Musicality in MJ vs WCS

[robd]

Moved from the "downbeat and upbeat" thread - DavidJames

Obviously, musicality is better in WCS than in MJ.

Can't believe you've made such a sweeping generalisation DJ even though I am a big fan of WCS myself. Yes, some of the stuff on YouTube is great and the top Americans are fantastically musical but that's because they are very talented professionals who've been dancing for years. I will concede that the lower barriers to entry for MJ mean that there are possibly more people doing that style who are unable to dance in time (though this ability doesn't count as 'musicality' for me). I just don't think there's anything inherent within the dance styles that would support your statement above.