Page 8 of 8

Re: Tension between partners

Posted: Wed Sep 22, 2004 5:16 pm
by bigdjiver
Re: Tension between partners
bigdjiver wrote: I am in favour of the majority, if not all, of the taxi dancers being female, and concentrating on the males, especially trying to split up couples. At my local venue there are many guys who will give a beginner lady a good dance.

Gadget wrote: :what: Not at my venue thank you!
- there are always more lady beginners than men] Maybe we are very fortunate at our local venue, but we have many dancers who, on other nights, are demos or taxi dancers. If the taxi dancers whisk off the guys, then the ladies are free for asking. This is especially important for beginner couples who are not used to MJ dance culture. They sometimes think that other men are trying to hit on the woman, and are reluctant to accept invitations from outside. As you pointed out, the Taxi dancer has an implicit authority to persuade the beginner to dance. As men tend to be more reluctant, I am still of the opinion that they should use that authority to concentrate on the men.

The taxi dancers are told to take the beginners through the class, which tends to encourage the ladies into the "learn the move" mode. The other leads can introduce them to freestyle, and following.

I find that some beginner ladies are convinced that they cannot do it in the class, because they cannot follow the teacher on the stage, and are prone to make an early exit, often never to return. If they are persuaded to dance, and can follow, it may make a difference.

Taxi dancers do tend to be business bent, though they do try and have fun too. A normal dancer who sees that the lady is going to have difficulties with the dancing, can concentrate on the social side of things, and may persuade a doubter to give it another chance, just for the fun aspect.

Re: Tension between partners

Posted: Wed Sep 22, 2004 5:35 pm
by ChrisA
Gadget wrote:Then the experienced guys have to dance with beginners all through the lesson and never get a chance to improve on the nuances of leading the moves.
Of course they do. Leading beginners who have no idea where to go is a very good way of refining a lead. Another is dancing with a follower that is so good that she follows everything the guy does, including the unintentional stuff. But that presupposes that the guy is sensitive enough to be aware of both what she's doing, and why.

In any case, the experienced guys will have all sorts of other opportunities to do more complicated stuff with experienced followers.
The beginner ladies get used to a good lead and don't know what to do with a bad one, or how to cope with being led wrong.
Quite so, and a good thing too. That way they never learn to anticipate or lead when the guy should be leading.
The experienced ladies have to put up with being led all over the place all the time and don't get a chance to develop their following skills.
By "experienced", I mean ladies that are already good followers, that don't need to do beginners classes to learn how to follow. They put up with it out of the goodness of their hearts, and tell the guys immediately if they're yanking or pulling them in the wrong direction.
The beginner guys get used to ladies just flowing where they lead and get no experience of 'wrestling' with a beginner lady.
Another damn good thing too, IMHO. Wrestling on the dancefloor is completely undesirable. (except if it's a cabaret, between two girls in bikinis covered in oil :devil: ).

In fact, if the beginner ladies have all learned to follow in conjunction with dancing with experienced guys, they'll never be wrestling in the first place.

Chris

Re: Tension between partners

Posted: Thu Sep 23, 2004 8:16 am
by Gadget
ChrisA wrote:{....}In fact, if the beginner ladies have all learned to follow in conjunction with dancing with experienced guys, they'll never be wrestling in the first place.
But now you are dictating that during a beginner lessons, only the 'advanced' can dance with the 'beginners': How many "advanced" people currently take part in the beginner lessons? How many would you loose due to "I came here to dance, not to be told who I can/cannot dance with"? How many would say "no, I'm not risking injuring myself"?

You are also generating a segrigation problem: you would now have "Begginers" and "advanced" dancers. Who judges who should be in which group? How can it be policed? Just now it is seen to be that no matter how good you are, you are doing the same lesson as complete novices: ataining this level seems more approachable.

In preventing beginner leads and followers from dancing together you are also isolating the men who have been brought by their partners, you are preventing shared comradeship that develops when people learn together and make mistakes together.

In my opinion, this may make logical and technical sense; but socially and emotionally it strikes too many dischords - and MJ is more a social dance than a technical dance.

Re: Tension between partners

Posted: Thu Sep 23, 2004 8:55 am
by ChrisA
Gadget wrote:But now you are dictating that .... generating a segrigation problem .... who judges ... How can it be policed? ... also isolating the men ...strikes too many dischords - and MJ is more a social dance than a technical dance.
For heavens sake, Gadj, get back in your box - I'm not dictating anything, and neither am I advocating a wholescale restructuring of the whole MJ world!!! :flower:

I originally said
ChrisA wrote:from the point of view of accelerated learning, the "stick beginners in a class together and expect them to learn to dance" format is highly inefficient.
and also
ChrisA wrote: Probably not practical though.

I know perfectly well there are other considerations than just learning to dance well.

Chill, dude, everything's still Ok :flower: :hug: You'll still be able to wrestle with beginners for as long as you like :devil:

Chris

Re: Tension between partners

Posted: Thu Sep 23, 2004 9:47 am
by Gadget
ChrisA wrote:You'll still be able to wrestle with beginners for as long as you like :devil:
Glad I have your approval { :D :wink: :devil: }

Re: Tension between partners

Posted: Thu Sep 23, 2004 10:00 am
by MartinHarper
On the other hand, according to an article I read:
http://www.howtojive.com/spotlight-ceroc.htm
In Ceroc's early days there were no formal dance classes. A group of taxi dancers (the girls in full, taffeta skirts and the boys wearing white jeans and shirts) were on hand to help beginners.
So ChrisA's radical new vision of how to teach Ceroc is apparently very similar to how it got going in the first place. Learning to dance by actually dancing? It'll never catch on... :)

Re: Why do women anticipate moves?

Posted: Fri Sep 24, 2004 11:05 pm
by Leo
My dear friend

There will always be ladies out there who refuse to be led , it's just one of those things. But for the worst offenders who really get up your nostrills and tug on your nasil hairs there are a few moves that will catch them completely off guard. they won't be able to anticipate and will (maybe for the first time) break the mould and go with the flow.

Here is an example of one such move I use alot myself on beginners who really will not give up the lead and follow...

Re: Why do women anticipate moves?

Posted: Sat Sep 25, 2004 2:15 pm
by under par
Leo wrote:My dear friend
Here is an example of one such move I use alot myself on beginners who really will not give up the lead and follow...
We could do with a few more moves like this...

but seriously I do use a couple of moves with anticipators that will catch them out a little.

And to help cover their mild embarrasment :flower: I offer them a fig leaf of advice in there ear and then try to lead with only fingertips for as long I can keep it going. :whistle:

You can then see the look of extreme concentration :eek:

a little less anticipating often occurs :yeah:

Re: Tension between partners

Posted: Mon Sep 27, 2004 10:18 pm
by MartinHarper
a more humane alternative?
Well... I think I have one. I frequently lead the wrong thing anyway, either due to my spectacular inability to remember what order the teacher has called the moves in, or due to my general inability to lead clearly. About 5% of the time, my partner will actually pick up on this and follow my lead. As someone else noted, we guys always get grumpy when this happens, because nobody likes to mess up, and I'm no exception. However, now I make an effort to also say something along the lines of:
*grumble to self, facing ground*
"... but hey - you followed what I lead!"
*face up, eyes light up, big grin*
"That's great! I mean, that means we were actually dancing. Wow!"
Due to the rareness of ladies in classes actually following, all that's entirely sincere: it's just that previously my mind only got onto the plus points after several minutes of grumbling...

The other humane method I am developing for the future is my response to the frequent MJ questions "got it yet?" and "how long have you been dancing?". Previously I had answered honestly, but I now discover from this forum that this is in fact subtle female code for "would you like me to backlead you?". Thus, the conversation now goes more like...
"Have you..."
"Yes!"
"... got... it?"
"Definately. And its eight variations. Though to be fair I'm still working on putting Nina's salsa style into the reverse blues whirligig"

Or alternatively "How long have you been dancing?"
"Five years. Of course, that's not including former lives."
(no one ever admits to dancing for more than five years anyway)

Re: Tension between partners

Posted: Mon Sep 27, 2004 11:20 pm
by Gadget
MartinHarper wrote:Or alternatively "How long have you been dancing?"
"Five years. Of course, that's not including former lives."
(no one ever admits to dancing for more than five years anyway)
I thought it was four! eh tramp? :)

Why do women anticipate moves in freestyle?

Posted: Wed Feb 09, 2005 12:42 am
by MartinHarper
Comments elsewhere made me wonder about the causes of inadvertant anticipation in freestyle, and I came to this thread looking for ideas. I think Amir has expressed one issue very well:
Amir wrote:Try to read the following sentence and do not finish it even in your head

"The quick brown fox jumped over the lazy..."

You probably immediately completed the sentence in your head and thought 'dog.' It could have been cat, stone or anything, but if you think you recognize something, you automatically complete it. It takes a lot of training and concentration not to.
I guess I'd call this habit formation. I know that it's popular to always blame the leader, but it seems to me that this is one of the cases where it's chiefly something for the women to work on. I'm not saying that all anticipation is the result of habits, mind.

Re: Why do women anticipate moves?

Posted: Wed Feb 16, 2005 8:59 pm
by Commis Chef
One of the reasons is that during lessons women often pick up the move quicker and as they circulate they come across men who ask for help. Learning the move means they know what to expect.

I think there should be lessons just for men to learn how to lead clearly who are then returned to the women to test if they can actually lead the move they have just learnt when the woman does not know what to expect.

I admit to leading in two circumstances;

1 When the man is completely out of time it is instinctive to try to return him to some sort of timing.
2 When it is a tune with wonderful stops and interpretations and the man dances through all of it I try to influence the flow to hint at how I would like to interpret the music. I would not do it to beginners but some who should know better by the length of time they have been dancing.

I know it may confuse and it is just the devil coming out.

Re: Why do women anticipate moves?

Posted: Wed Feb 16, 2005 9:47 pm
by Yogi_Bear
Commis Chef wrote: I admit to leading in two circumstances]No, that would be a really good approach and I would endorse it fully. From the perspective of a leader it can be really frustrating to be working with the music, looking for breaks, hesitations and interesting things to do and to get entirely the wrong sort of reaction, even from fairly experienced dancers, along the lines of "You stopped", or "What am I supposed to do now?"..