Page 5 of 8
Posted: Mon Apr 12, 2004 6:12 pm
by ChrisA
Originally posted by Sheepman
I feel it is finally starting to "happen" for me, the trouble is, I can't now switch it off, and I'm sure in the process I have ruined many a dance with partners who have no idea what I'm on!
..........
It takes such a lot of work. For example...
Beginners class. Wade in the water. Teeth gritted.
I can now go right through every break as if they weren't there. But gawd it's taken some work
I just wish I could do something better with the breaks when it's not the beginners class
Chris
Posted: Mon Apr 12, 2004 7:57 pm
by Stuart M
Originally posted by TheTramp
That's okie. Stuart will be able to identify with this. He's trying too
Trampy
Yeah, I can be very trying sometimes, eh?
Don't make me take back what I said on Saturday...I mean, come on, how often has anyone said that to you Steve?
foofs, I have no memory of any strangulation incidents, so you shouldn't either

. All I remember is loads of lovely ladies with rabbit's ears and Sheena's, erm, outfit.
Now, back to my chargrilled monkfish in citrus marinade

Posted: Mon Apr 12, 2004 9:35 pm
by Tiggerbabe
Originally posted by Stuart M
All I remember is loads of lovely ladies with rabbit's ears and Sheena's, erm, outfit.
You didn't like it?

and it was strokeable too

Posted: Tue Apr 13, 2004 11:54 am
by DavidB
Originally posted by Sheepman
After doing various workshops on musicality, and dancing with particular partners who feel the music in the same way, I feel it is finally starting to "happen" for me, the trouble is, I can't now switch it off, and I'm sure in the process I have ruined many a dance with partners who have no idea what I'm on!
The best workshop I ever did (Musical Interpretation by Mario Robau) started with the words "This workshop will ruin your dancing". And he was right. 3 years later I can do about 20% of what he was talking about, and still lead at the same time.
Posted: Tue Apr 13, 2004 12:01 pm
by ChrisA
Originally posted by DavidB
The best workshop I ever did (Musical Interpretation by Mario Robau) started with the words "This workshop will ruin your dancing". And he was right. 3 years later I can do about 20% of what he was talking about, and still lead at the same time.
Care to summarise it? Is any of it the sort of thing one can work on, idea by idea, or did you have to be there to get any of it?
Chris
Posted: Tue Apr 13, 2004 12:03 pm
by DavidY
Originally posted by ChrisA
I can now go right through every break as if they weren't there.
Me too, but not for the right reasons... I can hear stuff going on in the music, but don't know how to turn it into dancing.
I just wish I could do something better with the breaks when it's not the beginners class

Posted: Tue Apr 13, 2004 12:25 pm
by ChrisA
Originally posted by DavidY
Me too, but not for the right reasons... I can hear stuff going on in the music, but don't know how to turn it into dancing.
Been there.
Spent a lot of time there.
So long, in fact, that it drove me so crazy that I came within a hairsbreadth of giving up MJ completely.
However...
A musicality workshop from Amir was what put me on the road to cracking it, and the part of it that somehow opened up the relevant mental pathways for me was putting on a track with entirely regular predictable breaks, and getting the class to just stop in the break, on every break, regardless of where in the move we all were.
Don't know quite what happened after that, but I suddenly found myself hearing the breaks coming, long enough ahead of time to be able to do something about it.
Occasionally I would be in the right place in a move on the break, and it wouldn't be an accident. I didn't know what I was doing, but it felt deliberate, and gradually the proportion of breaks where I was able to be somewhere useful at the right time increased.
I would suggest listening to, and dancing to, tracks with a regular structure that includes a break... examples that come to mind are "Wade in the water", "King of the Road", but there are lots of others like it... (help, please, DJs ??)
Listen not only for the break, but the start of the phrase that follows it.
Aim initially to stop on the break, and to start simply with a step back at the beginning of the next phrase.
There are some, doubtless advanced musical dancers, who speak disparagingly of just stopping on the breaks as playing "musical statues" - but IMHO you should disregard such comments, since we all have to start somewhere.
Chris
Posted: Tue Apr 13, 2004 12:53 pm
by Geordieed
Leading a partner isn't just about listening to the music to do the breaks etc... I have only read a little of this thread but haven't seen anyone pick up on characterisation.
I know that musical interpretation and characterisation are only the tip of learning new ways to enjoy dancing but find it quite a challenge to suggest in my dancing what theme we are following to the style of music that it being played.
Posted: Tue Apr 13, 2004 1:02 pm
by ChrisA
Originally posted by Geordieed
Leading a partner isn't just about listening to the music to do the breaks etc...
Indeed. I don't think anyone is suggesting it is...
I have only read a little of this thread but haven't seen anyone pick up on characterisation.
I know that musical interpretation and characterisation are only the tip of learning new ways to enjoy dancing but find it quite a challenge to suggest in my dancing what theme we are following to the style of music that it being played.
Could you elaborate, Ed?
For beginner interpreters like me, it's so frustrating to hear only the "what", and much less often the "how".
Chris
Posted: Tue Apr 13, 2004 1:19 pm
by Gadget
Originally posted by ChrisA
Could you elaborate, Ed?

What exactly do you mean by
characterisation?
Posted: Tue Apr 13, 2004 1:33 pm
by Sheepman
Originally posted by DavidB
"This workshop will ruin your dancing".
Nice to hear an honest approach, nearly every workshop I take does this to my dancing, but hopefully only in the short term.
It's probably not something most people want to hear at the start of something they have forked out for though.
Greg
Posted: Tue Apr 13, 2004 1:50 pm
by Geordieed
Sorry guys. Chris you know all this anyway. I have been told from dancers doing MJ that they recognise 5 basic rules for the want of a better description.
Characterisation as I've been led to understand basically means changing your style to fit the music. This would include body shape and movement and range of moves that you choose from to make the dance interesting. MJ is regarded as a frame from which you add form onto. So you wouldn't dance the same to Justin Timberlake if you had just finished with All that Jazz. Sorry to make the difference a little black and white.
You guys already know this if not under another label. It is pretty much a different topic from musical interpretation. I am still trying to pick up on the techniques of changing body levels and weight distribution that changes the style of the dance. Having a look at a Hipsters night is a good experience because there are a variety of styles in one room.
Posted: Tue Apr 13, 2004 2:32 pm
by ChrisA
Originally posted by Geordieed
Characterisation as I've been led to understand basically means changing your style to fit the music.
Ah. Didn't know it was called this.
Did know it's a Good Thing to do.
Not very good at doing it though

Posted: Tue Apr 13, 2004 2:47 pm
by Divissima
Originally posted by ChrisA:
Not very good at doing it though
What tosh and fiddlesticks!
Posted: Tue Apr 13, 2004 2:48 pm
by TheTramp
Originally posted by Divissima
What tosh and fiddlesticks!
Oh. Lay off. He's just a beginner...
Trampy
Posted: Tue Apr 13, 2004 2:49 pm
by Geordieed
Better than me though.
It is hard to take on different forms of dancing. Actually going to classes for different forms of swing or tango etc kicks up how much you should be learning. Just because I have been to a few months of Savoy style doesn't qualify me to be a Lindy dancer.
Normally other dances require alot more application to learn.
You just get to know the basics but it is the style that we are trying to learn so the basics are not enough. Plus if the lady following has not learnt the same things that you have learnt it does get a bit difficult. (Rabbit in your headlights look)
Doesn't get any easier once you start learning about other dance techniques. It does help to keep things styling to a small degree. Whenever I see the really great dancers dancing socially they keep to simple dancing and you will get some people look and say they don't know what all the fuss is about, they are not doing anything. Then others will stand transfixed because they understand what they are seeing infront of them. (Getting off track)
I can count on one hand the dancers who will still be a little flashy even when dancing with the best female dancers.
Posted: Tue Apr 13, 2004 2:50 pm
by ChrisA
Originally posted by Divissima
What tosh and fiddlesticks!
Fair point. I do dance faster to faster music...
Chris
Posted: Tue Apr 13, 2004 3:16 pm
by Geordieed
By the way Chris when you coming out to play on a Friday night at Bisley.
What name did you have for characterisation. There are always additional debates about what to call what technique. People argue that 'musicality' is not a term to be used.
I forgot to say you can see good examples of characterisation when dancers dance a style that really doesn't fit the music. You see ballroom or ballet lines being shaped while dancing to an R&B track. I end up seeing myself as a total beginner when I see great dancers who can adapt easily.
Posted: Tue Apr 13, 2004 3:22 pm
by Jayne
.
Posted: Tue Apr 13, 2004 3:29 pm
by TheTramp
Originally posted by Jayne
.
:
(I'll see your . and raise you a .)
Trampy