Jon Brett wrote:Thanks for the feedback on the music last night everyone. Just wish you'd come to me and said it at the time, then I could do something about it on the spot.
I would find this very difficult for two reasons. Firstly, I respect the fact that the DJ is crafting his set as the night progresses, and I don't see it as my right to go and moan about one particular track that I might not like (except the Jive Aces

).
Secondly, it takes me several tracks to build up a feeling for the shape of the music on a particular night - I'm busy dancing, so it's only after several tracks that I might start to feel "wait a minute, I'm not enjoying this, and it's because of the music rather than anything else".
Difficult choice having Hipsters regulars & lots of WCS visitors at the same time. Do you keep the visitors happy and upset the regulars, or keep the visitors happy & upset the regulars?
Well I'm not convinced these are mutually exclusive. But I've spoken to several people who are both Hipsters regulars and WCS dancers at one level or another, and they seem to share my view.
But as has been said, Hipsters is now Jive and WCS as far as the teaching is concerned (and

for that), not Jive and Lindy. I do think that should be reflected more in the music.
The "Jive Aces" track was a request from one of our regulars. Referring to my comment above, if you ain't happy, tell the DJ. If you want something played, tell the DJ. He might listen.
Ok, but you knew it was a crap idea to play it

- you even apologised as you put it on. And god help us all if you start playing requests with any kind of frequency. I don't feel remotely competent to try and do your job at all, let alone while I'm busy concentrating on dancing, and I bet most people would be the same.
In fact, I don't want to hear my pet tracks, I want to experience the whole musical landscape over the course of the night, and that needs to be shaped by a craftsman, not hacked together by the locals
I was watching the floor the whole night & had a good floor throughout. Which is my job. It wouldn't be so crowded on the floor if I didn't. So to suggest that most people weren't happy is not a fair reflection on the evening.
Well, I didn't suggest most people weren't happy - I was speaking for myself and the few that I've spoken to.
But I think measuring success
only by how many people are on the floor is a big mistake. Dancers come to dance, and mostly they'll dance even to awful stuff. Put the Mavericks on, and the floor fills. Even when Peter put that ghastly "dance" mix of Stairway to Heaven on, at Camber, people were rushing on to the floor. And why? Because it had a damn thump-thump beat.
I danced to it, in fact, but I hated it.
At risk of sounding elitist, I'll say this too:
You could achieve a packed floor by putting on pop music from one end of the night to the other... but the people there would be the ones that like a diet of pop. All the ones that love dancing to slower tracks, rich in colour and accents, would have gone elsewhere.
I reckon at Hipsters you've got one of the fussiest audiences out, and hence the most difficult job. You've given us such a lot of good stuff over the last couple of years that our expectations are very high.
So when people like me have a moan, it's because you've educated us to expect the best, and if it's only as good as it was last month, it's no longer good enough. We want you to inspire us, excite us, wrap us in velvet, tease us... reliably, every week, and for the high to get higher every time.
God knows how you (or any of the other really good DJs) do it at all, never mind most of the time. But speaking just for myself, I am finding your sets a touch samey at the moment
Finally, thank you once again for the feedback. Keep it coming. I do read it all and think about it more than you perhaps realise!
I know you do. And it's hugely appreciated, believe me
Chris