Originally Posted by
El Salsero Gringo
In what way is the teaching better? How do the taxi-dancers help more?
I think perhaps I was unclear - I was talking about the UK teaching of beginner v.s. intermediate. In other words, we teach UK beginners better than UK intermediates, because UK beginners get much more direct feedback and guidance (from taxi-dancers) than intermediates (who don't get help from the taxis). I wasn't comparing against the Australian taxi-dancers, and although individual dancers were very helpful (Gary ), I don't actually recall whether they even had taxi-dancers at the classes I visited. Does that make more sense?
In what ways should the beginners classes be more demanding? Is the difference compatible with the emphasis of UK Ceroc as "fun and easy to learn"?
I'm not sure I really saw enough to answer this (I only did 2 or 3 classes). Let me describe the class first:The beginners class I went was about the same as an easy-ish UK intermediate class. It contained a pretzel (or variation thereof) and a basket lean, and had about 6 or 7 moves in total. The teaching was faster paced than over here, with a lot less padding - there was maybe 3 seconds pause between getting your next partner and practising the move with her. The result was a lot more repetitions of each move in a given period of time.
I remember at the time being quite surprised what was being taught to the beginners, and particularly that it was taught with relatively little time spent on explanation compared with the UK. However, everyone seemed happy and I didn't notice anyone having any trouble with it. That's the key point - if you can teach more complex moves, leans etc. in a beginners class and have everyone follow them, I can't really see any downside. But it did surprise me that everyone did so well, and I'm not really sure why they did. Maybe we underestimate our beginners. A more complex possible explanation is cultural - I think dancers there are quicker to jump in and give advice than we are over here. (Not because we're unfriendly in the UK, but because our MJ culture is less judgemental, so people tend not to give advice/corrections unless asked for them).
Where you did see a bigger difference was in the intermediate class. It was expected people knew how to do drops (i.e. taking/supporting weight). There were lots of moves with footwork, without the "Don't panic everyone - footwork coming up. But we'll explain it really s l o w l y..." routine you usually have over here. But, as counterpoint, I didn't get one of the footwork moves, and to be honest, I wasn't really sure how I was supposed to get it. To explain further, I had maybe 2 minutes of being taught it, and after that was just desparately faking it to try not to upset my partner too much. I didn't get far enough to remember it, or practise it, so I'm not sure how I would have got better at it.
As a more general comment on the speed of teaching, for the intermediate class, a lot of the learning seemed to come from the other students rather than the teacher. By the time the teacher stopped explaining, it seemed only a very few people had it down pat, but during the rotations and repetitions, gradually we would all 'evolve' to doing the correct move. Again - I'm not totally sure how this worked; one thing was definitely that people are a lot more ready to give comments and advice over there!
Maybe I'm just seeing things, but the UK website
www.ceroc.com seems to place more emphasis on getting people off the ground with some kind of dance (in its loosest definition) whereas the two Australian sites
www.cerocaustralia.com.au and
www.ceroc.com.au don't, and I wonder if this is evidence of a cultural difference between the two.
I think there is a bit of a difference; it's probably true to say they are a bit more competitive, and we are a little more "doesn't matter how you dance as long as you enjoy yourself". But I don't think the difference is actually as big as you'd think from the websites. To be honest, it's www.ceroc.com that is a bit of an outlier - this forum isn't terribly different from the Australian one.
Bookmarks