Are Great Dancers born or made?

Confused by the Accordion Comb Pull Crab?

Spinning gets you dizzy?
Would like some help with a tricky intermediate move? Ask here, and share your fave tips...
You need to be registered / logged in to read this forum
User avatar
cerocmetro
Senior Member
Posts: 518
Joined: Tue Sep 24, 2002 11:00 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by cerocmetro »

Originally posted by Sheepman
So your saying it's natural because he started young? Isn't that the same as learning, but learning at a time when the mind and body is most receptive?


Actually no. Perhaps I was a little too sarcastic. What I was saying that if you practice that hard from that age, you can be good at what ever you want to be good at provided you have the basics requirements.

The majority of us started Ceroc too late to take it too seriously in terms of being "Great"dancers. We have commitments, work, families, lives.

Very few are able to commit 7 days a week to it. Work out to tone the muscles, study videos and dancers for hours and hours. Yes it can all be taught/learnt, but how many of you are prepared to go through that.

By the way Ben, Alina, Heather Mc, Mick, Lydia, Linda B, Lily B, Robert C, Lisa (aberdeen), Simon Selmon should be added to that list.

Both myself and Nigel are almost exceptions. We are both accountants, well me not any more. For both of us Ceroc was our first introduction to dancing. (Nigel did confrim this to me today). Both of us gained our rythme through playng instruments from an early age.

Why did we both get hooked on Ceroc, we were both single and very quickly found that men who could dance were far more attractive. (We both needed the help) Nigel then stuck a hat on his head and went onto do other styles of dancing, I got married, twice and was quite happy with Ceroc, although I have dabbled in Salsa, Lindy, Tango, etc etc since then. Also watched many hours of the Simpsons.

Both of us were however so sad that I used to leave work early 5 days a week to be the first at the class, I was also the last to leave. I did not miss a class for a year. Yes that includes the beginners classes.

I am always amazed when I ask advanced dancers to help me with beginners workshops. Guaranteed they will say, "I cannot believe how much I learnt" There's a surprise when I feel I learn something new everytime I teach a beginners workshop.

To me, to do the beginners classes is still part of the process of learning. It is also both sociable and helps new commers enjoy the dancing. It also helps keep the business going.

Both Nigel and myself are not natural dancers, we have both worked hard at it. Watch Nigels face in any competition or performance and the concentration is intense. Mandy said something very interesting to me the other day. She told me she was dancing with some guy, (actually i believe he is an accountant) who I always thought of as good. She said he had a whole conversation during the dance. He did not stop talking. He still hit every break, moved on every accent, used the music. He had no idea of what he was doing, he was not thinking or concentrating. Mandy told me he was one of the most natural dancers she had ever danced with. She said he could be GREAT, but he was happy enjoying the dancing.

There are many dancers out there who could be great. But maybe if they were, they would no longer enjoy it.

James Cronin never wanted to run a competition as he believed it would take the pureness away from Ceroc. I always dissagreed with him. I now believe he was so so right.

But we now have our competitions, heck I even run one. Have I mentioned the JIvemasters video yet??? :grin:

Why are you all so obsessed with becoming great dancers? What did you want when you started dancing? To be great dancers, or to have a great night out? When where did that change? Personally I wish some of the "great dancers" sorry lets tone that down, very advanced dancers, sorry lets say what we mean, people who think they are advanced dancers, would climb off their horses and share their skills with others. Join in the beginners classes, dance with beginners.

To be fair, the "great dancers" do this. It is the ones who think they are great who do not.

Sorry coming back to my point, Tiger Woods is the Greatest" because he is both natural and totally devoted. Also lucky, did we mention luck?

You get out what you put in. You also need the basic requirements, timing, comprehension, movability, arrogance, a decent body, half decent looks, style (not dancing, but appearance), hygene, health. You also need one more thing, the desire to be great.

Adam
User avatar
Gadget
Senior Member
Posts: 7053
Joined: Wed Oct 09, 2002 9:08 pm
Contact:

Report a concern about this post

Post by Gadget »

In my mind, a "Great" male dancer is one that I look to for inspiration and to steal some of their greatness for myself.
A "Great" female dancer is one that glides and flows on the floor; becoming an extension to the lead and the music.

"Great" dancers are admired by all and can lose themselves, their partner and the audience in the music.

This is what I aspire to, and this is why I want to be a "Great" dancer.
I used to be an angel, you know with halo and those wings;
Now that i'm a devil, my mind's on other things...
My feathers turned to ash, and my harp has broke in two;
I took uppon myself, to have a dance with you...
User avatar
Minnie M
Senior Member
Posts: 7924
Joined: Tue Sep 09, 2003 11:00 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by Minnie M »

Originally posted by Minnie M
Can we go inside now please :grin:


Thank you :cheers: :kiss: :hug:


--ooOoo--
Age is a question of mind over matter, if you don't mind, it doesn't matter
Leroy (Satchel) Paige (1906-1982)

Mickey Mouse's girlfriend, Minnie, made her film debut, along with Mickey, in "Steamboat Willie" on November 18, 1928.
That date is recognized as her official birthday.
User avatar
ChrisA
Senior Member
Posts: 3831
Joined: Wed Sep 10, 2003 11:00 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by ChrisA »

Originally posted by cerocmetro
James Cronin never wanted to run a competition as he believed it would take the pureness away from Ceroc. I always dissagreed with him. I now believe he was so so right.
I was turned right off dancing by doing it competitively in my former life. Many years later, as I start to get a bit better at jive, people are starting to say, "hey, why don't you enter some of the comps"... it's a seductive idea, certainly.

I entered my first ever jive comp last night - DWAS at Uxbridge. Got to the final but not placed.

It brought back a lot of memories - some good ones, some bad ones, and quite a lot of angst.

Very mixed feelings about competing, I have to say. I still want to be as good as I can be - just as much as I ever did, in fact maybe even more so. But I'm not sure I want to get back into wanting to win stuff again.

I know no-one's holding a gun to my head. Just musing, really.

Chris
User avatar
Tiggerbabe
Senior Member
Posts: 5844
Joined: Thu Jan 17, 2002 12:00 pm

Report a concern about this post

Post by Tiggerbabe »

Originally posted by Franck
Ceroc Scotland: Gave a voice to CerocMetro!

and gave dancing feet to so many others - Thanks Franck :kiss: :hug:
"If you rebel against high heels, take care to do so in a very smart hat.'' George Bernard Shaw
User avatar
Emma
Senior Member
Posts: 1606
Joined: Tue May 07, 2002 11:00 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by Emma »

Originally posted by Gadget
I agree, but which came first? the chicken or the egg?
Is the self-confidence a bi-product of being great, or is it the self-confidence that leads them to become great?
I think they feed one another, but I believe you have to have a degree of self-confidence (or an ability to push yourself, if that's the same thing) in the first place. And I think that *working* upon what you do is absolutely crucial, because otherwise you stagnate.
It's only dancing - but I like it :)
User avatar
ChrisA
Senior Member
Posts: 3831
Joined: Wed Sep 10, 2003 11:00 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by ChrisA »

Originally posted by Emma
I believe you have to have a degree of self-confidence (or an ability to push yourself, if that's the same thing) in the first place.
Wow, now that's a thought.

I've never thought of myself as self-confident, but if I'm aiming at something I want, I can definitely push myself, and I can continue to push myself even when it's going terribly and I'm feeling really bad.

Are they the same thing? I'm not sure they are, because sometimes (not often in dancing) I do feel confident about something, and it doesn't feel the same as when I'm dragging myself stubbornly towards some goal despite all appearances that I'll never get there...

Chris
User avatar
Tazmanian Devil
Senior Member
Posts: 5010
Joined: Mon Sep 01, 2003 10:18 pm
Contact:

Report a concern about this post

Post by Tazmanian Devil »

Originally posted by Emma
I think they feed one another, but I believe you have to have a degree of self-confidence (or an ability to push yourself, if that's the same thing) in the first place. And I think that *working* upon what you do is absolutely crucial, because otherwise you stagnate.



Hey you have hit the nail right on the head there luv :waycool: Only problem is that Brilliant statement at this time of the morning makes Emma a dull girl!! I haven't had me breakfast yet :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
Live for the moment dance dance dance :D
Jon
Senior Member
Posts: 283
Joined: Sat Sep 14, 2002 3:29 pm

Report a concern about this post

Post by Jon »

Originally posted by cerocmetro
Why are you all so obsessed with becoming great dancers? What did you want when you started dancing? To be great dancers, or to have a great night out? When where did that change?


Speaking for myself what I wanted when I started was too make new friends after I moved house. I'd always been musical but to me dancing was something men just didnt do until I saw my dad doing jive. Then the wow factor hit me and thought why not give it a try and never looked back. But now I have lots of friends and make more all the time, I enjoy taxiing and teaching moves and now I have confidence in dancing I'm on a quest to become one of the 0.5% because I love dancing, but I dont think I'm there yet :tears:
It's only one dance. What's the Worst that could happen!
User avatar
David Franklin
Senior Member
Posts: 3426
Joined: Fri Feb 22, 2002 1:52 pm

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Franklin »

Originally posted by cerocmetro
What I was saying that if you practice that hard from that age, you can be good at what ever you want to be good at provided you have the basics requirements.
I think one thing we're losing sight of is that "basic requirements", "good", and "great" are all relative, not absolutes.

If you look at ballet, you have tens of thousands of girls training from a young age. A lot will fall by the wayside, but thousands of them will audition at, say 16. At this point they are probably all in the top 0.1% or so of dancers. Only a very few will make it to be a professional dancer, only a very few of those will become a principal dancer. Of those, only a few will be invited around the world. And only one or two of those will be a Darcey Bussell, or a Sylvie Gullem. And only time will tell whether they make it to join the ranks of Anna Pavlova or Margot Fonteyn.

Who had the basic requirements? Who is good? Who is great?

Going back to modern jive, everything being relative has it's upside - the office party usually has all of us getting the "great dancer" accolade!

I also don't know what you mean by the 'X-factor'? If you asked me, I'd say it's the ability to do the simplest moves and make them look amazing. But again, it's not all or nothing. Clearly Viktor has a lot of it. But I did a street dance class with Dan, where he did a single turn, "just going through the motions". And then explained how to "perform it", and showed us the difference. It was absolutely astounding - orders of magnitude beyond anything I'd seen before. The other interesting bit was that a lot of it was "taught" - look here, make eye contact over there, etc... I'm not convinced I could do it like him, even with practice, but I'm sure I could get a lot better at it.

Dave
JamesGeary
Senior Member
Posts: 287
Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 10:40 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by JamesGeary »

By born I mean emphasis on natural talent, as opposed to emphasis on training.

There are tens of thousands of people across the country who trained in ballet from age 8 onwards in an attempt to go professional by getting into a top ballet school (i mean one of the full-time ones with the associated dance companies). As stated maybe 0.1% or less make it.

Amir didn't take up Ballet until in his 20s, and then with a few years of occasional evening classes and no noticeable sacrifice, got a full scholarship to one of the top ballet schools in London. Michael Flatley would be another example of a pensioner starting late.

They prove that top dancers, that 0.1%, can be born into it rather than made.

Viktor is the top ceroc or modern jive dancer pretty much anywhere. Mick was Viktor's boss before he got into dancing. Mick is now UK Ceroc's best dancer (based on the jivemasters 2003, buy the video www.cerocmetro.com - grin). I find it statistically impossible that both Mick and Viktor were in that top 0.1% born, given that they worked together and were friends before they got involved with ceroc. Put it this way, of the 10,000 people doing ceroc every night of the week across the UK, isn't it rather odd that the 2 top ceroc dancers in the country were friends before they got into dancing.

They both went along to ceroc together for years and years with Mick always learning from Viktor. So Mick proves that top dancers, that 0.1%, can get there through good teachers and practise.
"If you compare yourself with others, you may become vain or bitter; for always there will be greater and lesser persons than yourself" - Desiderata
User avatar
Will
Senior Member
Posts: 1476
Joined: Thu Aug 22, 2002 11:00 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by Will »

Originally posted by David Franklin
I also don't know what you mean by the 'X-factor'?

Dave.... You mean you danced with Brittany for several months doing a team cabaret and you don't know what the "X-Factor" is??? :grin:
User avatar
David Franklin
Senior Member
Posts: 3426
Joined: Fri Feb 22, 2002 1:52 pm

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Franklin »

Originally posted by Will
Dave.... You mean you danced with Brittany for several months doing a team cabaret and you don't know what the "X-Factor" is??? :grin:
Actually, I never danced with Brittany... It was enough being in the same room as her...

But I was also wondering what Adam would define it as...

Dave
User avatar
cerocmetro
Senior Member
Posts: 518
Joined: Tue Sep 24, 2002 11:00 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by cerocmetro »

Originally posted by David Franklin
Actually, I never danced with Brittany... It was enough being in the same room as her...

But I was also wondering what Adam would define it as...

Dave


Would that be dancing in the same room as Brittany or what x-factor is?

Adam
User avatar
Sheepman
Senior Member
Posts: 3687
Joined: Wed May 14, 2003 4:52 pm
Contact:

Report a concern about this post

Post by Sheepman »

Originally posted by Gadget
A "Great" female dancer is one that glides and flows on the floor; becoming an extension to the lead and the music.
I couldn't disagree with that, but in addition they will be prepared to take the initiative (preferably not "taking over"), adding their own interpretation to the music, giving the "leader" the challenge of complementing this. It can be obvious, or oh so subtle, but when you both react in identical fashion to something in the music it is just sublime!

Greg
With one hand the past moves us forward, with the other it holds us back.
Jon L
Senior Member
Posts: 472
Joined: Sat Jul 26, 2003 7:54 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by Jon L »

Originally posted by cerocmetro
Actually no. Perhaps I was a little too sarcastic. What I was saying that if you practice that hard from that age, you can be good at what ever you want to be good at provided you have the basics requirements.

The majority of us started Ceroc too late to take it too seriously in terms of being "Great"dancers. We have commitments, work, families, lives.

Very few are able to commit 7 days a week to it. Work out to tone the muscles, study videos and dancers for hours and hours. Yes it can all be taught/learnt, but how many of you are prepared to go through that.

By the way Ben, Alina, Heather Mc, Mick, Lydia, Linda B, Lily B, Robert C, Lisa (aberdeen), Simon Selmon should be added to that list.

Both myself and Nigel are almost exceptions. We are both accountants, well me not any more. For both of us Ceroc was our first introduction to dancing. (Nigel did confrim this to me today). Both of us gained our rythme through playng instruments from an early age.

Why did we both get hooked on Ceroc, we were both single and very quickly found that men who could dance were far more attractive. (We both needed the help) Nigel then stuck a hat on his head and went onto do other styles of dancing, I got married, twice and was quite happy with Ceroc, although I have dabbled in Salsa, Lindy, Tango, etc etc since then. Also watched many hours of the Simpsons.

Both of us were however so sad that I used to leave work early 5 days a week to be the first at the class, I was also the last to leave. I did not miss a class for a year. Yes that includes the beginners classes.

I am always amazed when I ask advanced dancers to help me with beginners workshops. Guaranteed they will say, "I cannot believe how much I learnt" There's a surprise when I feel I learn something new everytime I teach a beginners workshop.

To me, to do the beginners classes is still part of the process of learning. It is also both sociable and helps new commers enjoy the dancing. It also helps keep the business going.

Both Nigel and myself are not natural dancers, we have both worked hard at it. Watch Nigels face in any competition or performance and the concentration is intense. Mandy said something very interesting to me the other day. She told me she was dancing with some guy, (actually i believe he is an accountant) who I always thought of as good. She said he had a whole conversation during the dance. He did not stop talking. He still hit every break, moved on every accent, used the music. He had no idea of what he was doing, he was not thinking or concentrating. Mandy told me he was one of the most natural dancers she had ever danced with. She said he could be GREAT, but he was happy enjoying the dancing.

There are many dancers out there who could be great. But maybe if they were, they would no longer enjoy it.

James Cronin never wanted to run a competition as he believed it would take the pureness away from Ceroc. I always dissagreed with him. I now believe he was so so right.

But we now have our competitions, heck I even run one. Have I mentioned the JIvemasters video yet??? :grin:

Why are you all so obsessed with becoming great dancers? What did you want when you started dancing? To be great dancers, or to have a great night out? When where did that change? Personally I wish some of the "great dancers" sorry lets tone that down, very advanced dancers, sorry lets say what we mean, people who think they are advanced dancers, would climb off their horses and share their skills with others. Join in the beginners classes, dance with beginners.

To be fair, the "great dancers" do this. It is the ones who think they are great who do not.

Sorry coming back to my point, Tiger Woods is the Greatest" because he is both natural and totally devoted. Also lucky, did we mention luck?

You get out what you put in. You also need the basic requirements, timing, comprehension, movability, arrogance, a decent body, half decent looks, style (not dancing, but appearance), hygene, health. You also need one more thing, the desire to be great.

Adam


I have just found this thread. Adam your posts make a lot of sense.

I realise my limitations, I am not the most gifted, naturally co-ordinated person. In fact throughout my life I have been plagued with some co-ordination problems, and doing jive/ceroc has been a revelation. That's why for the first time enterring the intermediates section and getting into the second round at the first attempt was for me an achievement.

This year a lot more people have said to me that I have improved enormously. These include people like Alina, Lily and Nina - not a bad list of people to tell you are getting better.

That said there are some people who are naturals out there. I was dancing with someone at Ceroc Surrey who had fab rhythm and whem I asked how long she had been dancing she said 8 months.

One point I will say again, the really great natural dancers will know they are good and take time to encourage those who are trying to get better. Viktor is good with beginners so to is Nigel. I have no time for dancers who perceive themselves as being great and refuse to dance with developing people. This is my definition of Cliques by the way.
Jiving right across the South..........
User avatar
stewart38
Senior Member
Posts: 7480
Joined: Fri May 09, 2003 8:56 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by stewart38 »

Originally posted by David Franklin
Agreed. Though I don't think anyone becomes great without a lot of practice. (or previous experience). But you then say:
Don't know if I'm misunderstanding you, but you now seem to be saying no amount of practice will make you a great dancer. At the highest level I might agree (might not - I think it depends on the arena), but to be in the top 5%? I think that's very achievable for almost anyone who wants to put in the work. [It occurs to me you may be meaning only 5% have the potential to be great. In which case forget I said anything...]

Dave




No amount of practice or time will put many people into the top 5%. Same for anything I'm afraid. I still think dancing is 50% natural ability,so hard work may put you into top 50% if you have no natural ability.

The best dancers do cira 20 moves they know more but 20 is enough
DavidB
Senior Member
Posts: 2263
Joined: Wed Feb 20, 2002 12:00 pm

Report a concern about this post

Post by DavidB »

Originally posted by stewart38
No amount of practice or time will put many people into the top 5%. Same for anything I'm afraid. I still think dancing is 50% natural ability,so hard work may put you into top 50% if you have no natural ability.
Only when things are taken close to their physical limit does natural ability become the limiting factor.

Modern Jive is nowhere near this limit. If you have people who can teach you, and you have the resources and dedication to put into it, then just about anyone could win Blackpool etc. (Why anyone would bother is a completely different topic.)

David
User avatar
TheTramp
Senior Member
Posts: 10672
Joined: Mon Nov 18, 2002 12:00 pm

Report a concern about this post

Post by TheTramp »

Originally posted by DavidB
Only when things are taken close to their physical limit does natural ability become the limiting factor.

Modern Jive is nowhere near this limit. If you have people who can teach you, and you have the resources and dedication to put into it, then just about anyone could win Blackpool etc.
Sorry David. Don't agree with this statement at all.

Unless you are taking it to the nth (and thus totally unrealistic) degree. Yes, an infinite of moneys with an infinite amount of time would write the complete works of Shakespeare. And yes, I suppose that possibly anyone could win MJ competitions, if they had an unlimited amount of resource and time.

In practise though, I think that it's highly unlikely....

Are you saying that the same couldn't be said of WCS competitions too though?

And if not, can you please say exactly what the difference between the two styles of dance that would preclude that happening would be then.

Steve
Fluent in sarcasm! :flower:
DavidB
Senior Member
Posts: 2263
Joined: Wed Feb 20, 2002 12:00 pm

Report a concern about this post

Post by DavidB »

Originally posted by TheTramp
Sorry David. Don't agree with this statement at all.

Unless you are taking it to the nth (and thus totally unrealistic) degree. Yes, an infinite of moneys with an infinite amount of time would write the complete works of Shakespeare. And yes, I suppose that possibly anyone could win MJ competitions, if they had an unlimited amount of resource and time.

In practise though, I think that it's highly unlikely....

Are you saying that the same couldn't be said of WCS competitions too though?

And if not, can you please say exactly what the difference between the two styles of dance that would preclude that happening would be then.

Steve
You could do it in WCS. Or possibly even in Ballroom. It is just that the bar is so much higher in these styles that you would have to put more time, effort and money in.

In Modern Jive most couples who do well in competitions get together for a few weeks before a comp. They might practice a couple of times a week, and in extreme cases try to get one or two private lessons. But generally they learn things from classes, workshops and trial & error.

Your average competitive amateur ballroom couple would be getting one or two lessons a week, practicing most days, and competing every week. And still manage to fit in a day job. They might have been doing this for several years.

Professional ballroom couples competitors work even harder - it is their day job. They have to take very detailed exams over the course of several years to gain their teaching and judging qualifications. The top judges know exactly what they are looking for, and the standards they expect from the competitors. The top professionals still take regular lessons (ie learning from the trial and error of other people.)

WCS at an amateur level would be somewhere in the middle - with a mixture of social dancing, lessons and competitions. Most WCS dancers we know (even ones who have no wish to compete) take either regular or occasional private lessons.

WCS at a professional level is not quite as 'developed' as ballroom. There isn't the competition (and therefore influences) from many countries. You get 30 couples in a big comp, not 300 like in ballroom. But there are still several couples who dance and teach WCS at a very high level for a living.

At the very top level I'd rate ballroom dancers as having the best technique of any partner dancers. WCS and Lindy have specialised more in musical interpretation than absolute technique. Modern Jive doesn't come close, even in NZ :devil:

If someone really worked at it (like an amateur ballroom couple), it would take maybe 6 months for someone with lots of talent, maybe a year for an average dancer, and maybe 2 years for a Man City fan. But you are right - it is unlikely. I don't know of any modern jive dancers who would want to stop social dancing for a year just to win one competition.

David
Post Reply