Page 2 of 8
Posted: Tue Dec 16, 2003 1:46 pm
by Dave Hancock
Originally posted by Pammy
I don't know, but I volunteer to try and lead you next time 
Px
No offence Pammy, but I think Chris would learn far more about the lead and follow aspect if he danced the female part with a man leading. I appreciate that in other dances especially many of the tango classes in the UK that it is often a preferred teaching method to both learn to lead and to follow, but in MJ there is not normally such a crossover as both sexes tend to dance their traditional role for the majority of the time.
I would however partly qualify this by saying that I have been lead by some very good women especially Sheena and Lorna up here.
Posted: Tue Dec 16, 2003 1:57 pm
by ChrisA
Originally posted by Dave Hancock
No offence Pammy, but I think Chris would learn far more about the lead and follow aspect if he danced the female part with a man leading.
I was afraid of that.
Still, let's still give it a go, eh, Pamster?
Posted: Tue Dec 16, 2003 3:05 pm
by Mary
Originally posted by Pammy
I don't know, but I volunteer to try and lead you next time 
Px
I'd be up for it as well - but only if you demonstrate how you murmer 'no' in such a macho fashion
Pammy's a good lead and also The Tazmanian Devil if you ever get the chance.
M
Re: Re: Re: Re:Women anticipating/leading
Posted: Tue Dec 16, 2003 3:07 pm
by Lory
Originally posted by ChrisA
In my case, the key was realising that the problem lay with me, not with the ladies I was dancing with. I had a kind of "ok" dance once with someone, and came away with the impression that she wasn't a very good dancer.
A few minutes later I saw her dancing with someone else -- and she was awesome.
Chris
Chris, I don't think you are being fair on yourself, I've realised that some partners are just more compatable than others. We've all had it when we've seen a fantastic dancer, then danced with them and thought

Hmmm That didn't feel that good to me

I must be really bad because I can't follow them that well. and Visa Versa.
Luckily, I have a friend I go with regularly and we spend
ages on the way home, discussing who we danced with and who we liked best and why and we often choose different people. And the simple reason we like one more than another is because of the way they make
us feel about the way
we dance.
She likes a strong lead and to know she's done each move correctly, this gives her a sence of achievement, and she feels good about herself.
I like fun and i'm not too hung up on 'getting it right' all the time (which I KNOW drives some men MAD)(on the same token, it drives me nuts when a man takes it too seriously too)
So the lesson is, you
can't win all the time 
Posted: Tue Dec 16, 2003 3:14 pm
by TheTramp
Originally posted by ChrisA
How did the Trampster start off learning to be a follower, for instance?
I got Lydia to lead me a few times, and it just kinda carried on from there. Now I'll take anyone who's prepared to lead!!
Steve
Posted: Tue Dec 16, 2003 3:14 pm
by ChrisA
Originally posted by Mary
I'd be up for it as well - but only if you demonstrate how you murmer 'no' in such a macho fashion
I promise you it was firm, but not macho...
Anyway would I ever say "no" to you, Mster???

Posted: Tue Dec 16, 2003 3:17 pm
by Pammy
Originally posted by ChrisA
I was afraid of that. 
Still, let's still give it a go, eh, Pamster?
If you're up for it, who am I to say no!
Pamster
x
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re:Women anticipating/leading
Posted: Tue Dec 16, 2003 3:19 pm
by ChrisA
Originally posted by Lory
Chris, I don't think you are being fair on yourself, I've realised that some partners are just more compatable than others.
I'm sure this is true. But the lesson I needed to learn at that time was very real.
And I am quite certain that there are loads of guys out there that need to learn the same lesson.
it drives me nuts when a man takes it too seriously too)
I'm amazed you can stand to dance with me then
But it can be serious as well as fun - and at the same time.
Chris, multi-tasker, and a bloke

Posted: Tue Dec 16, 2003 3:43 pm
by Divissima
Chris, if you want to dance as follower, TwK would probably give you a go (he danced with Amir at Twyford on Saturday) - maybe at the tea dance on Sunday in the febrile atmosphere of Kent House... anything could happen

Posted: Tue Dec 16, 2003 3:47 pm
by ChrisA
Originally posted by Divissima
Chris, if you want to dance as follower, TwK would probably give you a go (he danced with Amir at Twyford on Saturday) - maybe at the tea dance on Sunday in the febrile atmosphere of Kent House... anything could happen
I spose if you will keep insisting on dancing with Bex, what choice do I have?
Probably won't be able to make this Sunday though

Posted: Tue Dec 16, 2003 3:50 pm
by Divissima
oh no!

when do I get my birthday dance, then??

Posted: Tue Dec 16, 2003 3:57 pm
by ChrisA
Posted: Tue Dec 16, 2003 3:59 pm
by Divissima
Sounds alright to me

Posted: Tue Dec 16, 2003 3:59 pm
by TheTramp
Posted: Tue Dec 16, 2003 4:01 pm
by Divissima
ooh - got anything planned for Saturday, Steve?

Posted: Tue Dec 16, 2003 4:17 pm
by TheTramp
Originally posted by Divissima
ooh - got anything planned for Saturday, Steve?
Yeah. And it's a lot closer than Twyford!
Would love to come down more often, but I'm a poor student now....
Of course, if you were going to Bognor in January.....!!
Steve
Re: Re: Tension between partners
Posted: Wed Dec 17, 2003 8:44 am
by horsey_dude
Originally posted by ChrisA
Which brings me to wonder, how do so many ladies learn to anticipate and even lead, so forcefully?
Last night at Twyford, a lady joined me in the class, about five minutes after the start. Despite having only watched from the side (maybe not even that), she seemed to think that she could lead it better than I could, and tried very hard (to do something other than the move being taught, naturally).
How do they get like this? Surely most of them don't like it - I can only imagine that it is learned behaviour. Is it encouraged by too much dancing with blokes that can't lead? If so, how do they cope with the frustration? Why do they still enjoy partner dancing at all?
Chris
I think it stems from trying to be helpful. Most people start in the beginner class and that means dancing with beginner men who are not going to be confident or sure of themselves. If every women only learned in classes where every male present was a teacher then it would not be common at all. The problem is that once you have learned a bad habit then it is very hard to unlearn....
Posted: Wed Dec 17, 2003 12:01 pm
by Lynn
Speaking as a beginner (who has snuck into the intermediate corner

) I find that I do sometimes anticipate moves with another beginner who is a weak lead, but not with a stronger lead (at least I hope not). Occasionally (with dancers I know well enough) I know what move they are wanting to do but their lead is suggesting a different move so I follow the lead instead (and usually explain that I was following the lead).
I would agree that having a weekly class but not much freestyle can result in this – dancing the routine rather than lead-follow. We have two types of dancers in the MJ class here, those new to dance – tend to dance the routine, and those who dance salsa – understand lead-follow.
If I get a move wrong I always apologise and say it was my follow and not their lead, but maybe that’s just me assuming it was me who messed up and trying to be polite, and maybe it isn’t always my fault?
So what should I do with those with a weak lead – or those who only dance the routine learnt in class that week and aren’t leading at all? I sometimes try to explain ‘if you do x then that lets me know you want me to move y’ (in a very nice way of course, not telling them off

). Is that OK?
I find this all very interesting, as my whole aim in learning dance has shifted in the past few weeks – from learning moves to learning to dance. Yes, basic stuff I know, and probably most people figure out that distinction in the first 3 weeks instead of 3 months, but I’ve got there now!

Posted: Wed Dec 17, 2003 12:07 pm
by Forte
Posted: Wed Dec 17, 2003 12:13 pm
by ChrisA
Originally posted by Lynn
If I get a move wrong I always apologise and say it was my follow and not their lead, but maybe that’s just me assuming it was me who messed up and trying to be polite, and maybe it isn’t always my fault?
It's most unlikely to be your fault. If you're dancing with beginners they haven't had time to learn to lead yet, and if you're dancing with more experienced dancers than yourself they shouldn't be leading you into moves that you can't follow.
To guarantee that it's always the guy's fault, just dance what he leads and nothing else. This will also give him feedback.
A wonderful taxi dancer said to me once, "I won't do anything if you don't lead me", and then proceeded to just stand there until I did.
I find this all very interesting, as my whole aim in learning dance has shifted in the past few weeks – from learning moves to learning to dance. Yes, basic stuff I know, and probably most people figure out that distinction in the first 3 weeks instead of 3 months, but I’ve got there now!
You're a fast learner. It took me three years to learn the difference.
Chris