Page 2 of 4
Re: Inadaquate Teaching Model?
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 6:49 pm
by Little Monkey
MartinHarper wrote:Nod. Sometimes I try to counteract this by making my own hold looser, but I find that tends to make them grip harder themselves, as if to compensate for my "wimpiness". At the moment, I'm experimenting with using my thumb more to grip onto their hand. My theory is that this will give them confidence that I have a hold on them, and they'll find it easier to let go a little. I figure it's worth trying.
Nonononononono! No thumbs!!!
But I have had the same experience as you: Loosen your grip (or just lead using two fingers), and they crush your hands in an effort to hold on even harder...
I have tried demonstrating to ladies what it will be like for them to do a return under my arm, if I was to keep a tight grip on their hands, and have demonstrated how this will be quite painful. For some, this has been an "aha!!" experience, and they've tried to loosen up a bit. For others, it's just no use. Whatever you say, it seems to go in one ear, and come out the other, without registering in the brains department on the way through....
Mostly, though, I do find people tend to relax more as they get used to the dance and the signals, and gain some confidence!
LM
Re: Inadaquate Teaching Model?
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 7:01 pm
by Minnie M
Minnie M wrote:
Don't get into bad habits Martin,........(too lazy to search for the thread)[/I]
found it - make note of DavidB's post
http://www.cerocscotland.com/forum/show ... php?t=2705
Re: Avoiding pain.
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 7:25 pm
by Andreas
Gus wrote:HOWEVER my main point, as yet unanswered, is what is going fundamentally wrong that allows a preponderance of such dancing. I was speaking to some of the more experienced dancers over the last few weeks asking why they didn’t do lessons ... and the majority view was that they were fed up with dancers in the line pulling them around (male and female). Having spent a weekend workshop working on lead and follow I know how difficult it is to break these bad habits ... but why so allegedly intelligent people start with such habits in the first place?
I find two explanations for that:
1) Teachers - you have a bouncy teacher, you will get bouncy pupils. The teacher may not actually bounce as much as the punters but nonetheless he/she gives the example and the parrots copy it. In my opinion this is no doubt the main reason for it. So your question should be 'how come somebody teaches with bouncy legs or hands'?
2) People are getting carried away. They just enjoy themselves so much that the only way to rid themselves of this excess energy is to put as much body action into it as possible. We all know that moving your hands to music is the most simple way to express your 'connection' to it.
Obviously these are my 'explanations' and opinions may differ
Regarding the pretzel, I don't do that move even in single execution with anybody who bounces as it used to really cock up my shoulders in the past ... during classes
Ladies who lead strongly in most cases will not enjoy dancing with me because I only do a handful of very simply moves just to protect myself.
Re: Avoiding pain.
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 8:17 pm
by drathzel
Andreas wrote:I find two explanations for that:
1) Teachers - you have a bouncy teacher, you will get bouncy pupils. The teacher may not actually bounce as much as the punters but nonetheless he/she gives the example and the parrots copy it. In my opinion this is no doubt the main reason for it. So your question should be 'how come somebody teaches with bouncy legs or hands'?.
I have recently encountered this, it was not bouncy but showy and the ladies and men tried to do this, making a complete balls up of it because they are only new! There should be a standard way of teaching (not all teachers have to freestyle this way but it would benefit the beginners specially, leting them develope their own style, as opposed to one enforced on them that may not suit them)
Andreas wrote:
Ladies who lead strongly in most cases will not enjoy dancing with me because I only do a handful of very simply moves just to protect myself.
This is probably the best thing to do for you, not always the follow but to save yourself anyway!

Re: Inadaquate Teaching Model?
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 8:51 pm
by Gadget
Little Monkey wrote:Nonononononono! No thumbs!!!

no thumbs.
But I have had the same experience as you: Loosen your grip (or just lead using two fingers), and they crush your hands in an effort to hold on even harder...
OK,
here I would use my thumb: to dissengage the lady's grip. I use my index finger as the contact point for the lead: the rest of my fingers can be used to slip free or pry myself loose.
I also think that as leads improve, they learn to lead lighter and dance with more ladies of a better standard who follow with a feather touch. They have fewer dances with 'true beginners' and like them less because they don't respond as well and some of the leads they ignore force the lead somewhere they didn't want to be. This leads to fewer dances with beginers, only dancing with better dancers and their lead hones to a fine artist's brush from the stubby stipple-brush beginnings. Since it so now so fine and delicate, it is more fragile and suceptable to damage.
Those of us who dance with everyone of every ability develop a more "chinese paintbrush" technique than the delicate porcelain artwork brushes with two or three hairs. {I
think the anology works...

}
Re: Inadaquate Teaching Model?
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 10:16 pm
by Little Monkey
Gadget wrote: This leads to fewer dances with beginers, only dancing with better dancers and their lead hones to a fine artist's brush from the stubby stipple-brush beginnings. Since it so now so fine and delicate, it is more fragile and suceptable to damage.
Those of us who dance with everyone of every ability develop a more "chinese paintbrush" technique than the delicate porcelain artwork brushes with two or three hairs. {I
think the anology works...

}
How long did it take you to come up with this analogy, then? Had me in stitches!
So...... When referring to "Chinese paintbrush" technique..... What did you have in mind? Calligraphy brushes? Potter's decoration brushes? Obviously you didn't mean silk brushes.......?
Rather amused LM

Re: Inadaquate Teaching Model?
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 11:09 pm
by Gadget
I was thinking on those big 'tear-drop' shaped ones that the large canvases are inked with - bigger than a caligraphy brush. See, it all depends on the pressure - more pressure, thicker strokes, light pressure, thinner strokes fo finer detail.
{:sulk: I still think it works as an anology

}
Re: Inadaquate Teaching Model?
Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2005 11:36 pm
by MartinHarper
I'm feeling in a (long-winded, boring) mathematical mood, so... Suppose the level of grip is a number from 0-10, where:
0 = air leading
1 = fingertip leading
5 = mild discomfort
8 = pain
10 = torture
My aim point is to have my grip around 2, for Ceroc, or around 3 for JazzJive. Sometimes I dance with follows who are gripping me with a strength of 6 or so. I'm assuming that they're concerned that they'll "lose" my hand. I find that often, if I try to loosen my own grip down to 0-1, then they react by gripping harder - perhaps a 7, or even an 8. Perhaps this is because they subjectively feel me "slipping away"?
My theory is, if I increase my own grip strength to, say, a 4, then this will reassure them that I'm not going anywhere, and they will reduce their own grip strength to around 4. Avoiding discomfort and pain! *grin* It's just a theory, mind - I need to play around with it more to try to figure out what the variables are, and try to get a more coherent model of what's going on. Still, I'm quietly confident.
Obviously the long term fix is to improve the quality of my lead. That will mean that beginners will have much more confidence in my ability to control them with mere fingertips, their fear and anxieties will evaporate, and they will instantly follow with grace and style. That's won't happen overnight. Until then, it's a choice between:
A) Suffer pain. I'm selfish. Nope.
B) Not dance with folks who grip on. I was a beginner once. Nope.
C) Thumbs. Yeah baby, yeah!
Also, the forum clearly needs an Austin Powers smiley.
Re: Inadaquate Teaching Model?
Posted: Thu Feb 24, 2005 12:18 am
by ChrisA
Gus wrote:If so ... what is so wrong with our teaching that we are allowing this to happen?
Lots of things, not all the teachers' fault, although some of it is:
- mostly, little is said about technique in the average MJ class.
- even if it's mentioned at all, it's usually in a gentle, easily-missed, don't ruffle feathers, kind of way
- by the time anything much in the way of L&F is actually taught, bad habits are so ingrained that it's virtually impossible to remove them
- people, especially the ones that have been dancing a couple of years or more are mostly very unreceptive to feedback. Doubtless everyone here is different, but I don't think we're all that representative.
- it's hard to give the sort of feedback that would actually result in change, because it would require the ability to articulate exactly what was wrong, and what needed to change. This risks confrontation, which most people are averse to. And regrettably, whereas there are many teachers that teach well from the stage, the skillset required to change an individual's dancing is different, and rarer, IMHO.
It's not an easy problem to solve, and when you add into the equation most organisers' desire to get and keep the dancing equivalent of 'bums on seats', and their fear of alienating the people who don't want to know that they're painful to dance with, maybe it's not surprising that it hasn't been solved yet.
I've solved it for myself - I don't dance with people that hurt me anymore. But that's not really answering your question
Chris
Re: Inadaquate Teaching Model?
Posted: Thu Feb 24, 2005 12:39 am
by MartinHarper
Chef wrote:The worst thing is coming up against people who have been dancing regularly for years and are still no better than the people that are doing their first 6 classes.
No it isn't.
The worst thing is being on someone's "avoid at all costs" list. Not knowing why. When all you had to do was take your jewelry off. The worst thing is going to ask someone for a dance. And finding that as soon as they see you coming, they run off to the other side of the room; refuse to make eye contact; pretend they can't hear you; desperately ask someone, anyone, for a dance first.
The worst thing is wanting to dance with a great dancer. But you never seem to be in the right place to ask them. And they never ask you. And they might have. But your rock step was too big. And nobody told you. And you've been coming to regular weekly lessons for years. And the teacher's never mentioned it. Because they were scared it might put you off. And they find footwork is too hard to teach.
The worst thing is going to a dance, and seeing someone who is dancing their socks off. And knowing that they're not doing it for fun; not doing it to make their partner happy; just to deter you from ever asking them. The worst thing is being a slow learner. And being treated like it's deliberate. As if every night you pray to god - "please grant me poor balance and awareness of my body. There's a natural dancer at my local venue, who learnt real quickly, and I want to rub their face in how gifted they are".
Bah. It must be getting late. So much bitterness. And so wrong to take it out on Chef. He's just saying what lots of other people think. So carry on with your clever techniques to avoid dancing with incompetents, without having to face the horror of actually refusing a dance. Just, do me one favour, if it's not too much to ask. Don't complain about how tough it is, being a good dancer.
Thanks.
Posted: Thu Feb 24, 2005 1:05 am
by johnthehappyguy
MartinHarper wrote:....
The worst thing is being on someone's "avoid at all costs" list. Not knowing why.....
Martin,
Your post sounds really despondent.
There is a good dancer at one of the venues I go to regularly who has refused me a dance on several occaisons, I have danced with her friends who are of a similar standard to her, and they have, without prompting complimented me on my dancing. So her refusals are a bit of a mystery.
I feel I am in a similar position to yourself. I am planning to bite the bullet, and ask her why not ?
What is the worst that can happen ?
On a similar vein, but this time with a happier outcome:-
There is a good dancer who I had danced with about 5 times, she looks like a goddess etc. and the dances were just ok.
The next time I asked her, she, as previously; accepted, and I said, "will you do me a favour, I feel that we don't dance very well together, and i am not sure why, will you give me some feedback after the dance please."
This question ( which was not answered in words) seemed to break a spell, and we immediately danced a lot better, and have done so at least 6 times since.
Give it a try
johnthehappyandoptimisticguy

Re: Avoiding pain.
Posted: Thu Feb 24, 2005 8:50 am
by Andreas
johnthehappyguy wrote:I feel I am in a similar position to yourself. I am planning to bite the bullet, and ask her why not ?
Don't. There are a number of reasons why people create their 'avoid at all cost' lists. It is rude and should not be rewarded but submissiveness. You will give her the feeling of power if you confront her as it shows that you desperately wish to dance with her. Why? As you said, her friends are of similar standard and they DO dance with you. Point is, there are so many dancers out there that would love to dance with you. Why waste your time and energy on somebody who is not worth it? Just imagine you get the ilusionary dance with her and walk off the dance floor thinking 'what a waste of time'? Just ignore her.
In the past a girl has avoided me after a while for two reasons: because she was scared me doing too advanced moves (when in fact most of them were low leve Intermediate but she jumped straight into advanced being the gf of a teacher) and secondly because when she asked me what she should improve I told her. Too big ego I guess. So while I did enjoy dancing with her, I stopped asking because it was just going to be a waste of time.
Re: Inadaquate Teaching Model?
Posted: Thu Feb 24, 2005 8:58 am
by Gadget
MartinHarper wrote:So carry on with your clever techniques to avoid dancing with incompetents, without having to face the horror of actually refusing a dance. Just, do me one favour, if it's not too much to ask. Don't complain about how tough it is, being a good dancer.

This thread was heading rapidly down the "eliteism" road - praising the virtues of having a select few dancers that you dance with. Personally, I don't care if you want to shun the rest of the dancing populous: it gives me a broader selection of dancers to choose from and improve with.
I'm not saying "Go ye and seek yonder ladies with arms of steel and wills of iron". I'm not condoning forcefull following or purposfully putting yourself in harms way: just that if you find yourself in this sort of situation, don't hold your tounge to complain about it later - fix it.

Re: Avoiding pain.
Posted: Thu Feb 24, 2005 9:26 am
by Zuhal
I have a theory about this.
A huge number of men have been introduced to dancing through the Modern Jive model and because they can enjoy themselves without too much effort they come back week after week. If you watch them, a very large percentage do not dance in time with the music and do not provide a clear lead.
What therefore is a poor lady supposed to do. Many of them are highly effective at recognising the start of classic move and then finishing it. OF COURSE. THEY HAVE TO.
I kid myself that I can lead so it always takes the first dance to control someone and give them the confidence that you know what you doing. As time goes on the lead can get lighter and lighter.
A much higher percentage of ladies dance with the music. Most of them are willing to be led but face sad disappointment with every new face.
Zuhal
Re: Avoiding pain.
Posted: Thu Feb 24, 2005 9:28 am
by Gadget
Andreas wrote:Don't.
Do.
There are a number of reasons why people create their 'avoid at all cost' lists. It is rude and should not be rewarded but submissiveness.
Yes]You will give her the feeling of power if you confront her as it shows that you desperately wish to dance with her. Why?[/i]
No, it will give you the feeling of power because you are simply asking why she refuses to dance with you; curiosity. After the answer, you can sinply say "thank you for your opinion" and move to another dancer, or "really? let's see what I can do to fix that" and take her onto the floor. It shows that you are wanting to improve your dancing, not that you have any particular interest in dancing with her.
As you said, her friends are of similar standard and they DO dance with you. Point is, there are so many dancers out there that would love to dance with you. Why waste your time and energy on somebody who is not worth it?
But everyone is worth it. If you can gleam knowledge to make even more dancers love to dance with you, then where's the fault? The ones that already do dance with you may see an improvement and want to dance more.
Just imagine you get the ilusionary dance with her and walk off the dance floor thinking 'what a waste of time'? Just ignore her.

I don't think I have
ever came off the dance floor thinking that. I hope I never will. Do not ignore her; use her to sound out her opinion of your dancing - You don't need to take everything on-board, but it may give you an idea of an area to concentrate on.
In the past a girl has avoided me after a while for two reasons: because she was scared me doing too advanced moves (when in fact most of them were low leve Intermediate but she jumped straight into advanced being the gf of a teacher)
Did you dance with her in the past; when she was just starting? If so, you may have used moves too advanced for her to follow well or feel comfortable with - If it was me, I would try and tone down the moves I do with beginners, if I do a more 'advanced' move, I would praise any good following and finish with nice, easy beginner moves to restore confidence and a familure base.
and secondly because when she asked me what she should improve I told her. Too big ego I guess.
From this, if it were me, I would try and improve my tact. Perhaps only concentrate on one thing and get them to improve on that. Once it's taken in, move to something else. Don't just say "well, you do this, this and that when you should be doing the other... and you shouldn't do that.. .and should do this... and... and..."
So while I did enjoy dancing with her, I stopped asking because it was just going to be a waste of time.
How? You didn't want to see if any suggestions made actually worked? You deny yourself the enjoyment of a dance with her?
Tit-for-tat philosophy is not condusive to a friendly atmosphere or enjoyable night. You need to get out of London and up north.

Re: Inadaquate Teaching Model?
Posted: Thu Feb 24, 2005 9:34 am
by ChrisA
MartinHarper wrote:The worst thing is being on someone's "avoid at all costs" list. Not knowing why.
There can be few people who have someone on their "avoid at all costs" list without good reason. If it's that bad to be on it, how much worse can it be to ask why?
The worst thing is wanting to dance with a great dancer. But you never seem to be in the right place to ask them.
This is an easy problem to fix, but it requires determination and preparation. You have to be not dancing at the end of the previous track, you have to get in the right place. If someone is in demand and you want to dance with them you have to put some effort into it. Relying on chance is not enough.
And they never ask you. And they might have. But your rock step was too big. And nobody told you. And you've been coming to regular weekly lessons for years. And the teacher's never mentioned it. Because they were scared it might put you off. And they find footwork is too hard to teach.
Regular weekly lessons are not going to be enough. If you want to dance with a great dancer (other than just to bathe in a bit of reflected glory), you are probably also the type that wants to become a better dancer. Which requires effort. More than once a week, workshops, weekenders, seeking feedback, watching what others are doing, learning to monitor your own body to see what you are doing, maybe even private lessons if you want to improve enough.
The worst thing is going to a dance, and seeing someone who is dancing their socks off. And knowing that they're not doing it for fun]
I don't believe this happens to any significant extent. Ok, occasionally there may be a reason someone behaves vindictively towards someone else, but it is not the norm.
Mostly IMO it is exclusively in the mind of someone who feels bad about their own dancing, and is seeking to feel better by blaming someone else.
Don't complain about how tough it is, being a good dancer.
I have no idea what it's like to be a good dancer.
But it's certainly tough to try to become one.
Chris
Re: Avoiding pain.
Posted: Thu Feb 24, 2005 9:40 am
by ChrisA
Gadget wrote:
Do.
... big snip...
Tit-for-tat philosophy is not condusive to a friendly atmosphere or enjoyable night.
Very strongly agree with all this.
You need to get out of London and up north.
But not this.

Mostly people aren't like this anywhere, in my experience.
Chris
Re: Avoiding pain.
Posted: Thu Feb 24, 2005 9:45 am
by Hamish_A
Gus wrote:HOWEVER my main point, as yet unanswered, is what is going fundamentally wrong that allows a preponderance of such dancing. I was speaking to some of the more experienced dancers over the last few weeks asking why they didn’t do lessons ... and the majority view was that they were fed up with dancers in the line pulling them around (male and female). Having spent a weekend workshop working on lead and follow I know how difficult it is to break these bad habits ... but why so allegedly intelligent people start with such habits in the first place?
I know RobC at Fleet makes a point, during the repeat beginners class, to cover lead & follow, no thumbs etc etc. This means that for the first few weeks new dancers get taught that the death grip (from either side) is "A Bad Thing". It does not prevent some of them from picking up bad habits - but at least it reduces the number quite significantly. It also means that whenever I feel the need to comment on grip/lead & follow they have already heard it from a teacher & I'm just reminding them.
On a similar vein, it always amazes me when you get a guy who has been dancing <6 weeks who says to their partner who I know is excellent "Your really getting the hang of this" - or something in a similar vein - usually after crushing her fingers in every move. Usually, it seems, these are the guys who never really progress, so I guess it's a barrier they put up where they believe they already know what they are doing so switch off from learning. Personally , I'm still learning (just very slowly).
Personally I enjoy dancing with partners of every standard. I think that as a lead I get inspired by a great partner & enjoy helping beginners realise that "I can do this". I rarely get yanked around to the point of pain - although my fingers do get crushed occasionally. I have always been a proponent of definate low/high hand position which helps & If I have a partner who tries to lead then I throw in a few simple variations & they usually get the message. If not - then I'm quite happy to speak up in as diplomatic a way as I can manage.
Re: Avoiding pain.
Posted: Thu Feb 24, 2005 10:32 am
by Hamish_A
Zuhal wrote:I have a theory about this.
A huge number of men have been introduced to dancing through the Modern Jive model and because they can enjoy themselves without too much effort they come back week after week. If you watch them, a very large percentage do not dance in time with the music and do not provide a clear lead.l
Sad but true. It's much harder, usually, for the men to learn to dance to a good standard, just because (IMHO) they have to learn the moves & often their brains get overloaded with thinking about (hopefully), the move, timing, moving their feet, hand positions, what the lady is doing, what move will I do next. Like learning any new skill, until some parts of this become automatic it's hard to deal with it all and some part of it will just be plain wrong.
Zuhal wrote:What therefore is a poor lady supposed to do. Many of them are highly effective at recognising the start of classic move and then finishing it. OF COURSE. THEY HAVE TO.
I agree to some extent, but they should be careful if they can to not LEAD the man, just carry on the move without a lead, a subtle but distinct difference.
Re: Avoiding pain.
Posted: Thu Feb 24, 2005 10:33 am
by Lory
I'm going to put my own spanner in the works now! I don't think it's always to do with how well or clearly the moves are lead.
If I'm dancing with someone who's slightly out of time, I find this the hardest thing of all to cope with and 'I' probably feel like i'm fighting all the way!
I find it extremely hard to give into dancing out of time. (or to what I perceive as being the wrong timing

)
Also, some people interpret the music in slightly differently ways, if I was to choose a preference, I like a laid back partner, who drags each move out to the very last possible moment. I don't like dancing with men who are slightly ahead of the music (and they probably don't like dancing with me either!

)
Another point, Picking up from what ChrisA said...
I can clearly remember my first Ceroc lessons and going to the beginners review class, the particular Taxi men at that venue, lead VERY firmly, almost brutally and I thought this was the 'correct' way, I had no reason to question it, I had no bench mark with which to compare! And surely they were the experts after all?
So anyone learning with these men as examples, will probably learn to be rough too!
