The judges decision is final!

Confused by the Accordion Comb Pull Crab?

Spinning gets you dizzy?
Would like some help with a tricky intermediate move? Ask here, and share your fave tips...
You need to be registered / logged in to read this forum

Should the judges voting in competitions be made available for all to see?

No. The results should be kept hidden. It allows for more (friendly) debate.
7
13%
Don't really care. I wouldn't look at them anyway.
5
9%
Yes. For the finals. Protecting the anonimity of the judges.
3
6%
Yes. For every round. Protecting the anonimity of the judges.
20
38%
Yes. For the finals. Allowing the judges names to be seen.
3
6%
Yes. For every round. Allowing the judges names to be seen.
15
28%
 
Total votes: 53

User avatar
Sheepman
Senior Member
Posts: 3687
Joined: Wed May 14, 2003 4:52 pm
Contact:

Report a concern about this post

Post by Sheepman »

Originally posted by Gus
The judges are being paid by the Organisers
I'm not sure this is always the case, or even if they are paid, it can be pretty much of a token payment. Not that this really affects this debate, but I think highlights the fact that some people are willing to put themselves up as judges more for the love of the art (and maybe to enhance their own reputation?) rather than for monetary reward.

Consider the Blackpool competition, and how many hours of work the judges are doing there. I'm sure they don't get paid a sum that would even get me out of bed in the morning, but if someone ever asked me (some chance!) I'd be willing to do my best at it.

Perhaps we needed a voting category that the results should be published, and judges identified, providing they agreed to be identified. I have asked judges for feedback after comnpetitions, but have never asked them to tell me what scores they gave.

Regarding David Bs comments, it looks like we're heading for the McGregor judging method debate again, there is plenty on this on other threads

Greg
With one hand the past moves us forward, with the other it holds us back.
Gus
Senior Member
Posts: 5203
Joined: Mon Mar 04, 2002 12:00 pm

Report a concern about this post

Post by Gus »

Well, with the Ceroc Scotland competition coming up .... what will be the level of transparency about judges scoring? Dont know who all the judges are ... or whether the majority will be local again. Seemed general agreement last year but with things getting a bit more serious this year will that change?
"We all believe in something... greater than ourselves, even if it's just the blind forces of chance" - G'Kar.
Bill
Senior Member
Posts: 2161
Joined: Thu Jan 24, 2002 12:00 pm

Report a concern about this post

Post by Bill »

Originally posted by Gus
Well, with the Ceroc Scotland competition coming up .... what will be the level of transparency about judges scoring? Dont know who all the judges are ... or whether the majority will be local again. Seemed general agreement last year but with things getting a bit more serious this year will that change?



Let's hope not. I think with the Open category there will be more experienced dancers from down south entering. Hope it is fun again and I'm certianly looking forward to doing more watching and less competing this year :D

Having talked to Steve I know he hasn't danced with his partner for ages and Fran and I haven't met up to practice at all so so not as prepared as we would like.

Hope to see last years winners back and especially looking forward to what should be a very good Intermediate comp - especially as Elliot and Dela are mulitple comp winners and will be in the Advanced :D .

There was pretty much unanimous agreement over the results last year and I hope that this doesn't change. Mind you a little bit of controversy can be fun :na: :wink:
Bill
Lounge Lizard
Senior Member
Posts: 1435
Joined: Tue Aug 05, 2003 11:00 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by Lounge Lizard »

Originally posted by DavidB
As well as looking at what the judges mark, you should also think about how they mark, and how these marks are collated.

For example if you look at the judging criteria for Blackpool
KEY
1 = Poor
2 = Below Average
3 = Average
4 = Good
5 = Excellent

COSTUME / PRESENTATION KEY
1 = Poor
2 = Average
3 = Excellent


Whether or not you agree with what they are looking for, they have made an effort to publish this in advance.

David

It is good that this is published in advance, but with this system it seems thst an average dancer with an excellent costume gets same marks as an excellent dancer in a poor costume.

I think the costume should not rank so highly in a 'dance' competition.

On the judging a number of judges expect competitors to direct their dance towards them, I always prefer dancers that just dance together and focus on each other.
This seemed evident at Blackpool where big music, big costumes and big cheesy grin were often the order of the day. The two girls dancing the socks off the rest were IMHO the best there.
Bill
Senior Member
Posts: 2161
Joined: Thu Jan 24, 2002 12:00 pm

Report a concern about this post

Post by Bill »

Originally posted by Lounge Lizard

I think the costume should not rank so highly in a 'dance' competition.

On the judging a number of judges expect competitors to direct their dance towards them, I always prefer dancers that just dance together and focus on each other.
This seemed evident at Blackpool where big music, big costumes and big cheesy grin were often the order of the day. The two girls dancing the socks off the rest were IMHO the best there.



At some comps I've seen couples dancing well in very plain outfits so they can't be too important at least at some events.

As for 'cheesy' grins........I have to agree. There are some dancers I've seen who are obviously very good at the 'competition smile' and in some cases they look very artificial. I much prefer to see a couple dancing for each other and having fun ( if at all possible at a comp :sick: ). It can look just too affected but..............some people win because of this so who am I to say anything !! :rolleyes:
Bill
User avatar
Sheepman
Senior Member
Posts: 3687
Joined: Wed May 14, 2003 4:52 pm
Contact:

DWAS judging

Report a concern about this post

Post by Sheepman »

I got into a debate recently on a topic I'd never given much thought. The judging of DWAS/take a chance competitions. There seem to be 2 methods employed here.

1. The tap on the shoulder from a judge and you're out.

2. The tap on the shoulder from the judge and you're through to the next round.

The main argument was over how you can be sure you've even been looked at by a judge. With either method you can't be sure, but with method 2 it is more drastic, because if you weren't noticed, you're out!

I've competed under both these methods, and have to say I prefer the first one. OK I know there is the theory about it being too "negative" being picked to leave, but I say if you're not performing well enough, let's clear the floor for those that are. With method 2 there is the panic towards the end of the record, "Oh no, only 45 seconds of this track to go, and no one has even looked at us yet." So you start leaping around like a mad thing in front of the judges nose! (And yes, it did work for me & my partner!)

Now I know these DWAS competitions are supposed to be a bit of fun (aren't they all??), but they should still be fair. So our theory went on to say that the only fair way to do it is for each competitor to be given scores in the same way as other categories, and for results to be totted up and announced afterwards. Is this practical? With up to 50 couples on the floor at the same time, I don't see how, though I suppose judges could pair off and work on allocated quadrants of the floor. Though this could lead to those on the fringes of each quadrant being missed out.

I haven't checked out how this is going to be judged at the up coming Britroc competition, but looking at the effort made generally regarding the judging of this competition, I reckon it should be as good as any, but how about a debate before it sounds like sour grapes?

Greg
With one hand the past moves us forward, with the other it holds us back.
Bill
Senior Member
Posts: 2161
Joined: Thu Jan 24, 2002 12:00 pm

Re: DWAS judging

Report a concern about this post

Post by Bill »

Originally posted by Sheepman
I got into a debate recently on a topic I'd never given much thought. The judging of DWAS/take a chance competitions. There seem to be 2 methods employed here.

1. The tap on the shoulder from a judge and you're out.

2. The tap on the shoulder from the judge and you're through to the next round.

but how about a debate before it sounds like sour grapes?

Greg



I think this has been touched on before and it is very difficult as there are so many people on the dance floor at once. last year I was on the edge of the floor for the first round in Blackpool and was caught quite heavily in the chest by another man's elbow - and it hurt ! :sick:

The only way to do this 'properly' would be to have a handful of couples on at a time but that would take forever. As it's supposed to be more fun than the 'serious' comp then I think it's less important who gets through but it does mean that judges will inevitably see a few familiar faces and perhaps be swayed by those they know - unless you are jumping up and down in front of their noses. :D
Bill
User avatar
TheTramp
Senior Member
Posts: 10672
Joined: Mon Nov 18, 2002 12:00 pm

Report a concern about this post

Post by TheTramp »

Well. Quite agree that DWAS aren't really to be taken all that seriously. Although, it's probably the best test of lead and follow - if they could somehow arrange it so that it was a 'stranger' you were dancing with.

I do prefer the tap on the shoulder and you're out method - for the first round anyhow. That way you could eliminate all the couples who don't really gel together. After the first round though, I think that it should be judged in the same way as the rest of the competitions.

Or you could just limit the number of entries in the first instance, as to make it a 'proper' competition. Though, I think that this defeats the objective.

Of course, an even better way, would be to do the same as the Aussie competitions, and split the competition into a beginners DWAS, an intermediate DWAS and an advanced DWAS, and then the rounds should be small enough to judge 'properly'. As well as giving those people who haven't been dancing as long more of a chance as well.

Steve
Fluent in sarcasm! :flower:
User avatar
Sheepman
Senior Member
Posts: 3687
Joined: Wed May 14, 2003 4:52 pm
Contact:

Report a concern about this post

Post by Sheepman »

Originally posted by TheTramp
do the same as the Aussie competitions, and split the competition into a beginners DWAS, an intermediate DWAS and an advanced DWAS, and then the rounds should be small enough to judge 'properly'.

Interesting idea, though this must completely change the nature of the competition. Plus you get into the old debate about who is eligible for each category. (I presume you'd stick with the beginners? :wink: ) And doesn't this end up with just this competition taking up the whole day?

Greg
With one hand the past moves us forward, with the other it holds us back.
User avatar
TheTramp
Senior Member
Posts: 10672
Joined: Mon Nov 18, 2002 12:00 pm

Report a concern about this post

Post by TheTramp »

Originally posted by Sheepman
Interesting idea, though this must completely change the nature of the competition. Plus you get into the old debate about who is eligible for each category. (I presume you'd stick with the beginners? :wink: ) And doesn't this end up with just this competition taking up the whole day?

Greg
Well, the usual way over there, is that the teachers tell them who is ready for which category (I think). Though, over there also, I think that people are pushing to be in the highest category - they'd prefer to be in the advanced, than do well in the intermediate. Because, lets face it, everyone in the advanced competition should be better than everyone in the intermediate (and down to the beginners). So, even if you come no-where in the advanced, you can still say that you did better than the winners of the intermediate - and with the prizes not being of any value, there's no incentive there (although, I'd guess that it doesn't always happen this way).

As for taking longer, possibly. Not sure. Because there's so fewer people in each category, it's a lot quicker to organise. The time it took to partner 150 couples up at Blackpool and Ceroc, you could probably have had a couple of rounds of dancing. They partner all the couples up prior to the competition in Oz (presumably by random draw :D ), and publish all the couples at the desk where you register, which speeds up that process. Then, there were a couple of heats at each level, straight into the final. I don't recall it taking that long to get out of the way.....

Steve
Fluent in sarcasm! :flower:
User avatar
Gadget
Senior Member
Posts: 7053
Joined: Wed Oct 09, 2002 9:08 pm
Contact:

Report a concern about this post

Post by Gadget »

I remember a wile ago that someone was complaining that since they got through to the finals {in a "tap and you're out" system}, it meant that they had danced the whole song of every heat, therefore they were knackered by the time they reached that stage and the performance wasn't up to the standard it could have been.

The "tap and you're through" system allows for the 'good' competitors to have more of a rest before the next round.
I used to be an angel, you know with halo and those wings;
Now that i'm a devil, my mind's on other things...
My feathers turned to ash, and my harp has broke in two;
I took uppon myself, to have a dance with you...
User avatar
TheTramp
Senior Member
Posts: 10672
Joined: Mon Nov 18, 2002 12:00 pm

Report a concern about this post

Post by TheTramp »

It's exactly the same for all the competitors though. They all have to dance to the end of the songs. If they did a tap to go through, then you could say that some competitors who get tapped through first, have an unfair advantage over those who only get tapped through right at the end of the songs.....

Steve
Fluent in sarcasm! :flower:
User avatar
Divissima
Senior Member
Posts: 1461
Joined: Sun Aug 25, 2002 11:00 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by Divissima »

Just to add a thought about the Australian DWAS competition. (DavidB has also posted up some interesting comments on the recent Australian competition in the Sydney Comp thread.) Mark Harding tried a new system this year which involved judging the leaders and followers separately with each round having three one-minute excerpts from different songs and having to rotate to a new partner within the heat for each song. Anyone who had danced with their new partner on a regular basis was asked to declare the interest and was swapped to a new partner. Once you got into the final, you were then judged as a couple for the places.

The major advantage of this was that it seemed to be a very fair system. The disadvantage was that it did take much longer to get through each round.

As the Tramp has commented, you could have smaller numbers of competitors in each round (and limit numbers overall) or you could allow a larger number of competitors and the competition to run for much longer. DavidB observed that in Sydney there was hardly any freestyle during the day (by my recollection, there was no more than 45 minutes (and possibly even less) during the event where you could freestyle - until the post comp party!) so by making it a fairer competition, you lessen one of the elements which makes competitions so popular as social events.

As with so many things, there is an element of trade-off.
Bill
Senior Member
Posts: 2161
Joined: Thu Jan 24, 2002 12:00 pm

Report a concern about this post

Post by Bill »

Whatever system is adopted there will always be some difficulties.

At Blackpool the only problem is that too many people are packed into the first round heats. It wouldn't take that much time to have an extra two heats to have fewer dancers on the floor - if everything started dead on time.

I do prefer the Ceroc system of posting the results after the heat so everyone gets to stay on for a whole record. It was obvious ( according to some viewers) that some dancers were being given the nod very very quickly and perhaps because their faces were already known to the judges.

I suppose the advanatage of a tap and you're off method is that it clears the floor and the judges can look more closely at the couples left but it is worrying knowing the end of the song is approaching and it looks as if you're staying on till the end. :sick: :sad:
Bill
DavidB
Senior Member
Posts: 2263
Joined: Wed Feb 20, 2002 12:00 pm

Report a concern about this post

Post by DavidB »

I'm not too sure of exactly how the 'tap on the shoulder' works. Either they come to a collective decision, or they each get to select one or two couples to go through.

I've never liked the idea of the judging by committee, where the judges come to some form of result between themselves. I particularly don't like it when they have to tap people through/out during the round itself. There is so little time to look at the couples anyway - making time for a group discussion in the middle of a heat just reduces their chance to see what people are doing. As a result, if you don't gel instantly with your partner, you have no chance. After the first minute, the judges have to start their discussion, and have enough time to tap the right people.

The alternative is to give each judge one or two 'taps' each. This has problems too. A judge may have selected his two couples after watching most of the heat, but find they've already been tapped by the time they get there. They might then have to make a quick decision based on whatever time is remaining.

I'd rather see it scored as any other category, with each judge coming to an independent decision, and the overall results posted after the heat. But if you stick with tapping, then tapping through is better. The couples have paid to enter - they should at least get chance to dance to a whole song.

BUT...
All this assumes the DWAS is a serious category, and in just about all the events it is run as a fun category. If it is run just for fun, then the tapping on the shoulder can add to the fun element. Give each judge 2 'taps' and wait for the last judge to be running around the floor trying to find someone to tap...

However I would like to see one event where there is a DWAS category run as a serious competition - after all it has to be the true test of 'lead and follow' dancing.

David
Geordieed
Senior Member
Posts: 521
Joined: Tue Mar 04, 2003 5:31 pm

Agree with DavidB

Report a concern about this post

Post by Geordieed »

:D It is ironic how we all dance the elements of DWAS when we are out doing our social dancing. For many it is what we do most of the time and are not locked away practising for a competition. Even when dancers practise at a social gathering they will have a break with their partner to dance with someone else.

No one seems to have found the ideal way to incorporate are basic dance habits in this country to one of the growing competitions.
Lounge Lizard
Senior Member
Posts: 1435
Joined: Tue Aug 05, 2003 11:00 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by Lounge Lizard »

Originally posted by DavidB
BUT...
All this assumes the DWAS is a serious category, and in just about all the events it is run as a fun category. If it is run just for fun, then the tapping on the shoulder can add to the fun element. Give each judge 2 'taps' and wait for the last judge to be running around the floor trying to find someone to tap...

However I would like to see one event where there is a DWAS category run as a serious competition - after all it has to be the true test of 'lead and follow' dancing.

David
I agree it is also the most popular and probably the most lucrative - Say 100 dancers x £6 with no prize money!!!
User avatar
Sheepman
Senior Member
Posts: 3687
Joined: Wed May 14, 2003 4:52 pm
Contact:

Report a concern about this post

Post by Sheepman »

Originally posted by Divissima
Mark Harding tried a new system this year which involved judging the leaders and followers separately with each round having three one-minute excerpts from different songs and having to rotate to a new partner within the heat for each song. . . . Once you got into the final, you were then judged as a couple for the places.
Not quite a new system, as Hipsters did competitions (both modern jive, and Lindy) in September 2002 using this format. (Except that you had a couple of complete records to dance to, each with different partners). (I also proposed a similar format to LeJive round about 1995). The Hipsters comps. were definitely all about having fun, with audience members being asked their views.


Greg
With one hand the past moves us forward, with the other it holds us back.
DavidB
Senior Member
Posts: 2263
Joined: Wed Feb 20, 2002 12:00 pm

Report a concern about this post

Post by DavidB »

Originally posted by Divissima
Mark Harding tried a new system this year which involved judging the leaders and followers separately with each round having three one-minute excerpts from different songs and having to rotate to a new partner within the heat for each song. Anyone who had danced with their new partner on a regular basis was asked to declare the interest and was swapped to a new partner. Once you got into the final, you were then judged as a couple for the places.
This got discussed last year on this board. The general opinion seemed to be that it might take the fun out of it. I'm starting to think that if the DWAS is a fun event, then you keep it simple as possible. Swapping partners might be nice for a more serious DWAS.

It was interesting to see a DWAS competition run like this in Australia. It seemed to work pretty well, but they had done it before at a different competition. The only glitch seemed to be what 'regular partner' meant. One couple got switched because they both came from the UK!


On a slightly different track - how about a DWAS version of the Jive Masters? The audience judges the best man and lady, but you get separate prizes for
- the best man according the men
- the best man according the ladies
- the best lady according the men
- the best lady according the ladies

David
Gary
Senior Member
Posts: 347
Joined: Tue Nov 12, 2002 7:29 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by Gary »

Originally posted by Divissima
Just to add a thought about the Australian DWAS competition. ... Mark Harding tried a new system this year which involved judging the leaders and followers separately with each round having three one-minute excerpts from different songs and having to rotate to a new partner within the heat for each song.
Not a big deal, but I believe this system was first trialled by Deb Cantoni's LeBop comp last year.

I like the system -- I was very insecure about competing in the advanced category, but could tell myself that each partner I got would get two other shots at a "real" advanced dancer. Plus I got to dance with three groovy girls instead of one!

I believe the system could be made to work faster when folks get more used to the rotation. I also think that if you've got three rotations, it's probably not a big enough deal to worry about if one of them is with a regular partner, which would also speed things up.
Post Reply