Baruch wrote:I'm with you on this. I've been taught basic footwork ever since I started Le Roc, so it's not an added burden for me. You get used to it quickly. I do think sometimes it looks better if you step back on a certain foot, e.g. mirroring your partner when doing a first move, and if you learn footwork from the start you don't have to unlearn any bad habits later on when you're improving.
I have no argument with the above, and agree that some footwork looks better than others in some circumstances, but in most cases footwork is a style point rather than an absolute necessary. You (and Lou) obviously survived / enjoyed the challenge, but what about the dozens of people who are / were truly ackward and self conscious about their feet? Forcing them to learn footwork, when they would be perfectly able to learn to dance and have a great time without it seems a shame to me!
Some people start at classes and are naturals, they do fancy footwork and follow / lead well from the start.
Others struggle to learn even the basics, but somehow get motivated and work hard at it.
Some struggle, are put off and don't come back. For them, the fun, inspirational element of dancing *had* to come first.
For all the above footwork and other style and technical aspects can be learned at a later date, when they are ready for it!
Baruch wrote:In reply to Franck, though, in Cardiff we do learn triple steps, columbians etc in the beginners' class occasionally. Generally the rest of the beginner moves will be relatively easy ones though, and the teachers usually make it clear that the trickier move is more for improvers than beginners. I guess the theory is that it makes the step up to intermediate easier.
That completely baffles me I must admit, there is a huge difference between introducing beginners to step back on (left / right) foot and teaching them the above fancy variations.
I also don't think this is a Leroc / Ceroc difference as most of the Leroc classes I am aware of, hardly ever teach any footwork at all. It is more likely to be an 'individual teacher' influence. Probably one or two of your local teachers are good at and love footwork and started teaching more and more of it.
To be clear, I don't mean that you cannot teach footwork to complete Beginners, any good teacher should be able to do so, I am only questioning the necessity and benefits of doing so... There are many really good dancers I know who would probably never have made it that far if having 2 left feet was a problem. In the long term, I see no evidence that teaching footwork produced better / more technical dancers either. There will be as many good dancers in Bristol say as in Edinburgh, Aberdeen etc... (Dundee notwithstanding as it is the centre of the dancing universe

)
Lou wrote:Although I'm quite disappointed that I received an anonymous neg rep for that post. I wish that person had posted their viewpoint instead, as I'm always open to a good debate.
Just to correct you there Lou, you never got any negative reputation, just a neutral reputation (I believe it was meant as a positive one) by someone who hasn't posted enough to give plus or minus points. So you can relax, everyone loves you still

Franck.
There's an A.P.P. for that!