Page 4 of 8

Re: Re: Re: sweet anticipation...

Posted: Mon Apr 05, 2004 11:25 pm
by Gary
Originally posted by ChrisA

What's my point?

Well, I can't help feeling, that for the girls at least, the teaching of moves in a routine is actually counterproductive - it encourages them to try and remember, and to stress when they can't - which always makes the anticipation worse.


:yeah:

I guess the ideal teaching environment would be the learning guys in one room, with experienced girls as partners while they learn the moves; and the learning girls in a whole different room, being led in freestyle by experienced guys, and with tips being supplied by experienced girls. Unfortunately that probably isn't very efficient.

I've even noticed with at least one girl that she was quite a decent follow on her very first night, but that she got progressively worse as she did more classes (she's gotten much better again).

Re: Re: Re: Re: sweet anticipation...

Posted: Tue Apr 06, 2004 11:58 am
by Lynn
Originally posted by Gary
I've even noticed with at least one girl that she was quite a decent follow on her very first night, but that she got progressively worse as she did more classes
Sounds like me... :tears:
(she's gotten much better again).
...there is hope! :clap:

Re: Re: Re: Re: sweet anticipation...

Posted: Tue Apr 06, 2004 12:29 pm
by Dreadful Scathe
Originally posted by Gary

I've even noticed with at least one girl that she was quite a decent follow on her very first night, but that she got progressively worse as she did more classes (she's gotten much better again).


if she had had great leads all the time she probably wouldnt have got any worse but with every leader being different she would quickly become overwhelmed with the differences, analyze them and get gradually worse until she came to terms with it all.

Posted: Sat Apr 10, 2004 6:02 pm
by Foofs
Hi All,

I think I'm one of those awful girls who try to lead. Problem is that I have done some (solo) dancing before where the emphasis is on me knowing the routine and having control over my own body and where I'm going.

I am trying hard to relax and I think I'm getting better but an apology to all those who have had the 'pleasure', or those who are yet to come!

Also - what do I do when guys are severely off the beat - it drives me up the wall!! Do I just keep going; try to 'lead' him back on to the beat; or do I stop and tell him....(nicely of course!)

Fiona. :nice:

Posted: Sun Apr 11, 2004 10:28 am
by Foofs
Ok - re-reading my last post it sounds a bit harsh and I really don't mean it to.

I know everyone has to learn (please don't shout at me because I've only been doing this a couple of months too!! :( ) but it is not the 'beginners' that I have a problem with. With guys who have recently started they say so and when they go off the beat we kinda slow down, have a laugh about it and carry on.

However, there are a few more experienced dancers who tend to dance off the beat and this coupled with them trying to do complicated moves gets me very confused.

Many I'll just stop digging now and leave it at that, other than to say I had a really good time at the party night last night - thank you for dancing with me. Stuart - I am trying, and the near strangulation moment was all my fault - my apologies! :flower:

Fiona. :cheers:

Posted: Sun Apr 11, 2004 1:40 pm
by ChrisA
Originally posted by Foofs
However, there are a few more experienced dancers who tend to dance off the beat and this coupled with them trying to do complicated moves gets me very confused.
Avoid them.

Any so-called "experienced dancer" who can't (a) dance in time with the music and (b) sense when a beginner doesn't want to be wound up in knots with complicated moves, we call a show-off, not a dancer.

They are dancing for themselves, maybe to impress (duuuuhhhhh :rolleyes: ), but not for their partner.

Chris

Posted: Sun Apr 11, 2004 1:47 pm
by TheTramp
Originally posted by Foofs
Stuart - I am trying,
That's okie. Stuart will be able to identify with this. He's trying too :yum:

Trampy

Posted: Mon Apr 12, 2004 8:37 am
by Foofs
Originally posted by ChrisA
Avoid them.


That I will do - thank you!

Fiona. :grin:

Posted: Mon Apr 12, 2004 9:35 am
by Sheepman
Originally posted by ChrisA
Avoid them.

Any so-called "experienced dancer" who can't (a) dance in time with the music
As I've said before, I know several dancers where it took years before they could dance in time to the music, at least one of whom is now a big success at entertaining his partners. So don't take the avoiding too far, especially when you have more experience yourself, so you can help them out - but maybe stick to tracks that have a VERY obvious beat.

Greg

Posted: Mon Apr 12, 2004 10:51 am
by ChrisA
Originally posted by Sheepman
As I've said before, I know several dancers where it took years before they could dance in time to the music, at least one of whom is now a big success at entertaining his partners. So don't take the avoiding too far, especially when you have more experience yourself, so you can help them out - but maybe stick to tracks that have a VERY obvious beat.

Greg
You're changing the sense of what I said by quoting me selectively here, Greg.

I'm referring to the so-called experienced dancers who are both off the beat AND do complicated moves with beginners, the net result of which is to confuse them as Foofs was referring to.

I'm NOT suggesting that she avoids all those that can't dance with the beat - that's not what I said.

I'm all for cutting beginners a little slack when it comes to dancing with the rhythm - coordination takes a bit of time to develop.

But if it took the guy in your example years to be able to dance even relatively simple moves in time, I would still be inclined to question what was going on during that time, and what he was concentrating on learning.

Chris

Posted: Mon Apr 12, 2004 11:08 am
by Lory
I hold my hands up! I'm guilty of antisipating certain moves :blush: but when 9 out of 10 men do the 'side to side' move with me on their left then pull me across and wrap me in, I always get a shock, when they don't!

P.s I can't do the side to side on the right very well :tears: it feels naff!

Posted: Mon Apr 12, 2004 11:17 am
by Sheepman
Originally posted by ChrisA
You're changing the sense of what I said by quoting me selectively here,
I agree with your points, I was just trying to highlight that not everyone who can't find the beat should be given up on as a hopeless case, one day they might be your favourite dancer.

Greg

Posted: Mon Apr 12, 2004 11:20 am
by ChrisA
Originally posted by Sheepman
I agree with your points, I was just trying to highlight that not everyone who can't find the beat should be given up on as a hopeless case, one day they might be your favourite dancer.
I agree with this too.

Best of all, if a guy's not dancing with the beat, tell him so.

If he gets enough such feedback, he might even believe it and act on it, as in the case, I believe, of one of your examples?

Chris

Posted: Mon Apr 12, 2004 12:10 pm
by Pink Lady
"Also - what do I do when guys are severely off the beat - it drives me up the wall!! Do I just keep going; try to 'lead' him back on to the beat; or do I stop and tell him....(nicely of course!)"


Well Foofs, I've reluctantly come to realise that some people HAVE no sense or rythm, and WILL never have any sense or rythm - even though they seem to enjoy dancing and are technicaly good at executing the moves. The really frustrating ones are those who have no rythm and don't execute the moves very well either. I've never had the gumption to refuse a dance with someone I don't particularly like dancing with so in the case of the no-rythm brigade, I try switching my brain off to the music. Not usually with much success I might add!
That's my moan over for today! :blush:

Posted: Mon Apr 12, 2004 12:27 pm
by Gadget
Originally posted by Pink Lady
I've reluctantly come to realise that some people HAVE no sense or rythm, and WILL never have any sense or rythm - even though they seem to enjoy dancing and are technicaly good at executing the moves.

Is "keeping the rhythm" that important?

Thinking about it, there are several times that I deliberatly ignore the beat and smooth moves over two/three/four... beats. During this time, I'm normally following lyrics or something in the music which may be completley 'off'.
I was under the impression that this was part of "musical interpritation" :what: :confused:

There are a few ladies that are perfectly responsive followers, but when I do stuff like this they tend to try and pickup the beat for me (does this make any sense?) Are they trying to be helpfull? Are the ladies who don't just being kind and ignoring my bout of temporal insanity? Is it just a natural thing of listening/dancing to the music they hear instead of what I'm leading? Should I stop it or lead them clearer?

{BTW if anyone thinks I'm talking about them - don't: I really can't remember who or when or anything more specific :blush: }

Posted: Mon Apr 12, 2004 1:01 pm
by Sheepman
Originally posted by Gadget
Should I stop it or lead them clearer?
No, and maybe!
I thought it wouldn't be long before this got included within this topic, but I don't think we've been talking about musical interpretation here. Yes you can slow moves down, speed them up, stretch and squeeze the rythmn to follow the vocals or a particular instrument, hopefully this all feels different to your follower compared to someone who is dancing to a regular beat, just not the one in the music that is playing!

It would be interesting to hear from followers who have only recently, or occasionally, come across leaders trying to interpret in these ways, how does it feel? A challenge, interesting, or a mess?

After doing various workshops on musicality, and dancing with particular partners who feel the music in the same way, I feel it is finally starting to "happen" for me, the trouble is, I can't now switch it off, and I'm sure in the process I have ruined many a dance with partners who have no idea what I'm on!

Greg

Posted: Mon Apr 12, 2004 1:04 pm
by Foofs
Originally posted by Gadget
Is "keeping the rhythm" that important?

Thinking about it, there are several times that I deliberatly ignore the beat and smooth moves over two/three/four... beats. During this time, I'm normally following lyrics or something in the music which may be completley 'off'.
I was under the impression that this was part of "musical interpritation"


I would argue there is a difference between dancing 'on the beat' and dancing in rythmn (or time) with the music. Taking an extra couple of beats to do a move doesn't mean you're off the beat - in fact if every dance had a movement on every beat it would be exhausting - plus variety is spice of life, no?!? :wink:

Indeed, it took me a few weeks to get used to not starting each move on the first beat of the bar, as many other styles of dance do - there is a difference in accent, which is to do with rythmn and not the 'beat'.

This is different from someone who cannot 'find' the beat.

I think my plan of attack is not to ask 'off the beat' and 'experienced' men to dance but also not to refuse them if asked...

Didn't mean to cause and argument.... :blush: But thanks for the advice.

Fiona.x

Posted: Mon Apr 12, 2004 1:22 pm
by Sheepman
Fiona, it sounds like we've been telling you what you already know!
Originally posted by Foofs
Didn't mean to cause and argument....

You think this has been an argument :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:

Greg :flower:

Posted: Mon Apr 12, 2004 3:13 pm
by Gadget
Originally posted by Sheepman
After doing various workshops on musicality, and dancing with particular partners who feel the music in the same way, I feel it is finally starting to "happen" for me, the trouble is, I can't now switch it off, and I'm sure in the process I have ruined many a dance with partners who have no idea what I'm on!

:yeah:

Foofs: the whole point of this forum is to encourage free debate into stuff like this and get people thinking. If this thread is what you meant by cause an argument then feel free to provoke as many arguments as you like. :flower:

Posted: Mon Apr 12, 2004 5:36 pm
by Foofs
Originally posted by Gadget
: If this thread is what you meant by cause an argument then feel free to provoke as many arguments as you like.


I may hold you to that!!! :wink: :grin: