SHOULD "REP" BE ANONYMOUS ?

[POPPET]

Be wary of the bricklayers ability to induce bulging eyes in his adversary
'Take one brick in either hand, extend arms to full width, bring together with maximum force at about 6"-8" below your adversarys waist level, listen for the ringing sound of baked clay meeting baked clay, softend by the dull thud of compressed fleshy parts
But dont worry it does not hurt, unless I get my fingers trapped

In the builders bum!

[Andy McGregor]

I can see you in floaty georgette ....

Makes me look like a fairy...

[POPPET]

Makes me look like a fairy...

Arnt you a bit old to beieve in fairies....oooh i get it ...say no more ! hee hee still a man that can double dip DangerousCurves and me simultaneously is by no means a fairie, we still talk about that......Andy you are a Dance God ...giggle

[Bardsey]

Makes me look like a fairy...

Oh yes? And what's wrong with looking like a fairy? But lets be honest, Andy, you couldn't look like me in a million years........you might be able to fake the "outwardly projecting" chest area, but not the wings.......never the wings!

[Andy McGregor]

but not the wings.......never the wings!

Mine are moving so fast you can't see them

[JamesGeary]

Everyone who uses the forum is wonderful.
(I just want to see if I can get some rep, its tough having no aura)

[POPPET]

Mine are moving so fast you can't see them

I think Andy has had to much..... Red Bull! > (gives you wings!)

[Bardsey]

Mine are moving so fast you can't see them

Yes I've heard you're a bit of a "humming" bird

[Andy McGregor]

Yes I've heard you're a bit of a "humming" bird

I thought nobody could hear the buzzing

[Minnie M]

How many voters are voting on the title rather than the question

View Poll Results: Should any “REP” given, (good or bad) automatically have the writers name attached

?

SHOULD "REP" BE ANONYMOUS

IMHO I think lots of votes for YES have been mislead

[Gadget]

Well, the "no" says "I think it should remain anonymous, NO.", don't you think that "yes" would be the opposite of that? ie be attributed to the reputer.

[Lynn]

Well, the "no" says "I think it should remain anonymous, NO.", don't you think that "yes" would be the opposite of that? ie be attributed to the reputer.

But if you read the poll quickly and looked at the title - 'Should rep be anonymous' you might just click on 'Yes' thinking you were voting 'yes it should be anonymous' but you are voting, 'yes, names should show'. Of course I'm sure everyone reads all polls very carefully before voting.

[DangerousCurves]

Fortunately, most people have not only voted, but left a reasoned argument as to why they voted the way they did. Looking at those arguments, no-one who has posted has gone on to vote the contrary way on the poll.

Raise the flag for the good sense of the forumites, who read the small print before they sign!

[Lynn]

Raise the flag for the good sense of the forumites, who read the small print before they sign!

At least it shows they are paying attention - and thinking about why they are voting.

[Minnie M]

But if you read the poll quickly and looked at the title - 'Should rep be anonymous' you might just click on 'Yes' thinking you were voting 'yes it should be anonymous' but you are voting, 'yes, names should show'. Of course I'm sure everyone reads all polls very carefully before voting.

that's what I meant

Raise the flag for the good sense of the forumites, who read the small print before they sign

I think you can vote without making a posting

[DangerousCurves]

:I think you can vote without making a posting

Yes, you can - but everyone who has posted and voted, has voted in a way consistant with the views which they expressed - so the issue of possible confusion doesn't seem to have in fact been a problem.

[Gordon J Pownall]

Yes, you can - but everyone who has posted and voted, has voted in a way consistant with the views which they expressed - so the issue of possible confusion doesn't seem to have in fact been a problem.

Eh...????

...someone tell me what to do...I'm too confused now.....


....is there a JiveMasters video I can borrow (unless there are still some for sale.......?)....

[Andy McGregor]

Fortunately, most people have not only voted,

"Most people" have NOT voted: 35 people have voted. Out of nearly 1000 people a mere 35 is not "most people" - at least when I did statistics it wasn't - it was 3.5%. So now we know that 2% of the forum vote one way and 1.5% voted the other - and that's if they weren't confused by the ambiguous construction of the question

However, the debate was well reasoned - but I don't think it changed anyone's mind.

Here is the main question, should Franck change his practice based on the view of 2% of the forum?

[bigdjiver]

... should Franck change his practice based on the view of 2% of the forum?

Any leader should be persuaded by the arguments, not by the numbers. Leaders have to make unpopular decisions at times. The greatest progress, (and greatest disasters) are made by leaders who believe X when everybody else believes Y.

[Sparkles]

Any leader should be persuaded by the arguments, not by the numbers. Leaders have to make unpopular decisions at times. The greatest progress, (and greatest disasters) are made by leaders who believe X when everybody else believes Y.

Well said, I like it.