps us protect our respective niggling injuries. I am sure that there are many and various reasons why other couples choose not to rotate - all of them as justifiable or unjustifiable as mine.
Sorry. While I agree with the rest of your post Divi. I don't quite understand why you can only 'bank' a move that you've done when you do it as a fixed couple.

If you like a move that much when you're moving round in a class, what's to stop you getting together with Toby after the class, running though it a couple of times, and then 'banking' it.

Seems like a bit of a fallacious arguement to me :flower:

Trampy

Re: A little moan

Posted: Fri Jul 30, 2004 1:23 pm
by Trish
spindr wrote:Well taking it to its logical extreme -- if the class goes to 100% fixed partners, then the "Do I have to bring a partner?" answer would have to be fixed on any advertising literature :)

SpinDr.
Yes that's what bothers me about it too. I don't personally agree with people dancing with fixed partners, except in exceptional circumstances (like where someones got a bad back and the teacher is teaching drops - although they do often teach alternatives anyway). As a woman who comes to Ceroc on her own (my husband doesn't dance) I get a bit fed up with it really. Especially when it's mainly the best men (who happen to be dancing with their regular partners) who are "at the back", leaving the lesson filled with the not so good men. It does make you feel that they think they're better than the rest of us. If it's beginners who are keeping to exclusive partners, I can understand this from a confidence perspective. Although two beginners together would in my opinion actually benefit more from rotating, as they're likely to be helped by the more experienced dancers that are rotating, and more likely to confuse each other if they are separate.

At my regular venue, you seem to get a lot of "exclusivity" anyway - which is a shame, as it cuts down the number/vairety of people to dance with.

There - got that off my chest - no offence meant!