Something similar was debated on another thread and I have to agree withthe view that most, if not all, really great dancers on te jive scene probably have natural ability but have become as good as they are through very hard work.
DavidB has indicated how much time he and Lily spend before competitions and he would also argue that he's not a 'natural' and has had to work to be as good as he is. He might be the exception that proves the rule.
Unfortunately, the vast majority of cerocers/ jivers will never have the time to be as good as they really could be because of work/family/ social commitments and I agree with Adam that most folk are happy to dance and have a social night out. Even most folk who compete know they won't win but do it for fun.
Teachers can make a difference but you can teach a 'natural' dancer how to break, how to perfect moves etc but if someone has no real ability or rhythm they can learn how it should be done but find it very difficult to hear the breaks in a song when freestyling.
I've seen and danced with some really lovely and very good dancers all over the country and would categorise many of the women as very good but the 'greats' would still be the likes of Lily, Nina, Viktor, Nigel etc...... And yes they all work very hard at dancing but I'd argue that they were already naturally gifted and so the hard work pays real dividends.
I could practice 20 hours a week and although I'd learn mvoes and polish my technique I'd never ever come close to men like Viktor, Nigel, Dan .......... I don't have the time, my partner lives over 100 miles away and I know I'd never reach that level. But at least we can all keep doing the best we can and having fun - still the most important part of dancing
