I don't need rep, people - this one's on the house.
Ash wrote:You’re right if we look at this thing rationally….but will everything fit neatly into your template? The universe has many patterns that you and I don’t understand…synchronicity, for example, works for many people, even though it’s completely illogical.
I feel a Gus "Count to infinity" moment coming on...
"Synchronicity" is a completely subjective phenomenon, following on naturally from our search for meaning in the universe we live in - we make connections where none exist between phenomena that have no external relationship, simply because we naturally look for patterns in everything.
I personally have found some meaning to life, but I'm not going to bang on about it, and I certainly didn't find it easily, quickly, or through an "Open mind to everything" approach. I had to work at it, doing this crazy thinking thing.
The specific "Tecumseh's Curse" post referred to a phenomenon which I personally believe to be less-than-massively improbable. I dunno the exact probabilities (David F, wanna give it a try?), but certainly it's way more likely than, say, the 5% level which mathematicians would class as "unlikely".
Ash wrote:I think the skeptics always make a schoolboy error when they compare ‘science’ and ‘mysticism’:
Great, do I get to wear a uniform?
Ash wrote:It’s like a poet trying to understand nuclear physics, for example, without changing his mode of thinking.
If you think you can make progress in nuclear physics without imagination and, yes, poetry, you're nuts. I resent your consistent implication that people who happen to work in scientific areas lack poetry, creativity or imagination. Or indeed that people working in creative areas lack discipline, rigour and pragmatism. I feel you want to put us all into "logical and boring" or "creative and interesting" boxes, and I profoundly disagree with such categorisation.
Humans are complex and comprehensive creatures, we're capable of simultaneous rationality and poetry. Or in other words, we're smart enough to fart and chew gum at the same time.
Ash wrote: (The skeptics can’t seem to grasp this basic concept.) For organic thought you need to be able to combine ‘logic’ and ‘intuition’.
I'd agree, but I'd also say this is an essential requirement for any progress in any field of study. Maths and logic only take you so far]Of course it is….just like arguing against UFOs, ghosts, ESP, mediumship, the after-life etc...if you’re trying to compare apples and oranges…[/QUOTE]
Out of interest, is there
any "mystical" phenomenon you don't believe in? In other words, how high / low is your belief barrier? Obviously, it's lower than mine, but I'd like to know where you draw the line and say "Nahh, that's clearly loony territory".
Ash wrote:Astrology is a diagnostic tool, rather than the final word. When people have their Saturn return, for example, they go through a big change between 28-30 years of age. (This is connected with the orbit of Saturn around the birthchart which takes about 29.5 years.) So everybody isn’t going to have big changes at the same time-but will be susceptible/prone/open to them between those ages.
Boy, it's not exactly a major test to predict that someone in a Western culture will have many life changes towards the end of their 20's - it's when lots of people settle down, get a house, get married, have kids... It's like saying they'll have life changes when they're 18. Colour me unsurprised, and s
keptical as to the infuence of Saturn in all that.
Ash wrote:There’s no official ‘white-man’ source
No]anywhere [/B]until a (white!) book published in 1934. That's why I said there's no 19th century source. And yes, 19th century sources tend to have to be written rather than remembered, it being nearly 200 years ago.
And, just in case I was ambiguous, let me put it another way:
- THERE'S NO SOURCE.
Ash wrote: Whatever the merits of the story the pattern is actually consistent.
But if the story is bull, why even look for a pattern? Even if a pattern existed (which it doesn't), without some explanation for it you've got nothing to work on...
Ash wrote:The 2000 winner was elected around the conjunction of an earth sign. Bush is vulnerable…
You're not going to get around me by raising my hopes up you know...
Possibly not - but that quote is, as David F said, a reply from, well, a nutter basically - the text at the top of that section saying
"Postscript: On 3 May 2001, Laura Ramsey sent me an interesting email in response to this page:" was maybe a bit of a giveaway.
But because I'm nice, kind, and at one with the flow of the universe, I'll assume you missed that part of it, and this was a genuine mistake on your part.
(Another quote from The Nutter:
"My father had a prophetic dream about the assassination attempt. There was an elephant standing on a body of water and a beach to his right. The right side of the elephant was visible. On the beach were silouettes of break dancers and in the back ground that appeared to be cliffs, were actually condos. One of the guys on the beach got angry and hit the elephant so hard it put a hole in his left side. My brother interpreted it partially but full understanding came after the attempt on Reagans life."
That brightened up my day - I especially liked the break dancers...)