Not really - some of them had, but most of them hadn't. Any peace overtures were feeble, halhearted and less-than-trustworthy, and the USA weren't going to accept anything less than total surrender.Barry Shnikov wrote:I specifically disavow the use of nuclear weapons in Japan, as in my view a substantial portion of the rationale does not stand up to scrutiny.
1. The allies war aim was 'unconditional surrender'. The Japanese had been seeking 'surrender providing we get to keep the emperor' for some months.
The head of Japan's government, Admiral Suzuki Kantaro, had a basic policy of, and I quote, the "honorable death of the hundred million" instead of surrendering. Even by the end of June, they were hoping for a negotiated surrender on their own terms - mainly relying on the casualties that the invasions of the Home Islands would generate as a negotiating tool.
Given the mentality of the ruling regime in both Germany and Japan, they both had to be comprehensively and undisputably defeated, without any "betrayal legend" such as Germany had after WWI.
Also, the Potsdam declaration didn't insist on "unconditional surrender", it had a list of quite specific terms. Admittedly, it didn't mention the emperor specifically, one way or the other, but I don't think that was a conspiracy - probably more an omission.
Again, I don't believe surrender was imminent. The Japanese didn't surrender after losing Manchuria, they didn't surrender after their fleet was obliterated, they didn't surrender after Okinawa, they didn't surrender when the Soviet Union attacked, they didn't even seriously consider surrendering after Hiroshima - they thought the USA could only have one of those super-bombs.Barry Shnikov wrote:2. The bombs were used to 'prevent the massive loss of Allied lives' that would follow an invasion of the Japanese mainland. It wasn't necessary to invade mainland Japan. Nothing could get in or out of the country and surrender was imminent in any event.
In fact, even after Nagasaki, when you'd think any halfway-sane person would have given up, there was still no clear majority at the top of the Japanese regime in favour of surrender - they still wanted to negotiate better conditions (e.g. handling their own disarmament and treatment of war criminals, and no occupation of Japan), which were clearly not going to happen.
It was only after the Emperor said "the game's up, boys" that the surrender was made.
Yes, this probably was true, and was probably a factor in Truman's calculation. But I very much doubt it was the main factor - which was to end the war as quickly as possible. Which it did. Not only did that save a lot of Allied lives, it saved a lot of Chinese lives (they were dying at a rate of 100,000 a month due to the occupation), and probably even a lot of Japanese lives.Barry Shnikov wrote:3. The released records, memoirs and so forth show that the US was desperate to end the war before Russia began to make territorial gains in the East.
Agree - but even then, there were plenty of naysayers who wanted to answer naked aggression with diplomacy.Barry Shnikov wrote:I'm not sure what was so terrible about the means used in the first gulf war. Iraq invaded a country and it was clearly justified that military means be employed to 'free' Kuwait and prevent Iraq from doing something like that again.
At the time, the official "legal" (!) justification was the WMD thing, but of course the real justification was that Bush and the American Right just hated Saddam Hussein and wanted him gone, no matter what the cost (which is 3,000 deaths a month at the moment).Barry Shnikov wrote:As for the Gulf War II - does anyone know what the 'ends' really were? I'm b()ggered if I can work out what they were. If they were either a) remove Saddam or b) destroy his WMD capacity, then the means were not justified.
I agree he's an idiot, I've got no respect for the guy.Barry Shnikov wrote:I've just seen Binyamin Netenyahu on the BBC, giving wholly meretricious arguments in favour of what Israel is doing to Lebanon.
Well, I think it's pretty well-established that Hizbullah is funded, armed, trained and supported by Iran and Syria. And yes, I think it's true that Iran would very much like to get nukes]Of course Israel is entitled to nuclear weapons by right, but isn't it dreadful that those horrid old Muslims should get some?[/QUOTE]Barry Shnikov wrote:He also advanced the argument that Hezbollah is a creature of Iranian policy, the justification for such argument being 'they get funding and training from Iran' - I'm afraid I'll need a bit more than that before I will accept it - and that Iran is attempting to produce nuclear weapons.
No, I don't think Israel should have nukes, nor India for that matter - but at least they're both democracies with some checks and balances. I sometimes think people have forgotten how truly scary it is when a dictatorship has nuclear missiles...