Page 11 of 20

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Posted: Sat Jul 29, 2006 1:14 pm
by El Salsero Gringo
Barry Shnikov wrote:Really? Admittedly it is unlikely we would see this in the short-term. But to believe that there will always be such people about would be seriously alarming.
Well it's a truism that there will always be such people. Just as there are always people who are prepared to steal, murder and commit any crimes. The question is, how do the countries in question deal with such people? Are they criminals to be investigated and proscuted to the full extent of the law? Or are they heroic fighters of the resistance, to be feted and celebrated with posters in the street and television eulogies?

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Posted: Sat Jul 29, 2006 2:34 pm
by David Bailey
El Salsero Gringo wrote:OK, let's say that Israel is no longer prepared to accept the presence of Hizbullah on its northern border.
I think that's more accurate.
Even more accurate would be to say "The current Israeli political leadership are not prepared to accept the presence of Hizbullah on its northern border".
El Salsero Gringo wrote:If I were Israeli, I'd probably find it rather hard to swallow that the world expects me to put my northern border at risk just to see if the Syrians will come to the table. A decisive military victory over your enemy in a war you didn't start should earn you some political advantage when it comes to negotiating a peace, shouldn't it?
All this makes sense - but in realpolitik, someone has to blink first. And the Golan Heights are a big chip that Israel can put on the table.
El Salsero Gringo wrote:By the way, I've been to the Golan. You don't have to be a military tactician of genius proportion to realise that the same stunning views of the plains of northern Israel would give a belligerent enemy a decisive strategic advantage. Unlike the Sinai, which is hundreds of miles of desert. So you might expect the Israeli public to be a little more cautious about taking a risk on Syria.
Absolutely - but then again, it wasn't a decisive strategic advantage 40 years ago, and I imagine it's much much less so now, with unmanned drones, satellite imaging and so on. In fact, I can't conceive of any Arab state launching a "proper" war on Israel, they know they'd have no chance.
El Salsero Gringo wrote:It seems rather a pity that Israel has to 'offer' something to Iran. I'm not quite sure what Israel has ever done to the Iranians to offend them, except perhaps to exist at all.
Yep, I think that pretty much sums up the Iranian point of view. I can't think of anything Israel can offer Iran - as to why this should be a factor, it's a negotiation, and you need to have things to offer to make any negotiation work.

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Posted: Sat Jul 29, 2006 3:06 pm
by bigdjiver
Barry Shnikov wrote:Sounds unlikely - Dresden was the best known but not by any means the only such raid in the waning days of that war.
I have no reason to doubt the guys word. His qualifications would have been rigorously checked. He had explanations for the selection of Hiroshima and Nagasaki too.
That's the missing element, by the way]Another reason I tend to believe him. The USA Bomber command faced tremendous losses in bombing Japan, they would have every reason for wanting to get it "right" when they got there. Dresden in itself does not seem a justifiable target.

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Posted: Sat Jul 29, 2006 4:41 pm
by El Salsero Gringo
DavidJames wrote:Absolutely - but then again, it wasn't a decisive strategic advantage 40 years ago, and I imagine it's much much less so now, with unmanned drones, satellite imaging and so on. In fact, I can't conceive of any Arab state launching a "proper" war on Israel, they know they'd have no chance.
Look around you. Given that warfare against Israel currently consists of blind rocket attacks, the principle disadvantage of which is that Hamas and Hizbullah can't target them very accurately (precisely because they *don't* have satelilte imaging or unmanned drones). That would not be the case with a few observers on the Golan. In current circumstances, occupation of the Golan is a much *more* strategic advantage than it was 40 years ago. Despite all that, the Golan is on the table, and has been, in return for a real peace, since 1967.
DavidJames wrote:Yep, I think that pretty much sums up the Iranian point of view. I can't think of anything Israel can offer Iran - as to why this should be a factor, it's a negotiation, and you need to have things to offer to make any negotiation work.
It's *not* a negotiation! There's nothing that Israel should have to offer to avoid be threatened with destruction by Mr Ahmedinejad, nor is there anything he'd like to have put on the table as an alternative. The guy has a serious attitude problem with Jews having a state in the Middle East; well, tough on him.

By the way, you may not be able to conceive of arab armies invading Israel, but it's not your imagination that counts. Iran has six million men under arms, including reservists. Israel has half a million. Go figure.

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Posted: Sat Jul 29, 2006 8:34 pm
by Ash
By the way, you may not be able to conceive of arab armies invading Israel, but it's not your imagination that counts. Iran has six million men under arms, including reservists. Israel has half a million. Go figure. ESG
I think you're missing the point:

http://www.thestar.com/NASApp/cs/Conten ... 2913812442

http://www.fair.org/index.php?page=2922

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Posted: Sat Jul 29, 2006 9:37 pm
by Ash

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Posted: Sat Jul 29, 2006 9:52 pm
by El Salsero Gringo
Sorry, but nothing either new or worth responding to there.

Even if there were, don't you think there are more interesting ways to carry on a discussion than just posting web-pages at each other? Believe me I've got stacks more, supporting both sides, than you do.

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Posted: Sun Jul 30, 2006 9:06 am
by WittyBird
El Salsero Gringo wrote: Believe me I've got stacks more, supporting both sides, than you do.
But my dad's bigger than your dad :rofl:

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Posted: Sun Jul 30, 2006 10:21 am
by El Salsero Gringo
From an email I recieved this morning:

On July 26, the daily UNIFIL press release reported the Israeli bomb that had destroyed a UN post the day before, leading to UN Secretary General Anan's infamous accusation that Israel deliberately attacked the site.

What the secretary general did not consider worth mentioning was the highly relevant information that attacks on UN posts by Hezbollah have been occurring almost daily and that Hezbollah have been drawing Israeli fire by lobbing their rockets at Israel from the vicinity of UN positions. The same UNIFIL press release reported that another UN position in the western sector was directly hit by Hizbollah mortar fire the same evening and that Hezbollah fired at Israel from the vicinity of four UN positions at Alma ash Shab, Tibnin, Brashit, and At Tiri.

On July 24, UNIFIL reported that one unarmed UN member of Observer Group Lebanon (OGL), was seriously wounded by small arms the previous afternoon originating, from preliminary reports, from the Hezbollah side. The UN evacuated him to the Israeli side, from where he was taken by IDF helicopter to a hospital in Haifa. He was operated on, and his condition was reported as stable. Of course there was not a word of thanks from the secretary general.

The July 25 UNIFIL report stated "This morning, Hezbollah opened small arms fire at a UNIFIL convoy consisting of two APC's on the road between Kunin and Bint Jubayl."

On July 27 It was also reported that Hezbollah fired from the vicinity of four UN positions at Marwahin, Alma Ash Shab, Brashit, and At Tiri.

On July 28, UNIFIL reported that Hezbollah fired from the vicinity of five UN positions at Alma Ash Shab, At Tiri, Bayt Yahoun, Brashit, and Tibnin.



My question is: why is none of this reported in the mainstream media? Is it too "detailed"? Does it not match the "story" that the media likes to build for its audience? I really don't know. This information doesn't excuse the death of four UN observers from Israeli bombing, but it forms part of the background that helps understand how to interpret these events.

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Posted: Sun Jul 30, 2006 11:25 am
by jiveknight
El Salsero Gringo wrote:From an email I recieved this morning:

On July 26, the daily UNIFIL press release reported the Israeli bomb that had destroyed a UN post the day before, leading to UN Secretary General Anan's infamous accusation that Israel deliberately attacked the site.

What the secretary general did not consider worth mentioning was the highly relevant information that attacks on UN posts by Hezbollah have been occurring almost daily and that Hezbollah have been drawing Israeli fire by lobbing their rockets at Israel from the vicinity of UN positions. The same UNIFIL press release reported that another UN position in the western sector was directly hit by Hizbollah mortar fire the same evening and that Hezbollah fired at Israel from the vicinity of four UN positions at Alma ash Shab, Tibnin, Brashit, and At Tiri.

On July 24, UNIFIL reported that one unarmed UN member of Observer Group Lebanon (OGL), was seriously wounded by small arms the previous afternoon originating, from preliminary reports, from the Hezbollah side. The UN evacuated him to the Israeli side, from where he was taken by IDF helicopter to a hospital in Haifa. He was operated on, and his condition was reported as stable. Of course there was not a word of thanks from the secretary general.

The July 25 UNIFIL report stated "This morning, Hezbollah opened small arms fire at a UNIFIL convoy consisting of two APC's on the road between Kunin and Bint Jubayl."

On July 27 It was also reported that Hezbollah fired from the vicinity of four UN positions at Marwahin, Alma Ash Shab, Brashit, and At Tiri.

On July 28, UNIFIL reported that Hezbollah fired from the vicinity of five UN positions at Alma Ash Shab, At Tiri, Bayt Yahoun, Brashit, and Tibnin.



My question is: why is none of this reported in the mainstream media? Is it too "detailed"? Does it not match the "story" that the media likes to build for its audience? I really don't know. This information doesn't excuse the death of four UN observers from Israeli bombing, but it forms part of the background that helps understand how to interpret these events.
Yes, the media obviously already have their story "written".

When i was in Israel last, about five years ago, it was when it was "all taking off again" and we met loads of israelies who knew the atmosphere was being created by the media. The local media, even national TV, could not enter the gaza strip, only BBC World and CNN could go in. The locals were more worried about the fact that the tourist board had told everyone not to travel there as this was imediatley affecting them in Tel Aviv, that was all they saw - the atmosphere was seen only via CNN etc. The people there have always been happy and friendly to me but this breeds fear and worry.

Who is the third party?

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Posted: Sun Jul 30, 2006 12:22 pm
by Ash
Sorry, but nothing either new or worth responding to there. ESG
The links aren't just for your benefit: everybody else can have a look and make up their own mind.

:)

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Posted: Sun Jul 30, 2006 12:26 pm
by WittyBird
Ash wrote:The links aren't just for your benefit: everybody else can have a look and make up their own mind.

:)
*sits back with popcorn waiting for a well informed but highly sarcastic response from El Stirrer Gringo*

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Posted: Sun Jul 30, 2006 12:31 pm
by Feelingpink
jiveknight wrote:Yes, the media obviously already have their story "written".

When i was in Israel last, about five years ago, it was when it was "all taking off again" and we met loads of israelies who knew the atmosphere was being created by the media. The local media, even national TV, could not enter the gaza strip, only BBC World and CNN could go in. The locals were more worried about the fact that the tourist board had told everyone not to travel there as this was imediatley affecting them in Tel Aviv, that was all they saw - the atmosphere was seen only via CNN etc. The people there have always been happy and friendly to me but this breeds fear and worry.

Who is the third party?
I never understand how people come to the conclusion that "the media ... have their story 'written'" on this or any other issue. The media is a number of news professionals & organisations & columnists. Sure, there are cases when one outlet will report something and others assume this to be 'true' without checking it out themselves. That's not great. But given that there are different news organisation owners, independent journalists and columnists (who love to give a dissenting view) from different countries, I just don't understand that there could possibly be a pre-ordained line for them all to follow, which they all would. Perhaps, JiveKnight, you could explain this? I do believe, however, that as individuals, it is good to get our news from different sources so that we can make up our own minds on different subjects.

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Posted: Sun Jul 30, 2006 1:46 pm
by El Salsero Gringo
Feelingpink wrote:But given that there are different news organisation owners, independent journalists and columnists (who love to give a dissenting view) from different countries, I just don't understand that there could possibly be a pre-ordained line for them all to follow, which they all would.
It doesn't have to be pre-ordained or the result of some great conspiracy (I'm not a big believer in conspiracies) for it still to exist.

It's always the same facts that *don't* get reported, the same quotes that mysteriously never make it to print, the same photographs that get cropped in the same way.

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Posted: Sun Jul 30, 2006 1:52 pm
by El Salsero Gringo
WittyBird wrote:*sits back with popcorn waiting for a well informed but highly sarcastic response from El Stirrer Gringo*
Not at all. I'd be much more interested (I assume others would too) to hear whether Ash actually thinks the things written in these webpages are correct, and which of the different opinions there impress here (sorry Ash, I'm assuming you're female... If you're a guy 100 apologies) On this forum I don't want to discuss things with anonymous columnists who aren't going to be able to back up their opinions; I'd rather engage with someone, like Ash, who's prepared to respond.

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Posted: Sun Jul 30, 2006 2:09 pm
by Feelingpink
El Salsero Gringo wrote:It doesn't have to be pre-ordained or the result of some great conspiracy (I'm not a big believer in conspiracies) for it still to exist.

It's always the same facts that *don't* get reported, the same quotes that mysteriously never make it to print, the same photographs that get cropped in the same way.
If they don't appear, then how do you know about them?

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Posted: Sun Jul 30, 2006 4:55 pm
by David Bailey
bigdjiver wrote:I have no reason to doubt the guys word. His qualifications would have been rigorously checked. He had explanations for the selection of Hiroshima and Nagasaki too.
Well, yeah - but from my point of view, it's third-hand hearsay, about the same level of provenance as "I heard it from the guy down the pub".

The Dresden bombing was originally requested by the The Deputy Chief of the Soviet General Staff, General Aleksei Antonov, at the Yalta conference, and was agreed to then, to degrade German lines of communication. This is all fairly well-documented.

Don't get me wrong, I don't doubt the Americans took great interest in the mechanics of firestorms, in Dresden and the other dozen or so German towns firestorm-bombed before then, and it certainly seems plausible that this bombing raid provided useful data to them. But I find it difficult to believe that the principle stratetic reason to launch a 1,000+ - bomber raid was launched just to see how a firestorm was created.

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Posted: Sun Jul 30, 2006 5:06 pm
by David Bailey
El Salsero Gringo wrote:Look around you. Given that warfare against Israel currently consists of blind rocket attacks, the principle disadvantage of which is that Hamas and Hizbullah can't target them very accurately (precisely because they *don't* have satelilte imaging or unmanned drones). That would not be the case with a few observers on the Golan. In current circumstances, occupation of the Golan is a much *more* strategic advantage than it was 40 years ago.
Good point - didn't think of that...
El Salsero Gringo wrote:By the way, you may not be able to conceive of arab armies invading Israel, but it's not your imagination that counts. Iran has six million men under arms, including reservists. Israel has half a million. Go figure.
Yeah, but I can't really see any conventional army defeating the IDF - the entire Iranian defence budget is about the same as the amount the US provides Israel in military aid. Iran are definitely number 2 in the region, but they'd be nuts to launch a conventional attack anyway, it'd be just the excuse the USA are looking for.

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Posted: Sun Jul 30, 2006 5:19 pm
by bigdjiver
DavidJames wrote:... But I find it difficult to believe that the principle stratetic reason to launch a 1,000+ - bomber raid was launched just to see how a firestorm was created.
I did not say it was the only "reason", and too much was already known about firestorms. What was alleged is that one of the reasons Dresden was on the list of potential targets was to check math and tactics. Very heavy losses could be expected whilst bombing Japan, and "bang for buck" was a major consideration. My source did not realise that his work had anything to do with the Manhattan project until after the event.

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Posted: Sun Jul 30, 2006 6:09 pm
by David Bailey
bigdjiver wrote:I did not say it was the only "reason", and too much was already known about firestorms. What was alleged is that one of the reasons Dresden was on the list of potential targets was to check math and tactics.
Weeell, I suppose it's possible - but I very much doubt whether it was in the top 10 of reasons to bomb Dresden, and probably way below the oft-repeated "Revenge for Coventry". Probably more of a beneficial side-effect than a reason, from a strategic point of view.